Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Measure and manage portfolio risk Lesson 14 of 14

Portfolio and risk · Long-run planning

Safe withdrawal rates: how much can a portfolio pay out?

Where the 4% rule comes from, what five withdrawal rates did to a 60/40 portfolio from 2000 to 2025, and why the safe rate depends on when you retire.

On this page
  1. The idea
  2. How it works
  3. Using it
  4. Where it fails or misleads
  5. Compared with its neighbours
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding
  10. Exercise

A safe withdrawal rate is the share of a retirement portfolio that can be spent in the first year, and then raised with inflation every year after, without running out of money over a chosen period. The best-known figure is 4%: withdraw 4% of the starting balance in year one, keep the dollar amount growing with prices, and historically the money has lasted 30 years.

The number comes from back-testing, not theory. William Bengen published it in 1994 after running every 30-year retirement the US record allowed and finding the highest rate that survived the worst one. It is a statement about the past, built on the worst case, and it depends on the portfolio, the length of retirement and the willingness to keep spending fixed. This lesson shows where the figure comes from and how sensitive it is.

The idea

A portfolio in retirement is a race between two things: what it earns and what is taken out. If it earns more than is withdrawn, it grows. If it earns less, it shrinks, and each year's withdrawal becomes a larger share of what remains.

The simplest benchmark needs no market at all. Suppose a portfolio only keeps up with inflation, a real return of zero. Then it lasts exactly 1 ÷ rate years.

Withdrawal rate Years the money lasts at zero real return
3% 33.3
4% 25.0
5% 20.0
6% 16.7
7% 14.3

Anything a portfolio earns above inflation extends those figures. The difficulty is that the earning is uneven, and Sequence of returns risk: why the order of returns matters means a bad start can do more harm than a good finish can repair.

Retiring in January 2000: five withdrawal rates $0k $250k $500k $750k $1.00m $1.25m $1.50m 0 5 10 15 20 25 3% of the starting balance a year ($30,000) 4% of the starting balance a year ($40,000) 5% of the starting balance a year ($50,000) 6% of the starting balance a year ($60,000) 7% of the starting balance a year ($70,000) Years since retirement Balance, in January 2000 dollars 60% SPY / 40% Treasury bills, total return after inflation. No taxes or fees.
A $1,000,000 portfolio of 60% SPY and 40% Treasury bills from January 2000, with five fixed real withdrawal amounts. Monthly total returns after inflation; balances in January 2000 dollars.

The figure runs five rates through one of the hardest retirement dates in the modern record. One point of withdrawal rate was the difference between a portfolio that lasted and one that did not.

How it works

At 4% on $1,000,000 the first year's spending is $40,000. If prices rise 3%, the second year's is $41,200, whether the portfolio is then worth $1,200,000 or $700,000. The rate is never recalculated. That is what makes the rule simple and what makes it rigid.

A worked example: retiring in January 2000

The data: 60% SPY and 40% Treasury bills, rebalanced monthly, with total returns adjusted for inflation, January 2000 to December 2025. Over those 26 years the portfolio returned 3.2% a year after inflation with a volatility of 9.1%. Balances are in January 2000 dollars.

Withdrawal rate A year After 5 years 10 years 15 years 20 years 26 years Outcome
3% $30,000 $722,763 $547,549 $595,171 $599,545 $630,764 Lowest balance $451,399
4% $40,000 $671,179 $449,864 $393,120 $275,866 $91,749 Still paying, nearly spent
5% $50,000 $619,596 $352,179 $191,069 $0 $0 Empty after 19.2 years
6% $60,000 $568,012 $254,494 $0 $0 $0 Empty after 14.8 years
7% $70,000 $516,429 $156,809 $0 $0 $0 Empty after 12.4 years

Taxes and fees are not included; both would lower every figure.

The portfolio's 3.2% real return was positive, and still the 5% retiree ran out in February 2019. An average return of 3.2% suggests that withdrawals of around 5% should last far longer than 19 years. They did not, because the losses came first.

The 4% retiree is the instructive case. After 26 years the money has not run out, and it is about to: $91,749 supports two more years of spending. The 4% rule held for 26 years and looks unlikely to reach 30. The 3% retiree, by contrast, has recovered to $630,764 and the balance is rising.

The retirement date matters more than the rate

What was left after 15 years of taking 4%, by retirement year 0.98 94 1.14 95 0.92 96 0.76 97 0.59 98 0.48 99 0.39 00 0.49 01 0.63 02 1.00 03 0.77 04 0.86 05 0.97 06 0.93 07 0.80 08 1.51 09 1.47 10 1.48 11 Balance as a multiple of the start, after inflation. 60% SPY / 40% bills. Bars are retirement years 1994 to 2011.
Real balance after 15 years of withdrawing 4% of the starting balance, as a multiple of the start, for each retirement year from 1994 to 2011. 60% SPY / 40% Treasury bills.

