Finabase Learn
Investing and trading strategies
How strategies are built and tested — the rules, a backtest with costs, the losing periods and the conditions that break each one.
Building and testing a strategy
- What is a trading strategy? Rules, parts and a first test What separates a trading strategy from an idea: the five parts every strategy needs, and how four exact readings of one sentence gave four different results on SPY.
- Edge and expectancy: the average trade, worked on real trade lists How to calculate the expectancy of a strategy from its win rate and average gain and loss, with two real SPY trade lists and a test of how much of each is luck.
- Overfitting and backtest bias: 4,094 rules tested on SPY How searching for the best rule creates results that vanish: 4,094 calendar rules and 23 moving-average lengths chosen on one half of SPY history, checked on the other.
- Out-of-sample and walk-forward testing, worked on SPY How to hold data back when testing a strategy: one in-sample and out-of-sample split and a five-round walk-forward test of a moving-average rule on SPY, 1995–2026.
- Trading costs in a strategy: what costs and slippage do to a backtest The costs a backtest must include, and how the same SPY rules change at 0%, 0.05%, 0.10%, 0.25% and 0.50% per trade: why trading frequency decides how much costs matter.
- Choosing a benchmark: what to compare a strategy against How to pick a fair yardstick for a strategy: one SPY rule judged against cash, buy and hold and a matched mix, and a QQQ rule that beats the wrong benchmark.
- How to read a backtest report, line by line Read a backtest report on a real test of QQQ: what total return, CAGR, deepest fall, time invested and win rate each say, and what each one hides.
- Position sizing inside a strategy: how much, not what See how the amount committed to each signal changes a strategy: one set of QQQ signals at nine sizes, the point where more size earns less, and volatility-scaled sizing.
- Systematic vs discretionary trading: rules or judgment Compare rule-based and judgment-based trading, and see on 33 years of SPY what happens to a simple rule when its follower hesitates, skips signals or overrides it.
- Why trading strategies stop working The five reasons a tested strategy fades, a rule on SPY and the small-company premium measured block by block, and how to tell a bad stretch from a broken idea.
- Paper trading a strategy: what a practice record proves What paper trading can and cannot show about a strategy, how many trades a record needs, and why the first 30 trades of a real rule pointed the wrong way.
Trend and momentum
- Moving average trend following: the 10-month rule, tested The 10-month moving average rule on SPY from 1993 to 2026: the exact rules, a backtest with costs, what it avoided in 2008 and what it gave up afterwards.
- Golden cross strategy: the 50/200-day moving average crossover, tested The 50-day and 200-day moving average crossover as a trading rule: exact rules, a 33-year SPY backtest with costs, the whipsaws of 2020 and 2025, and nearby settings.
- Donchian channel breakout: buying new highs, tested on SPY The Donchian channel breakout buys a new high and sells a new low. Exact rules, a 33-year SPY backtest with costs, and why every sale since 2009 came before a higher buy.
- 52-week high momentum: buying what is near its high, tested The 52-week high strategy buys what trades closest to its one-year high. What the research found, and a 27-year test on sector funds where it lost to holding them all.
- Time-series momentum: the 12-month return rule, tested Time-series momentum holds a fund only when its own return over the past year is positive. The exact rule, a 33-year SPY backtest with costs, and where it lost.
- Relative strength rotation: holding the strongest fund, tested A relative strength rotation holds whichever fund has risen most over recent months. The exact rules, a 22-year test on five ETFs with costs, and the years it lost badly.
- Dual momentum: relative and absolute momentum combined, tested Dual momentum picks the stronger of US and international stocks and moves to safety when both are falling. Exact rules, a 24-year backtest with costs, and where it lost.
- Sector rotation strategy: momentum across nine S&P sectors, tested A sector rotation strategy holds the stock market sectors that rose most in recent months. Exact rules, a 27-year test on nine sector ETFs with costs, and why it trailed.
- MACD trend strategy: the signal-line crossover rule, tested The MACD crossover as a complete trading rule: exact rules, a weekly SPY backtest with costs, the same rule on 30 stocks and on daily and monthly bars, and where it lost.
- Buying pullbacks in an uptrend: a dip-buying rule, tested A rule for buying pullbacks in an uptrend: buy a five-day low above the 100-day average, sell on the bounce. Tested with costs on SPY and 30 stocks.
- ATR trailing stop: a volatility-based exit rule, tested An ATR trailing stop sells when the price falls a set multiple of its average true range below its best close. Exact rules, a QQQ backtest with costs, and where it fails.
Mean reversion
- RSI mean reversion: the two-day RSI rule, tested The RSI(2) pullback rule on SPY and the 30 Dow stocks: exact rules, a two-year backtest with costs, why most trades win and where the losses come from.
- Bollinger Band mean reversion: buying the lower band, tested Buy a close below the lower Bollinger Band and sell at the middle band: the exact rules, a two-year backtest with costs on SPY and 30 stocks, and why it disappointed.
