Trading · Options
SPX vs SPY options (and XSP): settlement, size, assignment, tax
SPX, XSP and SPY options compared: cash or share settlement, European or American exercise, AM and PM settlement, size, dividends and 60/40 tax.
On this page
Three option contracts let a trader take a view on the S&P 500 through a listed option: SPX, the option on the index itself; XSP, a one-tenth-size version of it; and SPY, the option on the largest ETF that tracks the index. All three move with the same 500 stocks. They end differently, are sized differently, are exercised differently and, in the United States, are taxed differently.
Most of the practical differences come down to two facts. SPX and XSP are options on an index, which cannot be delivered, so they settle in cash. SPY options are options on ETF shares, so they settle in shares, and they follow the rules for stock options: American exercise, early assignment, dividends and ordinary capital gains treatment.
This lesson compares the three line by line, works through the settlement timetable, and shows the tax difference on one $10,000 gain.
The three contracts
SPX options were first listed by Cboe in 1983 and remain the largest index option market. The underlying is the S&P 500 index level; each point is $100. With the index at 7,400, one contract controls $740,000 of index exposure. They are traded only on Cboe and cleared by the OCC.
XSP (Mini-SPX) options are written on one tenth of the index level, also with a $100 multiplier, so one contract controls $74,000 at the same level. They have the same cash settlement and European exercise as SPX, are PM-settled, and since 2022 have had expirations every weekday.
SPY options are options on the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust. One contract covers 100 shares. SPY trades at roughly one tenth of the index (about $732 in mid-November 2026), so a contract also controls around $74,000. They are listed on all US options exchanges and behave like any other option on a stock.
Because SPX is ten times larger, one SPX option is roughly equivalent to ten SPY or ten XSP options, and its premium, bid-ask spread in dollars and margin are ten times larger too. A spread of $0.10 on SPX is $10 a contract; on SPY it is also $10, but per $74,000 instead of per $740,000. Comparisons of liquidity have to be made per dollar of exposure, not per contract.
Settlement: cash or shares, AM or PM
Cash-settled SPX and XSP
At expiration an in-the-money SPX option pays the difference between the settlement value and the strike, times $100, in cash, the next business day. An out-of-the-money option expires. No shares change hands, and nothing is left open in the account afterwards. Cash settlement also removes pin risk: there is no question of whether an option that closed a few cents in the money will be exercised into a position over the weekend.
The settlement value depends on the series:
- AM-settled. The standard monthly SPX options, expiring on the third Friday, stop trading at the close on Thursday. Their settlement value, published under the symbol SET, is computed from the opening prices of the 500 stocks on Friday morning. Anyone holding to expiration carries the overnight gap: news before Friday's open can move the settlement far from Thursday's close, and because each stock's opening print happens at a different moment, the value can differ from any index level actually shown at the open.
- PM-settled. SPXW options (the Weeklys, end-of-month options and the daily expirations) stop trading at 4:00 p.m. Eastern on expiration day and settle on the index's closing value. Holders see the number they traded against. These are the options behind same-day trading.
XSP options are PM-settled in the same way.
Share-settled SPY
At expiration a SPY option in the money by $0.01 or more is exercised automatically under the OCC's exercise-by-exception procedure. A long call becomes 100 SPY shares bought at the strike; a long put becomes 100 shares sold (or a short position if none are held). The writers on the other side are assigned. Holders may still instruct their broker not to exercise, or to exercise an option that closed just out of the money, until the 5:30 p.m. Eastern cut-off set by FINRA Rule 2360, while SPY keeps trading after hours. Writers learn the result the next morning. Option exercise and assignment: how it works and when it happens covers the timetable.
The practical result is that a SPY option held through the close can turn into roughly $74,000 of SPY, long or short, and that a short option can be assigned after an after-hours move even though it closed out of the money.
Exercise style and early assignment
SPX and XSP options are European-style: they can be exercised only at expiration, so a short SPX option can never be assigned early.
SPY options are American-style: the holder can exercise any business day. Most of the time that would throw away time value, so early exercise is rare. The exception is dividends. SPY pays a dividend each quarter, and a call holder who exercises the day before the ex-dividend date receives it. When an in-the-money call's remaining time value is smaller than the dividend, early exercise becomes worthwhile, and the writers of those calls are assigned. A short call in a SPY spread can be assigned before expiration, leaving the other leg open and a short stock position that owes the dividend. Deep in-the-money short puts can also be assigned early, when their time value is small.
