Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · Specialised funds

Target-date funds: structure, fees and the 2021 tax surprise

What a target-date fund holds, how its fees stack, mutual fund versus collective trust, the default-investment rule, and Vanguard’s December 2021 distributions.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. How it works
  3. Using it: two vintages and a balanced fund
  4. Where it fails or misleads
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

A target-date fund is a complete portfolio sold as one fund, with a year in its name. The year is roughly when the holder expects to retire. The manager holds mostly shares while that year is far off and moves gradually toward bonds as it approaches. The saver makes one decision, picks the year, and the fund does the allocating and rebalancing from then on.

That simplicity made these funds the standard holding in American workplace retirement plans. Since 2007 a federal rule has let employers place workers who make no choice into one. The strategy behind them, how the stock share should fall with age and how well that has worked, is covered in Lifecycle investing: a target-date glide path, tested and Glide paths: how a portfolio’s stock share changes with age.

This lesson is about the product itself: what the fund legally is, what it owns, how its fees are stated, why two funds with the same year can differ, and what happened to holders of Vanguard's funds in taxable accounts in December 2021.

The idea

One fund replaces a set of decisions. Without it, a saver has to choose a mix of shares and bonds, pick funds for each, rebalance when markets move the mix, and reduce the share portion over the decades. A target-date fund series offers one fund for each retirement year, usually five years apart (2030, 2035, 2040 and so on), and each fund follows the same schedule from its own starting point.

The schedule is the Target-date fund's glide path. Managers differ on where it ends. A "to" glide path reaches its most conservative mix at the target year and stays there. A "through" glide path keeps reducing shares for years after the target date, on the view that retirement lasts decades. The SEC's investor bulletin on these funds points out that a "to" fund generally turns conservative earlier, and that funds with the same year in their names can hold quite different mixes at any moment. The year tells a saver which fund in a series to pick. It does not say how much risk the fund holds.

How it works

A fund that owns funds

Most target-date mutual funds hold no individual securities. They own shares of other funds run by the same manager, an arrangement called a Fund of funds.

A target-date fund is a fund that owns other funds Target-date fund One share class the saver buys US stock index fund International stock index fund US bond index fund International bond index fund Inflation- protected bonds owns shares of Fees: the top fund may charge its own fee, and it bears the underlying funds’ fees (“acquired fund fees”). Taxes: when the top fund sells underlying shares at a gain, the gain is distributed to its holders. Over time the manager moves the weights from the stock funds toward the bond funds (the glide path).
A target-date fund owns shares of underlying funds and shifts their weights over time. Fees and capital gains pass up from the layer below.

Vanguard's Target Retirement 2035 Fund (VTTHX) is an example. Vanguard's profile of the fund for June 30, 2026 showed about 67.2% in stocks, 32.2% in bonds and 0.6% in short-term reserves, all through index funds. Nine years from its target date, it was still two-thirds in shares.

How the fees stack

A fund of funds can charge at two levels: a management fee on the top fund, and the expense ratios of the funds it owns. SEC rules require the second layer to be shown in the fee table as "acquired fund fees and expenses".

In Vanguard's case the top layer is free and the whole cost is the underlying index funds. Other series charge at the top as well, or hold actively managed funds underneath, and the total can be several times higher. The comparison that matters is the bottom line of the fee table. A fund that reports a low management fee and a large acquired-fund figure costs exactly as much as one that reports them the other way round.

Mutual fund or collective trust

Inside a large employer's plan, the target-date option is often not a mutual fund. It is a collective investment trust: a pooled fund maintained by a bank or trust company and open only to retirement plans. It follows the same glide path with the same underlying strategy, but it is not registered with the SEC as an investment company, has no prospectus and no ticker symbol, and cannot be looked up on a quote page. Its fees are negotiated with the plan and are usually lower. The information about it comes from the plan's own disclosures and fact sheets.

Mutual fund Collective investment trust
Who can buy Anyone, in any account Qualified retirement plans only
Regulated as Registered investment company (SEC) Bank-maintained trust (banking regulators, ERISA)
Documents Prospectus, shareholder reports Plan disclosures, trust fact sheet
Ticker and public price Yes No
Yearly distributions Required Not required

The last row matters for the story below.

Why most plans default to them

The Pension Protection Act of 2006 encouraged employers to enrol workers automatically. That raised a question: where does the money go when a worker picks nothing? The Department of Labor answered with a regulation published on October 24, 2007 (29 CFR 2550.404c-5). It protects a plan fiduciary from liability for investment losses when a defaulted worker's money goes into a qualified default investment alternative, or QDIA. Three kinds of long-term investment qualify: a fund whose mix changes with the participant's age or retirement date, a balanced fund suited to the plan's participants as a whole, and a managed account. Target-date funds are the first kind, and they became the usual default. The fiduciary must still choose and monitor the fund prudently.

Using it: two vintages and a balanced fund

The table compares two Vanguard funds at opposite ends of the glide path with a fixed 60%-share allocation fund (AOR) and SPY, from January 2017 to October 2026, with distributions reinvested.

