Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Trading · Options

Collar: capping the loss on a stock by capping the gain

How a collar pairs a bought put with a sold call on shares you own, how to compute the floor, cap and break-even, and what assignment, skew and taxes change.

On this page
  1. The idea: sell the top to pay for the bottom
  2. How it works
  3. Conditions that hurt the position
  4. Compared with its neighbours
  5. How Finabase does it
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Summary
  8. Check your understanding

A collar is three things held together: shares of a stock, a put bought below the current price, and a call sold above it. The put sets a floor under the position. The call pays for the put, and in exchange puts a ceiling over it. Until expiration the position's result is confined to a band between the two strikes.

The appeal is the cost. A Protective put: insuring a stock position with a put option alone can use up a large part of a stock's expected return. A collar finances that put with premium from the call, often completely, in which case it is called a zero-cost collar. Nothing is free, though: the payment is the upside beyond the call strike, which now belongs to someone else.

This page works one collar through in full, then looks at a real one on SPY, where the put turns out to cost three times what the call brings in.

The idea: sell the top to pay for the bottom

A stock's possible outcomes run from a total loss to an open-ended gain. A collar trades away both ends. You buy a put, which transfers the outcomes below its strike to the put's seller. You sell a call, which transfers the outcomes above its strike to the call's buyer. What is left is the middle.

Collar at expiration: stock $100, buy $95 put (1.92), sell $105 call (2.42) −$25 −$20 −$15 −$10 −$5 $0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $75 $80 $85 $90 $95 $100 $105 $110 $115 $120 $125 $95 $105 Stock alone Collar: stock + long put + short call Max loss −$4.50 Break-even $99.50 Max gain +$5.50 Stock price at expiration Profit / loss per share
Illustrative collar at expiration: 100 shares at $100, one 45-day $95 put bought for $1.92 and one $105 call sold for $2.42, a net credit of $0.50. Profit and loss per share, before commissions.

The collar's line has three segments. Below $95 it is flat: the put absorbs every further dollar of loss. Between $95 and $105 it follows the stock, shifted up by the $0.50 net credit. Above $105 it is flat again: the shares are worth more, but they have been promised to the call's buyer at $105.

A collar is a Protective put: insuring a stock position with a put option and a covered call on the same shares at once. It has the floor of the first and the cap of the second.

How it works

The example uses the same illustrative prices as the other strategy lessons: a stock at $100, 45 days to expiration, 30% implied volatility, a 4% interest rate, no dividend, Black-Scholes values rounded to the cent.

Stock at expiration Shares Long $95 put Short $105 call Position Shares alone
$80 −$2,000 +$1,308 +$242 −$450 −$2,000
$95 −$500 −$192 +$242 −$450 −$500
$99.50 −$50 −$192 +$242 $0 −$50
$100 $0 −$192 +$242 +$50 $0
$105 +$500 −$192 +$242 +$550 +$500
$120 +$2,000 −$192 −$1,258 +$550 +$2,000

For 45 days the position can lose at most 4.5% and gain at most 5.5%. For small moves it behaves like about 36 shares instead of 100: the put has a delta of −0.28 and the short call −0.36, and both are subtracted from the shares' delta of 1.

Why the example pays a credit, and real collars often do not

In the example, a call 5% above the price is worth more than a put 5% below it, so the collar brings in money. That is a feature of a model with one volatility for every strike. Real option markets charge more for downside protection: the Volatility skew: why implied volatility differs by strike lesson shows the pattern. A real chain makes the point.

That asymmetry is the practical reality of collars on stock indexes and most large stocks: for a zero cost, the cap sits closer than the floor.

Early assignment

The put is yours, so it carries no assignment risk. The call is sold, and US stock options are American-style: its buyer can exercise at any time.

Early exercise of a call is rational mainly in one situation: the call is in the money, and the stock is about to go ex-dividend with a dividend larger than the call's remaining time value. The call's owner exercises the day before to collect the dividend. If your call is assigned, your shares are sold at the strike and the dividend goes with them. The collar ends early at its maximum gain, leaving you with a put you may no longer need.

Assignment is also a sale for tax purposes. An investor who built the collar to avoid selling low-cost shares should watch an in-the-money short call closely as an ex-dividend date nears. Option exercise and assignment: how it works and when it happens covers the mechanics.

At expiration

One of three things happens (US rules, 2026: options in the money by $0.01 or more are exercised automatically).

  • Below the put strike: the put is exercised and the shares are sold at $95, unless you sell the put first to keep them.
  • Between the strikes: both options expire worthless and you still own the shares, with no protection from then on.
  • Above the call strike: the call is assigned and the shares are sold at $105.

Two of the three outcomes end with the shares gone. An investor who wants to keep them has to act before expiration: sell the put, or buy back the call, or move both to a later date.

Costs

A collar has two option legs, so two bid-ask spreads and two commissions to open, and up to two more to close or roll. In the SPY example the put's spread was $0.09 and the call's $0.07. Rolling a collar every month or two repeats those costs each time. Brokers typically require the options approval level for covered calls and bought puts, among the lowest tiers, because the shares cover the call (Options risks and approval levels: what brokers check and why).

Taxes (US, 2026)

Collars interact with several tax rules. IRS Publication 550 describes them. A collar with strikes very close to the current price on shares with a large gain may be treated as a constructive sale, taxing the gain as if the shares had been sold. Shares, put and call can be offsetting positions under the straddle rules, which defer losses and can affect the holding period. And dividends on collared shares may lose their qualified status. The details depend on strikes, dates and the holding period. This page does not give tax advice.

Conditions that hurt the position

A strong rally. Above the call strike every further dollar belongs to the call's buyer. In the example a rise to $120 earns $550 against $2,000 for the shares alone.

