Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · Specialised funds

SCHD vs. VYM: two dividend ETFs with different rule books

How SCHD’s 100 screened dividend stocks differ from VYM’s broad high-yield index, and what each returned, yielded and grew its payout from 2011 to 2026.

On this page
  1. Two ways to pick dividend stocks
  2. SCHD and VYM compared
  3. Worked example: 15 years head to head
  4. Which to use when
  5. Pitfalls
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

SCHD and VYM are two of the most popular dividend ETFs in the US, and they are often treated as interchangeable. Both hold large US companies that pay above-average dividends, both cost a few hundredths of a percent a year, and their monthly returns have a correlation of 0.96. Yet in some years they finish more than ten points apart.

The reason is their rule books. VYM takes the broad route: hundreds of stocks with higher-than-average forecast yields, weighted by size. SCHD takes the selective route: 100 stocks that pass a ten-year dividend record and then score well on yield, dividend growth and financial strength. This lesson sets the two methods side by side and measures them from November 2011, SCHD's first full month, to October 2026.

Two ways to pick dividend stocks

VYM's index starts from the FTSE US All Cap Index, removes real estate investment trusts and companies not expected to pay a dividend, and selects on forecast dividend yield for the next 12 months; Vanguard describes the result as stocks with higher-than-average yields. Those stocks are weighted by market value, so the largest dividend payers dominate: big banks, drug makers, energy and consumer-staples companies, and large technology firms that pay modest dividends. The published rules set no dividend-history requirement and no named quality screen, though FTSE notes "additional proprietary screens" it does not publish. The result is broad and close to a value-tilted slice of the large-company market.

SCHD's index is narrower and more rule-heavy. To enter, a company must have paid a dividend for at least ten consecutive years and meet size and trading minimums; real estate trusts are excluded. The survivors are ranked on four measures: cash flow to total debt, return on equity, indicated dividend yield, and five-year dividend growth. The top 100 are held, weighted by market value with each stock capped at 4% and each sector at 25%. The list is rebuilt once a year, which can bring large turnover. How a stock index is built: eligibility, float and the divisor explains how such rules turn into a fund.

SCHD and VYM compared

Feature SCHD VYM
Index Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 FTSE High Dividend Yield
Number of stocks 100 Several hundred
Entry test 10 years of dividends, then a quality and yield score High forecast yield
Weighting Market value, 4% cap per stock Market value
Launched October 2011 November 2006
Yield, October 2026 2.95% 2.24%
Payout growth, 2016 to 2026 11.3% a year 5.6% a year

Worked example: 15 years head to head

The test uses month-end prices with every dividend reinvested in the month it was paid, from the end of November 2011 to the end of October 2026. SCHD split three for one in October 2024; the prices and dividends are adjusted for it. Fund fees are already in the prices. Taxes are left out.

SCHD and VYM, total return, Nov 2011 – Oct 2026 $1 $2 $5 Growth of $1 VYM, Vanguard High Dividend Yield SCHD, Schwab US Dividend Equity 0% −10% −20% −30% Fall from the peak 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
SCHD and VYM, total return with dividends reinvested, month-end closes, November 2011 to October 2026. Bottom: the fall from the highest value so far.
Measure SCHD VYM
$10,000 became $66,004 $58,377
Return per year 13.5% 12.6%
Volatility (yearly) 13.8% 12.9%
Deepest fall from a peak −21.6% (2020) −23.9% (2020)
2020 +14.9% +1.2%
2024 +11.7% +17.6%
2025 +4.3% +15.4%

SCHD finished ahead by about one point a year, but the path matters more than the total. Until 2019 the two were almost level: from 2011 to 2019 SCHD returned 13.6% a year and VYM 13.3%. Then came 2020, when SCHD's screens left it with fewer of the banks and energy companies that weighed heavily in VYM and fell hardest; SCHD gained 14.9% and VYM 1.2%. From 2023 to 2025 the reverse happened. VYM, which holds more of the large companies that led those years, gained about 45% in three years, SCHD about 22%. SCHD led in only six of the 14 full calendar years.

Yield against growth of the payout

The two funds also pay differently. In the 12 months to October 2026, SCHD paid $1.054 a share on a $35.78 price, a 2.95% yield, and VYM paid $3.675 on $163.74, 2.24%. Ten years earlier SCHD's payout was $0.360 a share and VYM's $2.138. SCHD's payout per share grew 11.3% a year over the decade, roughly twice VYM's 5.6%, which is what its five-year dividend-growth score is designed to reward. For someone living on the income, a higher and faster-growing payout from SCHD's 100 stocks came with more concentration and larger yearly swings against its peer.

Income from money invested ten years earlier

Payout growth shows up most clearly in the income an old purchase pays today. Take $100,000 put into each fund at the end of October 2016, with the dividends spent rather than reinvested:

  • At SCHD's split-adjusted price of $13.88, it bought about 7,205 shares. In the 12 months to October 2026 those shares paid $1.054 each: about $7,594, or 7.6% of the original $100,000.
  • At VYM's price of $71.22, it bought about 1,404 shares, which paid $3.675 each: about $5,160, or 5.2% of the original amount.

In 2016 the two funds yielded about the same, 2.6% and 3.0%. Ten years later the income from the same starting sum differed by about $2,400 a year. That is the practical meaning of a payout that grows 11.3% a year rather than 5.6%. It is also a record of one decade; the screens that picked companies whose dividends grew fast from 2016 to 2026 will not necessarily find the same growth in the next ten years.