Dividends in the price
All three option prices account for the index's dividends. For SPX and XSP, expected dividends are reflected in the forward value of the index, which is why SPX calls are a little cheaper and puts a little dearer than a no-dividend model would say. For SPY the dividends are paid by the ETF on known dates, and the option prices reflect the expected payments the same way, plus the early-exercise feature above. Neither option holder receives the dividend itself.
Taxes: a worked comparison (United States, 2026)
SPX options are broad-based index options, which the tax code treats as nonequity options and therefore as section 1256 contracts. Cboe describes XSP as eligible for the same treatment. SPY options are options on an ETF's shares and follow the ordinary rules for equity options.
Two other section 1256 rules apply to SPX and not to SPY options. Open positions are marked to market on the last business day of the year and taxed as if sold, so an SPX position carried across December 31 is taxed in the year the gain accrued. And net section 1256 losses can, by election, be carried back three years against section 1256 gains. A SPY option held more than a year can produce a long-term gain, which most options never reach.
Section 1256 contracts: futures, index options and the 60/40 rule runs the comparison at four income levels with the 3.8% net investment income tax; How options are taxed: buyers, writers, covered calls and straddles covers the equity option rules, including wash sales and straddles. Tax treatment depends on individual circumstances; the example illustrates the rules, not anyone's return.
Side by side
| Feature | SPX | XSP (Mini-SPX) | SPY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Underlying | S&P 500 index | One tenth of the index | SPDR S&P 500 ETF shares |
| Size per contract (index 7,400) | Index × $100 ≈ $740,000 | ≈ $74,000 | 100 shares ≈ $74,000 |
| Exercise style | European | European | American |
| Settlement | Cash | Cash | 100 shares per contract |
| AM or PM | Monthly AM; SPXW PM | PM | Shares at the close; exercise until 5:30 p.m. |
| Early assignment | No | No | Yes, notably before ex-dividend dates |
| Expirations | Every weekday, monthly, quarterly, LEAPS | Every weekday and more | Every weekday, monthly, quarterly, LEAPS |
| Where traded | Cboe only | Cboe | All US options exchanges |
| US tax | Section 1256: 60/40, year-end mark | Generally section 1256 | Equity option: by holding period |
| After expiration | Nothing open | Nothing open | Possibly a stock position |
Which suits which purpose
Large hedges and spreads. Funds hedging a portfolio of hundreds of millions favor SPX: one tenth the number of contracts and orders, cash settlement and no assignment. Spread traders value that no leg can be assigned early.
Smaller accounts. An SPX contract's dollar size can be too large for a modest account to hold a position of sensible size. XSP and SPY are one tenth as large, and SPY's quotes are often a cent or two wide near the money.
Positions that should end in shares. A covered call or a cash-secured put on the index has to use SPY, because SPX cannot deliver shares.
Tax-sensitive trading. For short-term trading by US taxpayers, the 60/40 treatment of SPX and XSP lowers the tax on gains. The year-end mark removes the ability to defer a gain into the next year.
Pitfalls
Holding AM-settled SPX through Thursday. The value is set by Friday's opening prices, after an overnight gap, and trading has already stopped.
Assuming SPY options cannot be assigned before expiration. They are American-style; short calls near ex-dividend dates are the usual case.
Holding SPY options through the close. An in-the-money SPY option becomes 100 shares, around $74,000 per contract at these prices, which can exceed the account's buying power.
Comparing spreads per contract. A one-dollar spread on SPX and a ten-cent spread on SPY are the same cost per dollar of exposure.
Assuming SPX tax treatment for all index products. Options on index ETFs such as SPY or QQQ are equity options, not section 1256 contracts. Only broad-based index options (and some others listed in section 1256) get 60/40.
How Finabase does it
Finabase shows the SPY side of this comparison. The SPY option chain lists every expiration, from each weekday of the coming weeks out to LEAPS more than two years away, with bid, ask, last, volume, open interest and implied volatility for each strike, and the in-the-money strikes shaded. The SPY page shows the ETF's price and chart, and the S&P 500 chart the index itself, so the roughly one-tenth relationship between SPY and the index can be checked at any time.
Finabase does not show option chains for SPX or XSP, does not compute taxes, and does not show settlement values. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between SPX and SPY options?
SPX options are on the S&P 500 index, about ten times larger per contract, European-style and settled in cash. SPY options are on an ETF, American-style, settled in shares, and can be assigned early. In the US, SPX options get section 1256 (60/40) tax treatment and SPY options do not.
