Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Strategies · Long-term investing

Value vs. momentum: cheap stocks or rising stocks, tested

The rules behind value and momentum investing, and how the factor funds VLUE and MTUM did from 2013 to 2026, year by year, with their losing years and a mix of both.

On this page
  1. Two factors, two ideas
  2. The rules
  3. What the backtest shows
  4. Where each fails: the losing years
  5. Value and momentum compared
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Two of the best-documented patterns in stock returns pull in opposite directions. Value says buy what is cheap: companies whose prices are low relative to their earnings, book value or cash flow have, over long periods, earned more than expensive ones. Momentum says buy what is rising: stocks that have gone up most over the past year have tended to keep outperforming for a few more months. One buys the market's laggards, the other its leaders.

Both were found in decades of academic data, and both can now be bought as cheap index funds. This lesson states the rules each fund follows, tests the two funds from the same family, MTUM and VLUE, against each other from 2013 to 2026 with dividends, and shows their losing years, which are the real story.

Two factors, two ideas

Value goes back to Benjamin Graham, and in academic form to work such as Fama and French (1992), which found that stocks with high book value relative to price earned more than those with low. Explanations differ: cheap stocks may be riskier, or investors may over-extrapolate bad news and push them too low. Value investing as a strategy: the rules and a 26-year test tests a value rule on its own.

Momentum was documented by Jegadeesh and Titman (1993): stocks that rose most over the past 3 to 12 months tended to keep beating those that fell most over the following months. The usual explanation is behavioural: investors under-react to news, so prices adjust over months rather than days. Momentum has a known weakness, studied by Daniel and Moskowitz (2016): it can crash at turning points, when last year's losers rebound sharply.

The two are linked. A stock that falls becomes cheaper, so value funds tend to own recent losers, which momentum avoids. In long-short academic portfolios the two factors are negatively correlated (Asness, Moskowitz and Pedersen, 2013). In long-only funds, which both own the stock market, the link is weaker: MTUM's and VLUE's monthly returns had a correlation of 0.73.

The rules

An educational outline of how each fund chooses stocks, as published by its index provider, MSCI. Neither is a recommendation. Both funds charge 0.15% a year.

Value: VLUE (MSCI USA Enhanced Value Index)

  1. Start from the large and mid-sized US companies in the MSCI USA Index.
  2. Score each on three measures: price to book value, price to forward earnings, and enterprise value to cash flow from operations, compared within its sector.
  3. Hold the cheapest-scoring companies, weighted by a mix of their score and market value.
  4. Rebuild the list twice a year.

Momentum: MTUM (MSCI USA Momentum SR Variant Index)

  1. Start from the same MSCI USA Index.
  2. Score each stock on its price change over the past 6 and 12 months, excluding the most recent month, divided by its volatility.
  3. Hold the highest-scoring stocks, weighted by a mix of score and market value, with no issuer above 5%.
  4. Rebuild the list four times a year, in February, May, August and November, and in between if markets become very volatile. The fund's "SR Variant" index holds the same stocks as the MSCI USA Momentum Index but spreads each rebuild's trades over three days.

A holder's own rule is simply to buy the fund and keep it; the turnover happens inside the fund.

What the backtest shows

  • Data. Month-end closes of MTUM and VLUE from the end of May 2013, their first full month, to October 2026: 161 months.
  • Trading. Each fund is bought once and held, with dividends reinvested in the month paid.
  • Costs. Each fund's 0.15% fee and its internal trading cost are inside its price. No cost is charged for the one purchase.
  • Left out. Taxes. MTUM's November 2026 share split falls after the test.
MTUM (momentum) and VLUE (value), total return, May 2013 – Oct 2026 $1 $2 $5 Growth of $1 VLUE, value factor MTUM, momentum factor 0% −20% −40% Fall from the peak 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
MTUM (momentum) and VLUE (value), total return with dividends reinvested, month-end closes, May 2013 to October 2026. Top: growth of $1 (log scale). Bottom: fall from the highest value so far.
Measure MTUM, momentum VLUE, value
Total return 539.2% 403.7%
Return per year (CAGR) 14.8% 12.8%
Volatility (yearly) 16.9% 17.6%
Deepest fall from a peak −30.2% (Oct 2021–Sep 2022) −29.0% (Dec 2019–Mar 2020)
Longest time below a peak (months) 28 26

Momentum won the full period by two points a year. Split the period at the end of 2019 and the picture changes: before, MTUM returned 15.8% a year and VLUE 10.7%; after, VLUE returned 14.9% and MTUM 13.9%. One fund's lead depended on which stretch it was measured over.

