Trading · Orders and execution
Market makers: who quotes both sides and how they get paid
What US market makers must do under NYSE Rule 104 and Nasdaq’s quoting rules, how the spread pays them, and a worked example of the inventory risk that takes it back.
On this page
When you send a market order for 100 shares of a large US stock, someone is almost always there to take the other side within milliseconds. Often that someone is not another investor who happened to want the opposite trade at that moment. It is a firm whose business is to stand ready to buy and sell all day: a market maker.
This lesson covers what market makers are obliged to do on the two main US exchanges, how the spread pays them, and the risk that the spread is paying for. A worked example shows how quickly one-sided order flow can turn a day of collected spreads into a loss.
What a market maker does
A market maker quotes both sides: a price at which it will buy (its bid) and a price at which it will sell (its ask), each for a stated size. If the quote is bid $20.00, ask $20.02, the maker will buy from anyone who wants to sell at $20.00 and sell to anyone who wants to buy at $20.02. When one buyer and one seller each trade 100 shares with it, the maker ends where it started, with no shares, and two cents a share richer.
That is the whole business model in one line, and it explains why market makers care about three things: how wide a spread they can quote, how evenly buyers and sellers arrive, and how often the person trading with them turns out to be right about the next price.
The orders a market maker posts sit in the order book like anyone else's. The difference is that a maker updates them constantly, often thousands of times a minute across thousands of stocks, and is usually present on both sides at once.
Obligations on the exchanges
On a US exchange, being a registered market maker is a status with rules attached.
Nasdaq. A Nasdaq market maker must keep a continuous two-sided quote, for at least one normal unit of trading, in every stock it is registered in (Nasdaq Equity 2, Section 5). The quote cannot drift too far from the market: for the most liquid stocks (those in Tier 1 of the limit up-limit down plan) it must stay within 8% of the national best bid or offer for most of the day, with wider allowances near the open and close and for other stocks (28% or 30%). The rule exists so that a stock always has someone quoting it, even if far from the inside, and so that a "stub quote" a penny wide of zero cannot trade by accident.
NYSE. Each NYSE-listed stock has one designated market maker (DMM). NYSE Rule 104 asks more of a DMM than Nasdaq asks of its market makers. The DMM must maintain a fair and orderly market, keep a continuous two-sided quote for at least one round lot, and be at the national best bid or offer for a minimum average share of the trading day: 10% for stocks that trade a million shares a day or more, 15% for those that trade less, and 25% for exchange-traded products. The DMM also opens and closes the stock: it oversees the opening auction and sets the closing auction price within limits set by the rules, as covered in Opening and closing auctions: how the open and close are set.
Every quote is firm. Under SEC Rule 602 of Regulation NMS, a broker-dealer that publishes a quote must honour it, up to its published size, to anyone who sends an order at that price while the quote stands. A market maker cannot post a tight quote to attract attention and then refuse the trade.
In return, market makers receive benefits: lower fees or rebates on the exchange, a share of executions at their price on NYSE, and, under Regulation SHO Rule 203(b)(2)(iii), an exception from the requirement to locate shares before a short sale when the sale is part of bona fide market making. That exception matters, because a maker selling to buyers all day is often short for a while without having arranged a borrow in advance.
How the spread pays, and how it is lost
The textbook case is balanced flow, and the arithmetic is simple. The case that matters is one-sided flow.
Now suppose the sellers keep coming and the buyers do not. Perhaps a fund is selling a large block in pieces, or news has broken that the maker has not seen yet.
The loss on the one-sided stretch is larger than the profit from the balanced one. The maker did nothing unusual: it quoted, it traded, it adjusted. What changed was who was trading with it. The sellers in the second example were, as a group, right about where the price was going. Economists call this adverse selection: the people most eager to trade against a quote are disproportionately the ones who know something. The classic model of it, by Glosten and Milgrom (1985), shows that a spread must be wide enough that what the maker earns from uninformed traders covers what it loses to informed ones.
That is why spreads widen before earnings, around economic releases and in the first minutes of trading: the chance that the next order is informed is higher, so the price of standing in front of it rises. It is also why spreads are narrow in very active stocks. With heavy two-way flow, a maker can lay off inventory quickly and the risk on any one trade is small.
Inventory and hedging
A market maker that ends up holding 500 shares it did not want has three choices: lower its prices to encourage buyers and discourage further sellers (the approach in the example), sell the shares at the bid and take the loss, or hedge. Large firms hedge across related instruments: they might sell an index future or a correlated stock to offset a position they cannot unload immediately. Hedging reduces the price risk but costs money, which again comes out of the spread.
A maker's quotes therefore lean. A maker that is long a stock tends to show a slightly lower bid and a slightly lower ask than the market, so that it buys less and sells more. Watching which side keeps getting refreshed in the book is one of the few clues an outsider has about that inventory, and it is a weak one.
Wholesalers: the market makers retail traders meet
Most orders from US retail brokerage accounts do not go to an exchange first. They go to a handful of wholesale market makers that pay the broker for the order flow and fill the orders themselves, often at a price slightly better than the national best bid or offer. A buy order with the quote at $20.00 by $20.02 might fill at $20.0175: a quarter of a cent of "price improvement".
