Measure and manage portfolio risk Lesson 10 of 14
Portfolio and risk · Managing a portfolio
Rebalancing methods: calendar, threshold and what each one costs
Four ways to rebalance a 60/40 portfolio tested from 2004 to 2026: never, yearly, monthly and by tolerance band, with returns, risk and number of trades.
On this page
Rebalancing means trading a portfolio back to its intended mix after markets have moved it away. The beginner lesson on Rebalancing a portfolio: calendar vs threshold, drift and taxes explains why: a portfolio left alone drifts towards whatever has risen most, and its risk drifts with it. This lesson is about how. The choices are when to trade (on a schedule, or when the mix has moved far enough), how far to trade back, and what the trading costs.
The surprising result, which the test below confirms, is that the method matters much less than the decision to have one. Reasonable rules produce nearly the same portfolio. What differs is how many trades they need, and what happens when no rule is followed at all.
The idea
A portfolio's weights change on their own. If stocks rise 20% in a year and bonds 2%, a 60/40 portfolio ends the year at about 64/36 without a single trade. Repeat that for a decade and the "balanced" portfolio is mostly stocks. Nothing was decided. The market made the allocation.
The figure tracks the stock share of one portfolio under three rules. The untouched portfolio wandered from 47% stocks, at the bottom of the 2009 bear market, to 89% by 2026. Its owner held a cautious portfolio at the moment stocks were cheapest and an aggressive one after a long rise. Both rebalanced versions kept returning to the 60% they were meant to hold, though the yearly one still sagged to 47% in early 2009, before its December trade.
How it works
There are three families of rule.
| Method | When it trades | Typical setting | Needs monitoring? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calendar | On fixed dates, whatever the weights are | Once a year; sometimes quarterly | No |
| Threshold (bands) | When a weight moves outside a tolerance band | 5 points either side of the target | Yes |
| Calendar plus bands | On fixed dates, and only if a weight is outside its band | Check yearly; trade if 5 points off | A little |
For a $100,000 portfolio that has drifted to $68,000 in stocks and $32,000 in bonds against a 60/40 target: 68,000 − 0.60 × 100,000 = $8,000. Sell $8,000 of stocks and buy $8,000 of bonds.
A worked example: four rules on one portfolio
The data: monthly total returns of SPY and AGG, January 2004 to October 2026 (274 months). Each portfolio starts at 60% SPY and 40% AGG. Over the period SPY returned 10.7% a year and AGG 3.0%.
| Rule | Return a year | Volatility | Deepest fall | Rebalances | Stock share, lowest to highest | $10,000 became |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Never rebalanced | 8.9% | 10.4% | −31.3% | 0 | 47% to 89% | $69,471 |
| Once a year, in December | 8.0% | 9.2% | −30.4% | 22 | 47% to 67% | $57,580 |
| When stocks leave 55%–65% (checked monthly) | 8.0% | 9.4% | −31.5% | 15 | 54% to 66% | $58,347 |
| Every month | 7.8% | 9.3% | −32.3% | 274 | 56% to 62% | $55,897 |
Returns are after fund expenses. Trading costs and taxes are not included, and they would weigh most on the rule that trades most.
The three rules that rebalance are the same portfolio. Returns within 0.2 points of one another, volatility within 0.2 points, and deepest falls within 2 points. Yearly rebalancing took 22 trades, the band rule 15, and monthly rebalancing 274. The extra 250 trades bought nothing.
Not rebalancing won on return, by taking more risk. The untouched portfolio ended with $69,471 against about $58,000. That is not a point in its favour as a method. It earned more because it held more stocks for most of the period, and stocks outran bonds by nearly eight points a year. An investor who wanted that return could have chosen an 80/20 portfolio at the start and known what they held.
The deepest falls look alike, and that is misleading. The untouched portfolio's worst fall, 31.3%, was no worse than the others. The reason is timing: when the 2007 to 2009 decline began, it had drifted only to 66% stocks. Today it holds 89%. Applying the 2007 to 2009 returns (SPY −50.8%, AGG +6.5%) to its current weights gives a loss of about 44%, against 28% for a portfolio at 60/40. The drift has not been tested yet at its present size.
Wider bands
A band of 10 points either side (rebalance only outside 50% to 70%) traded five times in 23 years and returned 8.2% a year with a volatility of 9.7% and a deepest fall of 32.0%. Wider bands let more drift through, which in this period meant slightly more stocks and slightly more return and risk. The cost of being imprecise was small.
