Funds · ETFs in depth
Active ETFs and ETF share classes: how stock picking moved into ETFs
How actively managed ETFs work, why most show their holdings daily, what mutual fund conversions change, and what the SEC’s 2025 ETF share class relief allows.
On this page
For most of their history "ETF" and "index fund" meant nearly the same thing. An ETF tracked a published index, anyone could see what it held, and the manager made no choices. That is no longer an accurate description of the market. By the end of 2024 almost half of all US ETFs were actively managed, and during 2025 they became the majority by number.
Two different changes are behind this, and they are easy to confuse. The first is the active ETF: a fund with a manager who picks securities, wrapped in the ETF structure instead of the mutual fund one. The second is the ETF share class: an existing mutual fund that adds an exchange-traded class of shares beside its ordinary ones, so one portfolio can be bought both ways.
This lesson explains how each works, what the wrapper changes and what it leaves alone, and what the SEC decided in November 2025.
What makes an ETF active
An index ETF's portfolio is dictated by a rulebook someone else publishes. An active ETF's portfolio is decided by its adviser. That is the whole difference in principle. The range in practice is wide:
- a stock picker running 40 positions;
- a bond manager choosing among thousands of issues, where "active" is the long-standing norm;
- a rules-based strategy that follows a formula of the manager's own without licensing an index;
- an options-based fund that holds stocks and sells calls each month (Covered call ETFs: JEPI, JEPQ and QYLD against SPY and QQQ);
- an ultra-short bond fund used as a cash substitute.
The first US active ETF was the Bear Stearns Current Yield Fund, launched on March 25, 2008, according to the SEC's Division of Economic and Risk Analysis. For a decade after that, growth was slow. Each ETF needed its own exemptive order from the SEC, a process that took months and money.
Rule 6c-11, adopted in September 2019, removed that step. Any open-end fund that meets the rule's conditions can operate as an ETF, and the rule draws no line between index and active funds. The main condition is disclosure: before the market opens each day, the fund must post the holdings that its next NAV will be based on.
The numbers
The SEC's economists counted ETFs from the annual Form N-CEN filings.
| Year end | Index ETFs | Active ETFs | Active share of funds | Assets in active ETFs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | 1,661 | 412 | 19.9% | $122 billion |
| 2021 | 1,743 | 638 | 26.8% | $293 billion |
| 2022 | 1,841 | 884 | 32.4% | $340 billion |
| 2023 | 1,841 | 1,131 | 38.1% | $452 billion |
| 2024 | 1,907 | 1,531 | 44.5% | $768 billion |
In four years the number of active ETFs multiplied by 3.7 and their assets by 6.3. The number of index ETFs rose 15%.
The Investment Company Institute's count for the end of 2025 is 2,454 active ETFs with $1.4 trillion and 1,970 index ETFs with $11.5 trillion. Active funds had become 55% of the total by number and about a tenth of the assets.
Those two shares say something about size.
A worked example with the SEC's 2024 figures. Active ETFs held $768 billion in 1,531 funds. Index ETFs held $7,709 billion in 1,907 funds.
active: 768 ÷ 1,531 = $0.50 billion per fund
index: 7,709 ÷ 1,907 = $4.04 billion per fund
The average index ETF was eight times the size of the average active one. An average hides the spread: a handful of active funds hold tens of billions each, and many hold very little. The ETF market also closes funds briskly. In 2025, 1,099 ETFs were launched and 224 were liquidated or merged, by ICI's count.
Showing the portfolio every day
A mutual fund discloses its holdings quarterly, with a delay. An ETF relying on Rule 6c-11 shows them every morning. For an index fund that costs nothing, because the index is public anyway. For an active manager it raised a fear: if everyone can see what the fund bought yesterday, others can trade ahead of the rest of its order, or simply copy the strategy without paying for it.