Wholesalers can do this because retail orders are, on average, less informed than orders from professional traders: the adverse selection described above is smaller, so a narrower effective spread still pays. Whether the arrangement serves retail investors well is a long-running policy debate, covered with the reporting rules in Order routing and best execution: NBBO, Rule 611, PFOF and 606.
What this means for your orders
- Your spread is a market maker's income. Crossing the spread on every trade is a cost; a limit order that rests at the bid or ask earns it instead, at the risk of not filling. Market vs limit orders: price certainty vs getting filled covers the choice.
- Wide spreads are a warning, not a flaw. When the people paid to quote a stock quote it widely, they are pricing risk you would also be taking.
- Size near the top is limited. The firm quote covers the published size. A larger order walks into deeper, worse prices or the maker requotes.
- The quote you see is reactive. Market makers' algorithms adjust within microseconds of a trade elsewhere. An order that arrives late often finds a different price.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not show quotes by market maker or the order book. The symbol pages show last price, volume and the day's range, and the Performers page lists the day's biggest winners and losers: the names where one-sided flow, the situation in the second example, is most likely and where market makers are most likely to widen their quotes.
The paper account at /trading fills at live prices without a spread or market maker in the middle, so it understates the cost of crossing the spread. If you practise there, keep a note of what each trade would have paid at the ask (buying) or received at the bid (selling).
Frequently asked questions
What does a market maker do?
It posts a bid and an ask in a stock at the same time and trades with anyone who accepts either price. It earns the spread when it buys and sells in balance and bears the risk of holding the stock when orders arrive on one side only.
What is a designated market maker?
The one firm assigned to each NYSE-listed stock. Under NYSE Rule 104 it must keep a fair and orderly market, quote both sides continuously, be at the best national price for a minimum share of the day, and run the stock's opening and closing auctions.
Do market makers trade against their customers?
They trade with anyone who takes their quote, and they profit when the price moves their way. That is not the same as betting against a particular client: the business depends on earning the spread on many trades and keeping inventory small, not on predicting direction.
Why do spreads widen before news?
Because the chance that the next order comes from someone who knows the news is higher. Market makers widen their quotes to cover the expected loss to informed traders, a cost economists call adverse selection.
Summary
- A market maker quotes both sides and earns the spread when trades arrive in balance.
- On Nasdaq, registered market makers must keep a continuous two-sided quote within set percentages of the best price; NYSE's DMMs must also be at the best price for a minimum share of the day and run the auctions. Every published quote is firm under SEC Rule 602.
- The spread pays for inventory risk and adverse selection. In the worked example, the $20 earned from balanced flow was outweighed by a $25 loss on 500 shares bought from one-sided sellers.
- Spreads widen when informed trading is more likely and narrow when two-way flow is heavy.
- Most US retail orders are filled by wholesale market makers off exchange, usually at or slightly inside the quote.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A market maker quotes $30.00 bid, $30.03 ask. It buys 200 shares from one seller and sells 200 to one buyer. What has it earned, before fees?
- $3
- $6
- $12
Show the answer
B. $6 It bought 200 at $30.00 and sold 200 at $30.03: 200 × $0.03 = $6, with no shares left over.
What is adverse selection, from a market maker’s point of view?
- Being forced to quote stocks it does not want
- The tendency of the traders most eager to hit its quote to be the ones who know where the price is going
- Choosing the wrong exchange to quote on
Show the answer
B. The tendency of the traders most eager to hit its quote to be the ones who know where the price is going Informed traders trade when the quote is wrong in their favour, so the maker loses on those trades. The spread must cover that expected loss.
Which obligation applies to an NYSE designated market maker but not to every Nasdaq market maker?
- Keeping a two-sided quote
- Honouring its published quote
- Being at the national best bid or offer for a minimum share of the trading day and running the closing auction
Show the answer
C. Being at the national best bid or offer for a minimum share of the trading day and running the closing auction Nasdaq market makers must quote both sides within set percentages of the best price. NYSE Rule 104 adds time at the inside and the auction role for DMMs. Rule 602 makes every published quote firm.
A stock’s quoted spread widens from 2 cents to 15 cents in the minute before an earnings release. What is the main reason?
- Exchanges require wider spreads before news
- Market makers are pricing the higher chance of trading against someone who knows the result
- Volume always falls to zero before news
Show the answer
B. Market makers are pricing the higher chance of trading against someone who knows the result The risk that the next order is informed rises sharply around news, so makers widen their quotes or step back.
Sources and further reading
- NYSE Rule 104 — Dealings and responsibilities of DMMs (quoting and NBBO obligations)
- Nasdaq Stock Market rulebook, Equity 2, Section 5 — market maker obligations (two-sided quote, designated percentages)
- SEC Rule 602 of Regulation NMS (17 CFR 242.602) — dissemination of quotations; firm quote obligation
- SEC Regulation SHO Rule 203(b)(2)(iii) (17 CFR 242.203) — locate exception for bona fide market making
- Lawrence R. Glosten and Paul R. Milgrom, "Bid, ask and transaction prices in a specialist market with heterogeneously informed traders", Journal of Financial Economics 14(1), 1985
- Finabase worked example — illustrative quotes; profit and loss computed in the Finabase figure script (scripts/learn/figures/trading-mechanics.ts)
