Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · ETFs in depth

Securities lending in funds: who borrows, who earns, what goes wrong

How index funds and ETFs lend their holdings, what collateral backs a loan, how the income is split, how much it adds in real funds and the risks holders carry.

On this page
  1. How a loan works
  2. How the income is divided
  3. What seven funds earned
  4. The limit on lending
  5. What can go wrong
  6. Who is on the other side
  7. Lending compared across fund types
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

An index fund that owns every stock in the Russell 2000 will hold most of them for years. In the meantime other people want those exact shares for a few days or weeks: short sellers who need to deliver stock they have sold, and dealers covering a trade that failed to settle. The fund can lend its shares to them, take collateral, and collect a fee.

That is securities lending. It is a side business run inside most large index funds and ETFs, it rarely appears in marketing, and for some funds it pays for more than half of the management fee. For others it adds almost nothing. The income belongs to the fund's shareholders only after a lending agent, often the fund manager's own affiliate, has taken a share.

This lesson goes through how a loan works, what the split is at two large fund families, what seven real funds earned in their latest fiscal year, and the risks that come with the income.

How a loan works

A securities loan has three parties.

A securities loan from a fund The fund (lender) owns the shares keeps the economic exposure Lending agent finds borrowers, holds and invests the collateral Borrower a broker-dealer, often for a client who is short Shares go out on loan → ← Collateral worth at least 100% of the loan comes back, reset every day Where the income goes The borrower pays a fee, or the cash collateral earns interest. The agent takes a share and the rest is fund income: 81% to the fund at iShares, about 95% at Vanguard (2024).
The fund lends shares and holds collateral. The income is shared between the lending agent and the fund. Diagram: Finabase; splits from iShares’ and Vanguard’s published terms.

The fund owns the security and lends it. Legal title passes to the borrower for the length of the loan, which is what lets the borrower sell or deliver the shares. The fund keeps the economic position: if the stock rises or falls, the fund's NAV rises or falls exactly as before, because the borrower owes back the same number of shares.

The lending agent arranges the loans, collects and invests the collateral, and checks every day that the collateral still covers the loan. For iShares funds the agent is BlackRock Institutional Trust Company, an affiliate of the funds' adviser, acting under an SEC exemptive order. Other fund families use an affiliate or an outside bank.

The borrower is usually a broker-dealer. Its client may be a hedge fund selling the stock short (Short selling explained: borrowing, fees, rules and unlimited risk), a market maker hedging options, or a firm covering a delivery it would otherwise fail.

The steps:

  1. The borrower takes the shares and posts collateral. The iShares Statement of Additional Information requires collateral at least equal to the market value of the securities lent. Vanguard states that it takes cash collateral of at least 102% and lends only stocks.
  2. Each day the loan is valued again and collateral is added or returned so the cover is maintained.
  3. If the company pays a dividend while the shares are out, the borrower pays the fund an equal amount.
  4. The fund can recall the shares at any time, and the borrower can return them at any time.
  5. When the shares come back, the collateral goes back.

Where the income comes from

If the collateral is cash, the agent invests it in a money market vehicle and the fund earns interest. Part of that interest is handed back to the borrower as a rebate. The fund keeps the difference. For a stock that is easy to borrow, the rebate is close to the interest earned and the fund's margin is thin. For a stock in heavy demand from short sellers, the rebate falls to nothing or turns negative, meaning the borrower pays the fund outright.

If the collateral is securities, the borrower simply pays a fee.

Either way the fund's income depends on how scarce its holdings are in the lending market. A stock most owners are glad to lend earns almost nothing. One that is heavily shorted and tightly held can earn several percent a year, sometimes far more for short periods (Short squeeze: how it works, warning signs and the GameStop case).

How the income is divided

Lending income is not all the shareholders'. The agent is paid from it, and the terms differ between fund families.

