Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Strategies · Long-term investing

Quality investing: the rules, and QUAL against the market

What a quality strategy screens for, and what 13 years of the QUAL fund against SPY show: nearly the same return, the same volatility and no smaller falls.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. The rules
  3. What the backtest shows
  4. Where it fails: the losing periods
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Quality investing means owning companies that are good businesses by measurable standards: they earn a lot on the money invested in them, they carry little debt, and their profits do not swing wildly from year to year. Where value asks whether the price is low, quality asks whether the company is good, and pays little attention to price.

The idea has strong academic support and an intuitive appeal: surely better companies make better investments. This lesson states the rules one widely held fund uses, then tests that fund, the iShares MSCI USA Quality Factor ETF (QUAL), against SPY since 2013. The answer is undramatic and worth knowing. Over 13 years the quality fund's price tracked the market's almost exactly, and in the one real bear market of the period it fell further.

The idea

A company that earns 25% a year on its shareholders' money, without borrowing heavily to do it, is doing something competitors have not been able to copy. If the stock market fully understood how long such advantages last, the price would already reflect it and there would be nothing to gain. The quality idea is that the market does not: it underprices dull, steady profitability and overprices exciting stories.

Robert Novy-Marx gave the idea its modern form in 2013. He found that gross profit divided by assets predicted US stock returns about as well as cheapness did, and that profitable companies outperformed even though they were more expensive. Fama and French added a profitability factor to their own model in 2015. Asness, Frazzini and Pedersen built a broader measure (profitable, growing, safe, well managed) and found that high-quality stocks had earned more than low-quality "junk" in most countries they examined.

There is an important detail in that research. Much of the measured effect comes from avoiding the worst companies, the unprofitable and heavily indebted ones, which have had poor returns. A fund that holds good large companies and is compared with an index of mostly good large companies has much less to gain. The test below is of that second kind.

The rules

These are the rules of the MSCI USA Sector Neutral Quality Index, which QUAL tracks, in outline.

  1. Start from large and mid-sized US companies.
  2. Score each company on three measures: return on equity (higher is better), debt to equity (lower is better), and how much its earnings growth has varied over the last five years (steadier is better).
  3. Compare each company only with others in its own sector, and keep the best scorers in each.
  4. Weight each holding by its market value multiplied by its score, and hold every sector at the same weight it has in the broad market.
  5. Rebuild the list twice a year.
  6. Reinvest dividends.

A person holding the fund follows one rule: buy it and keep it. Steps 1 to 5 are the index's.

Step 3 is what "sector neutral" means, and it shapes the result. Without it, a quality screen would hold mostly technology and health care, where returns on equity are high, and almost no banks or utilities. With it, the fund holds the best-scoring bank, the best-scoring utility and the best-scoring software company in market proportions. That removes the bet on industries and leaves only the bet on quality within them. It also guarantees the fund cannot stray far from the market.

What the backtest shows

The test, stated in full so it can be checked:

  • Data. Month-end closes of QUAL and SPY from August 2013, QUAL's first full month, to October 2026: 159 months.
  • Trading. Each fund is bought once and held.
  • Costs. One purchase each. The funds' costs are inside their prices: QUAL charged 0.15% a year and SPY 0.0945% in their 2025 prospectuses. The index's twice-yearly turnover is paid inside the fund.
  • Left out. Dividends on both sides, and taxes. The two funds' dividend yields have been close, both around 1%, so the omission barely tilts the comparison.
QUAL against SPY, monthly, 2013–2026: price only, no dividends $1 $2 $5 Growth of $1 SPY (the market) QUAL (quality) 0% −10% −20% −30% Fall from the peak 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
QUAL against SPY, month-end prices, 2013 to 2026. Price only: dividends are not included for either fund. Top: growth of $1 (log scale). Bottom: the fall from the highest value so far.
Measure, price only QUAL SPY
Total return 353.3% 361.8%
Return per year (CAGR) 12.2% 12.3%
Deepest fall from a peak −28.6% −24.8%
Longest time below a peak 23 months 23 months
Volatility, annualized 14.6% 14.4%
Beta to SPY 0.99 1.00
Value of $1 at the end $4.53 $4.62

The two lines in the figure can hardly be told apart. One dollar became $4.53 in the quality fund and $4.62 in the market fund. Volatility and beta, measured from monthly price changes, say the same thing: this fund behaved like the market.

Two halves

Period QUAL, per year SPY, per year QUAL's deepest fall SPY's deepest fall
August 2013 – December 2019 12.1% 11.3% −15.1% −14.0%
December 2019 – October 2026 12.3% 13.3% −28.6% −24.8%

Quality was a little ahead in the first half and a little behind in the second. Neither gap is large enough to mean much.

