Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Trading · Futures

Hedging with futures: short and long hedges, basis risk, hedge ratio

How producers and buyers lock in prices with futures, worked P&L for a corn farmer and an airline, basis risk, the minimum-variance hedge ratio and over-hedging.

On this page
  1. The two kinds of hedge
  2. A short hedge: the corn farmer
  3. A long hedge: the airline
  4. Cross hedges and the hedge ratio
  5. Over-hedging and under-hedging
  6. When a sound hedge fails: Metallgesellschaft, 1993
  7. Pitfalls
  8. Futures hedges compared with other ways to manage price risk
  9. How Finabase does it
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Summary
  12. Check your understanding
  13. Exercise

A hedge is a position taken to offset a risk you already have. A farmer who will harvest corn in October is already long corn: she loses if the price falls before then. An airline that must buy jet fuel every week is already short fuel: it loses if the price rises. Futures let both turn an unknown future price into a known one, months ahead, by taking the opposite position in a contract that moves with the price they care about.

That is the reason futures markets exist. The first organized grain futures in Chicago, in the 1860s, served farmers and merchants who wanted to fix prices before the crop came in. Speculators are the other side of many of those trades, and they are paid for taking risk the hedgers want to give away. The CFTC's weekly Commitments of Traders report: reading the CFTC’s weekly COT data shows how the two groups are positioned in each market.

This lesson works through a short hedge and a long hedge with real contract sizes, shows what a hedge locks in (a price plus or minus the basis, not a price), estimates a hedge ratio from two years of real oil data, and ends with the most famous hedge that went wrong, at Metallgesellschaft in 1993.

The two kinds of hedge

Hedger Already exposed to Risk Futures position Example
Producer or holder Long the commodity Price falls Sell (short) Corn farmer, oil producer, grain elevator
Buyer or processor Short the commodity Price rises Buy (long) Airline, baker, refiner buying crude, food maker

In both, the futures gain when the physical position loses and lose when it gains. A hedge is not meant to make money: it is meant to make the total predictable. A hedger who ends the year with a loss on futures and a higher price for the crop has done exactly what was intended.

A short hedge: the corn farmer

For scale: front-month corn futures closed at $4.4675 a bushel on November 17, 2026.

A corn farmer’s short hedge: price received per bushel at harvest (illustrative) $3.00 $3.50 $4.00 $4.50 $5.00 $5.50 $3.40 $3.80 $4.20 $4.60 $5.00 $5.40 $5.80 Sold futures at $4.60 Unhedged: sells grain at the local cash price Hedged, basis −$0.35 as expected: $4.25 Hedged, basis −$0.25 (stronger): $4.35 Hedged, basis −$0.45 (weaker): $4.15 December corn futures price at harvest ($ per bushel) Price received per bushel
Illustrative short hedge: 10 December corn contracts sold at $4.60, expected harvest basis −$0.35. The hedged price is flat whatever the futures do; only the basis moves it.

What the hedge actually locks in

The flat lines in the figure differ only by the basis. The farmer's net price is:

The futures price at harvest cancels out. What remains is the price at which the hedge was placed and the basis on the day it is lifted. If the local basis is −$0.25 that October, because local demand is strong, she nets $4.35. If it is −$0.45, because the harvest is large and elevators are full, she nets $4.15. That 20-cent range on 50,000 bushels is $10,000, against an $80,000 range unhedged between the $3.80 and $5.40 cases. That is basis risk: smaller than price risk, not zero.

An oil producer's short hedge works the same way. A producer expecting to sell 100,000 barrels over a quarter sells 100 WTI crude contracts (1,000 barrels each); its realized price is the futures price at which it sold plus the difference between its own crude's price and WTI at Cushing, Oklahoma, when it sells.

A long hedge: the airline

An airline's jet fuel bill is one of its largest costs. There is no deep futures market in jet fuel itself in the US, so airlines usually hedge with heating oil (ULSD) futures, whose product is close to jet fuel, or with crude oil.

A baker who buys wheat, a food company buying soybean oil and a refiner buying crude for future runs do the same. Each is short the commodity in the business and long in the futures.

Cross hedges and the hedge ratio

When the futures contract is not on the exact thing being hedged, buying or selling one contract per unit of exposure may not be the best choice. If the futures price moves less than the cash price, more contracts are needed; if their moves are only loosely related, fewer.

The minimum-variance hedge ratio is the number of units of futures per unit of exposure that makes the hedged position's value vary least:

h* is the slope of a regression of cash price changes on futures price changes, and ρ² is the share of variance the hedge removes.

