Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Trading · Futures

Futures basis and convergence: cost of carry, fair value and arbitrage

What the basis between a cash price and a futures price is, how cost of carry sets fair value, how arbitrage holds it there, and why the gap closes at expiry.

On this page
  1. What the basis is
  2. The cost of carry
  3. Worked example: the E-mini SP 500 on November 17, 2026
  4. Real data: the sawtooth
  5. How arbitrage holds the price
  6. Commodities: storage, delivery and imperfect convergence
  7. Basis risk
  8. Pitfalls
  9. Basis in different markets
  10. How Finabase does it
  11. Frequently asked questions
  12. Summary
  13. Check your understanding
  14. Exercise

A futures price is not a forecast. It is the price of the asset today, adjusted for what it costs, and what it pays, to hold that asset until the delivery date. The gap between the two prices is called the basis, and the arithmetic that sets it is called the cost of carry. Because a trader who sees the gap stray too far can buy one side and sell the other, the basis is held close to that arithmetic for any liquid contract, and it shrinks to zero as the contract approaches expiry. That shrinking is convergence.

The basis matters to everyone who uses futures. A hedger who locks in a price with futures actually locks in a price plus or minus the basis on the day the hedge is lifted. An investor who reads "S&P futures are up 20 points" before the open needs to know how many of those points are carry and not news. And anyone who holds a contract into expiry should know that the last move is a forced one.

This lesson defines the basis, derives fair value from the cost of carry, works it through on the E-mini S&P 500 contract on November 17, 2026, shows how arbitrage keeps prices in line, and draws two years of real data where the gap closes into every quarterly expiry.

What the basis is

For any asset with a futures market there are two prices at the same moment: the cash or spot price for delivery now, and the futures price for delivery on a set date. The basis is the difference.

Traders in grain and livestock use this sign convention, and it is the one this lesson uses. Equity-index traders often talk about the opposite number, the futures premium (futures minus cash), and say "the premium is 18 points" when the basis is −18. Both describe the same gap; check which one a source means before using its numbers.

A basis that becomes more positive (or less negative) is said to strengthen; one that becomes more negative is said to weaken. The words matter in hedging: a short hedger gains when the basis strengthens, a long hedger when it weakens (Hedging with futures: short and long hedges, basis risk, hedge ratio works through both).

For commodities the "cash price" is local. A farmer in Iowa does not sell into Chicago; she sells to a local elevator, and the elevator's bid is the futures price plus a local basis that reflects freight, storage and local supply. That is why the agricultural basis is often quoted as "50 under December": the local cash price is 50 cents below the December futures.

The cost of carry

Why should a futures price differ from cash at all? Because the two are different ways of owning the same thing on the delivery date.

Consider two routes to owning the S&P 500 basket on December 18, 2026:

  1. Buy the stocks today, paying cash now. You give up interest on that cash until December, but you collect any dividends paid in between.
  2. Buy a futures contract today, pay nothing now except margin, and keep the cash earning interest. You receive no dividends.

If both routes end with the same basket on the same day, they must cost the same, or someone could buy the cheap route and sell the expensive one. So the futures price must equal the cash price plus the interest forgone, minus the dividends missed.

Three cases follow from the formula:

  • Financing cost above income (r > q): futures sit above cash. This is the normal state for stock indexes and gold, and the curve slopes upward. In commodity language it is contango.
  • Income above financing cost (q > r): futures sit below cash. A high-dividend index in a low-rate year, or a currency with high interest rates, can look like this.
  • Scarcity now: when a physical good is short, owning it today has a value of its own (the convenience yield), and near futures can trade above later ones. That is backwardation, and the cost-of-carry model then only sets an upper bound on how far the curve can rise, not the price itself.

The shape of the whole curve across many delivery months, and what rolling along it does to a long investor, has its own lesson: Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil. This one stays with the gap between cash and a single contract.

Worked example: the E-mini S&P 500 on November 17, 2026

Less than a point of difference is within the noise of the inputs. The dividend yield is a trailing figure, while fair value needs the dividends actually expected before December 18. The bill rate is not the rate an arbitrageur borrows at. And the two closing prices are not simultaneous: US stocks close at 4:00 p.m. Eastern, the futures' daily settlement price is taken at the same time but the "close" in most data feeds, including ours, is the last trade an hour later, at 5:00 p.m., when the session pauses. A one-hour move of a few points is common.