Year by year

Year MTUM VLUE
2014 +14.6% +12.8%
2015 +9.0% −3.5%
2016 +5.0% +15.3%
2017 +37.4% +21.9%
2018 −1.6% −11.1%
2019 +27.2% +27.2%
2020 +29.8% −0.3%
2021 +13.4% +28.9%
2022 −18.3% −14.1%
2023 +9.1% +14.2%
2024 +32.9% +7.2%
2025 +22.1% +32.6%

Momentum led in six of 12 years and value in five; 2019 was a tie to the nearest tenth of a point. The gaps were often wider than ten points, in both directions.

A mix of both

Because the two lose in different years, holding both smooths the ride. A portfolio of 50% MTUM and 50% VLUE, reset to equal weights each December, returned 14.1% a year, close to MTUM's 14.8%, and its deepest fall, 25.2% from December 2021 to September 2022, was shallower than either fund's on its own. That is the practical argument Asness and his co-authors made for combining the two.

Where each fails: the losing years

  • Value's losing stretches. In 2015 VLUE lost 3.5% while MTUM gained 9.0%. In 2018 it lost 11.1%. In 2020 it ended the year down 0.3% while MTUM gained 29.8%, as the pandemic favoured technology and punished banks and energy, value's usual holdings. Its deepest fall, 29.0%, came in the February and March 2020 crash.
  • Momentum's losing stretches. In 2016 MTUM gained 5.0% while VLUE gained 15.3%, as the stocks that had led in 2015 reversed. In 2021 it trailed by 15.5 points, and in 2022 it fell 18.3%, its worst year in the test. Its deepest fall, 30.2% from October 2021 to September 2022, took until March 2024 to recover: the rotation out of 2020's winners hit a fund that had just loaded up on them, the turning-point weakness momentum is known for.
  • Both funds fell together in broad declines: 2018's fourth quarter, early 2020 and 2022. A long-only factor fund still carries most of the market's risk.

Value and momentum compared

Feature Value (VLUE) Momentum (MTUM)
Buys Cheap stocks on fundamentals Stocks with the strongest past returns
Typical holdings Banks, energy, industrials Whatever has led: often technology
Typical failure Long stretches when growth leads Sharp reversals at market turns
Return, 2013–2026 12.8% a year 14.8% a year
Fee 0.15% 0.15%

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not build factor portfolios or say which factor to hold.

  • Comparison. The comparison tab draws MTUM, VLUE and SPY from the same start date, so any period can be checked.
  • Screener. The screener can rank stocks by P/E or by one-year return, the raw ingredients of value and momentum, though not the funds' exact scores.
  • Backtest and Strategy. The Backtest tool trades indicator signals on one symbol with a fixed $10,000 per signal and no trading cost, and the Strategy tool replays if/then rules over two years, also without costs. Neither tests a factor fund over a decade; two years would have shown only one side of this comparison.

Frequently asked questions

Is value or momentum better?

Over May 2013 to October 2026 the momentum fund MTUM returned 14.8% a year and the value fund VLUE 12.8%, but VLUE led after 2019. Academic studies find both have earned premiums over long periods, with long runs where each trails.

Can you combine value and momentum?

Yes, and it has helped. In this test a 50/50 mix reset each December returned 14.1% a year with a deepest fall of 25.2%, smaller than either fund's.

Why does momentum crash?

Momentum holds recent winners. When the market turns sharply, as after a crash or a big rotation, recent losers rebound and recent winners fall, and the momentum portfolio is caught on the wrong side until its next rebuild. MTUM's 2022 fall of 18.3% followed that pattern.

What costs do factor funds have?

MTUM and VLUE each charge 0.15% a year, plus internal trading costs from rebuilding their lists: twice a year for VLUE, four times a year for MTUM. Those costs are inside the returns shown here.

