Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Strategies · Long-term investing

Lifecycle investing: a target-date glide path, tested

Why lifecycle and target-date investing cut stocks with age, the rules of a glide path, and a 24-year test against fixed mixes, with and without monthly saving.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. The rules
  3. What the backtest shows
  4. Where it fails: the losing periods
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Lifecycle investing changes a portfolio on a schedule set by the investor's age, not by the market. It starts with mostly stocks, moves steadily toward bonds as the money comes closer to being needed, and never asks for a forecast. A target-date fund is the same idea sold as a single fund with a year in its name.

The schedule is called a glide path. This lesson explains why it slopes the way it does, writes one as rules, and tests it on a stock fund and a bond fund from August 2002 to October 2026, both as a single sum and with money added every month. The data holds prices only, without bond interest, so it shows what the path did to the falls and to their timing. It does not show what a saver would have earned.

The idea

Two things change as a saver gets older, and both point the same way.

The balance grows. A 30-year-old with $20,000 saved and thirty-five years of contributions ahead loses $6,000 in a 30% fall and then buys shares cheaply for years. A 62-year-old with $600,000 loses $180,000 and has three years of contributions left. The percentage is the same. The damage is not. This is the problem usually called sequence-of-returns risk: when a bad market arrives matters more than whether one arrives.

Future earnings shrink. Bodie, Merton and Samuelson put it this way in 1992: a young worker's largest asset is not the portfolio but the wages still to come, which behave more like a bond than a stock. Someone holding that large, steady asset can afford to hold stocks with their small financial savings. As working years run out, that hidden bond shrinks, and the portfolio has to supply the stability instead.

A glide path turns those two facts into a schedule. Vanguard's target-date funds, for example, hold about 90% in stocks for younger investors, about 50% at age 65, and settle at about 30% seven years later. Other fund families use different paths: the stock share at the target date ranges widely, which is why the SEC tells investors to read a fund's path and not only its year. Funds that stop changing at the target date are said to glide "to" retirement; those that keep reducing stocks afterwards glide "through" it.

In the United States these funds became the standard default in workplace plans after the Pension Protection Act of 2006 and a 2007 Department of Labor rule that named them a qualified default investment.

The rules

An educational outline of the glide path that is tested here:

  1. Hold two funds: a broad stock fund (SPY) and a fund of high-quality bonds (IEF, US Treasuries of 7 to 10 years).
  2. Fix the path in advance: 90% in stocks at the start, 50% at the end, falling by the same amount every month. Over the 24 years of the test that is about 1.65 percentage points a year.
  3. On the last trading day of every December, look up the path's stock share for that date and trade until the portfolio matches it.
  4. If money is being added, split each deposit by the path's share for that month.
  5. Do nothing else. The path does not speed up after a fall or slow down after a rise.

Rule 5 is what separates a glide path from market timing. The schedule is a function of the calendar alone.

A worked example

In December 2008 the path stood at about 80% stocks. A saver on the path had seen the stock part collapse during the year, so stocks were well under 80% of the balance. The December reset therefore bought stocks, at the end of their worst year in generations, even though the path as a whole was moving toward bonds. A glide path lowers the target slowly; in any one year the reset can still be a large purchase of whatever just fell.

What the backtest shows

The test, stated in full so it can be checked:

  • Data. Month-end closing prices of SPY and IEF from August 2002, IEF's first full month, to October 2026: 291 months, a little over 24 years. Think of it as the last 24 years of a working life, compressed: 90% stocks at the start and 50% at retirement.
  • Trading. The first purchase and every December reset happen at that month's closes.
  • Costs. 0.10% of the amount on every buy and every sell. Fund fees are inside the prices: about 0.09% a year for SPY and 0.15% for IEF (issuers' pages, November 2026). A target-date fund adds its own fee on top of the funds it holds.
  • Left out. Taxes, stock dividends and all bond interest.
Glide path from 90% to 50% SPY (the rest IEF) against SPY alone, monthly, 2002–2026, 0.10% per trade, prices only $1 $2 $5 Growth of $1 SPY alone Glide path 90% to 50%, price only 0% −20% −40% −60% Fall from the peak 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Glide path from 90% to 50% SPY (the rest IEF), reset each December, against SPY alone. Month-end prices, August 2002 to October 2026, 0.10% per trade; dividends and bond interest not included. Top: growth of $1 (log scale). Bottom: the fall from the highest value so far.
Measure Glide path 90% to 50%, prices only SPY alone, prices only
Total return 339.2% 723.4%
Return per year (CAGR) 6.3% 9.1%
Deepest fall from a peak −42.0% −52.2%
Longest time below a peak 57 months 64 months
Trading costs paid 0.6% in 24 years none

