Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · Indexes and index funds

Index weighting methods: cap, price, equal, fundamental and capped

Six ways an index can weight the same stocks, worked on four companies, with the Dow’s price weights, the tax rule behind 25/50 capping and how the Nasdaq-100 caps.

On this page
  1. Four companies, five sets of weights
  2. The methods one by one
  3. Why caps exist: the 25/50 test
  4. How the Nasdaq-100 caps
  5. Same sector, two capping rules
  6. What each method costs to run
  7. Where weighting misleads
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding

Once an index has chosen its members, it has to decide how much of each to hold. That one choice, the weighting method, changes the result more than most investors expect. The Dow Jones Industrial Average and the S&P 500 both hold Nvidia and Goldman Sachs. In the Dow, Goldman is the largest position and more than four times the size of Nvidia. In the S&P 500, Nvidia is the largest position and Goldman is far down the list.

Neither is a mistake. The Dow weights by share price and the S&P 500 by the market value of each company's publicly held shares. This lesson sets out six weighting methods, works each on the same four companies, and then looks at the method that has become common in sector and growth funds: weighting by market value up to a ceiling. The long-run comparison of equal weighting against market-value weighting has its own lesson (Equal weight vs market-cap weight: RSP against SPY, tested) and is not repeated here.

Four companies, five sets of weights

Take four invented companies.

Company Share price Shares Full market value Publicly held
A $400 50 $20,000 100%
B $50 1,000 $50,000 60%
C $150 100 $15,000 100%
D $20 750 $15,000 100%

B is the largest company, but a founder holds 40% of it. A has the highest share price only because it has few shares. The table below is the weight each method gives.

Method A B C D What sets the weight
Full market value 20.0% 50.0% 15.0% 15.0% Price × all shares
Float-adjusted 25.0% 37.5% 18.8% 18.8% Price × public shares
Price 64.5% 8.1% 24.2% 3.2% Share price alone
Equal 25.0% 25.0% 25.0% 25.0% Number of members

The same four stocks give B anything from 8.1% to 50.0% of the index. The return of the "index" on a day when B moves depends heavily on which line was chosen.

The methods one by one

Market value

A cap-weighted index holds every company in proportion to its market value. It is the portfolio of all investors added together, so it is the only weighting that every investor could hold at once. It also looks after itself: when a stock rises 10%, its weight rises with it, and a fund holding the index needs to do nothing. Trading is required only when members or share counts change. That is why funds on broad cap-weighted indexes report very low turnover: 2.4% for Vanguard's S&P 500 ETF in its latest fiscal year, according to its September 30, 2026 fact sheet.

The cost of that convenience is concentration. A cap-weighted index holds most of whatever has risen most. On June 30, 2026 the ten largest positions of the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF were 36.37% of the fund, led by Nvidia at 7.51% and Apple at 6.58% (Concentration risk: when one holding dominates a portfolio).

Float-adjusted market value

Nearly every broad index is in fact float-adjusted: it counts only shares available to the public, as described in How a stock index is built: eligibility, float and the divisor. FTSE Russell's rulebook says its US indexes weight stocks by available, or float-adjusted, market capitalization. In the four-company example, float adjustment cuts B from 50.0% to 37.5% and raises the other three. When people say "cap-weighted" about the S&P 500 or a Russell index, this is what they mean.

Price

A price-weighted index adds up the share prices of its members and divides by a divisor. It is how the Dow Jones Industrial Average has been calculated since the 1890s, when adding thirty prices by hand was practical and multiplying by share counts was not.

The result is that a company's weight depends on a number with no economic meaning. A share price is high or low mainly because of how many shares the company chose to issue.

Price weighting: the Dow’s six largest and four smallest weights, October 2026 GS 10.6% share price $894.55 CAT 6.7% share price $570.49 MSFT 6.1% share price $517.99 AMGN 5.5% share price $462.32 V 4.9% share price $413.59 UNH 4.9% share price $412.02 CSCO 1.2% share price $104.51 KO 1.2% share price $99.48 VZ 0.5% share price $44.73 NKE 0.5% share price $38.26 Weight = share price ÷ sum of the 30 share prices at the October 30, 2026 close.
Weights of ten of the 30 Dow stocks at the close of October 30, 2026, calculated from share prices.