Summary

Value buys cheap stocks; momentum buys rising ones. Tested on the two MSCI factor funds from May 2013 to October 2026, momentum returned 14.8% a year to value's 12.8%, but momentum's lead came before 2020 and value led afterwards. Each had calendar years more than 15 points behind the other, value in 2020 and momentum in 2021. Because they tend to lose at different times, a simple 50/50 mix kept most of the higher return with a smaller worst fall. Neither factor wins every period, and the losing years are part of the rule, not an exception to it.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Which describes the difference between a value rule and a momentum rule?

    1. Value buys stocks that are cheap on earnings, book value or cash flow; momentum buys stocks with the strongest returns over the past 6 to 12 months
    2. Both buy the largest companies
    3. Value buys recent winners and momentum buys recent losers
    Show the answer

    A. Value buys stocks that are cheap on earnings, book value or cash flow; momentum buys stocks with the strongest returns over the past 6 to 12 months Value looks at price relative to fundamentals; momentum looks only at past price changes. Because falling stocks get cheaper, value funds tend to hold names momentum avoids.

  2. MTUM returned 14.8% a year and VLUE 12.8% from 2013 to 2026. What happened when the period is split at the end of 2019?

    1. MTUM led in both halves
    2. MTUM led before (15.8% to 10.7%); VLUE led after (14.9% to 13.9%)
    3. They were equal in both halves
    Show the answer

    B. MTUM led before (15.8% to 10.7%); VLUE led after (14.9% to 13.9%) The full-period winner depended on the first six years. A result that hinges on one stretch should be read that way.

  3. Why did a 50/50 mix of MTUM and VLUE have a smaller deepest fall (25.2%) than either fund alone?

    1. Because the mix held bonds
    2. Because the two factors tend to lose in different years, so one often cushions the other
    3. Because the mix paid no fees
    Show the answer

    B. Because the two factors tend to lose in different years, so one often cushions the other Value lagged badly in 2020 while momentum soared; momentum lagged in 2021 and 2022. Combining two strategies whose bad years differ smooths the path.

  4. What is the known weakness of momentum that MTUM showed in 2022?

    1. It cannot hold technology stocks
    2. It can be caught holding last year’s winners when the market turns sharply, and fall hard until its next rebuild
    3. It pays no dividends
    Show the answer

    B. It can be caught holding last year’s winners when the market turns sharply, and fall hard until its next rebuild Momentum crashes happen at turning points. MTUM fell 30.2% from October 2021 to September 2022 and took until March 2024 to recover.

Sources and further reading

  1. Eugene F. Fama and Kenneth R. French, “The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns,” Journal of Finance 47 (1992)
  2. Narasimhan Jegadeesh and Sheridan Titman, “Returns to Buying Winners and Selling Losers,” Journal of Finance 48 (1993)
  3. Clifford S. Asness, Tobias J. Moskowitz and Lasse Heje Pedersen, “Value and Momentum Everywhere,” Journal of Finance 68 (2013)
  4. Kent Daniel and Tobias J. Moskowitz, “Momentum Crashes,” Journal of Financial Economics 122 (2016)
  5. iShares — MSCI USA Momentum Factor ETF (MTUM) and MSCI USA Value Factor ETF (VLUE): index and expense ratio of 0.15% each (read November 2026)
  6. MSCI — Momentum indexes and Enhanced Value indexes methodology
  7. MSCI — Momentum Indexes Methodology (July 2025): risk-adjusted 6- and 12-month momentum excluding the latest month, quarterly reviews in February, May, August and November, ad hoc rebalancing
  8. MSCI — Enhanced Value Indexes Methodology (June 2017): forward P/E, EV/CFO and P/B scored within sectors, semi-annual reviews in May and November
  9. iShares MSCI USA Momentum Factor ETF (MTUM) — summary prospectus (November 2025): tracks the MSCI USA Momentum SR Variant Index, reconstituted quarterly, 5% issuer cap
  10. MSCI — USA Momentum SR Variant Index Methodology (November 2020): the parent index’s rebalance changes spread equally over three days
  11. Finabase chart data — MTUM and VLUE month-end closes and dividends, May 2013 to October 2026; results computed by Finabase