Is SPX ten times SPY?
Approximately. SPY trades at about one tenth of the index level, and both contracts have a $100 multiplier per point or share, so one SPX option controls roughly ten times the value of one SPY option.
What is AM settlement for SPX options?
The standard monthly SPX options stop trading on Thursday and settle on a value calculated from the opening prices of the index's stocks on Friday morning. PM-settled SPXW options settle on the closing value of the index on their expiration day.
Are SPY options taxed 60/40?
No. SPY options are options on ETF shares and follow the ordinary equity option rules: short-term unless held more than a year. Broad-based index options such as SPX are section 1256 contracts taxed 60/40.
Can SPX options be assigned early?
No. They are European-style and can be exercised only at expiration, after which they settle in cash.
Summary
SPX, XSP and SPY options all track the S&P 500 but differ in everything around that. SPX is the index × $100, European and cash-settled, AM-settled for the standard monthly series and PM-settled for the daily SPXW series; XSP is the same at one tenth the size; SPY is 100 ETF shares, American-style and settled in shares, with early assignment around dividends. With the index at 7,400 one SPX option controlled $740,000 against $74,000 for SPY or XSP. In the US, SPX and generally XSP are section 1256 contracts: on a $10,000 three-month gain in the 24% bracket the tax was $1,860 against $2,400 on a SPY option, with SPX positions also marked to market each December.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
With the S&P 500 at 7,400, roughly how many SPY option contracts match the index exposure of one SPX contract?
- One
- About ten
- About a hundred
Show the answer
B. About ten One SPX contract is the index × $100, about $740,000. SPY trades near one tenth of the index, so 100 shares are about $74,000. Ten SPY contracts, or ten XSP contracts, match one SPX.
A trader is short a SPY call spread and short an SPX call spread, both in the money, a week before expiration and the day before SPY goes ex-dividend. Which short call can be assigned early?
- Both
- Only the SPY call
- Only the SPX call
Show the answer
B. Only the SPY call SPY options are American-style, and in-the-money calls are often exercised just before an ex-dividend date to collect the dividend. SPX options are European-style and can be exercised only at expiration.
A trader holds a standard monthly (AM-settled) SPX option into its expiration week. When is its settlement value set?
- At Thursday’s close, when trading stops
- From the opening prices of the index’s stocks on Friday morning
- At Friday’s close
Show the answer
B. From the opening prices of the index’s stocks on Friday morning AM-settled SPX options stop trading at Thursday’s close, and the settlement value (SET) is calculated from Friday’s opening prices. An overnight gap can move it well away from Thursday’s close. PM-settled SPXW options settle on the closing value.
A US taxpayer in the 24% bracket (15% on long-term gains) makes $10,000 on a SPY option and $10,000 on an SPX option, each held three months. What is the federal tax on each, before the NIIT?
- SPY $2,400, SPX $1,860
- SPY $1,860, SPX $2,400
- Both $2,400
Show the answer
A. SPY $2,400, SPX $1,860 The SPY option gain is short-term: 24% × $10,000 = $2,400. SPX options are section 1256 contracts: 60% at 15% plus 40% at 24% = $900 + $960 = $1,860.
Which position can only be built with SPY options, not SPX?
- A bull call spread
- A covered call on index shares
- A long put to hedge a portfolio
Show the answer
B. A covered call on index shares A covered call needs shares to deliver. SPX settles in cash and has no shares; SPY options are written on ETF shares, so a covered call can be written against 100 SPY shares.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the S&P 500 chart and note the index’s last level, then open the SPY page and note its price. Divide the index by the SPY price. Then work out the notional value of one SPX option (index × $100) and of one SPY option (SPY price × 100). How many SPY contracts would match one SPX contract?
Open the S&P 500 chartWhat you should find
The index comes out at about ten times SPY, usually a little more, because of the fund's expenses and the timing of its dividend payments. One SPX option therefore controls about ten times as much as one SPY option.
Sources and further reading
- Cboe — SPX options product specifications
- Cboe — SPX Weeklys (SPXW) product specifications
- Cboe — XSP (Mini-SPX) options product specifications
- The Options Clearing Corporation — Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options
- FINRA Rule 2360 — Options (exercise cut-off)
- 26 U.S. Code §1256, Section 1256 contracts marked to market (Cornell LII)
- IRS — Publication 550, Section 1256 contracts and nonequity options
- IRS — Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (tax year 2026 rate tables and capital gain thresholds)