Fair value also shrinks every day as t falls. With the same inputs, the premium would be 56.42 points with 90 days left, 37.56 with 60, 18.76 with 30, 6.25 with 10 and zero on the expiry date.

Real data: the sawtooth

The chart below plots the E-mini front-month price minus the S&P 500 index at each day's close for two years. Expiry days are shaded and left out of the line, because on those days the futures' final price is fixed from the morning's opening prices and cannot be compared with the afternoon close.

E-mini S&P 500 front month minus the S&P 500 index, daily, Nov 2024 – Nov 2026 0 25 50 75 Zero: futures = index Sep 18, 2025, day before expiry: +3.04 Next contract: +58.75 Futures − index (index points) Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct
E-mini S&P 500 front month (ES=F) minus the S&P 500 index (^GSPC), daily closes, November 18, 2024 to November 17, 2026. Shaded days are quarterly expiries, left out of the line. Source: Finabase chart data.

The pattern is a sawtooth. On the first day the data switches to the next contract, the gap jumps up, because the new contract has about three months of carry in it: between 42 and 88 points on the eight switches in this period. It then decays, unevenly, toward zero. On the day before each of the eight expiries the futures were between 0.39 points below and 4.40 points above the index.

Two features are worth noticing:

  • The decay is not a straight line. Daily noise comes from the closing-time mismatch and from changes in rates and expected dividends. The trend is still unmistakable.
  • The jump is not a price move. Nothing happened to the market on the roll days. A chart of a continuous futures series that splices contracts together contains these jumps; a backtest that treats them as returns overstates the profit of a long position by the carry. Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil shows the same effect on crude oil.

Implied carry can be read back from the data. Right after the September 2026 roll, on September 21, the December contract closed 68.80 points above an index of 7,764.70 with 88 days to go. Annualized, that gap is about 3.7%, close to a bill rate near 4% less a dividend yield near 1%.

How arbitrage holds the price

Fair value is not a rule anyone enforces. It holds because deviating from it creates a trade that earns money with little risk.

Cash-and-carry: futures too rich

Suppose the December E-mini traded at 7,380 when fair value was 7,359.91, about 20 points rich. An arbitrageur could:

  1. Sell the futures at 7,380.
  2. Buy the 500 stocks in index weights, financed at the bill rate.
  3. Collect the dividends and pay the financing until December 18.
  4. Deliver at expiry: the futures settle against the index, so the stock position and the futures cancel, whatever the index does.

The profit is the 20 points of excess, about $1,000 a contract, minus trading costs and the difference between the arbitrageur's real funding rate and the bill rate. Selling futures pushes their price down; buying stocks pushes the index up. The gap closes.

Reverse cash-and-carry: futures too cheap

If futures trade below fair value, the trade runs backward: buy the futures, sell the stocks (or sell stock already owned), and invest the cash at the bill rate. Institutions that already hold index portfolios do this most cheaply, by switching stock exposure into futures when the futures are cheap.

The no-arbitrage band

Costs create a band, not a line. Commissions, bid-ask spreads on 500 stocks, borrowing costs for short sales, and the gap between borrowing and lending rates mean that small deviations are not worth trading. For the most liquid contracts, such as the E-mini S&P 500, the band is narrow and the futures usually trade within a point or two of fair value during US trading hours. For thinner contracts, or when funding is scarce, it widens: in March 2020 dealers' balance sheets were stretched and Treasury futures in particular traded well away from their cash-market fair values for days.

The same reasoning, applied to options instead of futures, gives Put-call parity: the link between calls, puts and the stock: a portfolio of a call and a put is a synthetic futures position, and its price is held at the forward price by the same kind of trade.

Commodities: storage, delivery and imperfect convergence

For a stored commodity such as gold, carry includes storage and insurance. Take gold at $3,864.20 an ounce (the front futures close on November 17, 2026, used here as a stand-in for spot), the 4.14% bill rate and an assumed 0.10% a year for storage and insurance: a contract for delivery three months later would have a fair value about $41 higher, near $3,905. Gold is held mostly as an investment, there is a large stock of it, and it can be lent out, so its curve follows the carry formula closely.

Consumption commodities behave differently. Crude oil, natural gas, grains and livestock are used up, stocks can run low, and the convenience yield can be large. When it is, near futures trade above later ones and the cash price can sit above the front futures: a positive basis.

