Trading · Options
Volatility skew: why implied volatility differs by strike
What the volatility skew and smile are, why downside puts on stocks carry higher implied volatility than upside calls, how to read it on a real SPY chain, and its limits.
On this page
Volatility skew is the pattern of implied volatility across the strikes of one expiration. A pricing model assumes a stock has one volatility. The market disagrees: on stocks and stock indexes, puts far below the current price trade at higher implied volatilities than options at the money, and calls far above it trade at lower ones.
This is not a detail for specialists. It changes what protection costs, what selling an upside call pays, and how the two legs of a spread compare. A collar that looks as if it should cost nothing does not. A put spread that looks symmetric is not. And when a headline says "implied volatility is 20%", the skew is the reason that figure fits only one strike.
This page shows the shape on a real SPY chain, explains where it comes from, and sets out what it does and does not tell you.
The idea: one stock, many volatilities
Take every option of one expiration on one stock. Solve each one's price for its implied volatility, as the Implied volatility (IV): what it is and how to read it lesson describes, and plot the results against the strike. If the Black-Scholes model described the world, you would get a flat line: one stock, one volatility. You do not.
The line that slopes down from left to right is the usual shape for a stock or a stock index. Low strikes, which are out-of-the-money puts, sit high. High strikes, which are out-of-the-money calls, sit low. A market where both extremes are priced richly gives the U-shaped smile.
An implied volatility is a price in other units. A higher implied volatility on low strikes means one thing: per unit of model risk, downside options cost more.
How it works
Reading a real chain
On November 17, 2026, SPY closed at $732.44. The table shows the implied volatility reported on the Finabase option chain for the December 18 expiration, 31 days later. Strikes below the price use the put, strikes above it the call, because out-of-the-money options have the tightest quotes and the most trading.
| Strike | Percent of SPY price | Option | Bid / ask | Implied volatility |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $600 | 81.9% | Put | $1.52 / $1.55 | 41.0% |
| $650 | 88.7% | Put | $3.16 / $3.21 | 32.4% |
| $700 | 95.6% | Put | $8.26 / $8.35 | 24.8% |
| $730 | 99.7% | Put | $16.04 / $16.20 | 20.5% |
| $750 | 102.4% | Call | $8.74 / $8.86 | 18.7% |
| $770 | 105.1% | Call | $2.64 / $2.71 | 16.3% |
| $800 | 109.2% | Call | $0.28 / $0.29 | 15.2% |
The implied volatility falls at every step from left to right. A put about 4% below the price (the $700 strike) trades at 24.8%. A call about 5% above it (the $770 strike) trades at 16.3%. The same distance from the price, in opposite directions, and a gap of 8.5 volatility points. At the far right the curve flattens: the $790 and $800 calls are both near 15.2%.
What the skew does to prices
Volatility points are abstract. Dollars are not.
The percentages are large because far out-of-the-money options are almost all volatility value. The effect on at-the-money options is small by comparison.
How traders measure it
There is no single skew number, but three conventions are common.
- By moneyness: the implied volatility at 90% of the price minus the at-the-money figure. On the SPY chain above, 30.8% at $660 (90.1% of the price) against 20.5% is about 10 points.
- By delta: the implied volatility of the put with a delta of −0.25 minus that of the call with a delta of +0.25. Dealers call the pair a risk reversal. Using delta puts strikes on different stocks and expirations on a comparable footing.
- As a ratio: the out-of-the-money put's implied volatility divided by the at-the-money one.
Add the dimension of time, with a curve for every expiration, and you have the volatility surface. Skews are usually steepest in the nearest expirations and flatter further out.
Why the skew exists
Demand for protection. Investors who own stocks buy puts as insurance and sell calls to earn income. Both flows push the same way: puts up, calls down. Dealers who take the other side charge for carrying the risk.
Volatility rises when prices fall. A falling market is usually a more volatile market. An option that pays off after a drop will be alive in a higher-volatility world than one that pays off after a rise, and its price allows for that.
Crashes. Prices fall faster than they rise. A model with one volatility and smooth price paths gives almost no chance to a drop of 20% in a day. On October 19, 1987 the S&P 500 fell 20.5% in a single session. Before that day, index options showed little skew. Afterwards the skew appeared and never left, a change documented by Rubinstein (1994). The market had learned what the model omitted and began charging for it.
Fatter tails. More generally, large moves in both directions occur more often than a bell curve allows. Where both tails are feared about equally, as in many currency pairs, both wings rise and the result is a smile.
Where it shows up in positions
- Collars. Buying a put 5% below the price and selling a call 5% above it does not net to zero, because the put is priced at a higher volatility. To pay for the put, the call has to be closer to the price than the put is. See Collar: capping the loss on a stock by capping the gain.
- Vertical spreads. In a put spread, the lower strike has the higher implied volatility. A bear put spread buys the lower volatility and sells the higher one, which reduces its cost. A bull put credit spread does the reverse. See Vertical spreads: bull call, bear put and credit spreads explained.
- Protective puts. The further out of the money the put, the more of its price is skew.
- The VIX. The index is computed from a whole strip of S&P 500 options, puts and calls, so a steeper skew lifts it even when at-the-money volatility is unchanged.
Where it fails
It is not a forecast. The skew is always there in index options. A steep skew says protection is in demand and dear. Studies of whether it predicts returns give weak and mixed results, and a skew was in place before every rally of the past decades as well as before every fall.
The wings are thinly traded. The $600 put in the table costs about $1.50. A cent or two of bid-ask spread moves its implied volatility noticeably, and for strikes further out the figure can be an artifact of a stale quote.
