Funds · Specialised funds
Commodity ETFs: gold trusts, futures pools and their tax forms
The three legal forms of commodity ETF, what each holds and how each is taxed, with USO and UNG against oil and gas prices since launch and GLD against gold.
On this page
A commodity ETF lets an investor hold gold, oil, natural gas or a basket of raw materials through a brokerage account. The share trades like any other ETF. What stands behind it does not resemble a stock fund at all, and it comes in three different legal forms. One kind is a trust that owns metal in a vault. One is a partnership that owns futures contracts. One is an ordinary registered fund that reaches futures through an offshore subsidiary.
The form decides two things that matter more here than in any other corner of the fund market. It decides whether the share follows the commodity's price, which a vault of gold does and a rolling futures position often does not. And it decides the tax treatment, which ranges from a special 28% rate to a yearly partnership form to the ordinary fund rules.
The reason a futures fund drifts from the spot price, the roll, is explained in Contango, backwardation and roll yield: why USO lags oil. This lesson covers the structures, the tax consequences and the record of the largest funds against the commodities they are named for.
The idea
A share of stock can be held forever at no cost. A barrel of oil cannot. It has to be stored, insured and eventually delivered, and so does a bushel of wheat or a tank of natural gas. Only precious metals are compact and durable enough for a fund to simply buy and lock away. Everything else is held through futures contracts, which are agreements to buy at a set price on a future date and which expire. That practical difference produces the three structures.
None of the three is a conventional stock ETF, and two of them are not registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, the law that governs mutual funds and most ETFs (How a fund is organized: board, adviser, custodian and the 1940 Act). A fourth route, the exchange-traded note, is a bank's promise to pay a commodity index's return and holds nothing; it is covered in ETNs vs ETFs: an unsecured note is not a fund.
How it works
Trusts that hold metal
GLD, the SPDR Gold Trust, began on November 18, 2004. It holds gold bars in a custodian's vault, and each share is a fractional interest in that gold. Its expense ratio is 0.40%. IAU, which began in January 2005, does the same for a sponsor fee of 0.25%, and SLV holds silver.
There is nothing to roll and nothing to manage, so the share follows the metal.
| Fund against gold futures | Fund's price change | Gold's change | Gap per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| GLD, Dec 2004 – Oct 2026 | +712% (10.1% a year) | +791% (10.5%) | −0.5 points |
| IAU, Feb 2005 – Oct 2026 | +736% (10.3% a year) | 10.6% a year | −0.3 points |
The gaps are close to the fees. A gold trust is about as simple as a fund can be, and its whole cost is on the label. That is not the same as low risk: GLD fell 42.9% between August 2011 and December 2015, and SLV fell 72.2% between April 2011 and March 2020.
For US tax purposes these trusts are grantor trusts. The holder is treated as owning the metal directly. The trust itself pays no tax and distributes nothing, and the holder is taxed mainly on selling. (The small amounts of gold the trust sells to pay its fee count as sales by the holder too, so they produce small gains or losses each year.) The catch is the rate: the IRS classes gold and silver bullion as collectibles, and long-term gains on collectibles are taxed at a maximum of 28%, not the 15% or 20% that applies to most long-term gains. The SPDR Gold Trust's filings state that this applies to gains on its shares.
Partnerships that hold futures
USO, the United States Oil Fund, is a limited partnership and a commodity pool regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission. It began in April 2006. It holds crude oil futures and keeps the cash that backs them in Treasury bills. Its sister fund UNG does the same with natural gas.
A futures contract expires, so the fund must keep selling the contract that is about to expire and buying a later one. When later contracts cost more than nearer ones, a condition called Contango, each roll sells low and buys high, and the fund loses value even if the spot price never moves. When later contracts are cheaper, the roll adds value. Oil and gas have spent long stretches in contango because storage is expensive. The linked lesson works through the arithmetic.
The tax treatment follows from the partnership form. Holders receive a Schedule K-1 each year, not a Form 1099, and are taxed on their share of the fund's gains whether or not they sold anything. Futures are "section 1256 contracts", marked to market at each year-end and reported on Form 6781, with gains treated as 60% long-term and 40% short-term however long the position was held.
Registered funds with an offshore subsidiary
A fund registered under the 1940 Act cannot earn more than a small part of its income directly from commodity futures and keep its tax status. The workaround is a wholly owned subsidiary in the Cayman Islands. The fund puts up to 25% of its assets into the subsidiary, the subsidiary holds the futures, and the rest sits in Treasuries. PDBC, Invesco's diversified commodity fund, is built this way and says so in its name: the "No K-1" means, in its prospectus's words, that it reports income on Form 1099 like most other ETFs.
The price of that convenience is that the subsidiary's gains come up to the fund as ordinary income and are paid out in a yearly distribution, which can be large after a strong year for commodities. The holder does not get the 60/40 treatment. The roll cost is the same as in a partnership; only the paperwork differs.
