Trading · Options
Broken-wing butterfly: a butterfly with no risk on one side
How skipping a strike on one wing of a butterfly turns its debit into a credit and moves the risk from one side to the other, with worked numbers.
On this page
A butterfly buys one option, sells two at a middle strike and buys one more, with equal gaps between the strikes. A broken-wing butterfly makes one of those gaps wider. The far wing is cheaper, so the position costs less; skip far enough and it is opened for a credit. On the side of the short wing the position then cannot lose at all, because the credit is kept whatever happens there. On the side of the long wing it can lose more than a symmetric butterfly.
The broken wing does not remove risk. It moves it from one side of the stock price to the other, and turns a neutral bet on one price into a directional one. This page shows exactly how much risk moves, with the same illustrative prices as the butterfly lesson, so the two can be read side by side.
From a butterfly to a broken wing
The symmetric $95 / $100 / $105 call butterfly from the butterfly lesson costs $0.93. Its tent peaks at $4.07 at $100 and it loses the $0.93 debit below $95 or above $105.
Now move the upper wing from $105 to $110. The $110 call costs $1.19 instead of $2.42, so the position costs $1.23 less: the debit becomes a credit of $0.30.
The prices are the shared illustrative ones: XYZ at $100, 45 days, 30% implied volatility, 4% interest, no dividends, Black-Scholes values rounded to the cent.
| Stock at expiration | Symmetric $95/$100/$105 | Broken wing $95/$100/$110 |
|---|---|---|
| $90 | −$0.93 | +$0.30 |
| $95 | −$0.93 | +$0.30 |
| $100 | +$4.07 | +$5.30 |
| $104.07 | $0 | +$1.23 |
| $105 | −$0.93 | +$0.30 |
| $105.30 | −$0.93 | $0 |
| $110 | −$0.93 | −$4.70 |
| $120 | −$0.93 | −$4.70 |
Below $105 the broken wing is better by exactly $1.23 everywhere. Above $105 it gets worse, and from $110 it is $3.77 worse than the symmetric butterfly.
Why: a butterfly plus a call spread
Split the broken wing into two familiar pieces:
- the symmetric butterfly: buy $95, sell two $100, buy $105, for a $0.93 debit;
- a bear call spread: sell $105, buy $110, for a $1.23 credit.
The $105 calls cancel and what is left is the broken wing. Its credit is 1.23 − 0.93 = $0.30. Above $110 the call spread loses its full $5 width less its credit, and the butterfly loses its debit: −3.77 − 0.93 = −$4.70. Every number in the table is the sum of those two vertical spread and butterfly payoffs.
That is the honest description of the trade. A broken-wing butterfly is a butterfly financed by selling a call spread above it. Whoever opens one is also betting that the stock will not rise through the skipped strikes.
How wide to break the wing
The width of the skipped section sets the balance between the two sides:
| Upper wing | Net price | Below $95 | At $100 | Above the upper wing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $105 | $0.93 debit | −$0.93 | +$4.07 | −$0.93 |
| $106 | $0.63 debit | −$0.63 | +$4.37 | −$1.63 |
| $107 | $0.36 debit | −$0.36 | +$4.64 | −$2.36 |
| $108 | $0.11 debit | −$0.11 | +$4.89 | −$3.11 |
| $109 | $0.10 credit | +$0.10 | +$5.10 | −$3.90 |
| $110 | $0.30 credit | +$0.30 | +$5.30 | −$4.70 |
| $115 | $0.96 credit | +$0.96 | +$5.96 | −$9.04 |
Each extra dollar of skip improves the price by a fraction of a dollar, $0.30 for the first and less for each one after, and adds the rest of that dollar to the loss on the far side. Under the pricing model no row is better than another: each one is a fair price for the risk it carries. The rows differ in shape: a debit and a loss on both sides from $105 to $108; no risk on the downside from $109 on; and at $115, a position whose far-side loss is larger than its own best possible gain.