Using it
Choosing a rule
- For simplicity: once a year, on a date that is easy to remember. This is the least effort and gets nearly all the benefit.
- For fewer, better-timed trades: bands. They trade after large moves, which is when rebalancing matters, and do nothing in quiet years. The band rule in the test traded in late 2008 and early 2009, buying stocks during the decline, and again in 2021 and 2024, selling them after strong runs.
- To limit taxes in a taxable account: check once a year and trade only if a band has been crossed. Rebalance inside tax-deferred accounts first, where selling has no tax consequence.
Rebalancing without selling
Selling a winner in a taxable account realizes a gain. Three ways to move the weights without doing so:
- Direct new money to the underweight asset. For someone still saving, contributions can keep a portfolio near its target for years.
- Take withdrawals from the overweight asset. The same idea in retirement.
- Have dividends and interest paid in cash and use the cash to buy what is underweight.
How far to trade back
Rebalancing all the way to the target is the standard. Some investors trade only back to the edge of the band, or halfway. That reduces turnover further and leaves the portfolio slightly tilted towards recent winners. The differences are small next to the difference between having a rule and not.
The "rebalancing bonus"
Rebalancing is sometimes said to add return by "buying low and selling high". It can, when assets take turns leading and end up with similar long-run returns: the rule harvests the swings. Perold and Sharpe showed in 1988 that this works in markets that move back and forth and fails in markets that trend. From 2004 to 2026 stocks trended, and rebalancing cost about 0.9 points a year against letting them run. Rebalancing should be adopted for risk control. Any return benefit is occasional.
Where it fails or misleads
- In a long one-way market it lowers returns. Each trade sells some of the asset that goes on rising. This is the price of keeping the risk constant.
- In a long decline it buys all the way down. Rebalancing into stocks through 2008 meant adding to a falling asset several times before it turned. That takes cash from the safe asset when it is most reassuring to hold, and it worked out only because the market recovered.
- Costs and taxes are left out of most tests, including this one. In a taxable account, frequent rebalancing can cost more than the drift it corrects.
- Too-narrow bands cause churn. A 1-point band on a volatile asset triggers constantly.
- It assumes the target is right. Rebalancing faithfully to an allocation that no longer fits its owner's circumstances is disciplined and wrong. The target should be revisited when life changes, not when markets do.
- Illiquid holdings cannot be rebalanced on demand. Property, private funds and some bonds cannot be trimmed by a few percent.
Compared with its neighbours
| Approach | Stock share over time | Behaviour in a falling market | Behaviour in a rising market |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy and hold (no rebalancing) | Drifts towards the winner | Stock share shrinks | Stock share grows |
| Constant mix (rebalancing) | Held near the target | Buys stocks | Sells stocks |
| Glide path | Target itself declines with age | Buys stocks, to a lower target | Sells stocks |
| Portfolio insurance | Cut as the portfolio falls | Sells stocks | Buys stocks |
Perold and Sharpe's point was that these are opposites. A rebalancer sells what a trend-follower buys. Neither is better in all markets.
How Finabase does it
Finabase does not rebalance a portfolio, suggest trades or store a target allocation.
A portfolio page provides what a manual rebalance needs. Each position's market value is listed with the portfolio's total, and the allocation bar shows the largest holdings and cash as shares of the whole. Dividing a position's value by the total gives its current weight; comparing that with the target gives the trade, as in the formula above. For a portfolio of several funds in the same asset class, add them together first, since the bar is by position and not by asset class.
Price alerts can stand in for a band. If a stock fund is at 60% of a portfolio and bonds are roughly stable, a rise of about 24% in the fund takes it to 65%. An alert set at that price is a reminder to check the weights. The paper-trading account can be used to rehearse a rebalance before placing real orders.
Frequently asked questions
How often should a portfolio be rebalanced?
Once a year, or when a holding is about 5 points away from its target, is enough for most portfolios. Tests over long periods find little difference in risk between monthly, quarterly and yearly rebalancing, and more frequent trading costs more.
Does rebalancing improve returns?
Not reliably. Over periods when one asset steadily outperforms, it lowers returns. Its purpose is to keep the portfolio's risk where it was set.
What is a tolerance band?
A range around the target weight. With a 60% target and a 5-point band, no trade is made while stocks are between 55% and 65% of the portfolio; outside it, the portfolio is traded back to 60%.
