Trading · Futures
Futures accounts and regulation: FCMs, the CFTC and your money
Who holds the money in a US futures account, how CFTC segregation rules and the NFA protect it, why SIPC does not, and how day-trading margin works.
On this page
- Who is who
- Segregation: customer money is not the firm's money
- What went wrong in 2011 and 2012, and what changed
- Opening a futures account
- Daily money movement: a worked example
- Day-trading margin and the end of the session
- Pitfalls
- Futures accounts compared with securities accounts
- How Finabase does it
- Frequently asked questions
- Summary
- Check your understanding
A stock account and a futures account can sit in the same brokerage app, but they are built on different laws. Stocks and stock options fall under the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), FINRA and, if the broker fails, the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC). Futures fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), the National Futures Association (NFA) and a different set of rules for what happens to customer money. The firm that holds that money is not a "broker-dealer" but a futures commission merchant (FCM).
This lesson follows an order and its margin from the customer to the clearinghouse, explains the segregation rules that keep customer money apart from the firm's own, and shows what changed after two FCMs lost customer money in 2011 and 2012. It ends with the practical differences a trader notices: the risk disclosure, day-trading margin, forced liquidation and why the pattern-day- trader rule never applied here. Everything is US law as of November 2026.
Who is who
| Party | Role | Regulated by |
|---|---|---|
| Futures commission merchant (FCM) | Accepts orders and customer money; carries positions; usually a clearing member | CFTC, NFA, exchange |
| Introducing broker (IB) | Solicits and accepts orders but may not hold customer money; passes accounts to an FCM | CFTC, NFA |
| Clearinghouse (CME Clearing) | Becomes buyer to every seller and seller to every buyer; collects margin from FCMs | CFTC (as a DCO) |
| Exchange (CME, NYMEX, COMEX, CBOT) | Lists contracts, runs the order book, sets price limits | CFTC (as a DCM) |
| CFTC | Federal regulator, created in 1974, writes the rules and brings enforcement cases | Congress |
| NFA | Self-regulatory organization: registration, audits, arbitration, the BASIC database | CFTC |
Many retail brokers are registered both as a broker-dealer (for securities) and as an FCM (for futures). Their apps show one login, but futures positions live in a separate futures account, and money moves between the two by transfer or sweep. That separation is what keeps each side under its own protection regime.
Segregation: customer money is not the firm's money
Section 4d of the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC Regulation 1.20 require an FCM to hold every dollar that futures customers deposit, plus any gains on their positions, in accounts titled as customer segregated funds, at a bank, a clearing organization or another FCM. The firm may not use that money for its own trading or to pay its own bills, and the bank must acknowledge in writing that the account holds customer funds. Customer money for futures on foreign exchanges is held under a separate regime (Part 30), and cleared swaps under another (Part 22).
FCMs must also meet capital rules. CFTC Regulation 1.17 sets a minimum adjusted net capital of $1 million, and higher amounts for larger firms tied to the margin their customers carry. Every FCM files financial reports, and the NFA publishes each firm's capital and segregated-fund figures on its website, so a customer can compare firms before opening an account.
What went wrong in 2011 and 2012, and what changed
Two failures tested segregation and found it weaker in practice than on paper.
- MF Global, a large FCM, filed for bankruptcy on October 31, 2011. About $1.6 billion of customer money was missing: the firm had used customer funds to meet its own obligations in its last days. US futures customers eventually recovered their segregated claims in full through the trustee's work, but many waited years.
- Peregrine Financial Group, a smaller FCM in Iowa, collapsed in July 2012 when its owner admitted to having forged bank statements for about two decades. Roughly $200 million of customer money that regulators believed existed did not.
The CFTC's 2013 customer-protection rule and NFA rules adopted at the same time closed the gaps those cases exposed:
- Banks holding customer funds confirm balances directly and electronically to regulators every day, so a forged statement no longer passes an audit.
- FCMs file a daily segregation statement and report twice a month on where customer money is invested.
- Each FCM must hold its own money, called residual interest, in the customer accounts as a buffer against customer deficits, and may not withdraw a large share of it without approval from senior management and notice to regulators.
- FCMs must publish a disclosure document on their business, risks and finances.
