Strategies · Trend and momentum
Sector rotation strategy: momentum across nine S&P sectors, tested
A sector rotation strategy holds the stock market sectors that rose most in recent months. Exact rules, a 27-year test on nine sector ETFs with costs, and why it trailed.
On this page
Sector rotation means moving money between the parts of the stock market, such as technology, energy and utilities, as their fortunes change. The phrase covers two different practices. One reads the business cycle and buys the sectors expected to do well in the next phase. That needs a forecast and a judgment about where the economy stands, so it cannot be written as a rule or tested. The other is mechanical: rank the sectors by recent return and hold the leaders. That one can be tested, and it is the subject of this lesson.
The test covers the nine original Select Sector SPDR funds from 2000 to 2026. Holding the three strongest sectors returned 5.4% a year. Holding SPY returned 6.5%, and holding all nine sectors in equal parts returned 7.0%. The rotation fell almost as far as the market in 2008. It was ahead in the early 2000s and in 2022, and behind in most of the years between.
The idea
The stock market is divided into sectors by what companies do. The Stock market sectors and industries: GICS and sector ETFs explained lesson lists them. Sectors behave differently: energy stocks follow the oil price, utilities follow interest rates, technology follows growth expectations. In any year the best sector and the worst are usually far apart.
Moskowitz and Grinblatt reported in 1999 that momentum among US stocks was largely an industry effect: industries that had outperformed kept outperforming for some months. A sector rotation applies that finding directly. It is a relative strength rotation whose list is the sectors of one market.
Two things make sectors a harder case than a list of different asset classes.
- They move together. All nine are parts of the same index. In a broad decline all nine fall, and the rule has nowhere to hide.
- Leaders are often crowded. A sector at the top of a six-month ranking has usually had a great deal of good news already.
The rules
The list, fixed in advance: the nine Select Sector SPDR funds launched in December 1998. They are XLK (technology), XLF (financials), XLE (energy), XLV (health care), XLU (utilities), XLP (consumer staples), XLY (consumer discretionary), XLI (industrials) and XLB (materials).
Checked once a month, on the last trading day:
- Compute each fund's six-month return: today's close divided by the close six months earlier, minus one.
- Rank the nine funds by that return.
- Hold the top three, one third of the portfolio in each, for the next month.
- Trade only when the list of three changes. On that day, set all three back to equal parts.
Two sector funds launched later, real estate in 2015 and communication services in 2018, are left out so that the list is the same for the whole test. When communication services was created, some large companies moved out of XLK and XLY into it, so those two funds changed character in 2018.
A worked example
At the end of June 2022 the six-month returns were: XLE 28.9%, XLU −2.0%, XLP −6.4%, XLV −9.0%, XLI −17.5%, XLB −18.8%, XLF −19.5%, XLK −26.9% and XLY −32.8%. The rule held energy, utilities and consumer staples for July.
Only one of the three had risen. The other two were on the list because they had fallen less than the rest. This is the rotation's habit in a falling market: after the single leader, it fills up with defensive sectors. In 2022 that worked. The rule lost 3.9% for the year and SPY lost 19.5%.
What the backtest shows
The test, stated in full:
- Data. Month-end closes of the nine funds from January 1999. Twelve months are set aside so that every lookback in the settings table starts on the same date, and the test runs from January 2000 to October 2026: 322 months.
- Trading. Ranking and trading both use the month-end close.
- Costs. 0.10% of the amount of every sale and every purchase, including the trades that set the three holdings back to equal parts.
- Left out. Dividends and taxes. Utilities, staples and energy pay much higher dividends than technology, so price-only data understates them, both in the ranking and in the result.
- The comparisons are SPY bought once and held, and all nine funds in equal parts, reset every month at the same cost.
| Measure | Three strongest sectors | SPY, held |
|---|---|---|
| Total return | 306.8% | 441.5% |
| Return per year (CAGR) | 5.4% | 6.5% |
| Deepest fall from a peak | −48.4% | −52.2% |
| Longest time below a peak | 71 months | 80 months |
| Time invested | 100% | 100% |
| Changes of the list | 220 | 0 |
The list of three changed 220 times, turning the portfolio over 3.4 times a year. With no costs the rule returns 6.1% a year, so a 0.10% cost per trade took about 0.7 points.
The fairest comparison is not SPY but the same nine funds held in equal parts, which uses the same ingredients with no ranking. That returned 7.0% a year with a deepest fall of 50.6%. The ranking subtracted 1.6 points a year from it.