A single sum on the path fell 42.0% from October 2007 to February 2009. That looks like poor protection, and for that date it was: five years into the path the portfolio was still about 81% stocks. The path is not designed to protect a 40-year-old. By December 2021 it held 58% stocks, and in the fall to September 2022 it lost 21.3% against 24.8% for SPY.

Against fixed mixes and other paths

Portfolio Return per year, prices only Fall, Oct. 2007 – Feb. 2009 Fall, Dec. 2021 – Sept. 2022
Fixed 90/10 8.4% −46.9% −24.0%
Fixed 70/30 6.9% −35.7% −22.3%
Glide path 90% to 50% 6.3% −42.0% −21.3%
Fixed 50/50 5.2% −23.6% −20.7%
Steeper path, 100% to 30% 5.5% −43.9% −20.2%
Flatter path, 80% to 60% 6.6% −38.9% −21.8%
The path backwards, 50% to 90% 7.4% −29.2% −23.3%

Two things in this table are uncomfortable for the glide path, and both are worth stating.

First, on a single sum the path did worse than a fixed 70/30 mix, which has the same average stock share: a lower return and a deeper worst fall. It held the most stocks in 2008, the worst stock market of the test, and the fewest during the bull market after 2012. Running the path backwards would have done better on both counts. Over this particular history the schedule was badly timed.

Second, the 2022 column barely varies. Portfolios with 50% and 90% in stocks fell 20.7% and 24.0%. Bonds were supposed to be the safe part, and their prices fell as much as 17.9% that year as interest rates rose (The 2022 bear market: inflation, Fed hikes and falling bonds).

The two halves of the period

Period Glide path Fixed 90/10 Fixed 50/50 SPY
August 2002 – August 2014 6.2% a year 6.5% a year 5.0% a year 6.7% a year
August 2014 – October 2026 6.4% a year 10.3% a year 5.3% a year 11.5% a year

In the first half the path was close to an all-stock portfolio in both weight and return. In the second it had moved toward bonds just as stocks had their best twelve years, and it earned four points a year less than the fixed 90/10 mix. That is the cost of the path, and it was paid in exactly the years when the balance was largest.

With money added every month

A single sum is the wrong test of a lifecycle rule, because the rule exists for savers. So the same portfolios are run again with $500 added at every month-end, 291 deposits and $145,500 in all, split by each portfolio's weights.

The glide path of the test (share in stocks) and a saver's balance, 2002–2026 50% 70% 90% Share in stocks Glide path: 90% falling to 50% $0k $200k $400k Balance of $500 a month Fixed 90/10 Glide path Fixed 50/50 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
Top: the tested glide path. Bottom: the balance of $500 a month under three portfolios, month-end prices, August 2002 to October 2026, dividends and bond interest not included.
Portfolio Final balance Balance lost, Oct. 2007 – Feb. 2009 Balance lost, Dec. 2021 – Sept. 2022
SPY only $618,008 $16,763 $85,763
Fixed 90/10 $539,240 $13,712 $76,036
The path backwards $467,008 $4,408 $64,363
Fixed 70/30 $405,480 $7,741 $58,609
Glide path 90% to 50% $350,071 $11,210 $53,016
Fixed 50/50 $300,703 $1,949 $43,974

The losses are the change in the balance between the two month-ends, with deposits still arriving, so they slightly understate the market's damage.

This is the table that explains lifecycle investing. In 2008 the saver on the glide path lost about $11,200 from a balance of $40,345, and went on buying. In 2022 a fall half as deep for a single sum (21.3% against 42.0%) took $53,016 from a balance of $267,408: nearly five times as many dollars. The fixed 90/10 saver lost $76,036 in the same months. The path's whole purpose is the difference between those two numbers, and its whole cost is the difference between the final balances: $350,071 against $539,240 at prices only, a gap the missing bond interest would narrow but not close.