QUAL price divided by SPY price, month-end, 2013–2026 (start = 1) 0.95 1.00 1.05 QUAL ÷ SPY 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
QUAL’s price divided by SPY’s price, month-end, 2013 to 2026 (start = 1). The whole range is 0.95 to 1.07: the fund never moved far from the market in either direction.

The ratio of the two prices peaked at 1.067 in February 2016 and reached its low of 0.950 in May 2026. The whole range, over 13 years, is 12%. For comparison, the value fund IWD's price ratio to SPY nearly halved from 2007 to 2025 (Value investing as a strategy: the rules and a 26-year test). Over every five-year window in the data, QUAL's price was ahead of SPY's in 38 of 99, or 38%.

A second fund with different rules

Fund Index and rule Fund, per year SPY, same months Deepest fall
QUAL MSCI: return on equity, debt, earnings stability; sector neutral 12.2% 12.3% −28.6%
SPHQ S&P: return on equity, accruals, leverage; the top 100 of the S&P 500 12.2% 12.3% −25.3%

SPHQ, the Invesco S&P 500 Quality ETF, picks 100 companies without holding sectors at market weight, and uses accruals (how much of reported profit is not yet cash) in place of earnings stability. Its index was replaced in March 2016, so its earlier months follow different rules. Over the same 159 months it produced the same 12.2% a year. Two definitions, two providers, one result.

Where it fails: the losing periods

2022. This is the result that most contradicts expectations. From December 2021 to September 2022 SPY's price fell 24.8% and QUAL's fell 28.6%. Quality is often described as defensive, and in this fall it was not. The companies with the highest returns on equity were also among the most highly priced, and when interest rates rose quickly in 2022, high prices were what the market punished (The 2022 bear market: inflation, Fed hikes and falling bonds). A sector-neutral fund also holds its full share of technology, which a defensive fund would not.

The 2020 crash. From December 2019 to March 2020 QUAL fell 19.8% and SPY 19.9%. No difference.

Years behind.

Year QUAL SPY
2014 10.1% 11.3%
2016 7.0% 9.6%
2018 −7.4% −6.3%
2022 −21.7% −19.5%
2025 11.5% 16.4%

QUAL's price finished ahead of SPY's in four of the twelve full calendar years: 2015, 2017, 2019 and 2023.

Ten years below its own relative high. The fund's price against the market peaked in February 2016 and had not regained that level by October 2026, 128 months later.

Other ways it fails or misleads:

  • Paying for quality. The rules ignore price. A wonderful company bought at 40 times earnings can be a poor investment for a decade. Novy-Marx's own result was strongest when profitability was combined with cheapness, which this fund does not do.
  • Accounting measures can be managed. Return on equity rises when a company buys back shares with borrowed money, which shrinks equity. A high score can reflect financial engineering as well as a good business (Quality of earnings: accruals, cash conversion and red flags).
  • Quality fades. High returns attract competitors. A score is a record of the last few years, and the list is rebuilt twice a year precisely because companies fall off it.
  • A short, kind sample. From 2013 to 2026 large US companies of every kind did well. A period in which weak companies fail in numbers, the setting where the research finds the largest effect, was mostly absent, and the fund holds no small companies at all.

Compared with its neighbours

Strategy Selects on Price result against SPY in its test Deepest fall against SPY's
Quality (QUAL) Profitability, low debt, stability −0.1 points a year, 2013 to 2026 Deeper: −28.6% to −24.8%
Dividend growth (VIG) Ten years of dividend increases −0.9 points a year, 2006 to 2026 Shallower: −42.7% to −52.2%
Value (IWD) Low price to book −0.4 points a year, 2000 to 2026 Deeper: −57.4% to −52.2%
Market (SPY) Nothing n/a n/a

The periods differ, so the rows are not a ranking. They show that each selection rule changed the shape of the ride more than the destination.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not score companies for quality and no Finabase tool says what to buy.

  • Stock pages. A stock's page shows return on equity, P/E, price to book and beta, and its financial statements show debt and equity. Those are the inputs for judging one company against rule 2; the earnings-stability measure has to be read off several years of the income statement.
  • Screener. The screener filters on market capitalization, P/E, price to sales, dividend yield, earnings per share and volume. It has no field for return on equity or debt, so it cannot run a quality screen. It can narrow a list to profitable companies of a given size, which is a starting point for reading individual pages.
  • Comparison. The comparison chart linked above draws QUAL against SPY as percentage change, on prices, like this page.
  • Backtest and Strategy. These tools replay indicator signals and if/then rules on one symbol, buying a fixed $10,000 per signal with no trading cost; Strategy covers two years. They work on prices and cannot select companies by their accounts.

