Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · Indexes and index funds

S&P 500 vs. Nasdaq-100: broad market or the largest Nasdaq stocks

How the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq-100 choose and weight companies, and what SPY and QQQ did from 1999 to 2026: QQQ ahead overall, after an 81% fall and 14 years under water.

On this page
  1. How each index chooses its companies
  2. The two indexes compared
  3. Worked example: QQQ against SPY since 1999
  4. Which to use when
  5. Pitfalls
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

The S&P 500 and the Nasdaq-100 are the two US stock indexes that most people buy through a fund. SPY, VOO and IVV follow the S&P 500; QQQ and QQQM follow the Nasdaq-100. Both hold large companies weighted by size, and today they share most of their biggest names: Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet, Meta and Broadcom.

They are still very different bets. The S&P 500 is a broad index of about 500 companies from every sector and exchange. The Nasdaq-100 holds 100 companies, all listed on Nasdaq, with no banks or other financial firms, and is dominated by technology. That difference made the Nasdaq-100 the better performer over the past quarter-century and also gave it the worst crash. This lesson compares the rules and measures QQQ against SPY from 1999 to 2026.

How each index chooses its companies

The S&P 500 is maintained by a committee at S&P Dow Jones Indices. To join, a company must be based in the US, list on a major US exchange (NYSE, Nasdaq or Cboe), meet size and trading minimums, and have positive earnings over the most recent four quarters combined and in the latest quarter. Financials, utilities and energy companies are all eligible. Weights follow float-adjusted market value (How stocks join the S&P 500: rules, committee and timing).

The Nasdaq-100 follows a mechanical rule. It takes the largest companies listed on Nasdaq, excluding financial companies, and holds the top 100 by market value, reconstituted each December. Since May 2026 the March, June and September reviews can also remove a member that has fallen below 125th place and add a very large company that ranks within the top 40, without waiting for December. There is no profitability test. Weights follow market value with caps: at each quarterly rebalance no company may exceed 24%, and companies above 4.5% may not add up to more than 48% of the index. Nasdaq ran an extra rebalance in July 2023 when the largest names breached that limit.

Because Nasdaq is where most large technology companies list, the Nasdaq-100 ends up roughly half technology, plus communication services such as Alphabet and Meta and consumer companies such as Amazon, Tesla and Costco. It holds no banks and few energy or industrial companies.

The two indexes compared

Feature S&P 500 Nasdaq-100
Companies About 500 100 (more share classes)
Exchanges NYSE, Nasdaq, Cboe Nasdaq only
Financial companies Included Excluded
Profitability test Yes No
Weighting Float-adjusted market value Market value with caps
Main funds and fees SPY 0.0945%; VOO, IVV 0.03% QQQ 0.20% until Dec. 2025, 0.18% since; QQQM 0.15%
Yearly volatility, 1999–2026 15.1% (SPY) 23.3% (QQQ)

Worked example: QQQ against SPY since 1999

QQQ began trading on March 10, 1999, and the frozen data starts with April 1999, so the test runs from the end of April 1999 to the end of October 2026: 330 months. Both funds are measured on month-end prices with every distribution reinvested; fees are inside the prices. QQQ's 2000 share split is adjusted for, and a dividend the vendor feed lists twice in December 2022 is counted once.

QQQ (Nasdaq-100) and SPY (S&P 500), total return, Apr 1999 – Oct 2026 $0.5 $1 $2 $5 $10 Growth of $1 SPY, S&P 500 QQQ, Nasdaq-100 0% −20% −40% −60% −80% Fall from the peak 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025
QQQ (Nasdaq-100) and SPY (S&P 500), total return with distributions reinvested, month-end closes, April 1999 to October 2026. Bottom: the fall from the highest value so far.
Measure QQQ, Nasdaq-100 SPY, S&P 500
$10,000 became $152,607 $91,514
Return per year 10.4% 8.4%
Volatility (yearly) 23.3% 15.1%
Deepest fall from a peak −81.1% (2000–02) −50.8% (2007–09)
Back above the old peak October 2014 March 2012
April 1999 – February 2009 −6.4% a year −4.3% a year
February 2009 – October 2026 +21.0% a year +16.1% a year

The full-period result favours the Nasdaq-100 by two points a year, but it is the sum of two very different eras. In the first ten years QQQ lost money, including a calendar-year loss of 36.1% in 2000, when SPY lost 9.7%. An investor who bought QQQ near the 2000 peak waited more than 14 years to get back to even, dividends included. In the second era, from the 2009 low, the largest technology companies became the most valuable businesses in the world, and QQQ compounded at 21% a year.

