Trading · Rules and regulations
Failures to deliver: Regulation SHO close-outs and threshold lists
What a fail to deliver is under T+1 settlement, the Rule 204 deadlines for closing it out, how a stock gets on a threshold list, and how to read the SEC’s fails data.
On this page
When you buy shares, you expect them in your account the next business day. Almost always they arrive. When they do not, because the seller's broker did not deliver them to the clearing house on time, the result is a fail to deliver. The buyer still owns the trade and still gets paid any dividends through the broker, but the shares have not moved.
Fails are a normal, small part of a market that settles millions of trades a day. They also have a reputation, because persistent fails can be a sign of short selling without borrowed shares, the practice known as naked short selling. Regulation SHO sets deadlines for closing fails out and publishes lists of stocks where they have built up. This lesson explains those deadlines, the list, and what the public data can and cannot show.
What a fail is
US stock trades settle on T+1: one business day after the trade, the seller's shares move to the buyer and the buyer's cash to the seller, through the clearing house (NSCC, part of DTCC). The lesson on T+1 settlement: trade date, settlement date and why they matter covers the process.
A fail to deliver is a seller's side that does not settle on time. The causes are mostly mundane:
- Paperwork and timing. Shares held in certificate form, transfers between brokers, or processing errors delay delivery.
- Long sellers who do not yet have the shares. An investor sells shares that are still in transit from another trade or account.
- Market makers. A market maker that sells to meet demand, as it must to keep quoting, may not have shares to deliver by the settlement date.
- Short sellers who have not borrowed. A short sale requires the broker to have located shares that can be borrowed before the sale (Rule 203(b)(1)). If the borrow falls through, or the locate was not honoured, the sale fails.
The clearing house nets each broker's obligations across all its trades in a stock, so the fails that appear in the data are net balances, not individual trades.
The close-out deadlines
Regulation SHO's Rule 204, adopted in its permanent form in 2009, sets deadlines by which a broker must close out a fail by buying or borrowing shares of the same kind and amount.
- Short sales: by the beginning of regular trading hours on the settlement day after the settlement date. With T+1 settlement, a short sale on Monday that fails to settle on Tuesday must be closed out by the open on Wednesday.
- Long sales and bona fide market making: by the beginning of regular trading hours on the third consecutive settlement day after the settlement date, which is T+4.
The penalty for missing the deadline falls on the broker's future business, not its past. Under Rule 204(b), until the fail is closed out and the purchase has settled, the broker may not accept or make a short sale in that stock, for anyone, without first borrowing or arranging to borrow the shares. A routine locate is no longer enough. Because that is costly and slow, brokers have a strong incentive to close fails on time.
Threshold securities
The rules add a second layer for stocks where fails pile up. Under Rule 203(c)(6), a stock becomes a threshold security when, for five consecutive settlement days, aggregate fails at a clearing agency are:
- at least 10,000 shares, and
- at least 0.5% of the company's shares outstanding,
and the stock appears on a list published by its listing market. Nasdaq and NYSE publish threshold lists every settlement day.
Once a stock is a threshold security, Rule 203(b)(3) applies a harder rule: a fail that has lasted 13 consecutive settlement days must be closed out immediately by buying shares, and until it is, the broker cannot short the stock without first borrowing. A stock comes off the list once it no longer meets the test for five consecutive settlement days.
Reading the SEC's fails data
The SEC publishes fails-to-deliver data for every security, in files covering half a month, with a delay. Each row gives a settlement date, a security and the total balance of fails at the clearing house on that date.
The data is easy to misuse. Points to keep in mind:
- It is a balance, not new fails. A fail of 100,000 shares that lasts three days appears on three days. Adding the daily figures overstates fails threefold.
- It does not say who failed or why. The SEC notes that fails are not necessarily the result of short selling. Long sales, market making and operational problems all produce them.
- It is net. The clearing house nets brokers' obligations, so gross fails between individual firms are larger than the published figure, and some fails are resolved bilaterally outside it.
- Fails in ETFs are common and different. Authorised participants can create new ETF shares to deliver, and often settle fails that way a few days later; ETF fails are routinely large without any sign of abuse.
Large, persistent fails in a single company's stock, especially together with a high Short interest: how it is reported, and why short volume is different figure and expensive borrowing, are worth noticing. They can mean that shares are hard to borrow and short sellers or market makers are struggling to deliver. They do not on their own prove naked short selling, and they cannot be used to calculate how many "fake shares" exist, a claim that circulates around heavily shorted stocks.