Comparing skews needs care. A 10-point skew on a stock with 60% at-the-money volatility is flat in relative terms; on an index at 15% it is steep. Compare at the same delta and the same time to expiration.
It changes with the market. When the stock moves, the implied volatility at a fixed strike does not stay put. After a fall, at-the-money options are now the strikes that used to be out-of-the-money puts, and the whole curve usually lifts as well. Greeks computed with one fixed volatility miss this.
Individual stocks differ. Single-stock skews are usually flatter than index skews. Stocks with a takeover offer, a binary drug approval or heavy speculative call buying can show a reverse skew, with calls at higher implied volatilities than puts. Many commodities do too, because their price shocks are upward.
Compared with its neighbours
| Term | Varies across | Typical shape | Shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volatility skew | Strikes, one expiration | Downward slope (stocks, indexes) | The relative price of downside options |
| Volatility smile | Strikes, one expiration | U shape (currencies, some stocks) | Both tails priced richly |
| Term structure | Expirations, one strike | Upward in calm markets, inverted in stress | When the movement is expected |
| Volatility surface | Strikes and expirations | Both of the above together | The full set of implied volatilities |
| IV rank | Time, one series | A score from 0 to 100 | Today against the past year |
How Finabase does it
The data for a skew is on every Finabase option chain. Open SPY options, choose an expiration, set Strikes each side to 20, 50 or All, and read the implied volatility column down the put side below the price and down the call side above it. In-the-money cells are shaded, which makes the out-of-the-money half of each side easy to pick out. The table and chart on this page were built from one such chain, frozen on November 18, 2026 with the closing quotes of the day before.
Finabase does not draw a skew or smile chart, compute a 25-delta risk reversal or show a volatility surface. The implied volatilities are reported by the quote provider and may be delayed; far out-of-the-money contracts with wide spreads or no bid can show erratic values.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a volatility skew and a volatility smile?
A smile is symmetric: implied volatility is lowest at the money and rises on both sides. A skew is lopsided: one side is higher than the other. Stock and index options show a skew with the higher side on low strikes.
Why are out-of-the-money puts more expensive than out-of-the-money calls?
Because more investors want to buy downside protection than upside exposure, because volatility tends to rise when prices fall, and because markets drop more suddenly than they climb. All three raise what sellers demand for puts.
Does a steep skew mean the market will fall?
No. It means protection is expensive. The skew has been present in index options continuously since 1987, through rising and falling markets alike.
Do all stocks have the same skew?
No. Indexes have the steepest and most stable skews. Individual stocks are usually flatter and can reverse when call buying dominates or a large upward jump is possible.
Summary
The volatility skew is the way implied volatility changes from strike to strike within one expiration. On stocks and indexes it slopes down: one-month SPY options on November 17, 2026 showed 41.0% at a strike 18% below the price, 20.5% at the money and 15.2% at a strike 9% above it. The slope comes from demand for protection, from volatility rising in falling markets and from crash risk that single-volatility models leave out, and it has been a fixture since 1987. It sets the real cost of puts, collars and spreads. It measures the price of protection, and it does not predict a decline.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A stock trades at $100. Its $90 put has an implied volatility of 34% and its $110 call 24%, same expiration. What does this say?
- The market expects the stock to fall to $90
- Per unit of model risk, the market charges more for downside options than for upside ones
- The $110 call is mispriced and should be bought
Show the answer
B. Per unit of model risk, the market charges more for downside options than for upside ones Implied volatility is a price in other units. A higher figure on the low strike means downside protection is dearer. That is the normal state of stock and index options, not a forecast and not a mistake.
Why did a persistent skew appear in US index options after October 1987?
- A one-day fall of about 20% showed that models with one volatility and smooth prices badly understated crash risk
- Regulators required puts to be priced above calls
- Interest rates rose, which makes puts more valuable
Show the answer
A. A one-day fall of about 20% showed that models with one volatility and smooth prices badly understated crash risk Before the crash, index options showed little skew. After the S&P 500 fell 20.5% in one session, sellers of downside puts demanded more, and the higher implied volatility on low strikes has remained ever since.
An investor wants a collar: buy a put 5% below the stock price and sell a call 5% above it. With a typical stock skew, what happens?
- The call premium exceeds the put premium, so the collar pays a large credit
- The two premiums are equal, so the collar is free
- The put costs more than the call brings in, so the call strike must be moved closer to make it free
Show the answer
C. The put costs more than the call brings in, so the call strike must be moved closer to make it free The put is priced at a higher implied volatility than the call at the same distance. In the SPY example a put 4% below the price traded at 24.8% and a call 5% above at 16.3%. To collect enough to pay for the put, the call has to sit nearer the price.
The $600 SPY put in the lesson is quoted $1.52 bid, $1.55 ask with 41.0% implied volatility. Why treat implied volatilities even further out of the money with caution?
- Because far strikes are not allowed to trade
- Because the options are so cheap that a cent of spread or a stale quote moves the implied volatility a lot
- Because implied volatility cannot exceed 40%
Show the answer
B. Because the options are so cheap that a cent of spread or a stale quote moves the implied volatility a lot A far out-of-the-money option is worth little, and nearly all of that is volatility value. Small pricing differences translate into large changes in the implied volatility solved from the price, so the far wings of a skew are the least reliable part.
Sources and further reading
- SPY option chain for the December 18, 2026 expiration, quotes of November 17, 2026 (Finabase option chain, frozen; strikes $600 to $800)
- Rubinstein, M., Implied Binomial Trees, Journal of Finance 49(3), 1994
- Hull, J., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapter on volatility smiles
- Report of the Presidential Task Force on Market Mechanisms (the Brady Report), January 1988
- Cboe — VIX index methodology