Two lessons come from those numbers. First, a cross hedge can need noticeably more (or fewer) contracts than the one-for-one count. Over this period diesel prices moved much more than crude prices, so matching gallons would have under-hedged. Second, a cross hedge leaves a lot of risk: 40% of the daily variance remained. Hedging with the matching product, ULSD futures for diesel, removes far more.

The ratio is an estimate from the past. Correlations and relative volatilities change, and a ratio from two years of data is not a promise about the next six months. Hedgers re-estimate it regularly and often round toward one.

Over-hedging and under-hedging

A hedge sized to an expected quantity can turn out wrong when the quantity changes.

Weather that cuts a harvest often raises prices too, so an over-hedged producer tends to lose on the futures exactly when output is short. For that reason many farmers hedge only part of the expected crop with futures before harvest, or use put options, whose loss is limited to the premium (Protective put: insuring a stock position with a put option, Options on futures: how they work, expire, are priced and taxed). Under-hedging leaves part of the exposure open. Either way, anything beyond the real exposure is a speculative position.

When a sound hedge fails: Metallgesellschaft, 1993

MG Refining and Marketing, the US subsidiary of the German industrial group Metallgesellschaft AG, sold customers fixed-price contracts to supply gasoline and heating oil for up to ten years, about 160 million barrels in total. To hedge, it bought short-dated energy futures and swaps for roughly the whole quantity and rolled them forward each month, a "stack and roll" hedge.

In late 1993 oil prices fell. The long futures lost money and required cash for margin calls at once, while the offsetting gains on the fixed-price supply contracts would only be realized over years. The market also moved into contango, so each monthly roll cost money (Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil). In December 1993 the parent's supervisory board replaced the subsidiary's management and unwound the positions. Reported losses were about $1.3 billion; some accounts put them near $1.5 billion.

Economists still argue about whether the hedge was sound and the unwinding the real mistake. The lessons are not in dispute: a hedge with a maturity mismatch carries roll risk, a hedge that is right in value can still drain cash through daily margin, and a hedger must be able to fund the futures side until the physical side pays.

Pitfalls

Treating the futures price as the locked price. The locked price is the futures price plus the basis at the end.

Hedging more than you have. The excess is a speculation that often loses at the worst time.

Ignoring cash for margin. A losing futures leg must be paid daily, even when the physical position is gaining.

Trusting a historical hedge ratio. It is an estimate. Re-check it, and prefer a contract that matches the exposure.

Forgetting delivery. A physically delivered contract held into its delivery period can lead to an obligation to deliver or take delivery; hedgers usually close or roll before then.

Futures hedges compared with other ways to manage price risk

Tool Upfront cost Gives up gains? Main remaining risk
Futures hedge Margin only Yes Basis, quantity, cash for margin
Forward contract with a buyer or seller Usually none Yes The counterparty failing to pay
Buying puts (producer) or calls (buyer) The option premium No, beyond the premium Premium spent if never needed
Collar Little or none Above the sold strike Basis, the range chosen
Not hedging None No The full price move

How Finabase does it

Finabase has symbol pages for the futures used in these examples: corn (ZC=F), heating oil (HO=F) and WTI crude (CL=F), each with the front-month price, previous close, day and 52-week ranges, returns, a chart and news. The Futures page lists 61 series, including grains, energy and metals, with their returns from one week to two years.

Finabase does not show local cash prices or basis, individual contract months, or hedge ratios. The corn example is illustrative; the crude and heating-oil hedge ratio on this page is ours, computed from frozen Finabase chart data.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a short hedge and a long hedge?

A short hedge sells futures to protect against a fall in the price of something you own or will produce. A long hedge buys futures to protect against a rise in the price of something you will need to buy.

Does hedging with futures guarantee a price?

It fixes the futures part of the price. The final price still depends on the basis when the hedge is lifted, so it is close to the target, not exactly on it.

What is a cross hedge?

A hedge using futures on a related asset because no contract exists on the exact one, such as heating-oil or crude futures for jet fuel. It leaves more basis risk.

How do you calculate the optimal hedge ratio?

Multiply the correlation of cash and futures price changes by the ratio of their standard deviations. It equals the slope of a regression of cash price changes on futures price changes.

Why did Metallgesellschaft lose money on a hedge?

Its short-dated futures lost money and needed cash for margin when oil prices fell in 1993, while the gains on its long-term supply contracts would only arrive over years. Rolling in contango added costs, and the positions were unwound at a loss.