Fund family What the funds keep Who the agent is
iShares 81% of securities lending income, 84% once complex-wide income passes a threshold in the year A BlackRock affiliate
Vanguard 95.2% of revenue in 2024 Not named by Vanguard

The iShares terms come from the notes to the funds' financial statements, which add that a fund's share may never be less than 70% of the total of lending income and the fees earned on investing the collateral. The cash collateral is placed in money market funds managed by BlackRock, and the fees those funds charge on it are capped at an effective 0.04%. In IWM's fiscal year to March 2026 the fund reported paying the agent $19.5 million for securities lending services.

The split is a cost that does not appear in the expense ratio. Two funds tracking the same index with the same stated fee can deliver different results if one returns more of its lending income. The place to see it is the Statement of Operations, in a line such as "Securities lending income, net".

What seven funds earned

The figures below are net lending income from each fund's annual financial statements, divided by the average of its net assets at the start and end of the year.

A worked example on IWM. The iShares Russell 2000 ETF reported net securities lending income of $69,894,011 for the year to March 31, 2026. Its net assets were $63.3 billion at the start of the year and $71.3 billion at the end, an average of $67.3 billion.

69,894,011 ÷ 67,336,000,000 = 0.104% = 10.4 basis points

A basis point is one hundredth of a percent. On $10,000 held for the year that is $10.38. The same statements show investment advisory fees of $127.9 million, so lending income offset 54.6% of the fee. IWM's expense ratio is 0.19%.

Net securities lending income, basis points of net assets, fiscal 2026 IWO (Russell 2000 Growth) 13.2 bp · $15.1m IWM (Russell 2000) 10.4 bp · $69.9m IWN (Russell 2000 Value) 8.5 bp · $9.9m EEM (MSCI Emerging Markets) 3.5 bp · $10.9m ITOT (Core S&P Total US) 1.1 bp · $7.7m IVV (Core S&P 500) 0.3 bp · $16.5m AGG (Core US Aggregate Bond) 0.2 bp · $3.3m Income ÷ average of opening and closing net assets (EEM: closing). Annual statements.
Net securities lending income divided by average net assets, fiscal years ending in 2026. Chart: Finabase, from each fund’s annual financial statements.
Fund Holds Net lending income Basis points of net assets Share of the advisory fee On loan at year end
IWO Small-company growth stocks $15.1 million 13.2 51.8% 14.3%
IWM Russell 2000 $69.9 million 10.4 54.6% 14.5% of net assets
IWN Small-company value stocks $9.9 million 8.5 36.1% 7.7%
EEM Emerging market stocks $10.9 million 3.5 6.1% 1.7%
ITOT Total US stock market $7.7 million 1.1 34.4% 1.2%
IVV S&P 500 $16.5 million 0.3 8.2% 0.1%
AGG US investment-grade bonds $3.3 million 0.2 8.5% 0.6%

EEM's figure uses year-end net assets. Its net assets grew by about two-thirds during the year, so on the average of the two the figure would be closer to 4 basis points.

The pattern is steep. The three small-company funds earned between 8 and 13 basis points. The S&P 500 fund earned a third of one basis point: on $10,000, about 25 cents.

Three things explain the gap.

Demand. Short sellers concentrate on smaller, more speculative companies, and growth stocks more than value stocks. IWO out-earned IWN on the same universe split in two.

Supply. The 500 largest companies are held by every index fund, pension fund and insurer, most of which lend. With so many shares on offer the fee is close to nothing. Small companies have fewer large holders.

How much is lent. At its year end IWM had $10.4 billion of securities on loan, 14.5% of net assets. IVV had $1.0 billion on loan out of $720 billion.

For a small-cap index fund, lending income can cover a large part of the fee and sometimes more, which is how such a fund can finish a year ahead of its index before anyone has done anything clever. For a large-cap fund the income rounds to zero and is not a reason to prefer one fund over another. Tracking difference in index funds: why a fund trails its index shows where lending fits among the things that separate a fund's return from its index.

The limit on lending

US funds cannot lend everything. The iShares Statement of Additional Information states that a fund will not make a loan if, as a result, the total of its loans would exceed one-third of its total assets, with the collateral received counted in those assets. Other US fund families state the same ceiling in their own documents.

