Trading · Futures
Futures vs options: obligation or right, payoff, margin and decay
A future against an option on the same market: obligation or right, straight or bent payoff, margin or premium, time decay and leverage.
On this page
A futures contract and an option are both derivatives, and both let a trader take a large position for a fraction of its value. They are often mentioned in the same breath. Their risks are not alike at all. A future is an obligation that gains and loses one for one with the market, in both directions, every day. An option is a right that the buyer pays for up front, which gains like the market on one side and stops losing on the other, and which loses value as time passes.
Everything else follows from that difference: how the payoff looks on a chart, what you put up to open the position, what time does to it, how "leverage" should be measured, and which jobs each one is suited to. This lesson puts the two side by side on the same market, the E-mini S&P 500, with one set of illustrative numbers.
Obligation against right
A long futures position commits you to buy the underlying at the agreed price on the delivery date, or, as almost everyone does, to close the position before then. The short side commits to sell. Both sides are bound, both post margin, and both are marked to market daily. Neither paid the other anything to enter.
A call option gives its buyer the right, not the duty, to buy at the strike price. The buyer pays the premium to the seller on day one. From then on the buyer can only lose what was paid; the seller, who collected that premium, carries the obligation to deliver if asked. The same holds for puts with "sell" in place of "buy". Derivatives explained: forwards, futures, options and swaps puts both families in context; Options basics: how calls and puts work, with payoff diagrams and Futures contracts explained: specs, clearing, expiry and settlement explain each in full.
Payoffs on one chart
The example uses the E-mini S&P 500 future (ES; see Stock index futures: ES, NQ, YM and RTY explained), $50 per index point, at 7,400, and options on it with a 7,400 strike and 45 days to expiration, priced with the Black-76 model at 18% implied volatility and a 4% rate. Both the call and the put come out at 185.64 points, or $9,282 a contract. These are illustrative numbers, not quotes.
| Future at expiration | Long future | Long 7,400 call | Short 7,400 put |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6,800 | −$30,000 | −$9,282 | −$20,718 |
| 7,000 | −$20,000 | −$9,282 | −$10,718 |
| 7,200 | −$10,000 | −$9,282 | −$718 |
| 7,400 | $0 | −$9,282 | +$9,282 |
| 7,600 | +$10,000 | +$718 | +$9,282 |
| 7,800 | +$20,000 | +$10,718 | +$9,282 |
| 8,000 | +$30,000 | +$20,718 | +$9,282 |
Three shapes, three different bets:
- The long future is linear. Every point up is +$50, every point down −$50, with no limit in either direction beyond the index reaching zero.
- The long call caps the loss at the premium, $9,282, and makes money only above 7,400 + 185.64 = 7,585.64. Above that it gains $50 a point like the future, always $9,282 behind it.
- The short put collects the premium and keeps all of it at or above 7,400. Below 7,400 − 185.64 = 7,214.36 it loses, and from there it loses $50 a point like the future, always $9,282 ahead of it.
The long future and the short put are both bullish, and both lose heavily in a fall. The call is bullish too, but its loss in a fall is fixed. That is the "nonlinear" payoff: the option's exposure to the market changes as the market moves (its delta changes, which is gamma), while the future's is always one for one.
Margin against premium
To open the future, both sides deposit initial margin, a performance bond set by the exchange and raised by brokers. It is not a payment and not a cost; it is collateral, and each day's gain or loss is added to or taken from it in cash. If the balance falls below the maintenance level, the account must be topped up. Suppose the requirement on one ES contract is $25,000 (an illustrative figure; CME publishes the current one and it changes with volatility). Futures margin and leverage: initial, maintenance and margin calls explains the mechanics.
To open the long call, the buyer pays $9,282 once. There are no margin calls, ever, on a long option, however far the market falls. The cost is that the money is gone: it is spent, not deposited.
To open the short put, the seller receives $9,282 but must post margin against the obligation, computed by the clearinghouse's risk model. As the market falls, that requirement rises, just as for a future.
Time decay
A future has no time value to lose. If ES is at 7,400 today and at 7,400 in 30 days, the future has made and lost nothing beyond any daily swings in between.
An option is different. Take the same 7,400 call and let 30 days pass with the future unchanged at 7,400. Under the same model its value falls from 185.64 points to 107.54: −$3,905 for the buyer and +$3,905 for the seller of the matching put, with nothing having happened in the market. That is theta, and it accelerates as expiration gets closer. The option buyer needs the market to move far enough, soon enough; the future holder only needs it to move the right way.
