Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · ETFs in depth

ETF tax efficiency: in-kind redemptions, heartbeat trades and limits

How ETFs avoid distributing capital gains, how much gain real funds remove in kind each year, where the method fails, and which taxes it does not touch.

On this page
  1. The rule in one paragraph
  2. How much gain leaves this way
  3. The result across the industry
  4. Heartbeat trades
  5. Where the method fails
  6. What it does not shelter
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

A mutual fund that sells a stock at a profit has to hand that profit to its shareholders by the end of the year, and shareholders in taxable accounts pay tax on it whether or not they sold anything. An ETF holding the same stocks, tracking the same index, usually hands out nothing of the kind.

The reason is not that ETFs trade less. It is a single sentence of the tax code about what happens when a fund pays a departing shareholder in securities. How ETFs work: creation, redemption, NAV and the arbitrage band sets out that sentence and a worked example of a fund choosing which tax lot to hand over. This lesson starts where that one stops: how large the effect is in real funds' accounts, the technique funds use when ordinary redemptions are not enough, where the method breaks down, and the taxes it leaves untouched.

The rule in one paragraph

When a company pays a shareholder with an asset that has risen in value, the tax code normally treats the company as if it had sold the asset, and taxes the gain. Section 852(b)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code switches that treatment off for a regulated investment company, which is what a mutual fund or ETF is for tax purposes, when the payment is a redemption of its shares at the shareholder's request.

A mutual fund could use the rule too, but its shareholders want cash. An ETF's only direct shareholders are authorized participants, who expect securities. So nearly every ETF redemption is a chance to hand over shares bought long ago at low prices, and the gain on them leaves the fund without being taxed there.

How much gain leaves this way

Funds report the figure. The Statement of Operations in an ETF's annual financial statements has a line for realized gain on in-kind redemptions, separate from gains on ordinary sales.

Gain realized on in-kind redemptions in one fiscal year, % of net assets IVV (iShares Core S&P 500) 16.2% · $116.5bn gain, none distributed IWM (iShares Russell 2000) 17.4% · $12.4bn gain, none distributed ITOT (iShares Core S&P Total US) 2.9% · $2.31bn gain, none distributed EEM (iShares MSCI Emerging Markets) 0.7% · $0.22bn gain, none distributed Annual financial statements, fiscal years ending in 2026; net assets at year end.
Gain removed through in-kind redemptions in the fiscal year ending in 2026, as a share of net assets at the end of that year. Chart: Finabase, from each fund’s annual financial statements.
Fund Fiscal year to Gain on in-kind redemptions Year-end net assets Gain as a share of net assets
IVV March 2026 $116.5 billion $720.2 billion 16.2%
IWM March 2026 $12.4 billion $71.3 billion 17.4%
ITOT March 2026 $2.3 billion $79.7 billion 2.9%
EEM August 2026 $0.22 billion $31.2 billion 0.7%
AGG February 2026 a loss of $0.06 billion $141.5 billion none

The notes to the iShares statements describe the treatment in plain terms. In-kind redemptions are recorded as sales for financial reporting. The resulting gains are not taxable to the fund and are not distributed to shareholders. At year end they are moved out of distributable earnings and into paid-in capital. IWM's notes show $12.36 billion reclassified that way for the year.

Two details in the table are worth a second look.

The percentages vary a great deal. IVV and IWM cleared gains worth about a sixth of their assets in one year. ITOT, a fund of similar size to IWM holding similar stocks to IVV, cleared 2.9%. The amount depends on how much redeeming goes on. IVV and IWM are heavily used by traders, so shares are created and redeemed constantly, and each redemption carries low-cost lots out. A fund that mostly receives new money has fewer redemptions to work with.

The bond fund had nothing to clear. AGG's in-kind redemptions produced a small loss. Its bonds were bought at higher prices before interest rates rose, so there were no gains to remove.

IWM's statements show the other half of the picture. The fund had a capital loss carryforward of $23.7 billion that does not expire. When the Russell 2000 changes its members each year the fund has to sell and buy stocks in the market. It can pick its high-cost lots for those sales, realizing losses, while its low-cost lots leave through redemptions. The losses pile up as an asset that can offset future gains.

The result across the industry

State Street Investment Management tabulates Morningstar's data on how many funds paid a capital gain distribution each year.