None of this removes the risk that an FCM fails. It makes it much harder for an FCM to fail with customer money missing.
Opening a futures account
US FCMs and introducing brokers follow a set sequence before a customer can trade.
- Risk disclosure. CFTC Regulation 1.55 requires the firm to give the standard risk disclosure statement and get a signed acknowledgment before opening the account. Its first warning is that a customer can lose all the money deposited and more.
- Know your customer. NFA Compliance Rule 2-30 requires the firm to ask about income, net worth, age and trading experience, and to give extra warnings to customers whose answers suggest futures may be unsuitable.
- Account agreement. It gives the FCM the right to raise margin at any time and to close positions without notice if the account is under-margined. Read that clause before the first trade: it is how losses beyond the deposit are contained, at the firm's chosen moment.
- Funding and permissions. Futures permissions are usually a separate approval from options approval in the securities account.
Registration of any firm or individual can be checked in the NFA's free BASIC database, which also lists disciplinary actions. A firm offering futures to US customers that does not appear there is not allowed to.
Daily money movement: a worked example
Futures are settled every day: the clearinghouse marks every position to the day's settlement price and moves the gain or loss in cash. The FCM passes it from or to the customer's account.
Day-trading margin and the end of the session
Exchange margin applies to positions held through the daily settlement. Many FCMs offer much lower day-trading margins for positions opened and closed within the same session, sometimes a small fraction of the exchange's figure. These are a credit decision by the broker, not an exchange rule, and they have two catches:
- At a cutoff before the session ends, set by the broker, any open position must have full exchange margin. Positions that do not are closed by the broker, at market, often in a busy minute.
- Low intraday margin raises leverage. With a day-trading margin of, say, 5% of the exchange margin, a move that would cost a fraction of an overnight deposit can exceed the whole intraday deposit.
The pattern-day-trader rule was a FINRA rule for securities margin accounts, and FINRA replaced it with intraday margin standards in 2026 (see Pattern day trader rule: the legacy PDT test and the 2026 replacement). Neither version ever applied to futures accounts, which is one reason active traders with small accounts used futures. The absence of that rule is not the absence of risk: the margin call does the same job, faster.
Pitfalls
- Assuming one login means one protection. Cash in the securities side of a dual account is SIPC-covered; cash moved to the futures side is not.
- Reading margin as the risk. Margin is the deposit the firm wants, not the most you can lose. The risk disclosure says so in its first paragraph.
- Ignoring the liquidation clause. The FCM may close positions without calling first, and the customer owes any deficit that remains.
- Using an unregistered offshore platform. Products that look like futures but are offered by firms outside CFTC registration carry none of the protections above. The CFTC keeps a list of unregistered foreign entities that have solicited US customers.
Futures accounts compared with securities accounts
| Feature | Futures account (FCM) | Securities account (broker-dealer) |
|---|---|---|
| Regulators | CFTC, NFA, exchanges | SEC, FINRA, exchanges |
| Customer money protection | Segregation (Reg 1.20); no insurance | Customer protection rule (Rule 15c3-3) plus SIPC up to $500,000 |
| Settlement of gains/losses | Daily, in cash | At trade settlement (T+1 for most stocks) |
| Margin | Performance bond set by the clearinghouse and FCM | A loan under Regulation T and FINRA Rule 4210 |
| Day-trading rule | None; broker day-trading margins | FINRA intraday margin (formerly the PDT rule) |
| Tax reporting | Aggregate profit or loss on regulated futures (Section 1256) | Trade-by-trade gains and losses |
The tax line is explained in Section 1256 contracts: futures, index options and the 60/40 rule. The comparison of cash and margin accounts on the securities side is in Cash vs margin accounts: differences, rules and which fits you.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not hold money or execute futures trades. The futures board and symbol pages such as ES=F show prices, and the November 5, 2026 example above uses the same continuous series. Anyone choosing a futures broker can check its registration in NFA BASIC and its capital and segregated funds in the NFA's FCM financial data, both linked in the sources.
Frequently asked questions
Who regulates futures in the United States?
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission, under the Commodity Exchange Act. The National Futures Association, a self-regulatory organization overseen by the CFTC, registers and audits the firms and individuals who deal with the public.
