Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Measure and manage portfolio risk Lesson 9 of 14

Portfolio and risk · Managing a portfolio

Concentration risk: when one holding dominates a portfolio

How a single large position changes a portfolio’s volatility and worst day, how a 5% holding grew to 75% untouched, and how to measure concentration.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. How it works
  3. Using it
  4. Where it fails or misleads
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding
  10. Exercise

Concentration risk is the risk that comes from having a large share of a portfolio in one holding, or in a few that behave alike. A diversified portfolio's fate is tied to the market's. A concentrated one is tied to a company's: its products, its management, its accounting and its luck. The beginner lesson on Diversification: why spreading your investments reduces risk covers why spreading money reduces risk. This lesson measures what happens when it is not spread, and looks at the most common way concentration arises, which is success. A position that has grown tenfold is concentrated whether or not anyone decided it should be.

The idea

The risk of a stock has two parts. One is shared with the whole market. The other belongs to the company alone. In a portfolio of many stocks the second part averages out, as The mathematics of diversification: how many holdings are enough shows. In a portfolio dominated by one stock it does not.

Because company-specific risk can be removed at no cost by diversifying, markets do not pay investors a premium for bearing it. A concentrated holding may turn out brilliantly. On average it carries more risk for the same expected return.

Portfolio volatility as one stock takes a larger share of an index fund 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% SPY plus NVDA SPY plus TSLA SPY plus AAPL SPY plus KO Share of the portfolio in the single stock (the rest in SPY) Portfolio volatility a year Daily returns from closing prices, 2024-11 to 2026-11, rebalanced daily. Dividends not included.
Annualized volatility of a portfolio holding one stock at shares from 0% to 100% and SPY for the rest, rebalanced daily. Daily closes, November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026; price changes only.

The figure adds one stock to an index fund in growing amounts. For three volatile stocks the portfolio's risk climbs steadily. For Coca-Cola, a calm stock that moved independently of the market in these two years, it falls. So concentration is not a matter of weight alone. What matters is weight multiplied by how volatile the holding is and how closely it moves with everything else.

How it works

Risk concentrates faster than money

The data: daily closes from November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026, price changes only. SPY had a volatility of 16.9% and a worst day of −5.85%. Each row puts part of the portfolio in one stock and the rest in SPY.

Stock (its volatility) Measure 5% weight 10% 20% 30% 50%
NVDA (44.7%) Portfolio volatility 17.7% 18.6% 20.8% 23.2% 28.9%
Stock's share of risk 10% 19% 38% 54% 76%
Worst day −5.93% −6.00% −6.15% −6.31% −9.19%
TSLA (56.3%) Portfolio volatility 18.1% 19.4% 22.6% 26.3% 34.4%
Stock's share of risk 12% 23% 44% 60% 81%
AAPL (29.0%) Portfolio volatility 17.0% 17.1% 17.7% 18.5% 20.7%
Stock's share of risk 6% 12% 26% 40% 66%
KO (18.4%) Portfolio volatility 16.1% 15.3% 13.9% 12.9% 12.3%
Stock's share of risk 0% 1% 6% 17% 54%

"Share of risk" is the part of the portfolio's variance that comes from the stock: its weight times its covariance with the portfolio, divided by the portfolio's variance.

A 10% position in Nvidia supplied 19% of the portfolio's risk, and a 20% position supplied 38%. A holding's share of the risk is roughly double its share of the money until it becomes the majority of both. Position size understates what a volatile holding is doing to a portfolio.

SPY already held these companies. Nvidia and Apple are among its largest holdings, so the true exposure in each column is higher than the label.

How concentration builds: drift

Few people buy a 75% position. They buy a small one and it grows.

A 5% position in NVDA left alone beside SPY, 2016–2026: its share of the portfolio 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% NVDA’s share of the portfolio 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026
Share of a portfolio held in NVDA after starting at 5% NVDA and 95% SPY in January 2016, never rebalanced. Month-end values to October 2026; NVDA price only, SPY total return.

A portfolio started in January 2016 with 5% in Nvidia and 95% in SPY, and never touched.

Date Nvidia's share of the portfolio
January 2016 5.0%
December 2016 13.2%
September 2018 23.0%
December 2018 14.1%
November 2021 45.7%
October 2022 28.7%
December 2023 54.1%
December 2024 71.9%
October 2026 74.8%

The result was a compound return of 29.6% a year, against 14.7% for SPY alone. It is also a different portfolio from the one that was bought. Its deepest fall was 39.8%, against 23.9% for SPY. In 2022 it lost 31.7% when SPY lost 18.2%, because Nvidia fell 50.3% that year while making up between a quarter and a half of the holdings.

