Funds · ETFs in depth
Premiums and discounts in ETFs: why price and NAV disagree
How an ETF premium or discount is measured, why foreign-stock and bond funds show more of them, what stress and halted creations do, and what funds must disclose.
On this page
- How it is measured
- Cause one: the cost of closing the gap
- Cause two: a NAV that is out of date
- Cause three: bonds are priced by estimate, and at the bid
- Cause four: stress
- Cause five: creations have stopped
- What a fund must tell you
- The causes side by side
- How Finabase does it
- Frequently asked questions
- Summary
- Check your understanding
An ETF has two values at the end of every trading day. One is its net asset value (NAV), the worth of everything the fund holds divided by the number of shares. The other is the price of the last trade on the exchange. They are worked out by different people from different information, and they are rarely identical.
When the price is above NAV the fund is at a premium. When it is below, it is at a discount. For a large US stock fund the difference is usually a few hundredths of a percent and can be ignored. For a fund of foreign stocks or corporate bonds it is larger, it has a direction, and on a bad day it can reach several percent.
This lesson measures the gap on real funds and sorts its causes into four: trading costs, a NAV that is out of date, markets under stress, and a creation process that has stopped. Only the last one is a fault in the fund.
How it is measured
A positive result is a premium and a negative one a discount.
The SEC's ETF rule, Rule 6c-11, fixes both inputs. NAV is the fund's own calculation, usually as of 4:00 p.m. Eastern time. The market price is the official closing price on the exchange. If the midpoint between the national best bid and best offer at the moment NAV is calculated gives a truer picture, the fund uses that midpoint instead. The midpoint matters for a fund that trades rarely, whose last trade may have been hours before the close.
A worked example. On November 17, 2026 the iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG) closed at $95.26, and its page reported a premium/discount of −0.03%. Rearranging the formula gives the NAV that implies:
NAV = 95.26 ÷ (1 − 0.0003) = $95.29
discount in dollars = 95.29 − 95.26 = $0.03 a share
Three cents on a $95 share is smaller than the cost of trading most of the bonds inside the fund. The same day the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF (EEM) showed a premium of 0.37%, more than ten times as large, and nothing was wrong with either fund.
Cause one: the cost of closing the gap
An authorized participant can buy an ETF's holdings, hand them to the fund and receive new shares, or do the reverse. That trade pulls the price toward NAV, and it pays only when the gap is bigger than what the trade costs. How ETFs work: creation, redemption, NAV and the arbitrage band works through the arithmetic. The result is a band on either side of NAV inside which the price can wander.
The band is as wide as the holdings are expensive to trade. Large US stocks trade for a cent or two. A high-yield bond may cost half a percent or more to buy and sell. So the normal premium or discount of a fund is set mainly by what it owns.
Cause two: a NAV that is out of date
NAV is calculated from the last available price of each holding. If a holding's own market closed hours ago, that price is old.
A US fund of non-US stocks strikes its NAV at 4:00 p.m. in New York. Tokyo closed about fourteen hours earlier and London more than four. Anything that happened in the afternoon is in the ETF's price, because the ETF was trading, and is not in the closing prices of the stocks it owns. Funds adjust for this with fair value pricing, an estimate of what the foreign stocks would be worth at 4:00 p.m., but an estimate made by a pricing model and one made by a market of traders will not match.
There is a way to see this with public data. Vanguard runs several portfolios that have both an ETF share class and a conventional mutual fund share class. VTI and VTSAX are two classes of one US stock portfolio. VXUS and VTIAX are two classes of one non-US stock portfolio. The ETF closes at a market price. The mutual fund class is priced at NAV. The ratio between them should be constant, apart from dividends, and any wobble in that ratio is a premium or discount.
Over 487 trading days to November 16, 2026:
| Pair | Median gap | 95th percentile | Days over 25 basis points | Largest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| VTI against VTSAX (US) | 1.2 basis points | 4.4 basis points | 1 | +64 on April 9, 2025 |
| VXUS against VTIAX (non-US) | 6.2 basis points | 26.2 basis points | 28 | +90 on April 9, 2025 |
The two funds have the same manager and the same design, and both gaps are measured the same way. The only difference is where the stocks trade. The fund of non-US stocks has a typical gap five times as wide.
April 9, 2025 shows the mechanism. US stocks jumped in the afternoon, after European and Asian exchanges had closed. VXUS rose 7.13% on the day. The NAV of VTIAX, the same portfolio, rose 5.64%. The next day the ETF fell 1.80% and the NAV fell 0.95%, as the foreign markets caught up and the gap closed. Over the two days together the ETF gained about 5.2% and the NAV about 4.6%, a smaller difference than on either day alone. The ETF had priced on Wednesday part of what the NAV recorded on Thursday.
The method has limits. It measures the gap against its own recent median, so a premium that lasted for weeks would not show. A few days on which the data vendor repeated the previous NAV were dropped. The fund's own premium and discount table, described below, is the authoritative record.