Where it fails: the losing periods

  • October 2007 to February 2009. The path fell 42.0% as a single sum. Anyone who thought "target-date" meant "protected" learned otherwise. The SEC found that funds dated 2010, meant for people two years from retirement, lost almost 24% on average in 2008, with a range from 9% to 41%, because their paths still held so much in stocks.
  • December 2021 to September 2022. The path fell 21.3% with 58% in stocks. The bond part fell too. A saver near the end of the path, with the largest balance of their life, took the largest dollar loss of the whole test.
  • 2014 to 2026. The path trailed the fixed 90/10 mix by about four points a year. In a long bull market the schedule sells stocks every year on the way up.

Other ways it fails or misleads:

  • The year in the name hides the path. Two funds with the same target year can hold very different stock shares at that year. The path, not the date, decides the risk.
  • One schedule for everyone. The path knows a birth year. It does not know about a pension, a house, other savings, health or a plan to work longer, each of which changes how much risk the portfolio can carry (Time horizon and risk tolerance: matching investments to goals).
  • Safe is relative. Bonds lost value in 2022, and over a retirement of thirty years too little in stocks carries its own risk of running short.
  • The order of returns is luck. In this history the path was beaten by its own mirror image. In a history with a crash at the end instead of the beginning it would look wise. No schedule can know which one it is in.
  • Fees and taxes. A target-date fund charges for the packaging. In a US taxable account the yearly shift from stocks to bonds realizes gains; in a retirement account it does not (Retirement accounts explained: 401(k), IRA, Roth and 2026 limits).

Compared with its neighbours

Approach Stock share over time Deepest fall in this test What it asks of the investor
Stocks only 100% throughout −52.2% Tolerating the largest loss at the worst time
Fixed mix (say 70/30) Constant −35.7% Choosing one number for a whole working life
Glide path Falls on a schedule −42.0% Following the schedule through booms and busts
Target-date fund A glide path run by the fund Not tested here Reading the path, paying the fee

The asset allocation lesson covers fixed mixes, and the rebalancing lesson covers the yearly reset both rely on.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not set a glide path or manage one for you. It helps with the checking.

  • Portfolios. A Finabase portfolio records trades and shows what each holding is worth now (Track portfolios and trades on finabase.io), which gives the current stock share to compare with the path. It also records dividends and interest payments, automatically from each holding's payout history or entered by hand. The path itself, and the dates on it, are yours to keep.
  • Comparison and Treasury yields. The comparison link draws SPY and IEF from the same start over two years, and the Treasury page shows what bonds yield today.
  • Backtest and Strategy. The Backtest tool trades indicator signals on one symbol with a fixed $10,000 per signal and no trading cost. The Strategy tool replays if/then rules with fixed weights over two years, also without costs. Neither can change weights on a calendar or add monthly deposits, and a path that takes decades cannot be judged in two years.

Frequently asked questions

What is a glide path?

It is the schedule by which a lifecycle portfolio or target-date fund lowers its share in stocks over time. The path tested here falls in a straight line from 90% stocks to 50% over 24 years.

Why hold fewer stocks when older if stocks return more?

Because the balance is larger and the time to recover is shorter. In the test a saver lost about $11,200 in the 2008 fall and $53,016 in the much shallower 2022 fall, simply because the balance had grown. Holding fewer stocks late limits the dollar loss when it would hurt most, at the cost of return.

Did the glide path beat a fixed mix in this test?

No. As a single sum it returned 6.3% a year at prices only against 6.9% for a fixed 70/30 mix, with a deeper worst fall. It held the most stocks during 2008 and the fewest during the long rise that followed. A different order of good and bad years would give a different answer.

Are target-date funds safe near the target date?

Safer than an all-stock fund, not safe. Funds dated 2010 lost almost 24% on average in 2008, and in 2022 bonds fell alongside stocks. How much a fund can lose near its date depends on its glide path, which differs from one fund family to another.