Odds and exposures
With the example's inputs the model gives the $95 / $100 / $110 broken wing about a 32% chance of finishing below $95 (the $0.30 credit), about 37% of finishing between $95 and the $105.30 break-even (a gain of up to $5.30), and about 31% above the break-even, of which about 18% is beyond $110, the full $4.70 loss.
| Per share, at the start | Broken wing $95/$100/$110 | Symmetric $95/$100/$105 |
|---|---|---|
| Delta | −0.15 | 0.00 |
| Gamma | −0.016 | −0.008 |
| Theta (per day) | +$0.021 | +$0.010 |
| Vega (per point) | −$0.060 | −$0.030 |
The broken wing starts with a delta of about −0.15: the sold call spread above makes it lean bearish. It gains from time and loses from a rise in implied volatility, more than the symmetric butterfly does, because the added call spread is itself a short-volatility position.
The put version
A broken-wing put butterfly mirrors the call version below the price. Buying the $105 put, selling two $100 puts and buying the $90 put collects $0.24 with the same inputs. Above $105 the credit is kept and nothing can be lost; the maximum, +$5.24, is at $100; the break-even is $94.76; below $90 the loss is $4.76. It leans bullish and carries its risk on the downside, where stock and index options usually have higher implied volatility (Volatility skew: why implied volatility differs by strike). Skew changes the price of each of the three strikes by a different amount, so a real chain's credit can differ noticeably from this flat-volatility number. It also means the risk sits on the side where large, fast moves are most common.
The same idea works with an iron structure, a short straddle with one wing further out than the other, and with condors. The arithmetic is the same: the far wing is cheaper, the price improves, and the loss on that side grows by the skipped width.
Assignment, margin and costs
The broken wing has two short options at the middle strike, both American-style on US equity options. Either can be assigned early if it is in the money, the call usually before an ex-dividend date. At expiration, a stock that closes between the middle and the far wing leaves the two short options in the money against one long one: a close at $107 means two $100 calls are exercised against the holder and the long $95 call is exercised for them, leaving the account short 100 shares with only the out-of-the-money $110 call, which expires, as a hedge. Closing before the last day avoids it (Option exercise and assignment: how it works and when it happens).
In a US margin account (2026), brokers typically hold the maximum loss, $470 here, under FINRA Rule 4210 and the Cboe margin rules; the credit received counts toward it. It needs spread-level approval at most brokers (Options risks and approval levels: what brokers check and why). Four contracts trade on three strikes, with bid-ask spreads and commissions on each; a credit of $0.30 can be erased by $0.10 of spread per leg.
Pitfalls
Reading "no risk on one side" as "low risk". The maximum loss in the example is five times the symmetric butterfly's and fifteen times the credit received.
Forgetting the direction. A call broken wing is a bearish-leaning trade. A rally through the skipped strikes is its worst case, and it is the case that earnings reports and market rebounds produce.
Breaking the wing too far. With a $115 wing the far-side loss, $9.04, is larger than the best possible gain, $5.96. At that point the position is mostly a short call spread.
Holding into the last day. As with any butterfly, most of the gain arrives late, and a close between the middle and far strikes leaves an unhedged stock position.
Compared with its neighbours
| Position | Opened for | Maximum gain | Risk below | Risk above |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Symmetric butterfly | Debit $0.93 | $4.07 at $100 | $0.93 | $0.93 |
| Broken-wing call butterfly $95/$100/$110 | Credit $0.30 | $5.30 at $100 | None | $4.70 |
| Broken-wing put butterfly $90/$100/$105 | Credit $0.24 | $5.24 at $100 | $4.76 | None |
| Bear call spread $105/$110 | Credit $1.23 | $1.23 below $105 | None | $3.77 |
| Iron condor | Credit $2.39 | $2.39, $95–$105 | $2.61 | $2.61 |
How Finabase does it
On a Finabase option chain such as IWM options, choose an expiration in the Expires row and set Strikes each side wide enough to see five or more call strikes above the lowest one you would buy. For a broken-wing call butterfly, read the ask of the lower call, the bid of the middle call (counted twice) and the ask of a call two or three strikes above the symmetric wing. The bids minus the asks give the net price at realistic quotes; repeat it with the wing one strike nearer to see how much each skipped strike is worth.
Finabase does not combine legs into a net price, draw payoff diagrams or compute Greeks; the figures on this page come from the Black-Scholes model with the stated inputs. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.
Frequently asked questions
What is a broken-wing butterfly?