Funds that paid a capital gain distribution in 2025, % of funds ETFs Mutual funds 7% 52% All funds 6% 57% Equity 23% 37% Fixed income 4% 41% Index 9% 53% Active State Street Investment Management, from Morningstar data to December 31, 2025.
Share of ETFs and of mutual funds that paid a capital gain distribution in 2025. Chart: Finabase; data from State Street Investment Management, based on Morningstar, to December 31, 2025.
Category ETFs that paid a gain Mutual funds that paid a gain
All funds 7% 52%
Equity 6% 57%
Fixed income 23% 37%
Index 4% 41%
Active 9% 53%

Since 2016 the averages have been 9% of ETFs and 53% of mutual funds a year. The mutual fund payouts are large in total: the Investment Company Institute puts capital gain distributions paid by US mutual funds at $740 billion in 2025, of which 65% went to tax-advantaged household accounts.

The comparison is not purely about structure. Mutual funds have been losing assets to ETFs for years, and a fund meeting withdrawals in cash has to sell holdings and realize gains for the shareholders who stay. Part of the 52% is that pressure, which an ETF with inflows does not face. Fund distributions and capital gains: why funds pay out, what it costs explains how a distribution is taxed and why buying just before one is costly.

The active row matters most for what comes next. Active ETFs trade their portfolios far more than index ETFs, and still only 9% paid a gain. The structure is doing the work, not low turnover.

Heartbeat trades

Ordinary redemptions remove gains only when someone happens to redeem. An index change does not wait. If a stock leaves the index after rising tenfold, the fund must dispose of it, and selling it in the market would realize the whole gain.

The answer is a transaction that industry writers named a heartbeat trade, after the shape it leaves on a chart of the fund's shares outstanding: a sharp spike up and, a day or two later, a matching spike down.

  1. Shortly before the index change, an authorized participant, usually a bank working with the fund, makes a large creation. It delivers cash or the securities the fund is about to need.
  2. A day or two later the same participant redeems the same number of shares.
  3. For that redemption the fund does not hand back a slice of the whole portfolio. It hands over a basket made up mostly of the stock it needs to remove.

The fund ends the week the same size, holding the new index member and without the old one. Because the old stock left in a redemption, section 852(b)(6) applies and no gain is recognized.

The basket in step 3 is a custom basket in the language of the SEC's ETF rule, Rule 6c-11, adopted in 2019. The rule permits custom baskets if the fund has written policies that set the limits on them and name who reviews each one. Before the rule, only funds whose individual exemptive orders allowed it could build baskets this freely.

Heartbeat trades are legal and openly reported in fund flows. They are also the part of ETF tax treatment most often criticized, on the ground that a redemption arranged by the fund for its own tax purposes is not what the law had in mind when it spared funds from tax on redemptions "upon the demand of a shareholder". Congress has seen proposals to repeal the in-kind exemption and has not enacted one. An investor relying on the advantage for decades is relying on that staying true.

Where the method fails

Redemptions paid in cash. If the fund has to sell securities to pay a redeeming participant, it realizes gains like any mutual fund. Cash redemptions are common where securities cannot be passed across easily: many bonds, some emerging markets that restrict transfers between owners, and funds that get their exposure through swaps or futures. EEM cleared gains worth only 0.7% of its assets in kind.

Bond funds. Bonds mature, get called and drop out of indexes when they approach maturity, so a bond index fund trades whether it wants to or not. AGG's portfolio turnover was 62% in fiscal 2026. Baskets are a sample of the portfolio, not a slice of every holding. When rates fall and bond prices rise, those forced sales produce gains. That is the 23% in the table.

Funds with no redemptions. A fund that only grows has only creations. Without outflows or arranged heartbeat trades, gains stay inside.

Funds that close. A liquidating ETF sells everything and distributes what it realized.

Strategies that realize gains by design. A fund that sells options, holds futures, or shorts securities earns income that the in-kind rule does not reach. Fund yields explained: SEC yield, distribution yield and total return shows what those payouts look like.

Mutual funds, with one exception. A mutual fund that has an ETF share class can send low-cost lots out through that class, to the benefit of every class. Vanguard ran its index funds this way for two decades under a patent. The SEC began permitting other managers to add ETF classes in 2025, which Active ETFs and ETF share classes: how stock picking moved into ETFs covers.

