Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Portfolio and risk · Managing a portfolio

Liquidity risk: the cost of selling when you have to

What makes an asset liquid, how to estimate the days needed to sell a position from its trading volume, and why liquidity shrinks in a sell-off.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. How it works
  3. Using it
  4. Where it fails or misleads
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Liquidity risk is the risk of being unable to sell an investment quickly without accepting a lower price. It has two parts. An asset can be hard to sell at any time because few people trade it. And an asset that is normally easy to sell can become hard to sell on the days when many holders want out together.

Volatility describes how much a price moves. Liquidity describes what it costs to act on that price. The quoted price is for a small trade in calm conditions; a large or urgent sale gets something worse. The risk rarely appears in performance statistics, because it shows up only when a sale is forced. This lesson explains how to estimate it from public figures and how to arrange a portfolio so that a forced sale is unlikely.

The idea

Every asset has a price at which it last traded. Liquidity is about the next trade. Selling 100 shares of a large company moves nothing: there are buyers at the quoted price for many times that amount. Selling $1,000,000 of a small company's shares in an afternoon may require stepping down through every buyer on the order book, each at a lower price.

So liquidity is a relationship between the size of a position and the amount that usually trades.

Days needed to sell $1 million at one-tenth of daily trading ARKK 0.03 days SPLV (low-volatility ETF) 0.06 days AOR (allocation ETF) 0.23 days WINA (small company) 0.43 days TAIL (tail-risk ETF) 4.7 days HEDJ (hedged Europe ETF) 4.9 days FXY (yen ETF) 1.3 days From each fund’s or stock’s share volume in October 2026. SPY and NVDA: under a minute of trading.
Trading days needed to sell $1,000,000 of each security while being no more than 10% of its average daily dollar volume. October 2026 share volume × month-end close ÷ 22 trading days. SPY, NVDA and HYG, at under 0.01 days, are left off.

The figure applies one rule to a range of securities: sell no more than a tenth of what normally trades in a day, so as not to push the price. On that rule a million dollars of a mid-sized fund is sold within an hour or two, and the same amount of two small funds takes most of a week. The largest funds and stocks do not appear at all: for them a million dollars is a few seconds' worth of trading.

How it works

Three things are usually meant by liquidity.

Dimension Question it answers Visible measure
Cost How much is lost by trading at once? Bid-ask spread
Depth How much can be traded before the price moves? Size quoted at the bid and ask; volume
Time How long does it take to trade the full amount? Position size against daily volume

Liquidity and slippage: volume, depth, spread and market impact covers the cost and depth of a single order. This lesson is about the portfolio: how long it would take to turn holdings into cash.

A worked example: one million dollars in ten securities

The data: each security's share volume for October 2026, multiplied by its month-end close and divided by 22 trading days. Participation rate 10%.

Security Average daily dollar volume $1,000,000 as a share of one day Days to sell
SPY (S&P 500 fund) $30.18 billion 0.003% 0.0003
NVDA (Nvidia) $20.98 billion 0.005% 0.0005
HYG (high-yield bond fund) $4.29 billion 0.02% 0.002
ARKK (actively managed stock fund) $356.9 million 0.28% 0.03
SPLV (low-volatility stock fund) $170.2 million 0.59% 0.06
AOR (allocation fund) $44.0 million 2.27% 0.23
WINA (Winmark, a small company) $23.0 million 4.34% 0.43
FXY (yen fund) $7.77 million 12.88% 1.3
TAIL (tail-risk fund) $2.13 million 46.85% 4.7
HEDJ (currency-hedged Europe fund) $2.03 million 49.25% 4.9

The range is more than ten-thousand-fold. For a position of $10,000, every security in the table is liquid: even in the last row it is half a percent of a day's trading. Liquidity risk grows with the size of the holding, which is why it is a concern for funds and for large individual positions and hardly at all for a small account in large stocks.

One caution about the last rows. An exchange-traded fund can be more liquid than its own trading volume suggests, because large orders can be met by creating or redeeming fund shares against the underlying holdings. For a fund, the liquidity of what it holds sets the real limit. A small company's stock has no such mechanism: its volume is its liquidity.