Convergence is also less exact for physically delivered commodities. The futures converge to the cheapest way of making delivery: the cheapest acceptable grade, at the cheapest delivery location, at the most convenient time in the delivery window. A buyer whose own grain is a different grade, or in a different town, sees a basis that does not go to zero. And convergence can fail when the delivery mechanism does not work well. Between roughly 2006 and 2009 the Chicago Board of Trade's wheat contract repeatedly expired well above the cash price of wheat at the delivery points, a failure examined by a US Senate subcommittee in 2009 and addressed by the exchange with a variable storage rate in 2010.

Cash-settled contracts such as the E-mini avoid most of this. Their final settlement is defined as the index value (for the S&P 500 contracts, a Special Opening Quotation built from each stock's opening price on expiry morning), so convergence is guaranteed by the contract terms.

Basis risk

A hedge with futures replaces price risk with basis risk. A wheat farmer who sold futures to lock in a price still faces the uncertainty of the local basis on the day she sells her grain. An index fund manager who sold E-mini contracts against a portfolio still faces the gap between his portfolio and the S&P 500, and the gap between the futures and the index on the day he buys them back.

Basis risk is usually much smaller than price risk, which is why hedging works. It is not zero, and it is the main reason a hedge's result differs from the arithmetic on the day it was placed.

Pitfalls

Reading futures moves as market moves. A futures price 19 points above the index is not a signal that the market will rise 19 points. Subtract fair value first; the Stock index futures: ES, NQ, YM and RTY explained lesson shows how the premarket "futures are up" reading is done.

Treating continuous futures charts as returns. The jump on each roll day is carry, not profit. A long position earns the price change of the contract it holds, not the spliced series (Futures expiration and rolling: notice days, roll week and spreads).

Forgetting the closing-time mismatch. Comparing a 5:00 p.m. futures close with a 4:00 p.m. index close makes the basis look noisier than it is. Use simultaneous prices.

Assuming convergence for every contract. Physically delivered contracts converge to the cheapest deliverable, which may not be what you hold.

Ignoring the sign convention. "Basis" and "premium" are opposite numbers.

Basis in different markets

Market Usual sign of the basis (cash − futures) Main carry terms How it converges
Stock index (E-mini S&P 500) Negative Interest minus dividends Cash settlement to the opening index
Gold Negative Interest plus storage, minus lease income Physical delivery, close to exact
Crude oil, grains Either; positive when supply is tight Interest plus storage, minus convenience Physical delivery, to the cheapest
Treasury notes and bonds Varies with the cheapest-to-deliver Coupon income minus financing (repo) Delivery of the cheapest-to-deliver
VIX Varies; not a carry relationship None: VIX cannot be bought and stored Cash settlement to a special quote

The last row is a warning. The cost-of-carry argument needs an underlying that can be bought and held. The VIX index cannot, so VIX futures are expectations of future volatility and the gap to spot VIX is not carry (Volatility and the VIX: historical vs implied volatility explained). Treasury futures have their own twist, the deliverable basket, covered in Treasury futures: conversion factors, cheapest-to-deliver and DV01.

How Finabase does it

The E-mini front month has its own symbol page, ES=F, whose name shows the contract month it currently tracks (on November 18, 2026, "E-Mini S&P 500 Dec 26"), with the previous close, the day's range, 52-week range and returns. The index itself is on ^GSPC. Reading the two previous closes side by side gives the futures-minus-index gap shown on this page, with the closing-time caveat above. The Futures page lists 61 continuous series, from index futures to metals and bonds.

Finabase does not compute fair value or the basis, and does not show individual contract months; its charts of futures are continuous front-month series that include the roll jumps. The chart and the fair-value calculation on this page are ours, from frozen Finabase chart data and SPY's dividend history.

Frequently asked questions

What does a negative basis mean?

It means the futures price is above the cash price. For stock indexes and gold that is the normal state, because the cost of financing the asset exceeds the income it pays.

Why do futures and spot prices converge at expiry?

Because at expiry the futures contract becomes a claim on the asset right now. If the two prices differed, a trader could buy the cheaper and deliver into the dearer at once. Cash settlement makes the convergence exact by contract design.

Is the futures price a forecast of the future spot price?

Not for assets that can be stored and financed. Their futures price is set by carry arithmetic, and it is above spot because of interest costs, not because anyone expects a rise. For commodities that cannot be stored easily, expectations play a larger part.

What is fair value in premarket trading?

It is the futures price that would match the previous index close after carry. Commentators subtract it from the futures price to estimate where the index will open.

What is basis risk?