Which to use when

Patterns in how investors use the two, not a recommendation:

  • Broad exposure to dividend payers with minimal rules points to VYM's several hundred stocks and its simpler, yield-based selection.
  • A higher current yield and faster payout growth have come from SCHD's screens, with a narrower portfolio.
  • Holding both is common, but the overlap is large: most of SCHD's 100 stocks also sit in VYM, and the 0.96 correlation shows how similar the ride is.
  • Total return is still the yardstick. Neither fund's yield is a return on its own; it is part of the total (Fund yields explained: SEC yield, distribution yield and total return).
  • Dividend growth funds such as VIG choose differently again, by years of increases rather than yield (Dividend growth vs. high yield: VIG against VYM since 2006).

Pitfalls

  • Reading one stretch as the answer. SCHD looked clearly better at the end of 2022, and VYM looked better after 2025. Fifteen years contain both stories.
  • Ignoring the annual rebuild. SCHD's yearly reconstitution can replace a large part of the fund at once, which shifts its sector mix suddenly.
  • Comparing prices across the split. SCHD's share price fell to about a third in October 2024 because of a three-for-one split, not a loss.
  • Taxes. Most of both funds' dividends are qualified, but in a taxable account they are taxed every year, whichever fund pays them.

How Finabase does it

The comparison tab draws SCHD and VYM from the same start. Each fund's Dividends tab, SCHD and VYM, lists every payment and SCHD's 2024 split, which is where the yields and payout growth in this lesson were added up. The figures come from frozen copies of Finabase's month-end prices and dividend records.

Frequently asked questions

Is SCHD better than VYM?

From November 2011 to October 2026 SCHD returned 13.5% a year against 12.6% for VYM, with a higher yield and faster payout growth. It also trailed VYM badly in 2024 and 2025. The two follow different rules, and which does better depends on which kinds of dividend stocks lead.

Why does SCHD have a higher yield than VYM?

Its index scores stocks partly on yield and holds only 100 of them, so it concentrates in higher-yielding names. VYM selects on forecast yield across several hundred stocks, including large companies whose yields are only modestly above the market's.

Do SCHD and VYM hold the same stocks?

Many of the same. SCHD's 100 are mostly a subset of VYM's several hundred, but in different weights, and SCHD's screens leave out companies VYM holds, including some of the largest.

How often do SCHD and VYM pay dividends?

Both pay quarterly. Their payments in the 12 months to October 2026 came to 2.95% and 2.24% of their prices.

Summary

SCHD and VYM both own US dividend payers but choose them differently. VYM holds several hundred stocks with higher-than-average forecast yields, weighted by size; SCHD holds 100 stocks with ten-year dividend records that score best on financial strength, yield and dividend growth. Over 15 years to October 2026 SCHD returned 13.5% a year to VYM's 12.6%, yielded more and grew its payout twice as fast, but the lead came almost entirely from 2020 to 2022, and VYM pulled back much of it from 2023 to 2025. They are close cousins, not twins.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. What must a company show before SCHD’s index will consider it?

    1. A high forecast yield, nothing more
    2. At least ten consecutive years of dividend payments, plus size and trading minimums
    3. Twenty-five years of dividend increases
    Show the answer

    B. At least ten consecutive years of dividend payments, plus size and trading minimums The Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index requires a ten-year dividend record, then ranks companies on cash flow to debt, return on equity, yield and five-year dividend growth. VYM’s index selects mainly on forecast dividend yield, with no dividend-history test.

  2. SCHD returned 13.5% a year and VYM 12.6% from 2011 to 2026. What is the most accurate description of how that happened?

    1. SCHD beat VYM by about one point every year
    2. They were level until 2019; SCHD pulled far ahead in 2020 to 2022, and VYM won back much of it in 2023 to 2025
    3. VYM led throughout and SCHD caught up only in 2025
    Show the answer

    B. They were level until 2019; SCHD pulled far ahead in 2020 to 2022, and VYM won back much of it in 2023 to 2025 SCHD led in only six of 14 full years. In 2020 it gained 14.9% against 1.2%; in 2025 it gained 4.3% against 15.4%. The long-run figure hides long runs in both directions.

  3. Someone put $100,000 in each fund in October 2016 and spent the dividends. Why did SCHD pay about $7,600 in the year to October 2026 while VYM paid about $5,200?

    1. SCHD’s share price rose less
    2. SCHD’s payout per share grew about 11.3% a year over the decade, VYM’s about 5.6%
    3. VYM stopped paying dividends for a year
    Show the answer

    B. SCHD’s payout per share grew about 11.3% a year over the decade, VYM’s about 5.6% Both yielded close to 3% in 2016. Ten years of faster payout growth turned SCHD’s income into about 7.6% of the original investment, against 5.2% for VYM. Past growth is not a promise of future growth.

  4. SCHD’s price fell to about a third of its level in October 2024. What happened?

    1. The fund lost two-thirds of its value
    2. A three-for-one share split: three times as many shares, each worth a third
    3. A large special dividend
    Show the answer

    B. A three-for-one share split: three times as many shares, each worth a third A split changes the number of shares, not their total value. Charts and dividend histories must be adjusted for it before comparing.

Sources and further reading

  1. Schwab Asset Management — Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD): index, holdings and expense ratio of 0.06%
  2. Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD) — summary prospectus (February 27, 2026): index rules, 4% stock and 25% sector caps, annual review
  3. S&P Dow Jones Indices — Dow Jones U.S. Dividend 100 Index methodology
  4. Vanguard — High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM): tracks the FTSE High Dividend Yield Index
  5. FTSE Russell — FTSE High Dividend Yield Index ground rules, v2.5 (October 2026): FTSE US All Cap universe, REITs and non-payers removed, 12-month forecast yield, annual review
  6. Vanguard High Dividend Yield ETF (VYM) — summary prospectus (February 27, 2026): stocks with higher-than-average dividends, expense ratio 0.04%
  7. Finabase chart data — SCHD and VYM month-end closes, dividends and splits, November 2011 to October 2026; results computed by Finabase