At the close of October 2026 the thirty share prices summed to $8,477.17. Goldman Sachs, at $894.55, was 10.55% of the index. Nike, at $38.26, was 0.45%. The five highest-priced stocks were 33.7% of the index and the five lowest-priced 4.8%. Nvidia, at $204.64, was 2.41%, and Apple, at $352.78, was 4.16%. A 1% move in Goldman moved the Dow more than four times as far as a 1% move in Nvidia.

A stock split changes a price weight overnight. If Goldman split two for one, its weight would roughly halve although nothing about the company had changed. In a value-weighted index a split changes nothing.

Price weighting has not prevented the Dow from tracking the broad market over long periods, because its thirty members are large and varied. From June 2003 to October 2026 the Dow fund DIA's monthly price returns had a correlation of 0.949 with SPY's. But year by year the two part company: DIA was 10.7 points ahead of SPY in 2022 and 10.5 and 10.4 points behind in 2023 and 2024, on price returns. Over the whole period DIA's price rose 7.81% a year against 9.17% for SPY.

Equal

An equal-weight index gives every member the same share: 0.2% each for 500 stocks. It holds much more in smaller members than a cap-weighted index of the same stocks and much less in the largest. Because prices move every day, the weights drift at once, and the index must be reset on a schedule by selling what rose and buying what fell. That trading costs money and gives the index a built-in lean toward smaller and cheaper companies. RSP, the equal-weight fund on the S&P 500 stocks, had the same price return as SPY from June 2003 to October 2026 (9.16% a year against 9.17%) with higher volatility (16.5% against 14.5%), and trailed it by 12.6, 12.3 and 7.0 points in 2023, 2024 and 2025. The full analysis is in Equal weight vs market-cap weight: RSP against SPY, tested.

Fundamental

A fundamentally weighted index sets weights by measures of company size that do not include the share price, such as sales, cash flow, book value or dividends paid. The idea, set out by Arnott, Hsu and Moore in 2005, is that cap weighting necessarily holds more of any stock that is overpriced, and that weighting by business size avoids this.

In practice a fundamental index holds more of companies that are cheap relative to their sales or assets, which makes it a value strategy with a rulebook (Factor investing: five factor funds against the S&P 500, tested). It does well when cheap stocks do well and lags when expensive ones lead, and like equal weighting it must trade at each rebalance to pull weights back from where prices took them.

Capped

A capped index starts from float-adjusted market value and then limits how large a single company, or a group of the largest, may become. Capping is everywhere in sector, country and growth indexes, where a few companies would otherwise dominate.

Why caps exist: the 25/50 test

Most caps trace back to US tax law. A US fund avoids tax at the fund level only if it qualifies as a regulated investment company, and one condition is a diversification test in section 851(b)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. At the close of each quarter of the fund's tax year:

  • at least 50% of the fund's assets must be in cash, government securities, other funds, and other securities in which no single issuer is more than 5% of the fund's assets (or more than 10% of that issuer's voting shares); and
  • no more than 25% of the fund's assets may be in the securities of any one issuer.

Put the other way round: no holding above 25%, and the holdings that are each above 5% may not add up to more than 50%. Index providers call an index that embeds this a "25/50" index. An uncapped index of a narrow sector can fail the test on its own, and a fund tracking it would have to deviate from the index to stay qualified. A capped index moves that problem into the rulebook, usually with tighter limits than the law so that price moves between reviews do not cause a breach. The law allows 30 days after a quarter end to cure a failure caused by an acquisition.

How the Nasdaq-100 caps

The Nasdaq-100 calls its method modified market capitalization weighting. Under the 2026 methodology the index is reviewed each quarter against two limits. If any company is above 24%, it is cut to 20%. If the companies that are each above 4.5% add up to 48% or more, that group is scaled down to 40% in total, keeping their order, and the weight removed is spread across the rest. A stricter check applies at the annual reconstitution in December.

A worked case with invented weights: five companies stand at 14%, 13%, 12%, 6% and 5%, all above 4.5%, and together 50%. That is over 48%, so the group is scaled to 40%:

scale = 40 ÷ 50 = 0.8
new weights: 11.2%, 10.4%, 9.6%, 4.8%, 4.0%
the other 95 companies: 50% → 60%, each multiplied by 1.2

A fund tracking the index must then sell a fifth of each of its five biggest positions and buy every other member, on one day.