Cause three: bonds are priced by estimate, and at the bid
Most bonds do not trade every day. A bond fund's NAV is built from evaluated prices, a pricing service's estimate of what each bond would fetch. Those estimates are commonly set at the bid side of the market, the price a dealer would pay. The ETF itself trades all day at prices between its own bid and offer.
Two things follow. The ETF's price tends to sit a little above a NAV struck at bid prices, so a small premium is the normal state. And when the bond market moves fast, the ETF's price reacts at once while the evaluated prices follow.
Each fund publishes how many days it closed above and below NAV. The counts for 2025:
| Fund | What it holds | Premium | At NAV | Discount | Share of days at a premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY | S&P 500 | 123 | 0 | 127 | 49% |
| IVV | S&P 500 | 129 | 26 | 94 | 52% |
| IWM | US small companies | 121 | 17 | 111 | 49% |
| EEM | Emerging market stocks | 122 | 6 | 121 | 49% |
| AGG | US investment-grade bonds | 171 | 26 | 52 | 69% |
| LQD | Investment-grade corporates | 185 | 9 | 55 | 74% |
| TLT | Treasuries of 20 years or more | 220 | 10 | 20 | 88% |
| HYG | High-yield corporates | 218 | 6 | 25 | 88% |
| EMB | Emerging market dollar bonds | 225 | 2 | 23 | 90% |
The four stock funds are close to a coin toss. All five bond funds closed above NAV on at least two days in three. A count of days says nothing about size: most of those premiums were a few hundredths of a percent.
Cause four: stress
In a sell-off all three causes grow together. Trading costs rise, so the band widens. Prices move quickly, so evaluated bond prices lag. And investors who want out sell the ETF, because it is the thing they can sell.
March 2020 is the reference case. According to the Investment Company Institute, at the peak of that month's turmoil investment-grade bond ETFs traded at average discounts of nearly 300 basis points, or 3%, and high-yield bond ETFs at more than 200 basis points. Creations and redemptions were running at a record pace at the time, so authorized participants had not withdrawn. The discounts measured what it cost to sell corporate bonds that week, and how far the evaluated prices in the NAV were behind.
Whether the price or the NAV was "right" cannot be settled from the gap alone. A seller who needed cash received the ETF price. A fund holder who waited saw the discount close within weeks as bond markets recovered. ICI's study quotes an SEC staff report on that period as finding that ETFs "generally functioned as expected".
Cause five: creations have stopped
The first four causes are the ETF working as designed. The fifth is the mechanism being switched off.
If a fund cannot issue new shares, extra demand has nowhere to go except into the price. On April 21, 2020 the United States Oil Fund (USO) reported that it had sold every share it had registered and was suspending sales of new creation baskets until more were registered. Redemptions continued. A fund in that state can trade at a premium for as long as buyers outnumber sellers, in the same way a closed-end fund can (Closed-end funds: discounts, premiums, leverage and distributions). Exchange-traded notes whose issuers stop issuing behave the same way (ETNs vs ETFs: an unsecured note is not a fund).
A buyer who pays a premium of this kind is exposed to two things at once: the assets, and the premium disappearing when creations resume. Authorized participants and creation units: the ETF primary market covers how the creation window works and the other ways it can close.
What a fund must tell you
Under Rule 6c-11 an ETF's website must show, each business day:
- its NAV, market price and premium or discount as of the prior business day;
- a table and a line graph of its premiums and discounts for the latest calendar year and the quarters since;
- its median bid-ask spread over the last 30 calendar days; and
- if the premium or discount was above 2% for more than seven consecutive trading days, a statement saying so and discussing the likely causes, kept on the site for at least a year.
The rule covers ETFs organized as open-end funds. SPY is a unit investment trust and publishes the same kind of table on its page: 123 days at a premium and 127 at a discount in 2025.
The causes side by side
| Cause | Typical size | Direction | Does it correct by itself? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trading-cost band | Hundredths of a percent | Either | It is the normal state |
| Stale foreign NAV | Tenths of a percent, more on big days | Either | Yes, when the home market reopens |
| Bond pricing at bid | Hundredths to tenths | Mostly premium | It is the normal state |
| Market stress | Up to several percent | Mostly discount | Yes, as trading costs fall |
| Creations suspended | No limit | Premium | Only when creations resume |
How Finabase does it
Finabase shows an ETF's market price: the quote, the chart and the news on its symbol page. The Holders tab can show a fund card that includes the NAV when the data feed carries it for that fund. The comparison tab rebases two symbols to percent change from the first bar in view, so placing VXUS beside VTIAX shows the ETF's close and the mutual fund class's NAV moving together and, on some days, apart.
Finabase does not publish intraday indicative values or premium and discount history. The table and graph that Rule 6c-11 requires are on each issuer's fund page, usually under a heading such as "Premium/Discount".
Frequently asked questions
Is a discount a chance to buy the holdings cheaply?
Sometimes, and often not. If the NAV is stale, the discount is the market's updated estimate of the same assets and there is no bargain in it. A discount caused by trading costs is not collectable by an ordinary investor, who cannot redeem shares with the fund.