The same test for every retirement year from 1994 to 2011, looking 15 years ahead in each case:

Retired in January Left after 15 years at 4% At 5% At 6% Portfolio's real return in its first 5 years
1995 $1,142,778 $983,647 $824,517 16.2% a year
1998 $588,151 $422,468 $256,784 −0.7%
2000 $393,120 $191,069 $0 −2.6%
2003 $1,004,959 $783,092 $561,225 5.5%
2008 $798,180 $587,349 $376,518 −0.2%
2009 $1,508,068 $1,278,034 $1,048,001 8.5%
2011 $1,476,500 $1,225,270 $974,040 5.9%

Of the 18 starting years, 13 left less than the starting balance after 15 years at 4%, and five left more. The best start was 2009 and the worst 2000. A person who retired in 2009 on 6% was better off after 15 years than a person who retired in 2000 on 3% was after 26.

The last column is the best single predictor in the table: the return in the first five years. That is sequence risk at work.

Using it

  • Treat 4% as a starting point for a 30-year retirement, not a promise. A 40-year retirement needs a lower rate; a 20-year one can bear a higher one.
  • Look at what the market offers at the time. Bengen's worst cases began when stock valuations were high or inflation was about to rise. Starting yields on bonds and the valuation of stocks at retirement have historically said something about which kind of start is likely. Equity risk premium (ERP): the extra return stocks earn for their risk discusses expected returns.
  • Build in flexibility. Guyton and Klinger showed that simple rules, such as skipping the inflation increase after a year of losses or cutting spending by 10% when the current withdrawal rate rises well above the starting one, allow a higher initial rate. The price is a variable income.
  • Recalculate. A retiree who is at 8% of the current balance after five years is in a different position from one at 3%, whatever the original rate was. The current rate (this year's withdrawal ÷ today's balance) is the gauge to watch.
  • Count other income first. The withdrawal rate applies to what the portfolio must supply after Social Security, pensions and annuities.
  • Remember taxes and fees. A 4% withdrawal from a tax-deferred account is less than 4% of spendable income, and a 1% annual fee comes out of the same return.

Where it fails or misleads

  • It is fitted to US history. Pfau found that the 4% rule would have failed in most other developed countries over the twentieth century. The US was among the best stock markets of that period.
  • This lesson's sample is short. The data here begin in 1994, so no complete 30-year retirement can be tested, and every period shown overlaps the others. Bengen's and the Trinity study's longer records reach back to 1926.
  • The portfolio here is not Bengen's. He used intermediate government bonds; this example uses Treasury bills because of the data available. Bonds earned more than bills over most of this period, so these results are somewhat harsher.
  • "Safe" means "did not fail in the sample". The future can produce a worse sequence than any in the record.
  • Success is also a kind of failure. In most historical periods a 4% withdrawal left a large unspent balance. A rule built for the worst case means underspending in the typical one.
  • Nobody spends like the rule. Real spending in retirement tends to fall with age in real terms and then rise late with health costs, and people cut back in bad markets.

Compared with its neighbours

Method How spending is set Income Risk of running out
Fixed real withdrawal (the 4% rule) Starting percentage, then inflation Stable Present, in bad sequences
Fixed percentage of current balance The same percentage of each year's balance Varies with markets None, though income can fall far
Guardrails Fixed real, adjusted when the rate drifts too far Mostly stable Lower
Required minimum distributions Balance ÷ remaining life expectancy Varies; rises with age None by construction
Annuity An insurer pays for life Guaranteed None; no balance left to heirs

How Finabase does it

Finabase has no retirement calculator and does not test withdrawal rates or project a portfolio's future balance.

The current withdrawal rate can be read from a portfolio page: planned annual spending divided by the portfolio's total market value. The Treasury page shows what bills, notes and bonds yield today, which is the return available on the safe part of a portfolio, and the Economy page shows the consumer price index, the measure by which a fixed real withdrawal is raised each year. For the historical record behind tests like the one above, a symbol's chart at the maximum range and its Dividends tab give price and distribution history.

Frequently asked questions

What is the 4% rule?

Withdraw 4% of the portfolio in the first year of retirement and raise that dollar amount with inflation each year. In US data back to 1926, a portfolio of roughly half stocks and half bonds lasted at least 30 years on that rule in every period tested.

Is 4% still safe?

Nobody can say for a future period. It has held in US history, has failed in other countries, and looked strained for people who retired at the 2000 peak. Many researchers suggest a starting rate somewhat below 4% for long retirements or when stock valuations are high.

