Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Strategies · Long-term investing

Dividend growth vs. high yield: VIG against VYM since 2006

Rising payouts or high current yield: VIG and VYM tested with dividends reinvested from 2006 to 2026, with their losing years and what each pays now.

On this page
  1. The rules
  2. What the backtest shows
  3. Where each fails: the losing periods
  4. Dividend growth and high yield compared
  5. How Finabase does it
  6. Frequently asked questions
  7. Summary
  8. Check your understanding

Dividend investors split into two camps. One looks for high yield: stocks that pay a large dividend today relative to their price. The other looks for dividend growth: companies with a long record of raising their dividend, even if today's yield is modest. The first buys income now; the second buys income that rises.

The two camps end up owning different companies. A high yield often belongs to a mature or struggling business whose share price has fallen; a long record of increases belongs to a company that has grown its profits for years. This lesson states the rules of the two biggest Vanguard funds that embody each idea, VIG and VYM, and tests them against each other from 2006 to 2026 with every dividend reinvested.

The rules

An educational outline of each fund's published index rules, not a recommendation.

Dividend growth: VIG (S&P U.S. Dividend Growers Index)

  1. Start from US common stocks, excluding real estate investment trusts.
  2. Keep companies that have raised their regular dividend in each of at least the last ten years.
  3. Remove the 25% of those companies with the highest yields, to avoid companies whose yield is high because their price has collapsed.
  4. Weight the rest by a modified market value that limits the largest companies, and rebuild the list once a year, in March.

High yield: VYM (FTSE High Dividend Yield Index)

  1. Start from the FTSE US All Cap Index, excluding real estate investment trusts and companies not expected to pay a dividend.
  2. Rank them by forecast dividend yield over the next 12 months.
  3. Keep the higher-yielding part of the list (FTSE does not publish every screen it applies).
  4. Weight them by market value, and review the list once a year.

A holder's own rule is to buy the fund and reinvest or spend the dividends. Since Vanguard's fee cuts of February 2026, VIG and VYM each charge 0.04% a year.

What the backtest shows

  • Data. Month-end closes of VIG and VYM from the end of December 2006, VYM's first full month, to October 2026: 238 months.
  • Trading. Each fund is bought once and held. Every dividend is reinvested at the close of the month it was paid.
  • Costs. Each fund's fee and internal trading costs are inside its price. No cost is charged for the single purchase.
  • Left out. Taxes. In a taxable account the higher-yielding fund pays more tax each year, which this test does not deduct.
VIG (dividend growth) and VYM (high yield), total return, Dec 2006 – Oct 2026 $0.5 $1 $2 $5 Growth of $1 VYM, high dividend yield VIG, dividend growth 0% −20% −40% −60% Fall from the peak 2010 2015 2020 2025
VIG (dividend growth) and VYM (high dividend yield), total return with dividends reinvested, month-end closes, December 2006 to October 2026. Top: growth of $1 (log scale). Bottom: fall from the highest value so far.
Measure VIG, dividend growth VYM, high yield
Total return 583.3% 477.9%
Return per year (CAGR) 10.2% 9.3%
Volatility (yearly) 13.5% 14.6%
Deepest fall from a peak −41.1% (2007–09) −51.8% (2007–09)
Longest time below a peak (months) 40 57
Dividend yield, October 2026 1.47% 2.24%
Payout growth, 2016 to 2026 7.8% a year 5.6% a year

VIG returned about one point a year more, with lower volatility and a much smaller crash. Split the period at the end of 2016 and the first half is level: VIG 7.0% a year, VYM 7.1%. VIG's lead came from 2017 on, 13.5% a year against 11.4%, when the growing companies it holds, including large technology firms with rising dividends, did best. VIG finished ahead in only nine of the 19 full calendar years, so the yearly scorecard was close to even even though the total was not.

What a payout that grows does

In October 2026 VYM paid more income per dollar: 2.24% against 1.47%. But ten years earlier VIG's payout per share was $1.724 and VYM's $2.138; by the 12 months to October 2026 they were $3.646 and $3.675. VIG's dividend per share grew 7.8% a year over the decade, VYM's 5.6%. For an investor who bought in 2016 and lived on the dividends, that growth narrowed the income gap year after year, which is the dividend-growth argument in numbers. SCHD vs. VYM: two dividend ETFs with different rule books shows a third approach, SCHD, whose payout grew faster still.

The tax side of a higher yield

The test leaves taxes out, and they work against the higher-yielding fund in a taxable account. On $100,000 at October 2026 yields, VYM would pay about $2,240 a year in dividends and VIG about $1,470. At a 15% federal rate on qualified dividends, that is about $336 of tax against $221, due every year whether the dividends are spent or reinvested. The difference of about $115 a year, roughly 0.1 points, is small next to the gap in returns, but it compounds, and at a 20% rate plus the 3.8% net investment income tax it grows. In an IRA or 401(k) it does not apply, which is one reason some investors hold high-yield funds there and growth-oriented funds in taxable accounts.

Where each fails: the losing periods

  • High yield in the financial crisis. VYM fell 51.8% from May 2007 to February 2009, deeper than the S&P 500, and took until March 2012 to recover. In 2008 it lost 31.9% against VIG's 26.7%. Its index was full of banks, whose dividends looked generous right up to the moment many were cut. That is the yield trap at index scale (Dividend cuts and yield traps: GE, AT&T and Intel on the record).
  • High yield in 2020. VYM gained 1.2% for the year while VIG gained 15.4%; energy and financial stocks, large in VYM, lagged badly.
  • Dividend growth in 2022. VIG lost 9.8% while VYM ended almost level at −0.4%. Rising interest rates hit the growing, more highly valued companies VIG holds, while VYM's cheaper energy and financial stocks held up.
  • Dividend growth in 2021. VIG gained 23.7% against VYM's 26.1%, one of several years when the cheaper, higher-yielding stocks led.
  • Both fell in every broad decline: 2008, early 2020 and 2022. Neither is a substitute for bonds or cash.