Summary

A short hedge sells futures against something owned or produced; a long hedge buys futures against something that must be bought. Either one locks in the futures price plus the basis when the hedge is lifted: a corn farmer selling at $4.60 with a −$0.35 basis nets $4.25 whether futures end at $3.80 or $5.40, and $4.15 to $4.35 if the basis moves 10 cents. Where no matching contract exists, the minimum-variance hedge ratio sizes a cross hedge: crude-oil futures hedged heating oil with a ratio of 1.37 and removed 60% of daily variance over 2024–2026. Over-hedging becomes speculation, and a hedge must be funded through its margin calls, the lesson of Metallgesellschaft's $1.3 billion loss in 1993.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A soybean farmer sells futures at $11.00 and expects a harvest basis of −$0.50. At harvest the futures are $9.80 and the basis is −$0.60. What net price does she receive?

    1. $10.50
    2. $10.40
    3. $9.20
    4. $11.00
    Show the answer

    B. $10.40 Net price = futures sold + basis at lifting = 11.00 − 0.60 = $10.40. Check: cash is 9.80 − 0.60 = $9.20 and the futures gain $1.20, a total of $10.40. The weaker basis cost her 10 cents against her $10.50 target.

  2. Which business would place a long hedge with futures?

    1. A gold miner expecting to sell output next year
    2. A cereal maker that must buy wheat over the next six months
    3. A grain elevator holding corn in storage
    Show the answer

    B. A cereal maker that must buy wheat over the next six months A long hedge protects a future buyer against rising prices. The miner and the elevator already own or will produce the commodity, so they would sell futures.

  3. Changes in a cash price and a futures price have a correlation of 0.8. The cash price is 1.5 times as volatile as the futures. What is the minimum-variance hedge ratio, and how much variance does the hedge remove?

    1. 0.8, removing 80%
    2. 1.2, removing 64%
    3. 1.5, removing 100%
    Show the answer

    B. 1.2, removing 64% h* = ρ × σS/σF = 0.8 × 1.5 = 1.2 units of futures per unit of exposure. The variance removed is ρ² = 0.64. Even the best hedge leaves 36% of the variance.

  4. A farmer hedges her whole expected crop, then a drought halves it and prices rise. What happens?

    1. The hedge still fixes the price of the whole expected crop
    2. The futures on the missing half lose money with no crop to offset them
    3. The exchange cancels the excess contracts
    Show the answer

    B. The futures on the missing half lose money with no crop to offset them The hedge covered more than she ended up owning. On the missing bushels she is simply short futures in a rising market, which is why many producers hedge only part of the expected crop.

  5. What was the main practical problem with Metallgesellschaft’s 1993 hedge?

    1. It was hedged in the wrong direction
    2. Its short-dated futures needed cash for margin calls immediately while the offsetting gains on long-term supply contracts came only over years
    3. Futures on gasoline and heating oil did not exist
    Show the answer

    B. Its short-dated futures needed cash for margin calls immediately while the offsetting gains on long-term supply contracts came only over years When oil fell, the long futures lost value and had to be paid for daily. The fixed-price contracts gained value but produced no cash until delivery. Rolling in contango added costs, and the positions were unwound at a loss of about $1.3 billion.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the corn futures page (ZC=F) and note the price, which is quoted in cents per bushel. Imagine a farmer selling 10 contracts (50,000 bushels) at that price with an expected basis of 30 cents under. Work out her target price, then her total revenue if futures end 80 cents higher or 80 cents lower and the basis comes in at 40 cents under instead.

Open the corn futures page
What you should find

The target is the futures price minus $0.30. Whatever the futures do, a basis of 40 cents under leaves her 10 cents a bushel, $5,000 in total, below target. The ±80-cent futures move changes nothing in the hedged total, only how it splits between cash sales and futures gains or losses.

Sources and further reading

  1. CME Group — Corn futures contract specifications (5,000 bushels)
  2. CME Group — NY Harbor ULSD (heating oil) futures contract specifications (42,000 gallons)
  3. CME Group — Self-study guide to hedging with grain and oilseed futures and options
  4. CFTC — Basics of futures trading
  5. Hull, J., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapter on hedging strategies using futures; Business Snapshot on Metallgesellschaft
  6. Mello, A. and Parsons, J., Maturity structure of a hedge matters: lessons from the Metallgesellschaft debacle, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance 8(1), 1995
  7. Finabase chart data — ZC=F, HO=F and CL=F daily closes, Nov 18, 2024 to Nov 17, 2026 (frozen 2026-11-18)