What it does not shelter

The rule concerns one kind of tax: capital gains realized inside the fund. Everything else is unchanged.

Tax event Mutual fund ETF
Dividends from the stocks held Taxed each year Taxed each year
Interest from the bonds held Taxed each year Taxed each year
Gains the fund realizes on its holdings Distributed and taxed Mostly removed in kind, deferred
The investor's own gain on selling shares Taxed on sale Taxed on sale
Holding the fund in an IRA or 401(k) No tax until withdrawal No tax until withdrawal: no advantage

The last row is the one most often overlooked. Inside a retirement account neither kind of fund's distributions are taxed when paid, so the ETF's advantage is worth nothing there (Retirement accounts explained: 401(k), IRA, Roth and 2026 limits).

The third row says "deferred", not "avoided". Gains that leave the fund in kind are still reflected in the price of the ETF's shares. The investor pays tax on them when selling. What the ETF provides is time.

A worked example. Two funds each turn $10,000 into more at 8% a year for 20 years, with no dividends. Long-term gains are taxed at 15%. Fund A distributes nothing. Fund B distributes a capital gain equal to 5% of its value each year; the investor pays the tax from the distribution and reinvests the rest. Both are sold at the end.

Fund A: no distributions Fund B: 5% a year distributed
Value before the final sale $46,610 $40,095
Tax paid along the way $0 $3,390
Tax on the final sale $5,491 $1,632
Wealth after all tax $41,118 $38,462
After-tax return per year 7.33% 6.97%

Fund A's holder pays more tax in total, $5,491 against $5,022, and still ends $2,656 ahead, about 6.9%. The tax was paid later, and the money earned 8% a year in the meantime. The gap is about a third of a percentage point of return a year. It grows with the tax rate, the size of the distributions and the number of years, and it is zero in a tax-deferred account.

The example assumes the 15% federal rate that applies to long-term gains across a wide band of incomes in 2026. Short-term gains distributed by a fund are taxed at ordinary rates, which makes Fund B's position worse. State taxes are left out. Capital gains tax on stocks: 2026 rates, holding periods and basis has the rate structure.

How Finabase does it

A fund's symbol page on Finabase has a Dividends & splits tab listing every distribution with its ex-date and amount per share. An unusually large payment in December is the usual sign of a capital gain distribution, though the list does not label a payment as income or gain. /portfolio tracks holdings and the dividends received on them.

Finabase does not publish tax data: it does not split a distribution into ordinary income, qualified dividends, capital gains and return of capital, and it does not estimate a fund's unrealized gains. Those are in the fund's annual financial statements, on the issuer's distribution pages each autumn, and on the Form 1099-DIV a broker sends after year end.

Frequently asked questions

Do ETFs ever pay capital gain distributions?

Yes. About 7% did in 2025. Bond ETFs, funds using derivatives, funds in markets that require cash redemptions and funds that have just changed strategy are the most likely to.

Is the tax avoided or only postponed?

Postponed. The gain stays in the share price and is taxed when the investor sells. An investor who never sells, and whose heirs receive a stepped-up basis under current law, may never pay it, which is true of any appreciated asset.

Does the advantage apply in an IRA or 401(k)?

No. Distributions inside those accounts are not taxed when paid, so there is nothing to defer. Cost, tracking and trading convenience are the things left to compare.

Are ETF dividends taxed differently from mutual fund dividends?

No. Dividends and interest pass through both kinds of fund and are taxed to the holder each year. Whether a stock dividend is "qualified" depends on holding periods, not on the fund's structure (How dividends and interest are taxed: qualified, ordinary, muni).

Why do some index mutual funds also pay almost no gains?

Low turnover, steady inflows that let the manager avoid selling, losses carried forward from earlier years, and in some cases an ETF share class that removes low-cost lots for the whole fund.

Summary

  • Section 852(b)(6) lets a fund pay a redeeming shareholder in appreciated securities without recognizing the gain. ETFs redeem in kind as a matter of routine.
  • The amounts are large. IVV and IWM each removed gains worth about a sixth of their net assets in fiscal 2026 and distributed none.
  • In 2025, 7% of ETFs and 52% of mutual funds paid a capital gain distribution.
  • Heartbeat trades use a paired creation and redemption with a custom basket to remove a specific stock at an index change.
  • The method fails where redemptions are in cash, in most bond funds when prices have risen, and for income from options and futures.
  • It defers gains inside the fund. Dividends, interest and the investor's own gain on sale are taxed as usual, and in a retirement account the advantage is nil.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. In its fiscal year to March 2026, IVV realized $116.5 billion of gains on in-kind redemptions and ended the year with $720.2 billion of net assets. What happened to those gains?

