Measure and manage portfolio risk Lesson 13 of 14
Portfolio and risk · Long-run planning
Sequence of returns risk: why the order of returns matters
The same 26 years of stock returns in two orders: a retiree spending 4% ends with $60,000 or $2.4 million. How sequence risk works and how it is managed.
On this page
Sequence of returns risk is the risk that the order in which investment returns arrive, and not only their average, determines how a plan turns out. For money that is simply left invested, the order makes no difference: the same set of yearly returns multiplies out to the same final value however it is arranged. Once money is being added or taken out, that stops being true. A retiree who meets poor returns in the first years of withdrawals can run short on an average return that would have been ample in a different order.
This is the main reason that retirement planning cannot be done with an average return and a calculator. Two retirees with identical portfolios, identical spending and identical long-run returns can end decades later with a fortune and with almost nothing.
The idea
Take three yearly returns: +30%, +10% and −20%. Left alone, $100 becomes $114.40 whichever order they come in, because 1.30 × 1.10 × 0.80 is the same as 0.80 × 1.10 × 1.30.
Now withdraw $10 at the start of each year. If the loss comes first, $100 becomes $90, falls to $72, loses another $10, grows to $68.20, loses $10 and grows to $75.66. If the loss comes last, the same steps give $117, then $117.70, then $86.16. The returns were the same. The retiree who met the loss first has $10.50 less, about 12% of the portfolio, after only three years.
The reason is that a withdrawal made after a fall sells more of the portfolio to raise the same number of dollars, and what has been sold cannot take part in the recovery.
The figure shows the effect on real data. Both lines use the same 312 monthly returns. One starts with the bear market of 2000 to 2002 and the other ends with it.
How it works
A worked example: one set of returns, two orders
The data: SPY's monthly total returns from January 2000 to December 2025, adjusted for inflation, so every dollar figure is in January 2000 purchasing power. Over the 26 years SPY returned 5.3% a year after inflation. The first ten years returned −3.5% a year and the last ten 11.1% a year. The retiree starts with $1,000,000 and withdraws $40,000 a year, paid monthly.
| Years since retirement | Returns in the order they came | The same returns reversed |
|---|---|---|
| 3 | $491,204 | $1,537,171 |
| 5 | $568,143 | $1,335,850 |
| 10 | $324,443 | $2,183,915 |
| 15 | $312,370 | $3,373,257 |
| 20 | $224,260 | $3,200,002 |
| 26 | $60,240 | $2,353,089 |
Taxes and fees are not included. The reversed order is a thought experiment: it never happened.
With no withdrawals at all, both orders turn $1,000,000 into $3,817,130. With withdrawals, one retiree has spent $1,040,000 over 26 years and has $60,240 left; the other has spent the same amount and has more than twice what they started with.
The first three years did most of it. SPY lost 42.0% after inflation in 2000 to 2002. With withdrawals on top, the actual-order retiree had $491,204 left after three years. From there the portfolio earned excellent returns for long stretches, including 11.1% a year in the final decade, but on a base less than half the original size and with a $40,000 withdrawal that had become 8% of the balance instead of 4%.
A less aggressive portfolio softens the result without removing it. With 60% in SPY and 40% in Treasury bills, the actual order left $91,749 after 26 years and the reversed order $1,003,445.
The mirror image: a saver
A saver putting in $1,000 a month over the same 26 years pays in $312,000 either way.
| Years of saving | Returns in the order they came | The same returns reversed |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | $113,308 | $207,815 |
| 20 | $557,421 | $485,837 |
| 26 | $1,127,067 | $439,212 |
The order that ruined the retiree made the saver rich. Poor returns in the early years touched only the small sums saved so far and let later contributions buy at low prices; the strong final decade then applied to a large balance. In the reversed order, the best returns were earned on almost nothing and the bear market arrived when the pot was at its largest.
The general rule: returns matter most when the balance is biggest. For a saver that is the end. For a retiree it is the beginning. The years just before and just after retirement are both, which is why they are sometimes called the red zone.
Using it
Sequence risk cannot be diversified away, since it comes from the timing of market returns against the timing of cash flows. It can be reduced in several ways, each with a cost.
- Hold less in stocks around retirement. A lower stock share in the years either side of the retirement date shrinks the early loss that does the damage. This is the logic of Glide paths: how a portfolio’s stock share changes with age.
- Withdraw less to begin with. At 3% the same 2000 retiree, in a 60/40 portfolio, still had well over half the starting balance 26 years on. See Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out?.
- Cut spending after a fall. A fixed inflation-adjusted withdrawal is the most demanding rule there is. Skipping the inflation increase, or trimming withdrawals by a tenth after a bad year, leaves more invested for the recovery.
- Keep a reserve. A few years of spending in cash or short-term bonds allows withdrawals to continue without selling stocks at a low. The bucket approach: dividing retirement money by when it is needed is built on this.
- Secure a floor of income. Social Security, a pension or an annuity that covers essential spending means the portfolio is not being drawn on at a fixed rate whatever happens.
- Stay flexible on the date. Working a year or two longer, or part-time, after a market fall removes withdrawals at the worst moment.
For savers the lesson is the reverse and more comfortable: a bear market early in a working life is an opportunity, provided contributions continue.
Where it fails or misleads
- A reversed history is an illustration, not evidence. Markets do not deliver the same returns in a different order. The exercise isolates one effect and says nothing about how likely either order was.
- The example is close to a worst case. Retiring in January 2000 meant starting at the peak of a bubble, with two bear markets in the first decade. Most starting dates were far kinder.
- It is easy to overcorrect. Moving to very safe assets removes sequence risk and replaces it with the risk of outliving a portfolio that cannot grow, and with exposure to inflation. See Inflation and real returns: what an investment earns after prices.
