Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Portfolio and risk · Measuring return and risk

Beta vs. standard deviation: market risk or total risk

How beta and standard deviation measure risk differently, why Berkshire Hathaway matched the S&P 500’s volatility with a beta of 0.35, and when to use each.

On this page
  1. The two measures side by side
  2. Twelve investments, both measures
  3. A quick way to read both together
  4. Which risk matters depends on what you own
  5. Which to use when
  6. How Finabase does it
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding

Standard deviation measures how much an investment's returns swing around their average, whatever the reason. Beta measures how much they swing with the market: a beta of 1.5 means the investment has tended to move 1.5% for each 1% move in the market. Standard deviation is total risk; beta is the part of risk that comes from the market.

They are easy to mix up because both rise for jumpy stocks, and very often they agree. But they can diverge sharply. Over the two years to November 17, 2026, Berkshire Hathaway's class B shares had almost exactly the same annualized volatility as the S&P 500 fund SPY, 16.9%, yet a beta of only 0.35. Exxon Mobil was half again as volatile as SPY, with a beta of 0.16. This page shows how the two are calculated, works them for twelve investments, and explains which one answers which question.

The two measures side by side

Standard deviation (volatility) Beta
What it measures Total variability of returns Sensitivity to the market’s moves
Reference point The investment’s own average A benchmark, usually the S&P 500
Units Percent per year (annualized) A ratio (market = 1.0)
Can it be negative? No Yes (moves against the market)
Includes company-specific news? Yes No
Use it for A single holding, a whole portfolio A holding’s effect on a diversified portfolio, CAPM
Full lesson Volatility and standard deviation: how investment risk is measured Portfolio beta: how much of the market a portfolio carries

The second form of beta is the key to the comparison: beta is standard deviation scaled by correlation. A stock with high volatility and a correlation near zero has a beta near zero. A stock with modest volatility that tracks the market closely has a beta near 1.

Twelve investments, both measures

All figures use daily price returns from November 18, 2024 to November 17, 2026 (500 trading days), with SPY as the market. Betas are measured on returns in excess of the 3-month Treasury bill rate.

Beta against volatility, daily returns 2024-11-18 to 2026-11-17 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% -0.5 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 SPY 16.9% Beta 1 Nvidia Tesla Microsoft Apple JPMorgan Berkshire B Exxon Coca-Cola P&G J&J Gold (GLD) Long Treasuries (TLT) SPY Beta to the S&P 500 (SPY) Annualized standard deviation
Beta to SPY against annualized standard deviation, daily returns 2024-11-18 to 2026-11-17. Source: Finabase chart data.
Investment Volatility Beta Correlation with SPY
S&P 500 (SPY) 16.9% 1.00 1.00
Tesla 56.3% 2.21 0.67
Nvidia 44.7% 1.83 0.69
Microsoft 29.5% 0.94 0.54
Apple 29.0% 1.04 0.61
JPMorgan Chase 23.6% 0.90 0.65
Berkshire Hathaway B 16.9% 0.35 0.35
Exxon Mobil 25.4% 0.16 0.11
Gold (GLD) 24.8% 0.28 0.19
Procter & Gamble 19.8% 0.10 0.09
Johnson & Johnson 20.3% 0.02 0.01
Long Treasuries (TLT) 11.3% 0.11 0.17

Three groups stand out. High beta, high volatility: Tesla and Nvidia swung far more than the market and moved with it, so both measures agree they are risky. Near-market stocks: Microsoft, Apple and JPMorgan had betas near 1 but volatility well above SPY's, because a single company carries news the index averages away. Low beta, real volatility: Exxon, gold, Procter & Gamble and Johnson & Johnson had volatilities of about 20% to 25% and betas near zero over these two years; their swings came from oil, interest rates, legal and company news, not from the stock market.

Those near-zero betas belong to this window. Over longer history, measured on monthly returns since 1999, the consumer staples fund XLP had a beta of 0.50 and the energy fund XLE 0.96, against 1.31 for the technology fund XLK. Beta is an estimate from one sample of history, and it moves.

A quick way to read both together

The two numbers combine into a third that is often more useful: the share of a stock's risk that comes from the market, which is the correlation squared (R²). For Nvidia, 0.69² = 48% of its daily variance moved with SPY; for Microsoft, 0.54² = 29%; for Exxon, 0.11² = 1%. A high R² means beta is a good summary of the stock's risk. A low R² means beta leaves most of the risk out, and the stock's own volatility is the number to watch.

The same arithmetic explains why beta is unstable for low-R² stocks. When only a few percent of the moves line up with the market, a handful of days can swing the estimate, which is how the two-year betas of Coca-Cola, Procter & Gamble and Johnson & Johnson came out near zero while their long-run sector beta is about 0.5. Before relying on a beta, check the correlation behind it.

Which risk matters depends on what you own

If a stock is all you own, its standard deviation is your risk. Exxon's 25.4% volatility would hit your account in full, whatever its beta.