This example was chosen because it is the best case: the stock went on to become one of the largest companies in the world. The same drift happens with any big winner, and most big winners do not continue. Nvidia itself fell 87.2% from its December 2001 month-end high to September 2002 and did not recover the level until October 2006. Its monthly record since 1999 contains five separate falls of 50% or more from a peak.

Measuring concentration

Portfolio (illustrative weights) Positions Effective number
Ten holdings at 10% each 10 10.0
One at 40% and six at 10% 7 4.5
One at 25% and fifteen at 5% 16 10.0
Three at 20%, 15% and 10%, and eleven at 5% 14 10.0
500 holdings at equal weight 500 500

The second portfolio lists seven positions and behaves like four or five. The third lists 16 and is no more diversified than ten equal ones, because of the single 25% holding. The sum of squared weights is the Herfindahl index used by regulators to measure market concentration.

Two simpler checks: the weight of the largest holding, and the combined weight of the top five or ten.

Using it

  1. Look through funds. Three funds can hold the same seven large companies. Add up the exposure to any company held both directly and through funds.
  2. Count what is outside the brokerage account. An employee paid by a company, holding its stock and its unvested shares, depends on one business for salary and savings together. If the company fails, both go at once.
  3. Set a limit in advance. Many investors cap a single stock at 5% or 10% of the portfolio and trim when it passes. The number matters less than having one before the position has tripled, when selling feels hardest. Rebalancing methods: calendar, threshold and what each one costs covers the mechanics.
  4. Weigh the tax, without letting it decide. Selling a large winner in a taxable account realizes a gain. Staged sales over several tax years, directing new money elsewhere, donating appreciated shares and hedging with options (Hedging a portfolio: four ways to reduce risk and what each costs) are ways to reduce a position gradually. A tax bill of a known size is being compared with a risk of unknown size.
  5. Think in sectors and themes as well. Ten technology stocks are ten positions and one bet.

Where it fails or misleads

  • Concentration is how large fortunes are made. Founders and early employees become wealthy by holding one stock. The record of those who did is visible; the record of those whose stock went to zero is not. Bessembinder found that most US stocks since 1926 earned less than Treasury bills over their lifetimes and that a small minority of companies produced the market's entire net gain.
  • Counting positions is not measuring risk. Twenty holdings that fall together are concentrated. One holding of a total-market fund is not.
  • Volatility measured in a calm period understates. The two-year window above contains no bankruptcy and no fraud. Single-company risk includes outcomes that do not appear in a volatility figure until they happen.
  • The index is itself concentrated. In a market-weighted fund the largest companies can make up a third of the value. Diversifying into "the market" still leaves a meaningful exposure to a few names.
  • Low concentration does not mean low risk. A perfectly diversified stock portfolio halved in 2007 to 2009. Diversifying removes company risk and leaves market risk.

Compared with its neighbours

Risk Source Reduced by
Concentration risk One holding, sector or theme dominating Trimming, spreading holdings
Market risk The whole market falling Holding less stock; hedging
Liquidity risk Being unable to sell at a fair price Holding heavily traded assets; smaller sizes
Currency risk Exchange rates moving against foreign holdings Hedged funds; home-currency assets
Leverage risk Borrowing magnifying every move Borrowing less

Concentration and leverage both make a portfolio's outcome depend on fewer things going right. A concentrated position bought with borrowed money combines the two.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not compute an effective number of holdings, a position's share of portfolio risk, or a look-through of the companies inside the funds in a portfolio.

The portfolio page shows each position's market value and an allocation bar of the largest holdings and cash, which gives position weights directly. Dividing each market value by the total and squaring gives the inputs to the formula above. For a fund, the Holdings tab on its symbol page lists its largest positions, the combined weight of the top ten, and the sector split, which is what is needed to add indirect exposure to direct. A price alert on a large holding, set at the level where it would pass a chosen limit, is a way to be told when drift has done its work.

Frequently asked questions

How much of a portfolio in one stock is too much?

There is no rule. Common guidelines cap one stock at 5% to 10%. The honest test is the effect of that stock halving, which single stocks do regularly: a 30% position halving takes 15% off the portfolio by itself.