Dividend growth and high yield compared

Feature Dividend growth (VIG) High yield (VYM)
Selects on Ten years of dividend increases High forecast yield
Current income Lower (1.47%, Oct. 2026) Higher (2.24%, Oct. 2026)
Income growth Faster (7.8% a year, 2016–26) Slower (5.6% a year)
Worst crash −41.1% −51.8%
Tends to lag when Rates rise, cheap stocks lead Banks or energy are in trouble

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not run either rule for you or say which fund to hold.

  • Comparison. The comparison tab draws VIG, VYM and SPY from the same start date.
  • Dividends. Each fund's Dividends tab, such as VIG's, lists every payment, which is how the yields and payout growth here were added up.
  • Screener. The dividend payers screen lists established payers, a starting point for applying either rule to single stocks.
  • Backtest and Strategy. The Backtest tool trades indicator signals on one symbol with a fixed $10,000 per signal and no trading cost, and the Strategy tool replays if/then rules over two years, also without costs. Neither tests a selection rule over 20 years.

Frequently asked questions

Is dividend growth better than high yield?

In this test VIG returned 10.2% a year against 9.3% for VYM from 2006 to 2026, with a smaller crash, but VYM paid more income and led in 2021 and 2022. Each rule has its own bad years.

Why does VIG leave out the highest-yielding stocks?

Because a very high yield often means the share price has fallen on bad news and a dividend cut may follow. Removing the top quarter by yield is meant to avoid those traps.

Which pays more income, VIG or VYM?

VYM, today: 2.24% against 1.47% in October 2026. VIG's payout per share has grown faster, 7.8% a year against 5.6% over the ten years to 2026.

Are these dividend funds safer than the stock market?

Not reliably. VYM fell 51.8% in 2007 to 2009, more than the S&P 500. VIG fell 41.1%. Both are stock funds and fall with the market.

Summary

High-yield investing buys today's income; dividend-growth investing buys a record of rising income. On Vanguard's two funds from December 2006 to October 2026, with dividends reinvested, the growth fund VIG returned 10.2% a year and the high-yield fund VYM 9.3%. VIG's edge came from a much smaller fall in 2008 and from its holdings after 2016; VYM held up better in 2022 and pays more now, 2.24% against 1.47%, while VIG's payout grew faster. Both rules work as described and both lose for years at a time; the costs, in fees and in tax on dividends, are part of the comparison.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Why does VIG’s index remove the 25% highest-yielding dividend growers?

    1. To lower the fund’s fee
    2. Because a very high yield often signals a falling price and a possible dividend cut
    3. Because high-yield stocks cannot raise dividends
    Show the answer

    B. Because a very high yield often signals a falling price and a possible dividend cut A yield rises when a price falls. Leaving out the top quarter by yield is meant to avoid yield traps, the risk that hurt high-yield funds in 2008.

  2. What made VYM fall 51.8% in 2007–09 against 41.1% for VIG?

    1. VYM charged higher fees
    2. Its high-yield index held many banks, whose dividends were cut during the crisis
    3. VYM held bonds
    Show the answer

    B. Its high-yield index held many banks, whose dividends were cut during the crisis Selecting on current yield loaded VYM with financial stocks that looked generous just before the crisis. VIG’s ten-year growth record and yield cap kept it in steadier companies.

  3. In October 2026 VYM yielded 2.24% and VIG 1.47%. What did ten years of data show about income from each?

    1. VYM’s income grew faster
    2. VIG’s payout per share grew 7.8% a year against 5.6% for VYM, narrowing the gap for long-term holders
    3. Neither fund raised its payout
    Show the answer

    B. VIG’s payout per share grew 7.8% a year against 5.6% for VYM, narrowing the gap for long-term holders From 2016 to 2026 VIG’s payout per share rose from $1.724 to $3.646 and VYM’s from $2.138 to $3.675. A lower starting yield that grows faster can catch up.

  4. Which year shows dividend growth losing to high yield?

    1. 2008
    2. 2020
    3. 2022, when VIG lost 9.8% and VYM 0.4%
    Show the answer

    C. 2022, when VIG lost 9.8% and VYM 0.4% Rising rates hit VIG’s more highly valued growers while VYM’s cheaper energy and financial stocks held up. VIG won 2008 and 2020; every rule has losing years.

Sources and further reading

  1. Vanguard — Dividend Appreciation ETF (VIG): tracks the S&P U.S. Dividend Growers Index
  2. S&P Dow Jones Indices — S&P U.S. Dividend Growers Index methodology (ten years of increases; highest-yielding 25% excluded)
  3. Vanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF (VIG) — summary prospectus (May 28, 2026): modified market-cap-weighted index, REITs excluded, expense ratio 0.04%
  4. Vanguard Specialized Funds prospectus (May 29, 2025): the Dividend Growers index is reconstituted annually in March
  5. Vanguard — expense ratio reductions effective February 2, 2026 (VIG 0.05% to 0.04%, VYM 0.06% to 0.04%)
  6. Vanguard — High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM): tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index
  7. FTSE Russell — FTSE High Dividend Yield Index ground rules, v2.5 (October 2026): FTSE US All Cap universe, REITs and non-payers removed, 12-month forecast yield, annual review
  8. Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) — summary prospectus (February 27, 2026): stocks with higher-than-average dividends, expense ratio 0.04%
  9. Finabase chart data — VIG and VYM month-end closes and dividends, December 2006 to October 2026; results computed by Finabase