A slow decline that stops at the floor. The collar loses its maximum of $450 and the investor still owns shares now worth $95, with the protection expired.

Repeated renewal in a rising market. Each time the call is assigned or bought back at a loss, gains are given up. A stock position that is collared permanently should be expected to return less than the stock, with less risk; whether that trade is worthwhile depends on why the hedge is there.

Early assignment before a dividend, as above.

A fall in the stock with a rise in implied volatility, when you want to remove the collar. Before expiration the put will have gained, but buying back the call and selling the put both cross spreads that widen in a sell-off.

Compared with its neighbours

Position Up-front cost Loss Gain Assignment risk
Shares alone None To zero Unlimited None
Protective put Put premium Capped Unlimited None
Covered call Receives premium Nearly all Capped Short call
Collar Small debit or credit Capped Capped Short call
Bull call spread Net debit Capped (debit) Capped Short call

The last row is not a coincidence. By Put-call parity: the link between calls, puts and the stock, shares plus a $95 put pay like a $95 call plus cash. Add a short $105 call and the collar has the payoff of a $95/$105 bull call spread plus cash. A collar is a way of turning shares you already hold into a spread, without selling them.

How Finabase does it

A Finabase option chain shows both legs of a collar on one screen. On SPY options, choose an expiration and widen Strikes each side until a put strike below the price and a call strike above it are both in view. The put's ask, on the right, less the call's bid, on the left, is the net cost at current quotes; the formulas above turn it into the floor and the cap. The implied volatility column shows why the two premiums differ: the SPY collar on this page was computed from a chain frozen on November 18, 2026.

Finabase does not build or price multi-leg positions, does not draw a payoff diagram for your own strikes, and does not show ex-dividend dates on the option chain; the dividends calendar lists them. Signed-in users can star both contracts to follow them on the options page. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.

Frequently asked questions

Is a zero-cost collar really free?

It has no net premium. Its cost is the gain above the call strike, which you give up, plus trading costs and possible tax effects.

Can the shares in a collar be called away?

Yes. If the short call is in the money at expiration it is assigned and the shares are sold at the call strike. It can also be assigned earlier, most often just before an ex-dividend date.

How is a collar different from a covered call?

A covered call sells the upside and keeps almost all of the downside. A collar uses the call's premium to buy a put, so the downside is capped too.

How long should a collar last?

There is no rule. Short collars can be adjusted often and pay more spread and commission over a year. Long collars cost less to maintain and fix the band for longer, while the stock moves away from the strikes.

Summary

A collar holds shares, a bought put below the price and a sold call above it. The loss is capped at the stock price minus the put strike plus the net cost, and the gain at the call strike minus the stock price minus the net cost. With model prices the example collar confined a $100 stock to between −$4.50 and +$5.50 for 45 days and paid a $0.50 credit. On a real SPY chain the put cost three times the call, because downside options carry higher implied volatility, so the floor was further away than the cap. The short call can be assigned early, two of the three outcomes at expiration sell the shares, and US tax rules on constructive sales and straddles can apply.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. You own 100 shares at $60, buy a $55 put for $1.20 and sell a $66 call for $0.90. What are the maximum loss and maximum gain per share?

    1. Maximum loss $5.30, maximum gain $5.70
    2. Maximum loss $5.00, maximum gain $6.00
    3. Maximum loss $4.70, maximum gain $6.30
    Show the answer

    A. Maximum loss $5.30, maximum gain $5.70 Net cost = 1.20 − 0.90 = $0.30 debit. Maximum loss = 60 − 55 + 0.30 = $5.30. Maximum gain = 66 − 60 − 0.30 = $5.70. A net debit widens the loss and narrows the gain by the same amount.

  2. On the SPY chain in the lesson, a put 4.4% below the price cost $8.35 and a call 5.1% above it brought in $2.64. What does that imply for a zero-cost collar?

    1. It is impossible to build one
    2. The put strike must be moved closer to the price
    3. The call must be sold closer to the price than the put is, so the cap is nearer than the floor
    Show the answer

    C. The call must be sold closer to the price than the put is, so the cap is nearer than the floor Downside puts trade at higher implied volatility than upside calls. To collect enough premium to pay for the put, the call has to be nearer the money, the $750 strike, 2.4% above the price, in the example. The collar then gives up more upside than it removes downside.

  3. The short call of your collar is in the money and the stock goes ex-dividend tomorrow with a dividend larger than the call’s remaining time value. What is the main risk tonight?

    1. The put will be assigned
    2. The call may be exercised early, so the shares are sold at the strike and the dividend goes to the call’s owner
    3. The collar becomes unhedged on the downside
    Show the answer

    B. The call may be exercised early, so the shares are sold at the strike and the dividend goes to the call’s owner A call’s owner exercises early to capture a dividend when the dividend exceeds the time value they would give up. The assigned seller delivers the shares at the strike before the ex-dividend date and does not receive the dividend.

  4. A collar’s options expire with the stock between the two strikes. What is the investor’s position afterwards?

    1. Shares only, with no floor and no cap
    2. No shares: they are sold at the put strike
    3. Shares, still protected by the put
    Show the answer

    A. Shares only, with no floor and no cap Both options expire worthless. The investor keeps the shares and whatever net credit or debit the collar had, and the protection has ended. A new collar would have to be opened at the prices then on offer.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Options Clearing Corporation — Options Disclosure Document (Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options)
  2. Options Industry Council — Collar (protective collar)
  3. IRS Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses (constructive sales, straddles, qualified covered calls)
  4. FINRA Rule 2360 — Options
  5. SPY option chain for the December 18, 2026 expiration, quotes of November 17, 2026 (Finabase option chain, frozen)