Trading · Options
Butterfly spread: a small, defined bet on one price
How a long butterfly spread combines three strikes into a low-cost position that pays most at the middle strike, with its break-evens, costs and expiration risks.
On this page
A butterfly spread uses three strike prices, evenly spaced, in one expiration: buy one option at the lowest strike, sell two at the middle strike, and buy one at the highest. The long butterfly costs a small net debit, cannot lose more than that debit, and pays the most if the stock finishes exactly at the middle strike.
The attraction is the ratio. In the example below, $93 at risk can return as much as $407. The catch is in the word "exactly". The full payoff exists at one price on one day, the profitable range is narrow, and the position spends most of its life worth little more than was paid for it. The butterfly is a cheap ticket with a low chance of the top prize, and the arithmetic of that trade-off is what this lesson works through.
It is also the cleanest example of how multi-leg positions are assembled from simpler ones. A butterfly is two Vertical spreads: bull call, bear put and credit spreads explained that share a strike.
The idea: two spreads sharing a strike
Take a bull call spread: buy the $95 call, sell the $100 call. It gains as the stock rises from $95 to $100 and then stops. Add a bear call spread above it: sell the $100 call, buy the $105 call. It loses as the stock rises from $100 to $105 and then stops. Put the two together and the result rises to a point at $100 and falls back again.
The two short $100 calls are the "body" of the butterfly. The long $95 and $105 calls are the "wings". The wings cost money and the body brings money in, and because the body is nearer the stock price, it pays for most of the wings. What is left is the small debit.
The solid line is the profit at expiration: a tent. The flat parts on either side are the maximum loss, the debit. The peak is at the middle strike. The dashed line is the same position a week before expiration, and it is much flatter. That gap between the dashed curve and the tent is the subject of the section on time below.
How it works
The example uses the illustrative inputs shared by the other strategy lessons: a stock at $100, 45 days to expiration, 30% implied volatility, a 4% interest rate, no dividend, Black-Scholes values rounded to the cent.
| Stock at expiration | $95 call | Two short $100 calls | $105 call | Position value | Profit or loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $90 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | −$0.93 |
| $95 | $0 | $0 | $0 | $0 | −$0.93 |
| $95.93 | $0.93 | $0 | $0 | $0.93 | $0 |
| $98 | $3.00 | $0 | $0 | $3.00 | +$2.07 |
| $100 | $5.00 | $0 | $0 | $5.00 | +$4.07 |
| $103 | $8.00 | −$6.00 | $0 | $2.00 | +$1.07 |
| $104.07 | $9.07 | −$8.14 | $0 | $0.93 | $0 |
| $105 | $10.00 | −$10.00 | $0 | $0 | −$0.93 |
| $110 | $15.00 | −$20.00 | $5.00 | $0 | −$0.93 |
Above $105 the three legs cancel exactly: one call at $95 and one at $105 against two at $100. Below $95 everything expires worthless. Either way, the debit is lost and nothing more.
How likely is the payoff?
The ratio of $407 to $93 is 4.4 to 1, which sounds generous. The odds explain it. Under the same model that priced the options, the chance that the stock finishes between the two break-evens is about 30%, and the chance that it finishes within a dollar of $100, where the profit is at least $3.07, is under 8%. Roughly seven times in ten, the position loses some or all of the debit.
The model's probabilities are assumptions and real stocks do not follow them exactly. The qualitative point holds anyway: the price of the butterfly is low because the market judges its best outcome unlikely. A butterfly is fairly priced under the model, like every other position on these pages, before costs.
Time: the profit arrives late
| Days to expiration | Butterfly value with the stock at $100 | Profit if sold then |
|---|---|---|
| 45 (entry) | $0.93 | $0 |
| 20 | $1.36 | +$0.43 |
| 7 | $2.15 | +$1.22 |
| 2 | $3.25 | +$2.32 |
| 0 | $5.00 | +$4.07 |
Even if the stock sits at the best possible price for the whole period, the butterfly has earned only about a tenth of its maximum gain after 25 days, and less than a third with a week left. More than two-thirds of the profit comes in the final seven days. The reason is that the two short calls hold their time value until late, as at-the-money options do (Option theta: what a day costs, and why it speeds up).