If the stock is one of many, most of its company-specific swings cancel against the others' (the subject of Systematic vs. unsystematic risk: what diversification removes). What is left is the part that moves with the market, which beta measures. That is why the CAPM says investors are paid for beta, not for total volatility: diversification removes the rest for free.

For a whole portfolio, standard deviation is again the right single number, because it is what the account will actually do, and the portfolio's beta tells you how much of that comes from the market.

Which to use when

Question Use Why
How bumpy will this one holding be? Standard deviation Counts every source of movement
How will adding this stock change a diversified portfolio's market exposure? Beta Only the market-linked part survives diversification
How far might my whole portfolio fall in a normal bad year? Portfolio standard deviation What the account actually does
How much will my portfolio fall if the market falls 10%? Portfolio beta Sensitivity to the market
Required return under CAPM Beta The model prices market risk only
Comparing a bond fund or gold with stocks Standard deviation, then correlation Their betas are low for reasons other than safety

Neither measure covers everything. Both assume the past window is a fair guide, both treat up and down moves alike, and neither captures the size of rare crashes well. Maximum drawdown (MDD): the worst fall from a peak, and the way back and Fat tails: why extreme market moves are more common than models say cover those gaps.

How Finabase does it

Each symbol's overview lists the stock's market beta among its key statistics, for example Berkshire Hathaway B, and the Screener has a Beta column for filtering by it. The comparison tab draws a stock against SPY, which shows at a glance whether its swings line up with the market's. Volatility shows on the chart through Bollinger Bands, whose width is a multiple of the standard deviation. (The chart's BETA study is a short TA-Lib statistic on each bar's highs and lows, not market beta.) The Portfolio tools add up your holdings and show the portfolio's own return. The table on this page was computed by Finabase from two years of daily closes (price returns, no dividends), so it can differ from the beta on a symbol page, which may use a different window or monthly data.

Frequently asked questions

Is beta the same as volatility?

No. Volatility (standard deviation) measures all of a stock's movement; beta measures only the part that moves with the market. A stock can be very volatile and have a low beta, as Exxon did with 25.4% volatility and a beta of 0.16.

What is a good beta?

There is no good or bad beta, only a fit with the portfolio. A beta above 1 amplifies the market's moves in both directions; below 1 dampens them. Near zero means the stock's moves were mostly unrelated to the market in that window.

Why can a low-beta stock still lose a lot of money?

Because beta ignores company-specific risk. A low-beta stock can fall sharply on its own news, such as a lawsuit, a commodity price collapse or a failed product, without the market moving at all.

Which is better for measuring a portfolio's risk?

Standard deviation, because it measures what the portfolio actually does. Beta tells you how much of that comes from the market.

Summary

Standard deviation measures total risk; beta measures the share of risk that comes with the market, and equals correlation times relative volatility. Over the two years to November 17, 2026, Berkshire Hathaway B matched SPY's 16.9% volatility with a beta of 0.35, and Exxon showed 25.4% volatility with a beta of 0.16, while Tesla scored high on both. Use standard deviation for a single holding or a whole portfolio, beta for a holding's effect on a diversified portfolio and for CAPM, and remember that both are estimates from one window of the past.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A stock has a correlation of 0.5 with the market and twice the market’s standard deviation. What is its beta?

    1. 0.5
    2. 1.0
    3. 2.0
    Show the answer

    B. 1.0 Beta = correlation × (σ stock ÷ σ market) = 0.5 × 2 = 1.0. Half its volatility lines up with the market, and that half is as large as the market’s own moves.

  2. Exxon’s volatility was 25.4% while its beta was 0.16. What does that tell you?

    1. Exxon was less risky than the market
    2. Most of Exxon’s swings came from its own drivers, such as oil prices, not from the stock market
    3. The beta calculation must be wrong
    Show the answer

    B. Most of Exxon’s swings came from its own drivers, such as oil prices, not from the stock market A low beta with high volatility means the stock moves a lot but not in step with the market. Held alone, the full 25.4% volatility still applies.

  3. You hold one stock and nothing else. Which number best describes the risk to your account?

    1. Its standard deviation
    2. Its beta
    3. The market’s beta
    Show the answer

    A. Its standard deviation With no other holdings, nothing diversifies away the company-specific swings, so total volatility is the risk you bear.

  4. Why does the CAPM reward beta rather than total volatility?

    1. Because beta is easier to calculate
    2. Because volatility is always lower than beta
    3. Because company-specific risk can be diversified away at no cost, so only market risk needs a reward
    Show the answer

    C. Because company-specific risk can be diversified away at no cost, so only market risk needs a reward In a diversified portfolio the stock-specific parts largely cancel. What remains is the market-linked part, which beta measures.

Sources and further reading

  1. William F. Sharpe, “Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under Conditions of Risk”, Journal of Finance (1964)
  2. Finabase chart data — daily closes 2024-11-18 to 2026-11-17 (price returns, no dividends); monthly total returns of SPY, XLP, XLE and XLK since 1999
  3. Federal Reserve Board — H.15 Selected Interest Rates, 3-month Treasury bill (FRED series TB3MS)