Why do bond ETFs trade at a premium most days?
Their NAV is commonly struck from bid-side bond prices, while the ETF trades at prices between its own bid and offer. A price near the middle of the bond market is above a NAV at the bid. In 2025 HYG closed above NAV on 218 of 249 trading days.
How large a premium or discount is unusual?
It depends on the holdings. A tenth of a percent is large for an S&P 500 fund and ordinary for an emerging market fund. The fund's own history is the comparison. The rule treats more than 2% for more than seven trading days as worth a public explanation.
Does the premium or discount affect long-term returns?
Only through the difference between the gap on the day of purchase and the gap on the day of sale. Buying at a 0.3% premium and selling at a 0.2% discount costs 0.5%, once. Held for years, that is small beside the expense ratio. Traded monthly, it is not.
What is the intraday indicative value?
An estimate of NAV per share published during the trading day from the latest prices of the holdings. It shares the weakness of NAV: for foreign stocks and bonds it is built from old or estimated prices.
Summary
- A premium or discount is the ETF's market price measured against its NAV, as a percentage of NAV.
- The gap has a normal width set by the cost of trading the holdings, and it widens when those costs rise.
- For foreign stocks the NAV is partly out of date at 4:00 p.m. New York time. VXUS showed a typical gap five times as wide as VTI over the two years to November 2026.
- Bond ETFs sit at a small premium on most days, because NAV uses evaluated prices that are commonly set at the bid.
- Stress produces the large discounts, as in March 2020. Suspended creations produce premiums that have no ceiling.
- The issuer's page carries the daily figure, the history and the 30-day median spread. Rule 6c-11 requires all three.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
AGG closed at $95.26 and its page showed a premium/discount of −0.03%. What NAV does that imply?
- $95.23
- $95.29
- $98.12
Show the answer
B. $95.29 NAV = price ÷ (1 + premium) = 95.26 ÷ (1 − 0.0003) ≈ $95.29. A negative figure is a discount, so NAV is above the price, here by about three cents.
VTI and VXUS are both Vanguard ETFs with a mutual fund twin. Over two years VXUS’s median gap to its twin’s NAV was 6.2 basis points against VTI’s 1.2. What best explains the difference?
- VXUS has fewer market makers
- VXUS is managed less carefully
- VXUS holds stocks whose markets closed hours before its 4:00 p.m. NAV, so the NAV is partly out of date
Show the answer
C. VXUS holds stocks whose markets closed hours before its 4:00 p.m. NAV, so the NAV is partly out of date Same manager, same design, same measurement. The difference is where the stocks trade: foreign closing prices miss what happens in the New York afternoon, while the ETF’s price includes it.
In 2025 HYG closed above NAV on 218 of 249 trading days. What is the most likely reason?
- Its NAV uses evaluated bond prices commonly set at the bid, while the ETF trades between its own bid and offer
- Its creations were suspended for most of the year
- Investors were overpaying for the fund
Show the answer
A. Its NAV uses evaluated bond prices commonly set at the bid, while the ETF trades between its own bid and offer A market price near the middle of the bond market sits above a NAV struck near the bid. A small premium is the normal state for bond ETFs, and most of those premiums were a few hundredths of a percent.
An investor buys an ETF at a 0.3% premium and later sells it at a 0.2% discount. What did the change in premium cost, once?
- 0.1%
- 0.3%
- 0.5%
Show the answer
C. 0.5% The cost is the difference between the gap at purchase and the gap at sale: +0.3% to −0.2% is 0.5%. Held for years that is small beside the expense ratio; traded monthly it is not.
An open-end ETF closes at a premium above 2% for nine consecutive trading days. What does Rule 6c-11 require?
- A statement on its website saying so and discussing the likely causes, kept for at least a year
- An immediate halt of creations
- Nothing beyond the usual daily figure
Show the answer
A. A statement on its website saying so and discussing the likely causes, kept for at least a year A premium or discount above 2% for more than seven consecutive trading days triggers a website statement with a discussion of the factors behind it, maintained for at least one year.
Sources and further reading
- 17 CFR 270.6c-11 — Exchange-traded funds: definitions of market price and premium or discount; website disclosure, including the 2% for seven trading days statement
- Investment Company Institute — A Close Look at Exchange-Traded Funds and Their Investors, ICI Research Perspective vol. 31, no. 7 (September 2025): bond ETF discounts in March 2020
- iShares — fund pages for IVV, IWM, EEM, AGG, LQD, HYG, TLT and EMB: premium/discount tables for 2025 and the latest premium or discount, read November 18, 2026
- State Street Investment Management — SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY) fund page: days at a premium and at a discount, read November 18, 2026
- United States Oil Fund, LP — Form 8-K of April 21, 2020: sales of creation baskets suspended
- SEC, Investor.gov — Updated Investor Bulletin: Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs)
- Finabase chart data — daily closes of VTI, VXUS and the NAVs of VTSAX and VTIAX, November 2024 to November 2026; gaps computed by Finabase