Liquidity when it is needed

SPY’s daily trading range as a percent of its price, 2024-11 to 2026-11 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% Median 0.88% High minus low, ÷ close Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct Dec Feb Apr Jun Aug Oct
SPY daily range, (high − low) ÷ close, each trading day from November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026.

The daily range, the gap between a day's high and low, is a rough gauge of how far the price had to move to match buyers with sellers. For SPY over the two years to November 17, 2026:

Measure SPY daily range
Median day 0.88%
90th percentile 1.82%
April 7, 2025 8.20%
April 8, 2025 7.21%
April 9, 2025 10.13%
Average, April 3 to 11, 2025 5.63%

For seven trading days in April 2025 one of the most heavily traded funds in the world moved through a range 6.4 times its normal one. Shares could still be sold. The price at which they could be sold was uncertain by several percent within a single day. In less liquid assets the same episode means wider spreads, thinner order books and, in some markets, no bid at all.

This is the central feature of liquidity risk. It is highly correlated with the events that make people want to sell. Brunnermeier and Pedersen described the mechanism: falling prices bring margin calls and redemptions, which force sales, which push prices lower and make dealers less willing to hold inventory, which reduces liquidity further.

Over the same two years the median and largest daily ranges of other assets were: NVDA 2.78% and 15.50%; KO 1.35% and 5.80%; TLT 0.66% and 3.40%; GLD 1.00% and 8.82%.

Using it

  1. Rank holdings by how fast they turn into cash. Cash and Treasury bills; large stocks and broad funds; small stocks and narrow funds; then assets with no daily market, such as property, private funds, some bonds and certificates of deposit with penalties.
  2. Match liquidity to need. Emergency money and spending for the next few years belong in the first category. The bucket approach: dividing retirement money by when it is needed builds a retirement plan on this idea.
  3. Check volume before sizing a position. If a holding is more than a few percent of the security's average daily dollar volume, selling it will take time or cost money.
  4. Use limit orders in thin securities. A market order in a stock with a wide spread accepts whatever price is on offer. Liquidity and slippage: volume, depth, spread and market impact explains the difference.
  5. Read the terms of anything without a daily price. Lock-ups, redemption gates, notice periods and surrender charges are liquidity risk written into a contract.
  6. Avoid being a forced seller. Borrowing against a portfolio, or relying on it for near-term bills, turns a temporary fall in price into a sale at that price.

Where it fails or misleads

  • Average volume is not available volume. The formula uses a normal month. In a crisis, volume in the affected asset may rise while depth falls, and the participation rate that avoids moving the price is lower.
  • Stale prices hide risk. Assets valued by appraisal (property, private equity) show smooth returns and low volatility because they are not marked to a market price. Their risk has not gone away. It is waiting for a sale.
  • A fund's promise can exceed its holdings' liquidity. Open-end funds offer daily redemption while holding assets that take longer to sell. US rules limit a mutual fund's illiquid investments to 15% of assets for this reason. Under heavy redemptions a fund may sell its most liquid holdings first, leaving the remaining investors with the rest.
  • Liquid markets can stop. Exchanges halt trading after large moves, and single securities are suspended. On those occasions nothing can be sold.
  • Liquidity has a price in good times too. Holding everything in cash avoids this risk and guarantees a low return. The aim is enough liquidity, not the maximum.
  • The illiquidity premium is not assured. Amihud found that less liquid stocks earned higher returns on average. The premium varies over time and is paid for bearing exactly the losses described here.

Compared with its neighbours

Risk The danger When it shows
Market risk Prices fall Continuously, in the price
Liquidity risk Cannot sell near the quoted price Only when selling, mostly in stress
Funding liquidity risk Cannot meet a margin call, redemption or bill When cash is demanded
Concentration risk One holding dominates When that holding falls
Credit risk A borrower fails to pay At default or downgrade

Market liquidity (can the asset be sold?) and funding liquidity (does the holder have cash to meet obligations?) feed each other. A holder short of funding must sell; selling into a thin market lowers prices; lower prices tighten funding.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not calculate days to sell, a liquidity score or a bid-ask spread history for a portfolio.