The methodology also allows a special rebalance outside the schedule if a limit is breached. Nasdaq used it in July 2023, when a handful of very large companies had grown to nearly half the index. It announced the step in early July and applied the new weights before the open on July 24, 2023, with no change to the members. Funds tracking the index sold part of their largest holdings in a single adjustment.

Same sector, two capping rules

XLK and VGT are both US technology index funds. XLK holds the technology companies of the S&P 500 under the capping rules of S&P's Select Sector indexes. VGT follows an MSCI index of large, mid-sized and small US technology companies with 25/50 capping. In both, two or three companies would be far above the limits without a cap.

Two technology index funds: XLK’s price return minus VGT’s, by calendar year −3.9 ’05 +2.7 ’06 +0.3 ’07 +1.0 ’08 −12.1 ’09 −2.2 ’10 +1.3 ’11 +0.7 ’12 −5.7 ’13 −1.0 ’14 −0.0 ’15 +0.7 ’16 −3.3 ’17 −4.4 ’18 +1.1 ’19 −2.6 ’20 +4.2 ’21 +1.9 ’22 +3.2 ’23 −7.7 ’24 +2.6 ’25 Percentage points. XLK: S&P 500 technology stocks under Select Sector caps. VGT: MSCI US IMI Info Tech 25/50.
XLK’s calendar-year price return minus VGT’s, 2005 to 2025. Dividends are left out of both.

The two funds' monthly returns had a correlation of 0.989 from 2005 to October 2026, yet in an average year their price returns differed by 3.0 points in one direction or the other. XLK was 12.1 points behind in 2009 and 7.7 behind in 2024, and 4.2 ahead in 2021. Over the whole period VGT's price rose 14.68% a year and XLK's 13.86%.

The chart cannot say how much of each gap came from capping and how much from VGT's smaller companies, because the two indexes differ in both ways. What it does show is that "a technology index fund" is not one thing. The weight a capped fund gives its largest holdings is set by a formula, and when those holdings move sharply, funds on different formulas get different results.

What each method costs to run

Method Turnover needed Concentration Built-in lean
Cap / float Lowest: only member and share changes Highest in the largest companies None: it is the market
Price Low Depends on share prices Toward high-priced shares
Equal High: every rebalance Lowest Smaller, cheaper companies
Fundamental Moderate to high Moderate Cheap relative to sales and assets
Capped Low, with bursts when a cap binds Limited by rule Away from the largest company or companies

Where weighting misleads

"Diversified" is not the same as "many holdings". A cap-weighted index of 500 stocks with 36% in ten of them behaves much like those ten on many days. An equal-weight index of the same stocks spreads the risk and takes on more small-company risk in exchange.

Capping is not protection. A cap limits how much of a winner the fund may hold. It does not limit losses, and it forces sales of rising stocks at dates known to every trader in advance.

Back-tests favour the alternatives. Equal and fundamental weighting look good over periods when smaller and cheaper companies led, and such periods are easy to choose after the fact. From 2023 to 2025 the equal-weight S&P 500 fund trailed the cap-weighted one in all three years.

The fund's weights are not the index's between reviews. After a rebalance, capped weights drift with prices until the next one. A fund can show a holding above the cap on any given day without having broken a rule.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not build indexes or publish membership changes, and it does not calculate index weights. It shows the funds. Every fund has a symbol page with its quote, chart, news and a Dividends & splits tab, and the Holders tab can show a fund card with issuer, expense ratio, assets, net asset value, holdings and sector weights when the feed has them.

The comparison tab is the quickest way to see a weighting method at work. Open SPY and add RSP and DIA: the three lines hold largely the same big companies under three weighting rules. The tab rebases each to percent change from the first bar in view and tabulates price returns from one week to two years, excluding dividends. The heatmap sizes each tile by market value, which is what a cap-weighted index does with its money, and the screener can be scoped to the S&P 500 and sorted by market cap to list the members that carry most of the weight.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the Dow still use price weighting?

History. The method dates from a time when an average of prices was all that could be computed quickly, and the index's long record depends on continuity. Its owner manages the drawbacks by selecting members whose share prices are not too far apart.

Is cap weighting the same as buying high?