Should I rebalance during a market crash?
A rule says yes, and following it means buying what has fallen. That is uncomfortable and has historically been rewarded in broad stock markets, though not quickly or with any guarantee. Deciding the rule in advance is what makes it possible to follow.
Is rebalancing taxable?
Selling at a gain in a taxable account is. Rebalancing inside retirement accounts, or by directing new contributions, is not. See Capital gains tax on stocks: 2026 rates, holding periods and basis.
Summary
Rebalancing restores a portfolio to its intended mix. Tested on a 60/40 portfolio from 2004 to 2026, yearly, monthly and band-based rules gave almost identical returns and risk, with the band rule needing 15 trades and the monthly rule 274. The portfolio that was never rebalanced earned more, having drifted to 89% stocks, and now carries the risk of a much more aggressive allocation than its owner chose. Pick a simple rule, prefer the one with the fewest trades, use new money before selling, and treat the purpose as risk control.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A $200,000 portfolio has a 60/40 target and currently holds $134,000 in stocks. How much stock must be sold to restore the target?
- $14,000
- $7,000
- $34,000
Show the answer
A. $14,000 Target stock value = 0.60 × $200,000 = $120,000. Current value minus target = $134,000 − $120,000 = $14,000 to move from stocks to bonds.
In the 2004 to 2026 test, monthly rebalancing made 274 trades and a 5-point band made 15. How did their results compare?
- Monthly had much lower risk
- They were nearly identical in return and risk
- The band rule had much higher returns
Show the answer
B. They were nearly identical in return and risk Returns were 7.8% and 8.0% a year and volatility 9.3% and 9.4%. Frequent trading added cost and effort without changing the portfolio meaningfully.
The portfolio that was never rebalanced ended with the most money. Why is that not evidence against rebalancing?
- Because it drifted to 89% stocks, so it earned more by carrying far more risk than was chosen
- Because the calculation ignored dividends
- Because bonds outperformed stocks
Show the answer
A. Because it drifted to 89% stocks, so it earned more by carrying far more risk than was chosen It held an ever larger share of the higher-returning, riskier asset. The same return could have been sought deliberately with a more aggressive target; the drift made the choice unintentionally.
Which describes when rebalancing is most likely to add return, not only control risk?
- When one asset rises steadily for many years
- When assets swing back and forth and end with similar long-run returns
- When all assets fall together
Show the answer
B. When assets swing back and forth and end with similar long-run returns Selling what has risen and buying what has fallen pays when moves reverse. In a trending market the same trades sell the winner too early.
Which is a way to rebalance a taxable account without realizing gains?
- Selling the largest winner
- Directing new contributions to the underweight asset
- Switching to monthly rebalancing
Show the answer
B. Directing new contributions to the underweight asset New money, withdrawals and cash dividends can all shift the weights without a sale. Selling an appreciated holding triggers tax.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open Paper trading. Signed out, it shows a sample account of cash and three stocks; sign in to use your own. Read the Account value, then each row’s Value and Allocation in the Allocation table. For this exercise only, take an equal split as the target (25% each for four rows). Apply the lesson’s formula to the largest stock: its Value − 0.25 × Account value. Is the result a sale or a purchase, and is that stock more than 5 points away from 25%?
Open Paper tradingWhat you should find
A positive result is the amount to sell and a negative one the amount to buy. Done for every row, the amounts add up to zero. With a 5-point band only rows outside 20% to 30% trigger a trade, so a small gap means no trade at all, which is why the band rule needed so few trades in the lesson. The equal split is an arithmetic example, not a suggested allocation.
Sources and further reading
- André F. Perold and William F. Sharpe, “Dynamic Strategies for Asset Allocation,” Financial Analysts Journal, vol. 44, no. 1 (1988)
- Colleen M. Jaconetti, Francis M. Kinniry Jr. and Yan Zilbering, Best Practices for Portfolio Rebalancing (Vanguard Research, 2010)
- Gobind Daryanani, “Opportunistic Rebalancing: A New Paradigm for Wealth Managers,” Journal of Financial Planning, vol. 21, no. 1 (2008)
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Investor.gov — Beginners’ Guide to Asset Allocation, Diversification, and Rebalancing
- Finabase chart data — monthly bars and dividends of SPY and AGG, January 2004 to October 2026; simulations computed by Finabase