How even the sectors were over the whole period is worth seeing:
| Held throughout | Return per year | Deepest fall |
|---|---|---|
| XLY (consumer discretionary) | 8.3% | −56.3% |
| XLK (technology) | 7.6% | −80.5% |
| XLV (health care) | 7.0% | −37.4% |
| XLI (industrials) | 7.0% | −58.4% |
| XLE (energy) | 6.3% | −71.3% |
| XLB (materials) | 5.8% | −56.4% |
| XLP (consumer staples) | 5.2% | −35.0% |
| XLU (utilities) | 4.4% | −48.2% |
| XLF (financials) | 4.2% | −80.0% |
The rule spread its time widely: every fund was on the list in between 26% and 43% of months.
The two halves of the period
| Period | Three strongest | SPY, held | All nine, equal |
|---|---|---|---|
| January 2000 – February 2009 | −2.1% a year | −6.8% a year | −3.4% a year |
| February 2009 – October 2026 | 9.5% a year | 14.1% a year | 12.7% a year |
In the first half the rotation lost less than either comparison. Its best relative year was 2000, when it gained 16.6% and SPY lost 6.0%: technology, the leader in March 2000 with a six-month return of 46.8%, dropped out of the top three as the bubble burst. In the second half it trailed SPY by 4.6 points a year and the equal mix by 3.2.
Where it fails: the losing periods
A broad decline: 2008. The rule lost 36.1% against 38.3% for SPY. In June 2008 its leader was energy, up 11.5% in six months, just before the oil price collapsed. From October 2007 to February 2009 it fell 48.4%.
Quick changes of leadership. These are the years it fell furthest behind SPY:
| Year | Three strongest | SPY |
|---|---|---|
| 2009 | 12.4% | 23.5% |
| 2012 | 3.4% | 13.5% |
| 2019 | 19.2% | 28.8% |
| 2023 | 6.0% | 24.3% |
| 2024 | 11.6% | 23.3% |
| 2025 | 1.7% | 16.4% |
2023 shows the mechanism. The market's recovery that year was led by technology and consumer discretionary, the two sectors at the bottom of the ranking in mid-2022. A rule that buys after six months of strength reached them late, after much of the move was done.
Other ways it fails or misleads:
- Concentration. Three sectors are a narrower bet than the market. A single sector can fall 80%, as technology and financials each did.
- Taxes. With 220 changes, most gains are realized within a year and taxed as ordinary income in a US taxable account. An index fund held throughout defers its gains.
- The weakest sectors did as well. Holding the three with the lowest six-month return, the opposite rule, returned 6.1% a year, more than the three strongest, though with a deeper fall of 64.1%. If momentum among these nine funds were dependable, the opposite rule would have done clearly worse.
Neighbouring settings
Return per year for each lookback and each number of sectors held:
| Lookback | Top one | Top three | Top five |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 month | 3.2% | 4.7% | 6.7% |
| 3 months | 2.9% | 6.1% | 6.1% |
| 6 months | 7.0% | 5.4% | 6.9% |
| 12 months | 5.9% | 7.4% | 7.7% |
The benchmark to beat is 7.0% for all nine held equally. Only the two 12-month rows for three and five sectors did, by less than a point, and the 6-month top-one cell tied it. The table has no steady slope across lookbacks. What it does show is that holding more sectors was usually better, which is a way of saying that the closer the rule came to holding everything, the better it did.
Adding an absolute test, leaving a slot in cash when its sector's own six-month return is negative, cut the deepest fall to 25.2% and the return to 4.9% a year.
Compared with its neighbours
| Strategy | Return per year | Deepest fall | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| Three strongest sectors (this page) | 5.4% | −48.4% | 2000 to 2026 |
| All nine sectors, equal parts | 7.0% | −50.6% | 2000 to 2026 |
| SPY held throughout | 6.5% | −52.2% | 2000 to 2026 |
| Strongest of five broad funds | 9.6% | −61.0% | 2004 to 2026 |
The last row is the test in Relative strength rotation: holding the strongest fund, tested. It covers a different period and cannot be compared directly, but the contrast is real: a rotation among funds that differ a lot, such as US, international and emerging stocks, had more to work with than a rotation among slices of one index.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not rank sectors into a portfolio for you or say which to hold.
- Strategy. The Strategy tool takes if/then allocation rules with weights and replays them over two years. A sector rotation changes its list about eight times a year, so two years shows plenty of switches, but two years of any strategy is a sample of one market mood, and the tool charges no trading costs.