The risk that the gap between the price you are hedging and the futures price changes before you close the hedge. It is what remains after a hedge removes most price risk.

Summary

The basis is the cash price minus the futures price. For assets that can be bought and held, it is set by the cost of carry: financing cost minus income, plus storage for physical goods, over the time to delivery. On November 17, 2026 that arithmetic put fair value for the December E-mini S&P 500 at 7,359.91 against an index of 7,340.53; the contract closed at 7,359.00. Cash-and-carry and reverse trades keep liquid futures within a narrow band around fair value, and the gap closes as expiry approaches, as two years of E-mini data show in a sawtooth from 42–88 points after each roll to within 5 points the day before expiry. What a hedger cannot remove is basis risk, and physically delivered contracts converge only to the cheapest deliverable.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. The S&P 500 is at 6,000, the financing rate is 4% and the dividend yield is 1%. Ignoring costs, roughly where should a futures contract with three months left trade?

    1. About 6,000, because futures have no reason to differ from the index
    2. About 6,045
    3. About 6,060
    4. About 5,955
    Show the answer

    B. About 6,045 Fair value is the index plus net carry: 6,000 × (4% − 1%) × 0.25 ≈ 45 points, so about 6,045. Using only the interest rate (6,060) forgets that a futures holder does not receive the dividends.

  2. Futures trade 25 points above their fair value, well outside trading costs. Which trade captures the gap?

    1. Buy the futures and sell the stocks
    2. Sell the futures and buy the stocks, holding both to expiry
    3. Buy both the futures and the stocks
    Show the answer

    B. Sell the futures and buy the stocks, holding both to expiry This is cash-and-carry: sell the expensive futures, buy the underlying, finance it and collect its dividends. At expiry the futures settle against the index, the two positions cancel, and the excess over fair value is the profit before costs.

  3. A chart of a continuous futures series jumps up 60 points on the day after each quarterly expiry, while the index does not move. What is the jump?

    1. A rally in the futures market that the index missed
    2. The switch to the next contract, which carries about three more months of financing cost
    3. A data error that should be ignored
    Show the answer

    B. The switch to the next contract, which carries about three more months of financing cost Continuous series splice contracts together. The new contract has a full quarter of carry in its price, so the series jumps on the roll day. No holder of either contract made or lost that amount.

  4. A short hedger sold futures when the basis was −0.40 and closes the hedge when the basis is −0.25. How did the basis change affect the hedge?

    1. It helped: the basis strengthened by 0.15
    2. It hurt: the basis weakened by 0.15
    3. It had no effect; only the futures price matters
    Show the answer

    A. It helped: the basis strengthened by 0.15 Moving from −0.40 to −0.25 makes the basis less negative, which is a strengthening. A short hedger receives the cash price and pays the futures change, so the net price received rises by 0.15.

  5. Why does the cost-of-carry formula not set the price of VIX futures?

    1. Because VIX futures are cash-settled
    2. Because the VIX index cannot be bought and held, so no cash-and-carry trade exists
    3. Because interest rates do not affect volatility
    Show the answer

    B. Because the VIX index cannot be bought and held, so no cash-and-carry trade exists Carry pricing rests on being able to buy the underlying now and hold it to delivery. Nobody can own the VIX itself, so its futures reflect expectations of future volatility instead.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the ES=F page and note its previous close and the contract month in its name. Then open the S&P 500 index page (^GSPC) and note its previous close. Subtract the index from the futures. Count the days to the third Friday of the contract month and work out the fair premium with a 4% financing rate and a 1% dividend yield. Is the futures price above or below your fair value, and by how much?

Open the E-mini S&P 500 page
What you should find

The futures should be above the index by roughly the index × 3% × days/365: more points early in a quarter, only a few points in expiry week. A difference of a few points from your fair value is normal, because the two closes are taken an hour apart and the inputs are approximate.

Sources and further reading

  1. CME Group — E-mini S&P 500 futures contract specifications (multiplier, quarterly cycle, final settlement on the Special Opening Quotation)
  2. CME Group Education — Understanding E-mini S&P 500 futures
  3. CFTC — Basics of futures trading
  4. US Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations — Excessive Speculation in the Wheat Market (June 2009), on CBOT wheat convergence
  5. Finabase chart data — ES=F, ^GSPC, ^IRX, SPY and GC=F daily closes, Nov 18, 2024 to Nov 17, 2026; SPY dividend history (frozen 2026-11-18)
  6. Hull, J., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapter on determination of forward and futures prices