Does the 4% apply to each year's balance?

No. It is 4% of the balance at retirement, converted to a dollar amount that then rises with inflation. Taking 4% of the current balance each year is a different rule, with a variable income.

What if I retire early?

A longer retirement needs a lower rate. For periods of 40 years or more, studies commonly find sustainable starting rates nearer 3% to 3.5%.

What happens if the market falls soon after I retire?

That is the dangerous case. The practical responses are to reduce withdrawals for a time, skip inflation increases, or draw on a cash reserve instead of selling stocks.

Summary

A safe withdrawal rate is the starting percentage that a portfolio has historically been able to pay, inflation-adjusted, for a given number of years. The 4% rule is the US worst-case figure for 30 years. For a 60/40 portfolio begun in January 2000, 3% was comfortable, 4% lasted 26 years with little left, and 5% ran out after 19. The retirement date mattered more than the rate: after 15 years at 4%, results ranged from $393,120 to $1,508,068 per $1,000,000. Use the rule as a first estimate, watch the current rate, and keep spending adjustable.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Under the 4% rule, a retiree starts with $800,000. Inflation in the first year is 3%. What is the second year’s withdrawal?

    1. $32,000
    2. $32,960
    3. 4% of whatever the balance is then
    Show the answer

    B. $32,960 First year: 4% × $800,000 = $32,000. The dollar amount then rises with inflation: $32,000 × 1.03 = $32,960, regardless of the balance.

  2. A portfolio earns exactly the rate of inflation. How long does it last at a 5% withdrawal rate?

    1. 20 years
    2. 25 years
    3. 50 years
    Show the answer

    A. 20 years With a zero real return the portfolio lasts 1 ÷ rate years: 1 ÷ 0.05 = 20.

  3. The 60/40 portfolio from 2000 earned 3.2% a year after inflation, yet a 5% withdrawal emptied it in 19 years. Why so soon?

    1. Because fees were charged
    2. Because the losses came in the first years, when the balance was largest
    3. Because inflation was unusually high throughout
    Show the answer

    B. Because the losses came in the first years, when the balance was largest Two bear markets in the first decade, combined with withdrawals, shrank the base before the good years arrived. The average return hides the order.

  4. Where does the 4% figure come from?

    1. A law setting the maximum retirement withdrawal
    2. The average return on stocks
    3. Back-tests finding the highest rate that survived the worst 30-year period in US data
    Show the answer

    C. Back-tests finding the highest rate that survived the worst 30-year period in US data Bengen tested every available 30-year retirement and took the rate that survived the worst. It describes the historical worst case and guarantees nothing.

  5. Five years into retirement, which number best shows whether a plan is under strain?

    1. The original withdrawal rate
    2. This year’s withdrawal divided by today’s balance
    3. The portfolio’s return last month
    Show the answer

    B. This year’s withdrawal divided by today’s balance The current rate reflects what has actually happened. A plan that began at 4% and now stands at 8% of the remaining balance needs attention.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open Portfolios. Signed out, the page shows an example portfolio with a Market value; sign in to use the Market value of your own. Choose a yearly spending figure for the exercise, for instance $10,000 against the example. Work out the current withdrawal rate: spending ÷ Market value. Then work out the lesson’s benchmark, 1 ÷ rate. How many years would the money last if the portfolio only kept up with inflation?

Open Portfolios
What you should find

On an example worth about $250,000, $10,000 a year is about 4%, and 1 ÷ 0.04 is 25 years at a zero real return. Doubling the spending doubles the rate and halves the years. The result is a gauge, not a verdict on any rate. In the lesson a 5% withdrawal from January 2000 ran out after 19.2 years although the portfolio’s real return was positive, because the losses came first.

Sources and further reading

  1. William P. Bengen, “Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data,” Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 7, no. 4 (1994)
  2. Philip L. Cooley, Carl M. Hubbard and Daniel T. Walz, “Retirement Savings: Choosing a Withdrawal Rate That Is Sustainable,” AAII Journal, vol. 20, no. 2 (1998) — the “Trinity study”
  3. Jonathan T. Guyton and William J. Klinger, “Decision Rules and Maximum Initial Withdrawal Rates,” Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 19, no. 3 (2006)
  4. Wade D. Pfau, “An International Perspective on Safe Withdrawal Rates: The Demise of the 4 Percent Rule?”, Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 23, no. 12 (2010)
  5. Finabase chart data — monthly bars and dividends of SPY, January 1994 to December 2025; 3-Month Treasury Bill rate (TB3MS) and CPI-U (CPIAUCSL) via FRED; simulations computed by Finabase