A butterfly whose two outer strikes are unequally far from the middle strike. The far wing is cheaper, which lowers the cost or produces a credit, and increases the loss on that side.
Can a broken-wing butterfly lose money?
Yes. Opened for a credit, it cannot lose on the side of the near wing, but on the side of the far wing it loses up to the skipped width less the credit: $4.70 in the example.
Is a broken-wing butterfly bullish or bearish?
A call version with the wider wing above the price leans bearish; a put version with the wider wing below leans bullish. The lean comes from the extra credit spread hidden in the position.
Why open a broken-wing butterfly for a credit instead of a regular butterfly?
To remove the loss on one side and keep the peak, in exchange for a larger loss on the other. It fits a view that the stock will not move far in one particular direction.
How is a broken-wing butterfly different from a ratio spread?
Both sell two options against one bought below them. The broken wing adds a far option that caps the loss; a ratio spread leaves the second sold option uncovered, so its loss is open-ended.
Summary
A broken-wing butterfly widens one wing of a butterfly. On the shared prices the $95 / $100 / $110 call version collected $0.30 instead of paying $0.93 for the symmetric $95 / $100 / $105 butterfly: it keeps the credit below $95, earns up to $5.30 at $100, breaks even at $105.30 and loses $4.70 above $110. It is the symmetric butterfly plus a bear call spread on the skipped strikes, which is why it leans bearish and why its far-side loss grows almost a dollar for each extra dollar skipped. The put version mirrors it below the price. A broken wing removes risk on one side by moving it to the other, not by making it smaller.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A $95/$100/$110 call broken-wing butterfly is opened for a $0.30 credit. What is the result at expiration if the stock finishes at $80?
- A loss of $0.30
- A gain of $0.30
- A loss of $4.70
Show the answer
B. A gain of $0.30 Below $95 every call expires worthless, so the credit received is kept. On the side of the near wing a broken-wing butterfly opened for a credit cannot lose.
Why does the broken-wing version lose more than the symmetric butterfly if the stock finishes above $110?
- Because the $110 call costs more than the $105 call
- Because it is the symmetric butterfly plus a bear call spread on $105/$110, and that spread loses its width minus its credit above $110
- Because it has two uncovered calls
Show the answer
B. Because it is the symmetric butterfly plus a bear call spread on $105/$110, and that spread loses its width minus its credit above $110 Splitting the position shows a $95/$100/$105 butterfly and a short $105/$110 call spread. Above $110 the butterfly loses its $0.93 debit and the call spread loses $3.77, a total of $4.70.
A trader moves the far wing of a call butterfly from $105 to $115. What happens?
- The price improves by $10 and the risk stays the same
- The price improves by about $1.89 and the loss above the far wing grows from $0.93 to $9.04
- The maximum gain doubles with no change in risk
Show the answer
B. The price improves by about $1.89 and the loss above the far wing grows from $0.93 to $9.04 The $115 call is much cheaper than the $105 call, turning a $0.93 debit into a $0.96 credit, but most of the $10 of extra width becomes loss on that side. Risk is moved, not removed.
Which way does a call broken-wing butterfly with the wider wing above the stock price lean?
- Bullish
- Neutral
- Mildly bearish
Show the answer
C. Mildly bearish The hidden bear call spread above the price gives it a negative delta, about −0.15 in the example. A rally through the skipped strikes is its worst case.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open the IWM option chain and choose an expiration about six weeks away. Pick a middle call strike near the price, a lower call one strike below, and an upper call one strike above; read the asks of the outer calls and the bid of the middle one. Work out the net price of buying the outer two and selling two middle calls. Then move the upper call two or three strikes further out and work out the price again.
Open the IWM option chainWhat you should find
The symmetric butterfly costs a debit. Moving the upper wing out lowers the debit and, far enough out, turns it into a credit. Each strike skipped improves the price by much less than the strike gap; the rest of that gap is added to the loss above the upper wing.
Sources and further reading
- The Options Clearing Corporation — Options Disclosure Document (Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options)
- Options Industry Council — Long call butterfly
- Options Industry Council — Long put butterfly
- FINRA Rule 4210 — Margin requirements
- Cboe — Margin requirements (Margin Manual)
- Black, F. and Scholes, M., The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities, Journal of Political Economy 81(3), 1973