Jan 2017 – Oct 2026 Yearly return Volatility Deepest fall 2022
Target Retirement 2025 (VTTVX) 7.4% 9.8% −20.4% −15.6%
Target Retirement 2055 (VFFVX) 11.3% 13.7% −24.4% −17.5%
60/40 allocation fund (AOR) 8.1% 10.0% −20.8% −15.7%
SPY 14.9% 15.4% −23.9% −18.2%

The funds behaved as designed: the far-dated fund earned more and swung more (in 2025, 21.4% against 11.4% for the 2025 fund). The year 2022 is the instructive one. A saver three years from retirement, in the fund built for that date, lost 15.6%, barely less than the 2055 fund's 17.5%. Shares and bonds fell together that year, and a glide path that swaps one for the other gave little shelter. The 2025 fund's price did not regain its December 2021 level, with distributions reinvested, until March 2024.

Where it fails or misleads

December 2021: a distribution of 16%

From 2017 to 2019 Vanguard's target-date funds distributed 2% to 3% of their value a year, mostly the dividends and interest they collected. On December 29, 2021 Vanguard's Target Retirement 2035 Fund paid $4.65 a share. Its price fell from $27.73 at the end of November to $23.84 at the end of December. The payment was 16.3% of the fund's value before it was paid.

Vanguard Target Retirement funds: yearly distributions as a share of the fund’s price Target Retirement 2025 (VTTVX) Target Retirement 2055 (VFFVX) 2.3 2.2 2017 2.3 2.1 2018 2.8 2.6 2019 4.7 2.1 2020 15.4 10.6 2021 2.4 1.8 2022 4.4 2.6 2023 7.8 2.5 2024 4.7 2.5 2025 Percent. All distributions with an ex-date in the year ÷ the previous December’s closing price.
Yearly distributions of two Vanguard Target Retirement funds as a percent of the previous December’s price, 2017–2025.
December 29, 2021 distribution Per share Share of pre-payment value Price change in December With the payment added back
Target Retirement 2025 (VTTVX) $3.31 14.0% −12.3% +2.0%
Target Retirement 2035 (VTTHX) $4.65 16.3% −14.0% +2.8%
Target Retirement 2055 (VFFVX) $5.24 9.1% −5.9% +3.5%

Nobody lost money on the day: the price fell by the amount paid, and holders received that amount in cash or new shares. The damage was tax. In a 401(k) or IRA a distribution is invisible. In an ordinary taxable account it is income for the year. A holder with $100,000 in the 2035 fund received about $16,300. If all of it had been long-term capital gain taxed at 15%, the federal bill would have been about $2,450, for a fund the holder had not sold.

The SEC described the cause in an order dated January 17, 2025. On December 11, 2020 Vanguard announced that the minimum investment in a cheaper, institutional version of the same funds would fall from $100 million to $5 million. Retirement plans holding the ordinary Investor shares redeemed and switched. To pay them, the Investor funds sold underlying fund shares that had large gains, and by law a mutual fund must distribute realized gains to whoever still holds it at year-end (Fund distributions and capital gains: why funds pay out, what it costs). The plans that left paid nothing, because retirement plans are not taxed. The taxable holders who stayed were left with the bill.

The SEC found that the funds' 2020 and 2021 prospectuses were misleading because they did not disclose this risk. Vanguard agreed to pay $106.41 million into a fund for affected investors, including a $13.5 million civil penalty. A separate class action was settled for $40 million.

The lesson is general. A fund of funds owned mostly by tax-exempt plans can realize large gains when those plans move, and the gains land on the taxable minority. A collective trust does not have this problem because it has no taxable holders and no distribution requirement.

Other limits

  • One input. The fund knows a year. It does not know the holder's other savings, pension, spouse or tolerance for loss.
  • The glide path trades into bonds on a calendar, whatever bonds yield at the time.
  • Holding it beside other funds undoes it. A target-date fund is designed to be the whole allocation. Adding a share fund next to it raises the share weight above the glide path.

Compared with its neighbours

Product Mix changes with age Layers of fees Suits a taxable account
Target-date mutual fund Yes, automatically One or two Poorly: yearly distributions, and rebalancing inside the fund
Target-date collective trust Yes One, negotiated Not available
Fixed allocation fund (60/40) No One or two Poorly, for the same reason
Managed account Yes, individually Advice fee plus fund fees Depends on the service
Two or three index funds held directly Only if the holder does it One Better: the holder controls sales

How Finabase does it

Target-date mutual funds have symbol pages like any other fund: a quote updated with each day's net asset value, a chart and news. The Dividends & splits tab lists every distribution with its ex-date and amount, and the December 29, 2021 payment is plain to see there. The Holders tab can show a fund card with issuer, expense ratio, assets and holdings when the fund-data feed has it. The comparison tab rebases funds to percent change from the first bar in view and tabulates price returns from one week to two years, excluding dividends, which understates funds in a year with a large distribution.

Collective investment trusts have no ticker and do not appear on Finabase. Finabase does not publish the tax character of distributions. A holding entered in Portfolio is tracked with its dividends.

Frequently asked questions

Are target-date funds safe close to the target date?