In 2019 the SEC approved several structures meant to answer that fear. The agency's paper lists them: the Precidian ActiveShares model, T. Rowe Price's proxy portfolio model, the Blue Tractor Shielded Alpha model and Fidelity's model. They are called semi-transparent or non-transparent ETFs. Instead of the true portfolio, the fund publishes a stand-in, such as a proxy basket that behaves like the portfolio or the real holdings at altered weights, that market makers can use for hedging. These funds cannot rely on Rule 6c-11 and still need an exemptive order.
The market's answer was to prefer full transparency anyway. At the end of 2025 ICI counted 30 non-transparent ETFs holding $22.8 billion, out of an ETF market of $13.4 trillion. Managers found that daily disclosure hurt less than expected for diversified portfolios in liquid stocks, and that hidden holdings came with costs of their own. Market makers who cannot see the portfolio hedge less precisely and quote wider spreads (ETF liquidity and bid-ask spreads: volume is not the whole story). The exemptive orders also limited what such funds could hold.
| Design | Holdings shown | Relies on Rule 6c-11 | Typical use |
|---|---|---|---|
| Index ETF | Daily, full | Yes | Tracking a published index |
| Transparent active ETF | Daily, full | Yes | Most active ETFs |
| Semi-transparent ETF | A proxy or partial picture | No, needs an order | Concentrated stock picking |
| Active mutual fund | Quarterly, delayed | Not an ETF | Any strategy, including illiquid ones |
What the ETF wrapper changes for an active strategy
Tax. An active manager trades more than an index does, which in a mutual fund means realized gains passed to shareholders. In an ETF, low-cost lots can leave through in-kind redemptions. In 2025, 9% of active ETFs paid a capital gain distribution against 53% of active mutual funds, according to State Street's tabulation of Morningstar data. ETF tax efficiency: in-kind redemptions, heartbeat trades and limits explains the mechanism and its limits.
Cost. ETFs have no sales loads or distribution fees built into share classes, and the fund does not keep each shareholder's account, so expense ratios tend to be lower than the mutual fund version of the same strategy. The investor pays a bid-ask spread instead.
Trading. Shares trade all day at a market price that may differ from NAV, where a mutual fund trades once a day at NAV exactly.
No closing the door. A mutual fund that grows too large for its strategy can stop accepting new money. An ETF cannot turn buyers away on the exchange, and stopping creations would let its price detach from its holdings. A strategy with limited capacity, such as one in very small companies, fits the ETF structure poorly.
Retirement plans. Most 401(k) plans are built around mutual funds priced once a day and do not offer ETFs.
What the wrapper does not change is the central question about active management: whether the manager's choices earn more than they cost. Index investing: passive vs. active funds and what the data shows sets out the evidence on that. An active ETF is cheaper to run and easier on taxes than the same strategy in a mutual fund, and it carries the same odds against beating the index.
Mutual funds turning into ETFs
A manager who wants its existing fund in ETF form has two routes: launch a new ETF beside it, or convert the fund. In a conversion the mutual fund is reorganized into an ETF. Shareholders wake up owning ETF shares of equal value, the track record continues, and the reorganization itself is structured so that it is not a taxable sale.
ICI counts 191 mutual funds with $113 billion in assets converted to ETFs from 2021 through 2025. That was 2.4% of the $4.8 trillion that flowed into ETFs over those years, so conversions are a visible trend and a small part of ETF growth. DFAC, a US stock fund from Dimensional that appears in Finabase's data, is one of the early large conversions.
A conversion has frictions. Holders need a brokerage account that can hold ETF shares. Fractional shares may be cashed out. And a fund held mostly in retirement plans has little reason to convert, since those holders gain nothing from the tax treatment.
The ETF share class
A conversion replaces the mutual fund. An ETF share class keeps it and adds the ETF beside it. One fund, one portfolio, one manager, and several classes of shares: the familiar mutual fund classes bought and sold at NAV, and one class that trades on an exchange.
Vanguard has run its index funds this way since the early 2000s, under a patent on the structure. The patent expired in 2023, and other managers asked the SEC for permission to do the same. Permission was needed because the Investment Company Act generally requires every share of a fund to carry the same rights, and an exchange-traded class with its own way of entering and leaving the fund does not fit.