    1. They were distributed to shareholders as capital gains
    2. They equalled about 16% of net assets and were not taxable to the fund or distributed
    3. They were taxed inside the fund at the corporate rate
    Show the answer

    B. They equalled about 16% of net assets and were not taxable to the fund or distributed 116.5 ÷ 720.2 ≈ 16.2%. Under section 852(b)(6) the fund recognizes no gain when it pays redeeming shareholders in securities, so the gains are reclassified to paid-in capital rather than distributed.

  2. An investor holds an S&P 500 ETF and the matching index mutual fund, both inside an IRA. How much does the ETF’s in-kind tax advantage help?

    1. Not at all: distributions inside the IRA are not taxed when paid
    2. A little, about a third of a point a year
    3. A lot, because the ETF never distributes dividends
    Show the answer

    A. Not at all: distributions inside the IRA are not taxed when paid Inside a retirement account neither fund’s distributions are taxed when paid, so there is nothing to defer. Cost, tracking and trading convenience are what is left to compare.

  3. AGG’s in-kind redemptions in fiscal 2026 produced a small loss rather than a gain. Why?

    1. Bond ETFs are not allowed to redeem in kind
    2. AGG distributed its gains before year end
    3. Its bonds had been bought at higher prices before interest rates rose, so there were no gains to remove
    Show the answer

    C. Its bonds had been bought at higher prices before interest rates rose, so there were no gains to remove Redemptions in kind can only carry out gains that exist. Bonds bought before rates rose were worth less than they cost.

  4. In the lesson’s 20-year example, Fund A (no distributions) pays $5,491 of tax in total and Fund B (5% distributed yearly) pays $5,022. Why does Fund A’s holder still end $2,656 ahead?

    1. Fund A earned a higher pre-tax return
    2. The tax was paid later, and the money that would have gone in tax kept earning 8% a year
    3. Fund A’s gains were taxed at a lower rate
    Show the answer

    B. The tax was paid later, and the money that would have gone in tax kept earning 8% a year Both funds earn 8% before tax and are taxed at 15%. Deferral is worth the growth on the postponed tax, about a third of a percentage point of return a year here.

  5. Before an index deletion, a bank makes a large creation in an ETF and redeems the same number of shares two days later, receiving mostly the departing stock. What keeps this from realizing the stock’s gain?

    1. The stock leaves in an in-kind redemption, which section 852(b)(6) exempts from gain recognition
    2. The bank pays the tax on the fund’s behalf
    3. Index deletions are exempt from capital gains tax
    Show the answer

    A. The stock leaves in an in-kind redemption, which section 852(b)(6) exempts from gain recognition This is a heartbeat trade. The redemption uses a custom basket permitted by Rule 6c-11, and because the low-cost stock leaves in kind, no gain is recognized in the fund.

Sources and further reading

  1. 26 U.S. Code § 852(b)(6) — Section 311(b) does not apply to a regulated investment company’s distributions in redemption of its stock on a shareholder’s demand
  2. iShares Core S&P ETFs — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2026 (IVV, ITOT): realized gain on in-kind redemptions and the note on their tax treatment
  3. iShares Russell ETFs — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2026 (IWM): in-kind redemption gains, capital loss carryforward, portfolio turnover
  4. iShares Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended February 28, 2026: in-kind redemptions and portfolio turnover
  5. iShares MSCI Emerging Markets ETF — annual financial statements for the fiscal year ended August 31, 2026
  6. State Street Investment Management — share of ETFs and mutual funds paying capital gains in 2025, from Morningstar data to December 31, 2025 (article of February 18, 2026)
  7. Investment Company Institute — 2026 Investment Company Fact Book: capital gains distributions paid by mutual funds in 2025
  8. 17 CFR 270.6c-11 — custom baskets and the written policies they require
  9. IRS Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses — capital gain distributions and sales of fund shares