They hold less in shares, not none. Vanguard's 2025 fund lost 15.6% in 2022, three years before its date, because bonds fell with shares. How much a fund holds in shares at its target date differs from one manager to the next.

What are acquired fund fees and expenses?

The expense ratios of the funds that a fund of funds owns, shown as a separate line in the fee table. They are part of total annual operating expenses and are paid through lower returns of the underlying funds, not billed separately.

Should a target-date fund be held in a taxable account?

It can be, but the fund distributes income and gains every year and rebalances inside itself in a way the holder cannot control. In December 2021 Vanguard's 2035 fund distributed 16.3% of its value. The same fund in an IRA or 401(k) has no such consequence.

What is the difference between "to" and "through" funds?

A "to" fund reaches its most conservative mix at the target year. A "through" fund keeps lowering its share weight for years afterwards and so holds more in shares at the target date.

Why can I not find my 401(k) target-date fund by ticker?

It is probably a collective investment trust. These are pooled funds for retirement plans that are not registered mutual funds and have no ticker. The plan's website and fee disclosure describe them.

Summary

A target-date fund wraps a glide path in a single fund of funds. Its cost is the sum of its own fee and the fees of the funds underneath, shown on one line of the fee table: 0.08% for Vanguard's index-based series. The year in the name selects a point on one manager's schedule and guarantees nothing about risk, as 2022 showed. In retirement plans the same strategy often comes as a collective trust without a ticker, and the 2007 default-investment rule made it the usual destination for workers who choose nothing. Inside a tax-sheltered account the structure works quietly. In a taxable account the fund's own selling can produce a tax bill, and in December 2021 it produced a very large one.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A target-date fund’s fee table shows a management fee of 0.00%, other expenses of 0.00% and acquired fund fees and expenses of 0.08%. What does a holder pay each year?

    1. Nothing
    2. 0.08% of the amount invested, through the underlying funds
    3. 0.08% plus a separate bill from each underlying fund
    Show the answer

    B. 0.08% of the amount invested, through the underlying funds Acquired fund fees and expenses are the costs of the funds the target-date fund owns. They are part of total annual operating expenses and reduce returns; they are not billed on top.

  2. On December 29, 2021 a fund priced near $28 paid a distribution of $4.65 a share. What happened to a holder in a 401(k)?

    1. They lost 16% of their money
    2. Nothing of consequence: the price fell by the amount paid and no tax was due inside the plan
    3. They owed tax on $4.65 a share that year
    Show the answer

    B. Nothing of consequence: the price fell by the amount paid and no tax was due inside the plan A distribution moves value from the share price to cash or new shares. Inside a tax-sheltered account that changes nothing. Only holders in taxable accounts owed tax on it.

  3. Why did Vanguard’s Investor target-date funds realize such large gains in 2021?

    1. Retirement plans redeemed to switch to a cheaper institutional version, and the funds sold appreciated holdings to pay them
    2. The funds changed their glide paths
    3. The stock market fell sharply
    Show the answer

    A. Retirement plans redeemed to switch to a cheaper institutional version, and the funds sold appreciated holdings to pay them After the minimum for the institutional funds was cut from $100 million to $5 million, plans switched. The selling realized gains, which a mutual fund must distribute to the holders who remain at year-end.

  4. Two funds are both called “2040”. What can be said about their share allocations today?

    1. They are the same, because the year fixes the mix
    2. They may differ substantially: each manager sets its own glide path, including whether it runs “to” or “through” the target date
    3. Both hold 40% in shares
    Show the answer

    B. They may differ substantially: each manager sets its own glide path, including whether it runs “to” or “through” the target date The year identifies a fund within one manager’s series. Glide paths differ between managers in their starting and ending share weights and in how long they keep changing.

  5. A 401(k) statement lists a target-date option that has no ticker symbol. What is it most likely to be?

    1. A collective investment trust, a pooled fund open only to retirement plans
    2. An exchange-traded fund
    3. An error on the statement
    Show the answer

    A. A collective investment trust, a pooled fund open only to retirement plans Collective investment trusts are maintained by banks or trust companies for retirement plans. They are not registered mutual funds, have no prospectus or ticker, and are described in the plan’s own disclosures.

Sources and further reading

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — press release 2025-21, “Vanguard to Pay More Than $100 Million to Resolve Violations Related to Target Date Retirement Funds,” January 17, 2025
  2. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — order in the matter of The Vanguard Group, Inc., Securities Act Release No. 11359 (Administrative Proceeding File No. 3-22435), January 17, 2025
  3. Vanguard — Target Retirement 2035 Fund summary prospectus, January 28, 2026 (fee table)
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov — Investor Bulletin: Target Date Retirement Funds (“to” and “through” glide paths)
  5. U.S. Department of Labor — 29 CFR 2550.404c-5, Fiduciary relief for investments in qualified default investment alternatives (final rule published October 24, 2007)
  6. Finabase chart data — monthly prices and distributions of VTTVX, VFFVX, VTTHX, AOR and SPY through October 2026; total returns and distribution rates computed by Finabase