Frequently asked questions

Does quality investing beat the market?

Not in this test. QUAL's price returned 12.2% a year from August 2013 to October 2026 against 12.3% for SPY, and a second quality fund matched it. The academic studies that find a quality premium compare the best companies with the worst, over much longer periods, and include small companies.

Are quality stocks safer in a downturn?

Not in the downturns this test contains. QUAL fell as much as SPY in early 2020 and more than SPY in 2022 (28.6% against 24.8%). Its volatility and beta were the same as the market's.

What makes a company "high quality" in these funds?

A formula, not an opinion. QUAL's index scores return on equity, debt to equity and the variability of earnings growth, within each sector. SPHQ's uses return on equity, accruals and leverage. Competitive position, management and products are not measured directly.

Why did the quality fund track the market so closely?

Because of how it is built. It holds large companies only, keeps every sector at its market weight, and weights holdings partly by size. What is left is a modest tilt among companies that were mostly profitable to begin with.

Summary

Quality investing selects companies on profitability, low debt and stable earnings and ignores price. Tested through QUAL from August 2013 to October 2026, on prices without dividends, it returned 12.2% a year against 12.3% for SPY, with the same volatility, a beta of 0.99 and a deeper fall in 2022. A second fund using different measures landed on the same return. The test is short, covers only large companies and contains little of the corporate distress in which research finds quality matters most, so it cannot settle whether the quality premium exists. It does show that a sector-neutral, large-company quality fund has been a near copy of the market at a slightly higher fee.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A quality index scores companies on return on equity, debt and earnings stability. What does it leave out entirely?

    1. The size of the company
    2. The price paid for the stock
    3. The sector the company is in
    Show the answer

    B. The price paid for the stock Quality rules ask whether the business is good, not whether the stock is cheap. That is why a quality fund can hold very highly priced companies, and why it fell further than the market when high prices were punished in 2022.

  2. QUAL is "sector neutral". What does that do to the fund?

    1. It removes all technology stocks
    2. It holds each sector at its market weight and picks the best scorers inside each, which keeps the fund close to the market
    3. It gives every sector the same weight
    Show the answer

    B. It holds each sector at its market weight and picks the best scorers inside each, which keeps the fund close to the market Comparing companies only with others in their own sector removes the bet on industries and leaves a tilt toward quality within them. The price of that design is a fund whose beta was 0.99 and whose price stayed within 12% of the market’s for 13 years.

  3. From December 2021 to September 2022 QUAL fell 28.6% and SPY 24.8%. Which explanation fits the rules?

    1. Quality companies became unprofitable in 2022
    2. The highest-scoring companies were also highly priced, and rising interest rates hit high prices hardest
    3. The fund held more cash than the market
    Show the answer

    B. The highest-scoring companies were also highly priced, and rising interest rates hit high prices hardest Nothing in the rules protects against paying too much. The fall was about valuation, not business quality, and a fund that holds technology at full market weight had no defensive tilt to offset it.

  4. Research finds a quality premium over decades; this 13-year fund test finds none. What is the sound reading?

    1. The research is wrong
    2. The fund test settles it: quality does not work
    3. The two measure different things: the research compares the best companies with the worst, including small ones; the fund compares good large companies with a market of mostly good large companies
    Show the answer

    C. The two measure different things: the research compares the best companies with the worst, including small ones; the fund compares good large companies with a market of mostly good large companies A long-only large-company fund against a large-company index has little of the effect left to capture, and 13 mostly calm years contain little of the distress where weak companies fail. The test describes the fund, not the idea.

Sources and further reading

  1. Robert Novy-Marx, “The Other Side of Value: The Gross Profitability Premium,” Journal of Financial Economics 108(1), 2013
  2. Clifford S. Asness, Andrea Frazzini and Lasse H. Pedersen, “Quality Minus Junk,” Review of Accounting Studies 24(1), 2019
  3. Eugene F. Fama and Kenneth R. French, “A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model,” Journal of Financial Economics 116(1), 2015
  4. MSCI — MSCI USA Sector Neutral Quality Index methodology
  5. iShares — MSCI USA Quality Factor ETF (QUAL) fund page: index, expense ratio and yield
  6. Invesco PowerShares — announcement of ETF lineup changes, including SPHQ moving to the S&P 500 Quality Index (2016)
  7. Finabase chart data — QUAL, SPHQ and SPY monthly bars to October 2026; results computed by Finabase