- Average returns hide it completely. A plan built on "7% a year" shows a smooth rising line. No real retirement has looked like that.
- Fixed real withdrawals are a simplification. Real retirees adjust. Studies that assume nobody ever changes spending overstate how often portfolios fail.
- Sequence risk does not end at retirement. A deep fall ten years in still matters, though less, because fewer years of withdrawals remain to be funded.
Compared with its neighbours
| Risk | What it is | Who bears it most |
|---|---|---|
| Sequence of returns risk | Bad returns arriving when the balance is largest | People near or in early retirement |
| Market risk | Returns being poor on average | Every investor |
| Longevity risk | Living longer than the money lasts | Retirees |
| Inflation risk | Spending power falling | Holders of cash and fixed incomes |
| Volatility drag | Compound growth below the average return | Every investor, more with leverage |
Sequence risk and volatility drag both come from volatility. The drag applies to any portfolio. Sequence risk appears only when there are cash flows.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not model withdrawals or contributions, simulate a retirement or show the effect of reordering returns.
It shows the returns themselves. A symbol's chart at the maximum range and its History tab give the year-by-year record that the example above is built from; SPY's falls in 2000 to 2002 and in 2008 are visible on the long-range chart. A portfolio page charts the total value of a real portfolio over time, which is where sequence risk shows up for an actual investor. The Economy page charts the consumer price index used here to put the figures in constant dollars.
Frequently asked questions
What is sequence of returns risk in simple terms?
The risk that poor investment returns come at the wrong time: for a retiree, early in retirement, when withdrawals turn a temporary fall into a permanent loss of capital.
Does the order of returns matter if I am not withdrawing?
Not if no money goes in or out. A lump sum left alone ends at the same value whatever the order. It matters as soon as there are regular contributions or withdrawals.
When is sequence risk highest?
In the few years before and the ten or so years after retirement, when the portfolio is at its largest and withdrawals are beginning.
Is a market crash good or bad for me?
It depends on which way money is flowing. For someone decades from retirement and still saving, a fall early on has historically been helpful. For someone starting withdrawals, it is the most harmful event there is.
How can I protect against it?
By reducing the size of the early loss (a lower stock share near retirement), by reducing what has to be sold after a fall (a lower or flexible withdrawal, a cash reserve), or by covering essential spending with guaranteed income.
Summary
The order of returns is irrelevant to money left alone and decisive for money being drawn on. Using SPY's returns from 2000 to 2025, a retiree spending $40,000 a year from $1,000,000 finished with $60,240 in the order the returns arrived and $2,353,089 in the reverse order; a regular saver saw the opposite. Losses hurt most when the balance is largest, which for retirees is the start. The defences are a lower stock share around the retirement date, a lower or adjustable withdrawal, a reserve to spend from, and income that does not depend on the market.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A lump sum is invested for 20 years with nothing added or withdrawn. Does the order of the yearly returns affect the final value?
- Yes, early losses always reduce it
- No, the same returns multiply to the same result in any order
- Yes, late losses always reduce it
Show the answer
B. No, the same returns multiply to the same result in any order Multiplication is the same in any order. Sequence matters only when money flows in or out along the way.
$100 is invested and $10 is withdrawn at the start of each year. Returns are −20%, then +10%. What is the balance after two years?
- $68.20
- $70.40
- $79.20
Show the answer
A. $68.20 Year 1: (100 − 10) × 0.80 = 72. Year 2: (72 − 10) × 1.10 = 68.20.
Why do poor returns early in retirement do more damage than the same returns later?
- Because early withdrawals are taxed more
- Because the balance is largest then, and shares sold after a fall cannot recover
- Because inflation is higher early in retirement
Show the answer
B. Because the balance is largest then, and shares sold after a fall cannot recover A loss on the full balance, followed by selling at low prices to fund spending, permanently shrinks the base on which later returns are earned.
For a 30-year-old saving every month, which order of returns is better?
- Strong returns early and poor returns late
- Poor returns early and strong returns late
- The order makes no difference
Show the answer
B. Poor returns early and strong returns late Early losses affect only a small balance and let contributions buy cheaply. Strong returns late apply to the large balance built up by then.
Which is a way of reducing sequence risk?
- Raising the withdrawal rate
- Holding a few years of spending in cash so stocks need not be sold after a fall
- Moving entirely into stocks at retirement
Show the answer
B. Holding a few years of spending in cash so stocks need not be sold after a fall A reserve allows withdrawals to continue without selling depressed assets. The other two options increase the exposure.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open SPY’s chart at the MAX range and turn on Log scale under Chart tools, so equal percentage falls have the same height. Find the fall of 2000 to 2002, the fall of 2008 and the long rise of the last decade. Two people start in January 2000 and live through this exact order of returns. One retires and withdraws a fixed amount each year. The other begins saving a fixed amount each month. For which of them was this the better order, and why?
Open SPY’s full-history chartWhat you should find
The saver. The early falls touched only a small balance and let later contributions buy at low prices, and the strong final decade then applied to a large pot. The retiree met the losses when the balance was largest: in the lesson $1,000,000 was down to $491,204 after three years. The returns were the same for both. Returns matter most when the balance is biggest.
Sources and further reading
- William P. Bengen, “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data,” Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 7, no. 4 (1994)
- Moshe A. Milevsky and Anna Abaimova, “Retirement Ruin and the Sequencing of Returns” (IFID Centre, York University, 2006)
- Wade D. Pfau, “Safe Savings Rates: A New Approach to Retirement Planning over the Life Cycle,” Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 24, no. 5 (2011)
- U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers (CPIAUCSL), via FRED
- Finabase chart data — monthly bars and dividends of SPY, January 2000 to December 2025; 3-Month Treasury Bill rate (TB3MS) via FRED; simulations computed by Finabase