Measuring leverage honestly
"Leverage" is used loosely for both. Two measures are worth separating:
- Future: contract value 7,400 × $50 = $370,000. With $25,000 of margin, notional leverage is 370,000 / 25,000 = 14.8 times. A 1% move in the index, 74 points, is $3,700, about 15% of the margin.
- Long call: delta about 0.51, so the call behaves like 0.51 × $370,000 ≈ $188,700 of index exposure for a $9,282 outlay. Exposure leverage is about 20 times; notional leverage, $370,000 / $9,282, is about 40 times.
On these measures the call looks more leveraged than the future. The difference is in the downside. The future's leverage works in both directions without limit: a 7% fall, about 520 points, would cost $26,000, more than the illustrative margin. The call's leverage is lopsided: a 7% fall costs the premium and nothing more, while a rise is magnified. The price of that lopsidedness is the premium and its decay.
Which suits which purpose
Hedging a known exposure exactly. A portfolio manager who wants to remove most of the market exposure of a stock portfolio for a few months sells index futures. The hedge is linear, costs nothing up front beyond margin, and does not decay; it also gives up any gain if the market rises.
Insuring against a fall while keeping the upside. Buying puts, the futures-market equivalent of a Protective put: insuring a stock position with a put option, limits the loss below the strike and keeps the gains above it. It costs the premium, every time it is renewed.
Expressing a view on direction with limited loss. A long call or put caps the loss at the premium. It has to be right on direction, size and timing to profit.
Expressing a view on volatility. Only options can do this. A future has no exposure to implied volatility; an option's value moves with it (Option vega: what a point of implied volatility is worth).
Collecting a premium for taking risk. Selling options earns the premium and carries large losses in the tail. Selling futures earns nothing up front and is not "income" in any sense.
Side by side
| Feature | Future | Long option (call or put) | Short option |
|---|---|---|---|
| Obligation | Both sides bound | Right, no obligation | Obligation if assigned |
| Up front | Margin deposit (collateral) | Premium paid (spent) | Premium received; margin posted |
| Payoff | Straight line, ±$ per point | Loss capped at premium, gain open | Gain capped at premium, loss large |
| Daily cash flows | Variation margin every day | None | Margin can rise as the market moves |
| Time decay | None | Loses value each day | Gains as value decays |
| Sensitivity to volatility | None | Gains when implied volatility rises | Loses when it rises |
| Typical use | Hedging, exposure, spreads between months | Insurance, limited-loss directional views | Premium collection, income overlays |
| US tax (on regulated futures) | Section 1256, 60/40 | Section 1256 if on a future or SPX | Same as long |
Options on stocks and ETFs follow the equity option tax rules rather than section 1256; see How options are taxed: buyers, writers, covered calls and straddles and Section 1256 contracts: futures, index options and the 60/40 rule.
Pitfalls
Treating margin as the risk. Margin is a deposit, not a loss limit. A future can lose many times its margin in a gap. Compare the loss in a bad scenario with the account, not with the margin.
Treating the premium as small. A call that "only" costs $9,282 can go to zero, and in many cases does. The probability of losing all of it is much higher than the probability of a future falling by the same dollar amount.
Ignoring decay when replacing a future with an option. A trader who buys calls instead of the future to "cap the risk" pays for it every day the market goes nowhere: $3,905 in 30 days in the example.
Thinking a short put is a cheaper future. Below the break-even it loses like a future; above the strike it stops gaining. It combines the downside of the future with a capped upside, in exchange for the premium.
Comparing different sizes. One ES option covers one ES future. One SPY option covers 100 shares, about a fifth of one ES contract's value at these prices. Compare positions in dollars of exposure, not in number of contracts.
How Finabase does it
Finabase quotes futures on the Futures page: stock index, energy, metals, agricultural and bond futures with price, change, returns and 52-week ranges. The E-mini S&P 500 page shows the front contract's quote and chart. Multiplying that price by $50 gives the value of one contract, the starting point for the leverage arithmetic above.
For options, Finabase shows chains for listed stock and ETF options, such as the SPY chain, with bid, ask, last, volume, open interest and implied volatility for each strike. It does not show chains for options on futures, and it does not compute payoffs, Greeks or margin. The figures in this lesson are computed from the Black-76 formula with the inputs stated. Finabase does not place orders.
Frequently asked questions
Are futures riskier than options?