- Chart. The Rate of Change (ROC): percentage momentum and how to read it study set to 126 daily bars is the six-month return the rule ranks by. The link above opens it on XLK; change the symbol to see another sector.
- Backtest. The Backtest tool works on one symbol, buys a fixed $10,000 per signal and charges no costs, so it cannot test a rotation across nine funds.
Frequently asked questions
Does sector rotation beat the S&P 500?
Not in this test. The three strongest sectors returned 5.4% a year from 2000 to 2026 against 6.5% for SPY, and against 7.0% for simply holding all nine sectors equally. It was ahead until 2009 and behind afterwards.
What is the difference between sector rotation and the business cycle approach?
The business cycle approach forecasts which phase the economy is entering and buys the sectors that have tended to do well in it. That depends on judgment and cannot be tested as a rule. Momentum rotation uses only past prices, so it can be tested, and this page tests it.
How many sectors should a rotation hold?
In this test holding more was usually better: five beat three in three of four lookbacks, and one sector alone had the widest range of outcomes. More holdings means less concentration and fewer trades, and it also means the strategy differs less from owning the whole market.
Why did the strongest sectors not keep winning?
Sector leadership among these nine funds often changed within months, and the rule buys after six months of strength. The published evidence for industry momentum comes from finer groupings and long-short portfolios, which this test of nine funds, long only, does not reproduce.
Summary
A momentum sector rotation holds the sectors with the best recent returns. On the nine original sector funds from 2000 to 2026, holding the top three by six-month return earned 5.4% a year after costs, less than SPY's 6.5% and less than the 7.0% from holding all nine equally, with a fall of 48.4% in 2008. It helped when one sector led for a long time, in 2000 and 2022, and hurt when leadership turned quickly, as in 2023 and 2025. Twelve nearby settings ranged from 2.9% to 7.7% a year, and the opposite rule did about as well, so this test gives no support for the idea that sector momentum alone is a dependable edge.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Why can a momentum sector rotation be backtested while a business-cycle sector rotation cannot?
- The momentum version uses only past prices and fixed rules; the cycle version needs a judgment about where the economy stands
- The cycle version uses more sectors
- Momentum data is more accurate
Show the answer
A. The momentum version uses only past prices and fixed rules; the cycle version needs a judgment about where the economy stands A backtest needs rules a computer could follow with no interpretation. "Hold the top three by six-month return" qualifies. "Buy what does well in the next phase of the cycle" depends on a forecast.
In June 2022 the top three sectors by six-month return were energy at +28.9%, utilities at −2.0% and staples at −6.4%. What does that show about the ranking?
- The rule only holds sectors that are rising
- The rule holds whatever ranks highest, including sectors that are falling less than the rest
- The data is wrong
Show the answer
B. The rule holds whatever ranks highest, including sectors that are falling less than the rest A ranking is relative. In a falling market most of the top three may be falling too. The rule is always fully invested in stocks, which is why it fell 48.4% in 2008.
The three strongest sectors returned 5.4% a year, SPY 6.5% and all nine sectors in equal parts 7.0%. Which comparison isolates the effect of the ranking?
- Against SPY
- Against all nine sectors in equal parts
- Against cash
Show the answer
B. Against all nine sectors in equal parts The equal mix holds the same nine funds with no ranking. The gap, 1.6 points a year, is what choosing the leaders subtracted. SPY weights sectors by size, so it differs for other reasons too.
Holding the three weakest sectors returned 6.1% a year, more than the three strongest. What does that suggest?
- Buying losers is the better strategy
- Six-month momentum did not separate winners from losers among these nine funds in this period
- Costs were charged only to the strongest
Show the answer
B. Six-month momentum did not separate winners from losers among these nine funds in this period If the ranking carried reliable information, the opposite rule would do clearly worse. It did not, so neither result should be read as an edge. The weakest three also fell 64.1% at their worst.
Sources and further reading
- Tobias J. Moskowitz and Mark Grinblatt, “Do Industries Explain Momentum?” Journal of Finance 54(4), 1999
- Sam Stovall, Standard & Poor’s Guide to Sector Investing (McGraw-Hill, 1996) — sectors and the business cycle
- Mebane T. Faber, “Relative Strength Strategies for Investing” (2010) — momentum rotation among sectors
- State Street Global Advisors — Select Sector SPDR fund prospectus (the nine funds launched in December 1998)
- Finabase chart data — monthly bars for XLK, XLF, XLE, XLV, XLU, XLP, XLY, XLI, XLB and SPY, January 1999 to October 2026; rules and results computed by Finabase