In practice a broad index fund is far below it, because most of its holdings are not in demand. A fund concentrated in heavily shorted stocks can sit close to the ceiling.

What can go wrong

Lending income is payment for taking risks. They are small and they are real.

The borrower fails and the collateral is not enough. If a borrower cannot return the shares, the fund uses the collateral to buy them back. If the stock has jumped since the last daily reset, the collateral may fall short. This is the reason collateral is set at or above 100% and reset every day. Some agents add a promise: the iShares document states that BlackRock indemnifies the funds against a shortfall when a borrower defaults. An indemnity is as good as the firm that gives it, and not every fund family offers one.

Cash collateral loses value. Cash collateral is invested, and the fund owes the full amount back whatever happens to the investment. A loss in the collateral pool is the fund's loss. The indemnity for borrower default does not usually cover it. Collateral pools are conservative money market vehicles, and the risk is the same remote one such vehicles carry (Money market funds and cash: T-bills, savings and real returns).

Votes. Whoever holds the shares on the record date votes them. A fund with shares on loan cannot vote those shares unless it recalls them first. Managers say they recall for votes that matter. The trade-off between fee income and voting is a judgment the fund makes on shareholders' behalf.

Dividends change character. The payment a borrower makes in place of a dividend is not itself a dividend for tax purposes. A fund that has shares on loan over a dividend date may pass on slightly less qualified dividend income than it otherwise would.

Conflicts of interest. When the agent is an affiliate of the manager, the manager earns more the more the fund lends, while shareholders carry the risks. Fund boards review the arrangement, and the split is disclosed, which is why it is worth reading.

Recalls and settlement. If the fund needs to sell a stock that is on loan and the borrower is slow to return it, the sale can settle late. Daily liquidity management is designed around this.

Who is on the other side

A fund holder lending through an index fund is, at one remove, lending to people betting against the fund's own holdings. That can feel odd. It does not hurt the fund in any direct way: the fund is paid, it keeps its exposure, and a stock that is being shorted is one someone will have to buy back. Whether short selling pushes prices down in a way that harms long-term holders is debated. The evidence in academic finance generally finds that it makes prices more accurate. The income, on the other hand, is certain.

Lending compared across fund types

Fund type Typical lending income Why
Large-cap US index fund Under 1 basis point Abundant supply, little borrowing demand
Total-market US index fund About 1 basis point Mostly large companies, with a small-cap tail
Small-cap US index fund 8 to 13 basis points Scarce shares, heavy shorting
Emerging market stock fund A few basis points Lending is restricted or impractical in some markets
Investment-grade bond fund A fraction of a basis point Treasuries and corporates are easy to borrow

The ranges are the fiscal 2026 results of the seven iShares funds above, not industry averages.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not show securities lending data. A fund's symbol page has its quote, chart, news and the Dividends & splits tab. The Holders tab can show a fund card with the issuer, expense ratio, assets, NAV, top holdings and sector weights when the data feed carries them. The expense ratio shown there is the stated fee and does not net off lending income.

The lending figures in this lesson come from each fund's annual financial statements: the Statement of Operations for the income, the Statement of Assets and Liabilities for securities on loan, and the notes for the split. The Statement of Additional Information describes the program and its limits.

Frequently asked questions

Do I lose anything when my fund lends its shares?

Not in the ordinary course. The fund keeps the price exposure and receives payments equal to any dividends. What you take on is a small risk of loss if a borrower fails or the collateral investment loses value, in exchange for a share of the income.

Does all the lending income go to the fund?

No. The lending agent keeps part. iShares funds keep 81%, rising to 84%. Vanguard reports returning 95.2% of revenue to its funds in 2024. The split is in the notes to each fund's financial statements.

Why do small-cap funds earn so much more from lending?

Borrowing demand from short sellers is concentrated in smaller companies, and fewer large institutions hold those shares to lend. Scarcity sets the fee.