It depends on which side of the option. A long option can lose only its premium, so its loss is smaller than a future's in a large adverse move. A short option can lose about as much as a future in that move while earning only the premium when it goes well.
Do options on futures expire worthless more often than futures lose money?
They are different questions. A future loses money whenever the market moves against it, by any amount. A long out-of-the-money option loses its whole premium whenever the market does not move far enough in its favor before expiration, which is common.
Why would anyone choose a future over an option?
It has no premium and no time decay, and it tracks the market exactly. For a hedge meant to offset a known exposure, or a position expected to move soon, that is cheaper than paying for optionality.
What is the main advantage of options over futures?
The limited loss for the buyer and the ability to shape the payoff: protect one side, keep the other, or trade volatility itself. None of that is possible with a future alone.
Summary
A future is a two-sided obligation with a straight-line payoff, margin deposits that move every day, and no time decay. An option is a right bought for a premium, with a bent payoff, no margin calls for the buyer and a value that decays with time; its seller holds the obligation. On ES at 7,400 the future gained or lost $50 a point; a 7,400 call cost $9,282, lost no more than that and broke even at 7,585.64; a short 7,400 put kept $9,282 at best and lost like the future below 7,214.36. The choice between them is a choice of payoff shape and of what you pay for it, margin risk for one and premium and decay for the other.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
ES is at 7,400. A trader is long one ES future; another bought one 7,400 call for 185.64 points. At expiration ES is at 7,000. What did each lose?
- Both lost $20,000
- The future lost $20,000; the call lost its premium, $9,282
- The future lost $9,282; the call lost $20,000
Show the answer
B. The future lost $20,000; the call lost its premium, $9,282 The future loses $50 a point: 400 × $50 = $20,000. The call expires worthless below 7,400, so its buyer loses only the premium, 185.64 × $50 = $9,282.
Thirty days pass and the futures price is exactly where it started. What has happened to a long future and to a long at-the-money option on it?
- Both are unchanged
- The future is unchanged; the option has lost time value
- The future has lost value to the cost of carry; the option is unchanged
Show the answer
B. The future is unchanged; the option has lost time value A future has no time value: if its price is unchanged, so is the position. An option loses time value each day; in the lesson’s example the 7,400 call fell from 185.64 to 107.54 points, −$3,905, with no change in the market.
Why is a short put not simply a cheaper way to be long a future?
- Because it loses like the future below its break-even but stops gaining above the strike
- Because a short put has no margin requirement
- Because a short put gains when the market falls
Show the answer
A. Because it loses like the future below its break-even but stops gaining above the strike The short put keeps the premium at most. Below the strike minus the premium it loses about $50 a point like a long future, while above the strike its gain is capped. It trades the upside for the premium.
A trader says: "Futures margin is $25,000, so that is the most I can lose." What is wrong with this?
- Nothing: margin is the maximum loss on a future
- Margin is a deposit, not a limit; a large move can lose more than the margin and the account must cover it
- Futures have no margin
Show the answer
B. Margin is a deposit, not a limit; a large move can lose more than the margin and the account must cover it Initial margin is a performance bond. Gains and losses are settled daily in cash, and a move of more than about 500 points on ES would exceed $25,000. The account owes the difference.
Which position gains if implied volatility rises while the futures price stays the same?
- A long future
- A long option
- A short option
Show the answer
B. A long option Option values rise with implied volatility (vega), so the holder gains and the seller loses. A future has no exposure to implied volatility at all.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the E-mini S&P 500 future (ES=F) and read its last price. Work out the value of one contract ($50 × price) and what a 1% move is worth in dollars. Then open the SPY option chain, pick an expiration about a month away and read the Ask of the call whose strike is nearest the SPY price. Multiply by 100. How many of those calls would it take to pay for a 1% move on one ES future?
Open ES=FWhat you should find
A 1% move on one ES contract is worth several thousand dollars, roughly the cost of two to four at-the-money SPY calls a month out, depending on implied volatility. The call can lose all of that premium if SPY does not rise; the future can lose the same amount on a 1% fall, and more on a bigger one.
Sources and further reading
- CFTC — Futures market basics
- NFA — Opportunity and Risk: An Educational Guide to Trading Futures and Options on Futures
- The Options Clearing Corporation — Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options
- CME Group — E-mini S&P 500 futures contract specifications
- Black, F., The Pricing of Commodity Contracts, Journal of Financial Economics 3, 1976