On November 17, 2025 the SEC issued an order to DFA Investment Dimensions Group and related Dimensional funds. It was the first order of its kind since a series the SEC granted between 2000 and 2007, which Vanguard used for its index funds. The order permits a fund to offer one class of exchange-traded shares, an ETF Class, together with one or more Mutual Fund Classes. The application had been filed in July 2023, and the SEC published notice of it on September 29, 2025. Dozens of other fund companies filed similar applications.
The attraction is clear. The mutual fund classes gain a route for low-cost lots to leave in kind, which reduces capital gain distributions for every class. The ETF class starts with the scale and record of an established fund. A holder may be able to exchange mutual fund shares for ETF shares of the same fund without selling.
The concern is that the classes can affect each other. When mutual fund shareholders redeem for cash, the fund may have to sell holdings, and the trading costs and any realized gains land on the whole portfolio, ETF class included. Cash held to meet redemptions drags on returns for everyone. The conditions attached to the relief are aimed at this: the fund's board must find that the structure is in the interest of each class, and the adviser must monitor and report on the costs one class imposes on another. If the SEC adopts a general rule, the individual orders give way to it.
For an investor the practical points are modest. An ETF class is one more way to hold a fund that already existed. Its expense ratio may differ from the other classes (Fund share classes and loads: Class A, C, I and what each one costs). Its tax behavior depends on the whole fund's flows, not only on the ETF class's.
Four ways to package one strategy
| Feature | Active mutual fund | Active ETF | Converted fund | ETF share class |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trades | Once a day at NAV | All day on an exchange | All day on an exchange | ETF class on an exchange |
| Holdings shown | Quarterly | Daily, as a rule | Daily, as a rule | Daily |
| In-kind redemptions | Rare | Standard | Standard | Through the ETF class |
| Can close to new investors | Yes | No | No | Mutual fund classes can |
| Shares one portfolio with | Its other share classes | Nothing | Nothing | The fund's mutual fund classes |
| Available in most 401(k) plans | Yes | No | No | Through the mutual fund classes |
How Finabase does it
An active ETF has the same pages on Finabase as any other symbol: quote, chart and news, and a Dividends & splits tab listing its distributions. The Holders tab can show a fund card with the issuer, expense ratio, assets, NAV, top holdings and sector weights when the data feed carries them for that fund. The comparison tab rebases an active fund and an index fund to percent change from the first bar in view and tabulates price returns from one week to two years, leaving out dividends.
Finabase does not label a fund as active or index, and does not publish premium and discount history, median spreads or tax data. A fund's prospectus states whether it tracks an index, and its issuer's page carries the daily holdings.
Frequently asked questions
Is an active ETF riskier than an index ETF?
The structure is the same. The risk comes from the portfolio. An active fund can hold fewer positions and stray further from the market, so its return can differ from an index by a wide margin in either direction.
Do active ETFs beat their benchmarks?
The wrapper does not change the odds. Lower costs help at the margin. Long-run studies of active management find that most funds trail their index after fees, and nothing about being an ETF repeals that.
Why would a manager choose to hide the holdings?
To keep others from trading ahead of the fund or copying it. In practice most managers accepted daily disclosure: non-transparent ETFs held $22.8 billion at the end of 2025.
What happens to my shares if my mutual fund converts to an ETF?
They are exchanged for ETF shares of equal value, normally without a taxable sale, and appear in a brokerage account. An account that cannot hold ETFs has to be moved or the position is cashed out, which is taxable.
Is an ETF share class the same as a separate ETF?
No. A separate ETF has its own portfolio. An ETF share class is a claim on the same portfolio as the fund's mutual fund classes, so large flows in the other classes affect it.
Summary
- An active ETF puts a manager's choices inside the ETF structure. Rule 6c-11 treats index and active ETFs alike, provided holdings are posted daily.
- Active ETFs went from 412 funds and $122 billion in 2020 to 1,531 funds and $768 billion in 2024, and outnumbered index ETFs by the end of 2025. They hold about a tenth of ETF assets.