Is my futures account protected by SIPC?
No. SIPC does not cover futures contracts or the money held for them. Futures customers are protected by segregation of customer funds and, if a firm fails, by a pro rata distribution of the segregated property under bankruptcy rules.
What is a futures commission merchant?
A firm registered with the CFTC that accepts orders for futures and holds the customers' money and positions. It is the futures equivalent of a broker-dealer, and most are clearing members of the exchanges.
Does the pattern day trader rule apply to futures?
No. It was a FINRA rule for securities margin accounts and has been replaced by intraday margin standards. Futures brokers instead set day-trading margins and require full exchange margin for any position held past their cutoff.
What happened to customer money at MF Global?
The firm used customer funds for its own needs before it failed on October 31, 2011, leaving about $1.6 billion missing. The trustee later recovered enough for US futures customers' segregated claims to be paid in full, and the 2013 rules now require daily confirmation of customer balances directly from banks.
Summary
A US futures account is held at a futures commission merchant and regulated by the CFTC and the NFA, not the SEC and FINRA. Its main protection is segregation: Regulation 1.20 keeps customer money in labelled accounts apart from the firm's money, backed since 2013 by daily electronic bank confirmations, residual-interest buffers and public financial data. SIPC does not apply, and a failed FCM's customers share what is left. Gains and losses move in cash every night, as the two-micro example on November 5, 2026 showed (−$3,375 in one session), and the FCM may close an under-margined position without asking. The pattern-day-trader rule never applied; broker day-trading margins, and their end-of-session cutoff, take its place.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A brokerage app shows one login for stocks and futures. The futures commission merchant behind the futures side fails. What protects the cash in the futures account?
- SIPC, up to $250,000 of cash
- The segregation of customer funds; customers share the segregated property pro rata, with no insurance
- The FDIC
Show the answer
B. The segregation of customer funds; customers share the segregated property pro rata, with no insurance SIPC covers securities accounts at broker-dealers and expressly excludes futures. Futures customer money is protected by being held apart from the firm's money under CFTC Regulation 1.20, and in a failure customers share what is in the segregated pool.
Why did regulators start confirming FCM bank balances directly with the banks every day from 2013?
- Because Peregrine Financial had forged bank statements for years, and MF Global had used customer money before failing
- Because SIPC asked them to
- Because futures moved to T+1 settlement
Show the answer
A. Because Peregrine Financial had forged bank statements for years, and MF Global had used customer money before failing Both failures showed that reported segregated balances could differ from real ones. Electronic confirmation straight from the bank makes a forged statement useless, and daily segregation reports show a shortfall within a day.
A broker offers a day-trading margin far below exchange margin on MES. What happens to a position still open at the broker’s end-of-session cutoff if the account cannot cover full exchange margin?
- It becomes a pattern-day-trader violation
- It is held at the low margin until the next day
- The broker closes it, at market, around the cutoff
Show the answer
C. The broker closes it, at market, around the cutoff Day-trading margin is the broker's own credit decision for intraday positions only. Positions carried through the settlement need full exchange margin; the account agreement lets the broker liquidate what is not covered. The PDT rule was a securities rule and never applied to futures.
An account long two MES contracts holds $8,000 and the index future settles 337.5 points lower. What is in the account that night?
- $8,000: futures losses are only realized when the position is closed
- $4,625
- $6,312.50
Show the answer
B. $4,625 Futures are marked to market daily: −337.5 × $5 × 2 = −$3,375 moves out of the account the same evening, leaving $4,625 even though the position is still open.
Sources and further reading
- CFTC — Futures Commission Merchants (registrant overview)
- CFTC — 17 CFR 1.20 (futures customer funds to be segregated)
- CFTC — 17 CFR 1.55 (risk disclosure statement)
- CFTC — 17 CFR 1.17 (minimum financial requirements for FCMs)
- CFTC — Enhancing protections afforded customers and customer funds held by FCMs (final rule, 2013)
- NFA — BASIC (Background Affiliation Status Information Center)
- NFA — FCM financial information
- SIPC — What SIPC protects
- Finabase continuous E-mini S&P 500 settlements (ES=F), November 2026