- Pairs trading: rules, a backtest and the pair that broke How pairs trading works, with exact rules and a backtest with costs on four well-known stock pairs. Coca-Cola and PepsiCo, the textbook pair, lost 17% in two years.
- Short-term reversal: buying last week’s losers, tested The weekly reversal strategy on the 30 Dow stocks, 2021 to 2026: the rules, a backtest before and after costs, and why 42 portfolio turnovers a year erase the edge.
- Gap fading: buying the open after a gap down, tested Fading the opening gap on SPY, QQQ and IWM over two years: the exact rules, a backtest with costs, and how one day in April 2025 accounts for the whole gross gain.
- Mean reversion vs trend following: two rules on one market A trend rule and a mean-reversion rule tested side by side on SPY, daily and monthly, with costs: how their trades, win rates, losing periods and bad markets differ.
- The turn-of-the-month effect as a strategy: a four-day rule, tested Holding stocks only from the last trading day of a month through the third day of the next: the rules, a backtest with costs on 24 month-ends, and what so few can show.
- Buying after large one-day falls: the rules and a backtest Buy after a big down day and hold a week: exact rules, a two-year backtest with costs on QQQ, and what followed 146 falls of 5% or more in the 30 Dow stocks.
Long-term investing
- Buy and hold, tested: 33 years of SPY and the cost of selling Buy and hold as a rule set, tested on SPY from 1993 to 2026 against selling after a 20% fall: what holding earned, its long flat stretch, and why selling cost more.
- Buy and hold vs. market timing: 33 years of SPY, tested Holding SPY against a rule that steps aside below its 10-month average, 1993 to 2026 after costs, plus what missing the 10 best or worst months did to the result.
- Lump sum or instalments: every start month since 1993, tested All at once or in 12 monthly parts: both rule sets tested on every SPY start month from 1993 to 2025, with the worst outcomes of each and the starts where each lost.
- Dividend growth investing: the rules, and VIG against the market How a dividend growth strategy picks companies, and 20 years of VIG against SPY: smaller falls in 2008 and 2022, a lower price return, and what dividends change.
- Dividend growth vs. high yield: VIG against VYM since 2006 Rising payouts or high current yield: VIG and VYM tested with dividends reinvested from 2006 to 2026, with their losing years and what each pays now.
- Value investing as a strategy: the rules and a 26-year test Value as a rule set: how an index picks cheap stocks, and IWD against SPY from 2000 to 2026, with seven strong years, thirteen weak ones and a near tie overall.
- Quality investing: the rules, and QUAL against the market What a quality strategy screens for, and what 13 years of the QUAL fund against SPY show: nearly the same return, the same volatility and no smaller falls.
- Low-volatility investing: the rules, and USMV against SPY How minimum-volatility funds are built, and 15 years of USMV against SPY: smaller swings and falls, level with the market until 2019 and far behind it since.
- Small-cap investing and the size effect: a 26-year test The size effect as rules: what a small-cap index holds, and IWM against SPY from 2000 to 2026, with a strong first half, a weak second and more volatility throughout.
- Factor investing: five factor funds against the S&P 500, tested What value, size, momentum, quality and low volatility are, the rules of an equal mix of five factor funds, and how it did against SPY from 2013 to 2026 after costs.
- Value vs. momentum: cheap stocks or rising stocks, tested The rules behind value and momentum investing, and how the factor funds VLUE and MTUM did from 2013 to 2026, year by year, with their losing years and a mix of both.
- Core-satellite portfolio: the rules and a 22-year test How a core-satellite portfolio works, the arithmetic that limits what satellites can add or cost, and a test of 80% SPY with 20% in four satellites from 2004 to 2026.
- Equal weight vs market-cap weight: RSP against SPY, tested How equal-weight and cap-weight indexes differ, the rules of each, and what RSP did against SPY from 2003 to 2026: level overall, far ahead to 2015 and far behind since.
- The 60/40 portfolio: rules, a price-only backtest and 2022 The 60% stock, 40% bond portfolio as exact rules, tested on SPY and IEF from 2002 to 2026: what bonds did to the falls, what the price data leaves out, and why 2022 hurt.
- Permanent and all-weather portfolios: rules and a price-only test The permanent portfolio and the all-weather mix as exact rules, tested on funds from 2004 to 2026: small falls in 2008, a hard 2022, and what price data omits.
- Dogs of the Dow: the rules, and the nearest honest test The Dogs of the Dow rule in full, why this data cannot test it as defined, and a 40-year test of the nearest version: last year’s weakest Dow members against all of them.
- Lifecycle investing: a target-date glide path, tested Why lifecycle and target-date investing cut stocks with age, the rules of a glide path, and a 24-year test against fixed mixes, with and without monthly saving.
Educational content, not investment advice. Finabase Learn explains how markets and tools work. It does not recommend any security or strategy, and examples are for illustration only. Investing involves risk, including the loss of principal. Rules and figures are for the United States unless stated and can change — check the cited source before you act. Data and corrections policy.