Year by year QQQ led in 16 of 26 full calendar years, and the gaps were large in both directions: 2008 (−41.7% against −36.8%), 2022 (−32.6% against −18.2%), 2023 (+54.8% against +26.2%). The monthly correlation of the two funds was 0.84, high but well short of the near-1.0 seen between two S&P 500 funds.

The starting date decides the winner

Because the two funds took turns, the result depends heavily on when the money went in. Measured to October 2026, with dividends reinvested:

Invested at the end of QQQ a year SPY a year
March 2000 (the dot-com top) 7.9% 8.1%
October 2007 (pre-crisis top) 15.2% 10.7%
February 2009 (crisis low) 21.0% 16.1%
October 2016 20.3% 15.3%

Someone who bought QQQ at the March 2000 peak was still slightly behind an S&P 500 fund bought the same month, 26 years later. Someone who bought either at the 2007 peak, just before the financial crisis, did far better in QQQ, because the technology companies recovered fastest. No single comparison of the two is "the" answer.

Overlap

The two indexes now overlap heavily at the top, so owning both is less diversified than it looks. The Nasdaq-100's largest members are also the S&P 500's, but in the S&P 500 they share space with banks, health insurers, energy companies and industrials that the Nasdaq-100 leaves out. A portfolio of an S&P 500 fund plus a Nasdaq-100 fund is, in effect, an S&P 500 fund with an extra helping of its biggest technology names.

Which to use when

How each is commonly used, not a recommendation:

  • A core holding of US stocks is usually a broad index, the S&P 500 or a total-market fund, because it holds every sector (S&P 500 vs total market funds: what the extra 3,000 stocks change).
  • A deliberate tilt toward large growth and technology companies is what a Nasdaq-100 fund provides. Over 1999 to 2026 the tilt paid; over 1999 to 2009 it cost heavily.
  • Short horizons are where the Nasdaq-100's higher volatility matters most: a 33% fall in a single year, as in 2022, is ordinary for it.
  • Cost is lower on the S&P 500 side: 0.03% for VOO or IVV. QQQM offers the Nasdaq-100 at 0.15%.

Pitfalls

  • Judging by the last ten years. The Nasdaq-100's record since 2009 is exceptional; its record from 1999 to 2009 was a loss. Both are real.
  • Thinking the Nasdaq-100 is "the Nasdaq". The Nasdaq Composite holds every Nasdaq-listed stock, several thousand of them; the Nasdaq-100 is its largest 100 non-financial members (NYSE vs. Nasdaq: two listing markets, one national market system).
  • Assuming diversification by owning both. The top holdings are the same companies.
  • Price charts. Both indexes are usually quoted without dividends; the S&P 500 pays more, so a price-only comparison flatters the Nasdaq-100 slightly.

How Finabase does it

The comparison tab draws QQQ and SPY, or the indexes ^NDX and ^GSPC, from the same start date. The heatmap shows the S&P 500's companies sized by market value, which makes its concentration visible, and the indices page lists both indexes. The figures in this lesson come from frozen copies of Finabase's month-end prices and distribution records.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Nasdaq-100 better than the S&P 500?

It has returned more since 1999, 10.4% a year for QQQ against 8.4% for SPY, but with far bigger falls, including 81% from 2000 to 2002. It is a narrower index concentrated in technology; the S&P 500 is the broader measure of the US market.

Why are there no banks in the Nasdaq-100?