Is lending income included in the expense ratio?

No. The expense ratio is costs only. Lending income is added to the fund's investment income, so it shows up as a slightly better return than the fee alone would predict.

Can a fund lend all of its holdings?

No. A US fund may not have loans outstanding worth more than one-third of its total assets, with the collateral counted in the total.

Summary

  • A fund lends securities against collateral of at least their full value, reset daily, and keeps its price exposure and the equivalent of any dividends.
  • Income depends on scarcity. In fiscal 2026 it was 8 to 13 basis points for three small-company iShares funds and 0.3 for the S&P 500 fund.
  • For IWM, lending income offset 54.6% of the advisory fee. For a large-cap fund it is too small to matter.
  • The lending agent takes a share: 19% falling to 16% at iShares, about 5% at Vanguard in 2024.
  • Loans are capped at one-third of total assets.
  • The risks are borrower default beyond the collateral, losses on reinvested cash, lost votes and a small tax effect on dividends. The annual financial statements and the SAI show the amounts and terms.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. IWM reported net securities lending income of $69.9 million on average net assets of about $67.3 billion. What did lending add for an investor with $10,000 in the fund for the year?

    1. About $1
    2. About $10
    3. About $100
    Show the answer

    B. About $10 69.9 ÷ 67,336 ≈ 0.104%, or 10.4 basis points. On $10,000 that is about $10.38, enough to offset more than half of IWM’s advisory fee.

  2. Under the iShares agreement, before the complex-wide threshold is reached, a fund’s loans generate $1,000,000 of securities lending income. How much does the fund keep?

    1. $1,000,000
    2. $840,000
    3. $810,000
    Show the answer

    C. $810,000 Each iShares fund keeps 81% of securities lending income, rising to 84% for the rest of the calendar year once the threshold is passed. The agent, a BlackRock affiliate, keeps the remainder.

  3. A fund has $900 million of total assets, counting collateral received. What is the most it may have out on loan under the limit in the iShares SAI?

    1. $300 million
    2. $450 million
    3. $900 million
    Show the answer

    A. $300 million No loan may be made if the total of loans would exceed one-third of total assets, with the collateral counted in those assets. One-third of $900 million is $300 million.

  4. A borrower defaults on the same day the borrowed stock jumps, before the daily collateral reset. What is the fund’s risk?

    1. None, because collateral always exceeds the loan
    2. The collateral may not buy back all the shares; an agent’s indemnity, where offered, covers that shortfall
    3. The fund loses the dividends it was owed
    Show the answer

    B. The collateral may not buy back all the shares; an agent’s indemnity, where offered, covers that shortfall Collateral is set at or above 100% and reset daily, so a jump since the last reset can leave it short. BlackRock indemnifies iShares funds against that shortfall; the indemnity does not usually cover losses on reinvested cash collateral.

  5. In fiscal 2026 the small-cap growth fund IWO earned 13.2 basis points from lending and the S&P 500 fund IVV 0.3. What mainly explains the gap?

    1. IWO’s lending agent charges less
    2. IVV is not allowed to lend
    3. Short sellers want smaller, more speculative stocks, and fewer large holders supply them, so their loans earn higher fees
    Show the answer

    C. Short sellers want smaller, more speculative stocks, and fewer large holders supply them, so their loans earn higher fees Lending income follows scarcity. The largest companies are held and lent by almost every institution, so their borrowing fee is close to nothing.

Sources and further reading

  1. iShares Russell ETFs — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2026 (IWM, IWO, IWN): securities lending income, securities on loan, advisory fees and the note on securities lending
  2. iShares Core S&P ETFs — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2026 (IVV, ITOT)
  3. iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2026
  4. iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended August 31, 2026
  5. iShares Trust — Statement of Additional Information: lending of portfolio securities, the one-third limit, collateral and the lending agent’s indemnity
  6. Vanguard — Understanding securities lending: share of revenue returned to the funds in 2024 and collateral levels