Why it matters to an investor
For most investors, fails are invisible. A buyer whose purchase fails still has the trade and an economic claim to the shares; the broker usually covers the gap from its own inventory or credit, and the close-out rules force the delivery within days. If a dividend is paid during a fail, the broker pays the buyer the cash equivalent.
The topic matters more for traders in heavily shorted stocks. A wave of forced close-outs, either under Rule 204 or from brokers recalling loaned shares, is buying that does not care about price, and it is one of the mechanisms behind a Short squeeze: how it works, warning signs and the GameStop case. Threshold lists and fails data are among the few public windows into how tight the borrowing market for a stock is.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not publish fails-to-deliver data or threshold lists. The volume history on any chart, such as GME, shows when trading surged, which can be compared with the SEC's fails files for the same dates. A price alert can watch a level in a stock where you expect forced buying.
Frequently asked questions
What is a fail to deliver?
A trade in which the seller's broker does not deliver the shares to the clearing house by the settlement date, which is one business day after the trade for US stocks. The trade remains valid; the delivery is late.
Are failures to deliver the same as naked short selling?
No. Naked short selling, selling short without borrowing or arranging to borrow, can cause fails, but so do long sales, market making and processing problems. The SEC notes that fails are not necessarily the result of short selling.
What is the Reg SHO threshold list?
A daily list published by each listing market of stocks with fails of at least 10,000 shares and 0.5% of shares outstanding for five consecutive settlement days. Fails in those stocks that last 13 consecutive settlement days must be closed out by buying shares.
How long can a fail to deliver last?
Rule 204 requires a short-sale fail to be closed out by the start of trading on the day after the settlement date, and a long-sale or market-making fail by the third settlement day after it. Fails can persist longer when brokers close them out and new fails arise, which is why the published balances can stay high.
Summary
- A fail to deliver is a sale whose shares are not delivered by settlement, one business day after the trade.
- Rule 204 requires short-sale fails to be closed out by the open on T+2 and long-sale and market-making fails by the open on T+4; missing the deadline forces the broker to pre-borrow before shorting the stock.
- A stock becomes a threshold security after five consecutive settlement days of fails of at least 10,000 shares and 0.5% of shares outstanding; in such stocks, 13-day fails must be bought in.
- The SEC's fails data is a net daily balance and does not show who failed or why.
- Persistent fails point to tight borrowing; they do not prove naked short selling.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A short sale on Monday fails to settle on Tuesday. Under Rule 204, by when must the broker close it out?
- By the start of regular trading on Wednesday
- By the end of the following week
- Only when the buyer complains
Show the answer
A. By the start of regular trading on Wednesday Short-sale fails must be closed out by the beginning of regular trading hours on the settlement day after the settlement date: T+2 under T+1 settlement.
A company has 20 million shares outstanding. Which daily fail level meets both threshold tests?
- 8,000 shares
- 60,000 shares
- 120,000 shares
Show the answer
C. 120,000 shares The tests are at least 10,000 shares and at least 0.5% of shares outstanding: 0.5% of 20 million is 100,000. Only 120,000 passes both.
The SEC fails file shows 100,000 shares failing on each of three consecutive days. How many shares of new fails does that show?
- 300,000
- Up to 100,000; it may be one fail that lasted three days
- None
Show the answer
B. Up to 100,000; it may be one fail that lasted three days The data is a daily balance. A fail that persists appears on each day it is outstanding, so adding the days overstates it.
What happens to a broker that misses a Rule 204 close-out deadline?
- Nothing
- It must borrow or arrange to borrow before any further short sale in that stock until the fail is closed out
- The trade is cancelled
Show the answer
B. It must borrow or arrange to borrow before any further short sale in that stock until the fail is closed out Rule 204(b) imposes a pre-borrow requirement on the broker for that security until the close-out purchase settles.
Sources and further reading
- SEC Regulation SHO Rule 204 (17 CFR 242.204) — close-out requirement
- SEC Regulation SHO Rule 203 (17 CFR 242.203) — locate requirement (203(b)(1)), threshold-security close-out (203(b)(3)), threshold security definition (203(c)(6))
- SEC — Fails-to-deliver data (published twice a month)
- Nasdaq Trader — Regulation SHO threshold security list
- NYSE — threshold securities list
- Finabase worked example — illustrative fails and threshold test computed in the Finabase figure script (scripts/learn/figures/trading-mechanics.ts)