Summary

Lifecycle investing lowers the share in stocks on a fixed schedule as the money comes closer to being spent, because a fall late in life hits a large balance with little time left. A path from 90% to 50% stocks, tested on SPY and IEF from 2002 to 2026, fell 42.0% in 2008 while it was still mostly stocks and 21.3% in 2022, and at prices only it earned less than a fixed mix with the same average. For a monthly saver the same path cut the dollar loss of 2022 by about $23,000 compared with a fixed 90/10 mix and ended with a much smaller balance. The schedule buys a smaller loss at the end for a lower return along the way; whether that trade pays depends on the order of markets, which nobody chooses.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Two savers each see their portfolio fall 30%. One has $20,000 and 35 working years ahead; the other has $600,000 and 3. Why does a glide path treat them differently?

    1. Because the older saver’s portfolio falls by a larger percentage
    2. Because the same percentage is a far larger dollar loss for the older saver, with little time or new saving to make it up
    3. Because younger savers are better at picking stocks
    Show the answer

    B. Because the same percentage is a far larger dollar loss for the older saver, with little time or new saving to make it up The damage of a fall depends on the balance it hits and the time left. In the test a saver lost about $11,200 in 2008 and $53,016 in the shallower fall of 2022, because the balance had grown from about $40,000 to about $267,000.

  2. After a year in which stocks fell sharply, what does the December reset on a glide path usually do?

    1. Sells more stocks, because the path is moving toward bonds
    2. Buys stocks, because they have fallen below the path’s target share
    3. Nothing until stocks recover
    Show the answer

    B. Buys stocks, because they have fallen below the path’s target share The path lowers the target by only a point or two a year. A crash pushes the actual stock share far below it, so the reset buys stocks. The schedule follows the calendar and never reacts to the market’s direction.

  3. On a single sum, the glide path returned less than a fixed 70/30 mix with the same average stock share, and fell further. What is the fair reading?

    1. Glide paths do not work
    2. In this history the worst stock market came early, when the path held the most stocks; a different order of markets would favour the path
    3. The test used the wrong bond fund
    Show the answer

    B. In this history the worst stock market came early, when the path held the most stocks; a different order of markets would favour the path The path held about 81% stocks going into 2008 and less every year during the long rise that followed: about 70% by 2014 and 58% by 2021. The mirror-image path did better here for the same reason. The order of good and bad years is luck, and one history cannot rank the two approaches.

  4. A fund is named for the year 2030. What does the year tell an investor about how much it could lose in 2029?

    1. Very little: that depends on the fund’s glide path, which varies between fund families
    2. That it cannot lose money so close to the date
    3. That it holds only bonds by then
    Show the answer

    A. Very little: that depends on the fund’s glide path, which varies between fund families Funds with the same target year can hold very different shares in stocks at that year. Funds dated 2010 lost between 9% and 41% in 2008. The path, published in the prospectus, is what sets the risk.

  5. Why does the lesson add a test with $500 deposited every month?

    1. Because deposits remove the effect of trading costs
    2. Because a lifecycle rule is designed for people who are still saving, and the dollar size of a fall depends on how large the balance has grown
    3. Because a single sum cannot be rebalanced
    Show the answer

    B. Because a lifecycle rule is designed for people who are still saving, and the dollar size of a fall depends on how large the balance has grown With one sum, only percentages matter and the path looked poor. With deposits the balance is small early and large late, which is the situation the path is built for: it accepts big percentage falls on a small balance and limits them on a large one.

Sources and further reading

  1. Zvi Bodie, Robert C. Merton and William F. Samuelson, “Labor supply flexibility and portfolio choice in a life cycle model,” Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 16 (1992)
  2. SEC, Investor.gov — Target Date Funds, Investor Bulletin
  3. SEC, Release No. 33-9126, “Investment Company Advertising: Target Date Retirement Fund Names and Marketing” (June 2010) — 2010-dated funds lost nearly 24% on average in 2008, range about 9% to 41%
  4. US Department of Labor — Default Investment Alternatives under Participant Directed Individual Account Plans (qualified default investment alternatives), final rule, 2007
  5. Vanguard — “Vanguard’s approach to target-date funds” (glide path: about 90% stocks early, about 50% at 65, about 30% seven years later)
  6. iShares — 7-10 Year Treasury Bond ETF (IEF), fund page: expense ratio 0.15%, 30-day SEC yield 4.86% as of November 17, 2026, inception July 22, 2002 (read November 2026)
  7. Finabase chart data — SPY and IEF month-end closes, August 2002 to October 2026 (prices only, no dividends or interest); portfolios and results computed by Finabase