The inputs to the formula are on each symbol page. The quote shows the day's volume, and the History tab lists each day's open, high, low, close and volume, from which a daily range and a dollar volume (volume × close) can be worked out for any date, including stressed ones. The screener filters by market value, which is a rough proxy for liquidity among stocks: the smallest companies are generally the hardest to trade. The portfolio page gives each position's market value, the numerator of the formula.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between liquidity and volatility?

Volatility is how much the price moves. Liquidity is how much it costs, in price and time, to trade at that price. An asset can be volatile and liquid, like a large technology stock, or calm and illiquid, like a private property fund.

Are ETFs always liquid?

Large, broad ETFs are among the most liquid securities there are. Small or specialized ETFs can trade thinly with wide spreads, and any ETF can only be as liquid, in the end, as the assets it holds.

How do I know whether a stock is illiquid?

Compare the amount you would trade with its average daily dollar volume, and look at the gap between the bid and ask as a percentage of the price. A spread above about 1% or a trade above a few percent of daily volume are signs of low liquidity.

Is illiquidity always bad?

No. An investor who will not need the money for decades can hold illiquid assets and may be paid for doing so. The harm comes from holding them with money that might be needed.

What is a liquidity crisis?

A period when many holders try to sell at once and buyers withdraw. Prices of even sound assets fall sharply because sales are forced, not because their long-run value has changed as much.

Summary

Liquidity risk is the cost of selling quickly, and it depends on the size of the position against what normally trades. A million dollars was a negligible share of a day's trading in SPY in October 2026 and half a day's trading in two small funds. Liquidity also changes with conditions: in April 2025 SPY's daily range averaged 6.4 times its median for seven trading days. Estimate days to sell from dollar volume, keep near-term money in assets that can always be sold, and avoid arrangements that could force a sale at a bad moment.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A stock trades an average of 200,000 shares a day at $25. An investor holds $1,500,000 of it and will not exceed 10% of daily volume. About how many days will it take to sell?

    1. 0.3 days
    2. 3 days
    3. 30 days
    Show the answer

    B. 3 days Daily dollar volume = 200,000 × $25 = $5,000,000. At 10% participation, $500,000 a day can be sold. $1,500,000 ÷ $500,000 = 3 days.

  2. Why does liquidity risk rarely show in a portfolio’s volatility or return statistics?

    1. Because it appears only when a sale has to be made, usually under stress
    2. Because it only affects bonds
    3. Because regulators remove it
    Show the answer

    A. Because it appears only when a sale has to be made, usually under stress Quoted prices assume small trades in normal conditions. The cost of illiquidity is paid at the moment of a large or urgent sale, which may never appear in a calm sample.

  3. In April 2025 SPY’s daily range averaged 6.4 times its median for several days. What does that illustrate?

    1. That SPY is an illiquid fund
    2. That even the most liquid assets become costlier and less certain to trade during a sell-off
    3. That trading volume fell to zero
    Show the answer

    B. That even the most liquid assets become costlier and less certain to trade during a sell-off Liquidity is not fixed. It deteriorates in the conditions that make holders want to sell, which is why it is treated as a risk and not just a cost.

  4. Which holder is best placed to earn a premium from illiquid assets?

    1. One who may need the money next year
    2. One who borrowed to buy them
    3. One with a long horizon and other sources of cash
    Show the answer

    C. One with a long horizon and other sources of cash The premium compensates for being unable to sell. Only an investor who will not be forced to sell can collect it without bearing the loss it pays for.

Sources and further reading

  1. Yakov Amihud, “Illiquidity and Stock Returns: Cross-Section and Time-Series Effects,” Journal of Financial Markets, vol. 5, no. 1 (2002)
  2. Markus K. Brunnermeier and Lasse Heje Pedersen, “Market Liquidity and Funding Liquidity,” Review of Financial Studies, vol. 22, no. 6 (2009)
  3. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov — Liquidity (or marketability); Microcap Stock: A Guide for Investors
  4. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investment Company Liquidity Risk Management Programs, Rule 22e-4 (2016)
  5. Finabase chart data — October 2026 monthly volume and close of ten US-listed securities; daily bars of SPY, NVDA, KO, TLT and GLD, November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026; statistics computed by Finabase