- Semi-transparent structures exist for managers who will not show the portfolio, and they have stayed small.
- The wrapper improves tax treatment and cost and adds exchange trading. It removes the ability to close a fund and does not improve the odds of beating an index.
- 191 mutual funds converted to ETFs between 2021 and 2025.
- Since November 2025 a fund can, with SEC relief, offer an ETF class beside its mutual fund classes. The classes share one portfolio, with the benefits and the cross-effects that brings.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
At the end of 2024, active ETFs held $768 billion in 1,531 funds and index ETFs $7,709 billion in 1,907 funds. Roughly how many times larger was the average index ETF?
- About twice as large
- About eight times as large
- About fifteen times as large
Show the answer
B. About eight times as large 768 ÷ 1,531 ≈ $0.50 billion per active fund and 7,709 ÷ 1,907 ≈ $4.04 billion per index fund, a ratio of about eight.
An active strategy in very small companies becomes too large for its market. What can its mutual fund version do that its ETF version cannot?
- Close to new investors
- Redeem shares in kind
- Publish its holdings quarterly
Show the answer
A. Close to new investors A mutual fund can stop accepting new money. An ETF cannot turn buyers away on the exchange, and stopping creations would let its price detach from its holdings.
A fund has an ETF class and several mutual fund classes. Mutual fund holders redeem heavily for cash. How can that affect the ETF class?
- It cannot, because each class has its own portfolio
- Only the mutual fund classes bear the trading costs
- The fund may sell holdings, and the trading costs and realized gains fall on the whole portfolio, ETF class included
Show the answer
C. The fund may sell holdings, and the trading costs and realized gains fall on the whole portfolio, ETF class included All classes share one portfolio. That is why the SEC’s conditions require the board to find the structure is in each class’s interest and the adviser to report on the costs one class imposes on another.
In 2025, 9% of active ETFs paid a capital gain distribution against 53% of active mutual funds. What does the lesson conclude from that?
- Active ETFs trade much less than active mutual funds
- The ETF structure does the work, not low turnover
- Active ETFs beat their benchmarks more often
Show the answer
B. The ETF structure does the work, not low turnover Active ETFs trade their portfolios far more than index ETFs, yet few paid gains. In-kind redemptions carry low-cost lots out of the fund. The wrapper does not change the odds of beating an index.
A stock picker does not want to publish holdings daily. What does the record since 2019 show about the structures built for that?
- They replaced transparent active ETFs
- They can rely on Rule 6c-11 like any ETF
- They need an exemptive order and stayed small: 30 funds with $22.8 billion at the end of 2025
Show the answer
C. They need an exemptive order and stayed small: 30 funds with $22.8 billion at the end of 2025 Semi-transparent and non-transparent ETFs fall outside Rule 6c-11. Most managers accepted daily disclosure, partly because market makers who cannot see a portfolio quote wider spreads.
Sources and further reading
- SEC, Division of Economic and Risk Analysis — The Fast-Growing Market of Active ETFs, by Rachel Li and Nadia Winn (February 2026): fund counts and assets from Form N-CEN, history, semi-transparent models
- SEC — Order under the Investment Company Act, Release No. IC-35786 (November 17, 2025): DFA Investment Dimensions Group Inc. et al., ETF Class and Mutual Fund Classes of one fund (File No. 812-15484)
- 17 CFR 270.6c-11 — Exchange-traded funds: daily portfolio holdings disclosure
- Investment Company Institute — 2026 Investment Company Fact Book, chapter 4: ETF launches, closures and mutual fund conversions, 2021–2025
- Investment Company Institute — Frequently asked questions about ETFs (updated April 2026): index, active and non-transparent ETFs at year-end 2025
- Investment Company Institute — ICI Research Perspective vol. 31, no. 7 (September 2025): growth of active ETFs to June 2025
- State Street Investment Management — share of active ETFs and active mutual funds paying capital gains in 2025, from Morningstar data (article of February 18, 2026)