Not in the sense of trading. A cap-weighted fund does not buy more of a stock because it rose; the shares it already holds are simply worth more. It does mean new money put into the fund is spread in proportion to current prices, so a larger share goes to whatever is most highly valued.

What does 25/50 in an index name mean?

That the index is capped so a fund following it can pass the US tax diversification test: no issuer above 25% of assets, and the issuers that are each above 5% totalling no more than 50%. Providers usually set their own limits a little inside those figures.

Do capped funds have higher taxes or costs?

They trade more than uncapped ones when a cap binds, since they must sell part of their largest holdings. In an exchange-traded fund much of that selling can be done without distributing gains (ETF tax efficiency: in-kind redemptions, heartbeat trades and limits). The larger effect is on returns: the fund holds less of its biggest companies than the market does.

Which weighting method is best?

None is best in every period. Cap weighting is the cheapest to run and matches the market. The others are deliberate departures from it that have led in some decades and trailed in others. Knowing which method a fund uses tells you when to expect it to differ.

Summary

The weighting method decides how much of each member an index holds. Float-adjusted market value is the standard for broad indexes: cheap to maintain and concentrated in the largest companies. Price weighting, used by the Dow, hands the most weight to the highest share prices. Equal and fundamental weighting cut the tie to price and pay for it in trading. Capped indexes are cap-weighted up to a ceiling that usually reflects the 25% and 50% limits of US tax law, and when a cap binds, as in the Nasdaq-100 in July 2023, every fund on the index sells its largest holdings together.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A price-weighted index holds three stocks at $300, $60 and $40. What is the weight of the $300 stock?

    1. 33.3%
    2. 75%
    3. It depends on the number of shares each company has
    Show the answer

    B. 75% Price weight is the share price divided by the sum of prices: 300 ÷ (300 + 60 + 40) = 75%. Share counts and company size play no part.

  2. Under the US tax diversification test for funds, which portfolio fails?

    1. One holding at 24%, one at 20%, and nothing else above 5%
    2. Three holdings at 20% each and nothing else above 5%
    3. Ten holdings at 4.9% each and the rest smaller
    Show the answer

    B. Three holdings at 20% each and nothing else above 5% Holdings above 5% may total no more than 50%. Three at 20% make 60%. The first portfolio has 44% in large holdings and none above 25%; the third has none above 5%.

  3. In an index capped the Nasdaq-100 way, companies above 4.5% add up to 52%. What happens at the quarterly review?

    1. Nothing, because no single company is above 24%
    2. The largest company alone is cut until the total is 48%
    3. The group is scaled down to 40% in total and the weight is spread over the other members
    Show the answer

    C. The group is scaled down to 40% in total and the weight is spread over the other members When the companies above 4.5% reach 48% or more together, the methodology reduces the group to 40% while keeping its order, and the remaining members are scaled up.

  4. Which weighting method needs the least trading to maintain?

    1. Float-adjusted market value
    2. Equal weight
    3. Fundamental weight
    Show the answer

    A. Float-adjusted market value Market-value weights move with prices, so the fund stays on target without trading. Equal and fundamental weights drift from their targets whenever prices move and must be reset.

  5. A company in a price-weighted index splits its shares two for one. What happens to its weight?

    1. Nothing changes
    2. It roughly halves, although the company is worth the same
    3. It doubles, because there are twice as many shares
    Show the answer

    B. It roughly halves, although the company is worth the same The share price halves, and a price-weighted index sees only the price. In a value-weighted index the doubling of shares offsets the halving of price and the weight is unchanged.

Sources and further reading

  1. Internal Revenue Code §851(b)(3) — diversification tests for a regulated investment company (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
  2. Nasdaq — Nasdaq-100 Index Methodology (2026 edition): modified market capitalization weighting, quarterly and annual weight constraints, special rebalance
  3. FTSE Russell — Russell US Equity Indexes, Construction and Methodology, v7.4 (November 2026): float-adjusted market capitalization weighting
  4. iShares — iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV) fact sheet, June 30, 2026: top holdings
  5. Robert D. Arnott, Jason Hsu and Philip Moore, “Fundamental Indexation,” Financial Analysts Journal, vol. 61, no. 2 (2005)
  6. Finabase chart data — monthly bars of SPY, RSP, QQQ, DIA, XLK and VGT and October 2026 closes of the 30 Dow stocks; statistics computed by Finabase