This has a practical consequence. To collect most of the tent, the position has to be held into the last days, which is when gamma is highest and a small move in the stock changes the result most (Option gamma: how fast delta changes, and what it costs). At the start the butterfly's exposures are small: delta close to zero, gamma about −0.008, theta about +$1.00 a day per butterfly, and vega about −$2.97 per point of implied volatility. It is short vega: a rise in implied volatility lowers its value, because it makes a finish near the middle strike less likely. At 40% implied volatility the same butterfly would cost $0.70, and at 20%, $1.36.
Costs
A butterfly is four contracts at three strikes. Commissions are charged per contract, and each strike has its own bid-ask spread. If the opening and closing trades together give up $0.20 a share to the spreads, that is $20 on a position whose total risk is $93: about 22% of the debit, before commissions. Letting the position expire avoids the closing trade but brings the expiration risks below. For this reason butterflies are usually entered as a single order at one net price, and they are practical only in options with narrow spreads.
Early assignment and expiration
The two middle calls are sold, and US stock options are American-style, so either can be assigned before expiration, most often the day before an ex-dividend date when they are in the money. The lower long call covers the risk, but the position's shape changes and restoring it costs money.
At expiration (US, 2026), options in the money by $0.01 or more are exercised automatically. What you are left with depends on where the stock closes:
| Stock closes | What is exercised or assigned | Shares afterwards |
|---|---|---|
| Below $95 | Nothing | None |
| $95 to $100 | Long $95 call exercised | Long 100 |
| $100 to $105 | Long $95 exercised, both short $100 calls assigned | Short 100 |
| Above $105 | All four | None |
In the two middle rows the profit shown in the payoff table is realised only after the leftover shares are closed, and they are exposed to the next session's opening price. The worst place for this uncertainty is the best place for the payoff. With the stock closing within pennies of $100, you cannot know whether the short calls will be assigned: this is pin risk (Option exercise and assignment: how it works and when it happens). Most traders close a butterfly before the final bell and accept a little less than the tent's peak.
Margin and approval
In a US margin account (2026), a long butterfly is a defined-risk spread under FINRA Rule 4210: the debit is paid in full and no further margin is normally required, because the long wings cover the short body. It needs spread-level options approval (Options risks and approval levels: what brokers check and why).
Conditions that hurt the position
A move away from the middle strike. Beyond either wing the whole debit is lost. A butterfly centred at today's price loses if the stock trends in either direction.
A rise in implied volatility before expiration, which lowers the butterfly's value even if the stock has not moved.
Wide bid-ask spreads, which can take a fifth of the debit or more.
Closing early. The position has little profit to give until the last week, so an early exit, even at the right price, collects a fraction of the maximum.
A close at the middle strike with the position still open, where pin risk replaces the maximum gain with an unknown share position.
Compared with its neighbours
| Position | Legs | Opened for | Maximum gain | Maximum loss | Pays most when |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long call butterfly | 4 | Debit ($0.93) | Spacing − debit ($4.07) | Debit ($0.93) | Stock at the middle strike |
| Iron butterfly | 4 | Credit ($4.05) | Credit ($4.05) | Spacing − credit ($0.95) | Stock at the middle strike |
| Iron condor | 4 | Credit | Credit | Width − credit | Stock anywhere in a range |
| Calendar | 2 | Debit | Not fixed | Debit | Stock at the strike, IV up |
| Short straddle | 2 | Credit | Credit | Not limited | Stock at the strike |
The iron butterfly has the same payoff shape built differently: sell a $100 put and a $100 call, buy a $95 put and a $105 call. It is opened for a credit of $4.05 and its maximum loss is $0.95. The two cents of difference from the call butterfly are interest on the cash involved; the positions are equivalent by Put-call parity: the link between calls, puts and the stock. A butterfly made entirely of puts costs $0.92 here.
An iron condor is a butterfly with the body pulled apart into two strikes. It gives up the high peak for a flat top: a smaller gain over a wider range. A short straddle is a butterfly without wings: more premium and no limit on the loss. The wings are what the butterfly buyer pays to make the risk defined.
A butterfly can also be placed away from the current price, as a low-cost bet on a specific target. A $105 / $110 / $115 call butterfly on a $100 stock pays if the stock rises to about $110 and stays there, and loses its small debit otherwise.