Is owning an S&P 500 fund concentrated?

It holds about 500 companies, weighted by size, so the largest few make up a large share. It is far less concentrated than any single stock and more concentrated than an equal-weighted or total-market fund.

Why is employer stock considered especially risky?

Because salary and savings then depend on the same company. Employees of firms that failed have lost their jobs and their retirement savings in the same month.

My concentrated position has done very well. Why change anything?

Past gains say nothing about what the position will do next, and the larger it has grown, the more of the portfolio now rides on it. The question is whether you would buy that much of it today with cash.

Does diversifying mean lower returns?

It means a narrower range of outcomes: the chance of the best result is given up along with the chance of the worst. The expected return of a diversified portfolio is not lower than that of a typical single stock.

Summary

Concentration ties a portfolio to one company or theme and adds risk that the market does not pay for. Risk concentrates faster than money: a 20% position in a volatile stock supplied 38% of a portfolio's volatility. Most concentration arrives by drift, as a 5% Nvidia position did in growing to 75% over a decade, producing an extraordinary return and a portfolio that fell 31.7% in a year when the index fell 18.2%. Measure it with the largest weight and the effective number of holdings, count employer stock and overlapping funds, and decide on a limit before a winner makes the decision.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A portfolio holds one position at 40% and six at 10% each. What is its effective number of holdings?

    1. 7
    2. About 4.5
    3. About 2.5
    Show the answer

    B. About 4.5 Sum of squared weights = 0.40² + 6 × 0.10² = 0.16 + 0.06 = 0.22. 1 ÷ 0.22 ≈ 4.5. The large position makes seven holdings behave like four or five.

  2. In the example, a 20% position in Nvidia supplied 38% of the portfolio’s volatility. Why is the share of risk larger than the share of money?

    1. Because the stock was far more volatile than the rest of the portfolio
    2. Because the stock pays no dividend
    3. Because of trading costs
    Show the answer

    A. Because the stock was far more volatile than the rest of the portfolio A holding’s contribution to risk depends on its weight times its covariance with the portfolio. A stock with 44.7% volatility beside a 16.9% index dominates the risk well before it dominates the value.

  3. How does most concentration in individual portfolios arise?

    1. By buying one very large position at the start
    2. By a successful holding growing while nothing is trimmed
    3. By holding too much cash
    Show the answer

    B. By a successful holding growing while nothing is trimmed Drift does it. A 5% holding that rises many times over becomes the majority of a portfolio without any decision being made.

  4. Why does the market not pay extra expected return for bearing the risk of a single company?

    1. Because that risk can be removed for free by diversifying
    2. Because single stocks are less volatile than indexes
    3. Because regulators forbid it
    Show the answer

    A. Because that risk can be removed for free by diversifying Company-specific risk averages out across many holdings. Since any investor can avoid it at no cost, there is no premium for carrying it.

  5. An employee holds company stock worth half of their savings. What is the concentration beyond the stock position itself?

    1. Their salary depends on the same company
    2. The stock is in a retirement account
    3. The stock is in the S&P 500
    Show the answer

    A. Their salary depends on the same company Income and savings would be hit together if the company struggled, which is the scenario in which the money is most needed.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open SPY’s Holdings tab. Read the number of Holdings, the Top 10 weight, and the weight of the first name under Top holdings. If every holding had an equal weight, what would ten of them add up to (10 ÷ the number of holdings)? Then suppose someone holds 80% in SPY and 20% directly in that first company. What is their total exposure to it: 20% + 0.80 × its weight in the fund?

Open SPY’s holdings
What you should find

At equal weights ten of about 500 holdings would be about 2% of the fund. The real top ten hold many times that, often a third or more: the index is itself concentrated. The look-through exposure comes out several points above the 20% on the label. A company held both directly and through a fund has to be added up, as the lesson says.

Sources and further reading

  1. Hendrik Bessembinder, “Do Stocks Outperform Treasury Bills?”, Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 129, no. 3 (2018)
  2. Meir Statman, “How Many Stocks Make a Diversified Portfolio?”, Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, vol. 22, no. 3 (1987)
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov — Concentration and diversification; Putting too much stock in your employer’s stock
  4. FINRA, Concentrate on Concentration Risk
  5. Finabase chart data — daily bars of SPY, NVDA, TSLA, AAPL and KO, November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026; monthly bars of NVDA from March 1999 and of SPY from January 2016, to October 2026; statistics computed by Finabase