Its rules exclude financial companies. Most large US banks also list on the NYSE, which keeps them out of any Nasdaq index.

Is QQQ more volatile than SPY?

Yes. From 1999 to 2026 QQQ's yearly volatility was 23.3% against 15.1% for SPY, and its deepest fall was 81.1% against 50.8%.

What is the difference between QQQ and QQQM?

Both track the Nasdaq-100. QQQ, launched in 1999, has far greater trading volume and option activity. It was a unit investment trust until December 2025, when its shareholders approved converting it to an open-end fund and its fee fell from 0.20% to 0.18%. QQQM, launched in 2020, charges 0.15% a year and was built for buy-and-hold investors.

Summary

The S&P 500 is a broad index of about 500 companies across every sector; the Nasdaq-100 is the 100 largest non-financial companies listed on Nasdaq, with technology at its centre. From 1999 to 2026 QQQ turned $10,000 into $152,607 against $91,514 for SPY, a two-point yearly lead, but only after an 81% fall that took 14 years to recover. Its lead came entirely after 2009. A Nasdaq-100 fund is a concentrated bet on the market's largest growth companies; an S&P 500 fund holds those same companies alongside everything else.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Which company type can be in the S&P 500 but never in the Nasdaq-100?

    1. A technology company listed on Nasdaq
    2. A bank or other financial company
    3. A company with more than one share class
    Show the answer

    B. A bank or other financial company The Nasdaq-100 excludes financial companies and holds only Nasdaq-listed stocks. The S&P 500 includes all sectors from the NYSE, Nasdaq and Cboe.

  2. QQQ returned 10.4% a year and SPY 8.4% from 1999 to 2026. What did QQQ’s path look like?

    1. A steady lead every year
    2. An 81.1% fall from March 2000 to September 2002, no new high until October 2014, then 21% a year from 2009
    3. It never fell more than SPY
    Show the answer

    B. An 81.1% fall from March 2000 to September 2002, no new high until October 2014, then 21% a year from 2009 The full-period lead came entirely after 2009. Before February 2009 QQQ lost 6.4% a year against 4.3% for SPY.

  3. Someone bought QQQ at the end of March 2000. How did it compare with SPY bought the same month, measured to October 2026?

    1. QQQ was far ahead
    2. QQQ was slightly behind: 7.9% a year against 8.1%
    3. Both had lost money
    Show the answer

    B. QQQ was slightly behind: 7.9% a year against 8.1% Starting at the dot-com peak left QQQ behind even after its huge gains since 2009. The starting date decides which index looks better.

  4. An investor owns an S&P 500 fund and adds a Nasdaq-100 fund “to diversify”. What actually happens?

    1. The portfolio gains exposure to sectors it lacked
    2. The portfolio adds more of the same large technology companies it already owns, concentrating it further
    3. Risk falls because the funds move independently
    Show the answer

    B. The portfolio adds more of the same large technology companies it already owns, concentrating it further The Nasdaq-100’s largest members are also the S&P 500’s largest. The two funds’ monthly returns had a correlation of 0.84; the pair is a tilt toward big technology, not diversification.

Sources and further reading

  1. Nasdaq — Nasdaq-100 Index methodology (eligibility, modified market-cap weighting, quarterly rebalancing and annual reconstitution)
  2. Nasdaq — Nasdaq-100 Index methodology document and change log (changes effective May 1, 2026: fast entry, removal below rank 125)
  3. S&P Dow Jones Indices — S&P 500 index methodology (eligibility, including the profitability rule)
  4. Invesco — Invesco QQQ Trust (QQQ) and Invesco NASDAQ 100 ETF (QQQM) fund pages
  5. Invesco — Invesco QQQ shareholders vote to approve modernization (December 19, 2025): conversion to an open-end fund, expense ratio cut from 0.20% to 0.18%
  6. State Street Global Advisors — SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY), gross expense ratio 0.0945%
  7. Finabase chart data — QQQ and SPY month-end closes and distributions, April 1999 to October 2026; results computed by Finabase