How Finabase does it
Finabase shows the inputs for a butterfly on one screen. Open an option chain such as AAPL options, choose an expiration, and find three evenly spaced strikes around the price you have in mind. For a long call butterfly, the cost at current quotes is the ask of the lower call plus the ask of the higher call minus twice the bid of the middle call. The bid and ask columns show how wide each strike's spread is, and the volume and open interest columns show whether those strikes trade at all. In-the-money contracts are shaded.
Finabase does not price a butterfly as a package, draw its payoff, compute its break-evens or show Greeks: the figures on this page come from the formulas above and the Black-Scholes model with the stated inputs. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.
Frequently asked questions
What is the maximum loss on a long butterfly spread?
The net debit paid. It is lost in full if the stock finishes at or below the lowest strike or at or above the highest.
Why is a butterfly so cheap compared with its maximum gain?
Because the maximum gain needs the stock to finish at one exact price. In the example the modelled chance of finishing between the break-evens was about 30%, and of finishing within a dollar of the peak, under 8%.
Is a butterfly spread long or short volatility?
Short. A long butterfly gains from the stock staying still and from implied volatility falling, and loses value when implied volatility rises.
What is the difference between a butterfly and an iron butterfly?
A butterfly uses all calls or all puts and is opened for a debit. An iron butterfly uses puts below the middle strike and calls above, and is opened for a credit. With the same strikes the payoffs are the same.
Should a butterfly be held to expiration?
Holding to expiration is the only way to receive the full payoff, and it is also where pin risk and leftover share positions arise. Closing shortly before expiration gives up part of the peak to avoid them.
Summary
A long butterfly buys one option at a lower strike, sells two at a middle strike and buys one at a higher strike. Its maximum loss is the debit and its maximum gain is the strike spacing minus the debit, reached only at the middle strike on the expiration date. In the example, $0.93 bought a tent with a $4.07 peak at $100 and break-evens at $95.93 and $104.07, with a modelled chance of about 30% of finishing between them. Most of the profit appears in the final week, four contracts make costs a large fraction of the debit, and a close at the middle strike leaves the outcome to assignment.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
You buy one $45 call for $6.10, sell two $50 calls for $2.90 each, and buy one $55 call for $1.00. What is the net debit?
- $1.30
- $4.20
- $7.10
Show the answer
A. $1.30 6.10 + 1.00 − 2 × 2.90 = 7.10 − 5.80 = $1.30 a share, or $130 per butterfly. That debit is also the maximum loss.
For that butterfly ($45 / $50 / $55, debit $1.30), what is the maximum gain and where does it occur?
- $5.00 a share, anywhere between $45 and $55
- $3.70 a share, only with the stock at exactly $50 at expiration
- $1.30 a share, at $50
Show the answer
B. $3.70 a share, only with the stock at exactly $50 at expiration Maximum gain is the strike spacing minus the debit: 5.00 − 1.30 = $3.70. It is reached only at the middle strike. On either side the profit falls by a dollar for each dollar the stock is away from $50.
What are the break-evens of the $45 / $50 / $55 butterfly bought for $1.30?
- $43.70 and $56.30
- $48.70 and $51.30
- $46.30 and $53.70
Show the answer
C. $46.30 and $53.70 Lower strike plus the debit and higher strike minus the debit: 45 + 1.30 = $46.30 and 55 − 1.30 = $53.70. Outside that range the position loses, up to the debit.
The stock sits exactly at the middle strike from the day a 45-day butterfly is opened. When does most of the profit appear?
- Evenly, a little each day
- In the first week
- In the last week before expiration
Show the answer
C. In the last week before expiration The two short at-the-money calls keep most of their time value until late. In the lesson the butterfly was worth $0.93 at entry, $2.15 with seven days left and $5.00 at expiration, so more than two-thirds of the gain came in the final week.
A $95 / $100 / $105 call butterfly is held through expiration and the stock closes at $102. What position is left afterwards?
- Short 100 shares
- Long 100 shares
- No shares
Show the answer
A. Short 100 shares The long $95 call is exercised (buy 100 shares) and both short $100 calls are assigned (sell 200 shares). The $105 call expires worthless. The net is short 100 shares, exposed to the next session’s opening price.
Sources and further reading
- The Options Clearing Corporation — Options Disclosure Document (Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options)
- Options Industry Council — Long call butterfly
- FINRA Rule 4210 — Margin requirements
- Black, F. and Scholes, M., The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities, Journal of Political Economy 81(3), 1973
- Hull, J., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapter on trading strategies involving options