Using it: the record against the commodity
The two charts compare each futures fund's share price with the front-month futures price of its commodity, the number usually quoted as "the oil price" or "the gas price".
| Fund against its commodity | Fund's price | Front-month futures price | Gap per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| USO, May 2006 – Oct 2026 | −68.8% (−5.6% a year) | +46.1% (+1.9% a year) | −7.4 points |
| USO, May 2020 – Oct 2026 | +552% (33.9% a year) | +193% (18.3% a year) | +15.7 points |
| UNG, May 2007 – Oct 2026 | −99.9% (−28.8% a year) | −63.4% (−5.0% a year) | −23.7 points |
| GLD, Dec 2004 – Oct 2026 | +712% (10.1% a year) | +791% (10.5% a year) | −0.5 points |
Three observations.
The long-run gap is the roll. An investor who bought USO in 2006 because oil would be worth more in twenty years was right about oil and lost two-thirds of the money. The fund's fee explains a small part of 7.4 points a year. The rest is the cost of replacing expiring contracts with dearer ones, month after month.
The gap can run the other way. From May 2020 to October 2026 USO gained far more than the front-month price. For much of that time later contracts were cheaper than near ones, so each roll added value, and the front-month price itself began the period at a depressed level. A futures fund is a different asset from the commodity, sometimes better and over this history mostly worse.
Natural gas is the extreme case. UNG has lost 28.8% a year for nineteen years. Its split-adjusted starting price is $6,622.72 and its price at the end of October 2026 was $9.08.
April 2020 and the reverse splits
In early 2020 oil demand collapsed. USO's month-end price went from $102.48 in December 2019 to $33.68 in March and $19.12 in April, in today's share terms. The front-month contract ended January at $51.56 and April at $18.84, having briefly traded below zero on April 20 as holders with no storage paid to be rid of expiring contracts. On April 28, 2020 USO carried out a 1-for-8 Reverse stock split. By the end of 2020 the futures price was back to $48.52, within 6% of where it had been in January. USO ended the year at $33.01, down 62% from January's $86.72. The fund had replaced its contracts near the lowest prices of the episode, and the loss did not come back with the oil price.
Reverse splits are the visible trace of roll losses. Finabase's split records show four for UNG (1-for-2 in 2011, then 1-for-4 in 2012, 2018 and 2024), so one share today represents 128 of the originals. A long-term chart, adjusted for those splits, shows a starting price in the thousands.
Where it fails or misleads
The name says oil; the holding is a schedule of contracts. No fund can deliver the spot price of a commodity that has to be stored. Charts of "oil" and of an oil fund answer different questions.
Tax surprises. The 28% collectibles rate catches gold fund holders who expected 15%. The K-1 arrives late in tax season, can complicate a simple return and taxes gains the holder never realized. The no-K-1 fund's December distribution is ordinary income. None of this matters inside an IRA or 401(k), where the differences between the structures disappear except for the roll. US rules as of 2026.
Diversified baskets still roll. PDBC's price was 6% lower in October 2026 than in January 2015, before distributions. DBC, an older basket fund, gained 1.7% a year on price from 2006. Spreading across commodities reduces the damage from any one curve without removing the cost.
Commodity producers are not commodities. A fund of oil companies or gold miners is a stock fund, with ordinary stock-fund structure and tax, and its returns depend on profits and management as well as on the commodity.
Spot bitcoin funds
On January 10, 2024 the SEC approved the listing of a group of spot bitcoin exchange-traded products, and its chair noted that the approval was not an endorsement of bitcoin. They copy the gold trusts' design: a trust that holds the asset itself with a custodian, issues shares against it and charges a sponsor fee (0.25% for the iShares Bitcoin Trust, IBIT, whose inception date is January 5, 2024; it began trading on January 11). IBIT's own description says it is not an investment company under the 1940 Act and not a commodity pool. Because the fund holds bitcoin and not futures, there is no roll, and the share follows the price less the fee. The glossary entry Spot bitcoin ETF has the details.
Compared with its neighbours
| Structure | Examples | Follows the spot price | Yearly tax event | US tax form |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Metal trust | GLD, IAU, SLV | Yes, less the fee | Mainly on sale (up to 28% long-term) | 1099 |
| Futures partnership | USO, UNG | No: roll gains and losses | Yes, marked to market, 60/40 | Schedule K-1 |
| 1940-Act fund with subsidiary | PDBC | No: roll gains and losses | Yes, distribution as ordinary income | 1099 |
| Exchange-traded note | Various | Follows an index, less fees | Generally on sale | 1099 |
| Spot bitcoin trust | IBIT | Yes, less the fee | No (tax on sale) | 1099 |
| Commodity producers' stock fund | XLE, GDX | No: company profits | Ordinary fund rules | 1099 |
How Finabase does it
Each commodity fund has a symbol page with a quote, chart and news. The chart is adjusted for splits, which is why UNG's early history shows prices in the thousands. The Dividends & splits tab lists every split and distribution, including USO's 1-for-8 reverse split in April 2020. The comparison tab rebases funds to percent change from the first bar in view and tabulates price returns from one week to two years, excluding dividends, which is enough to see two gold trusts differ by their fees.
Finabase does not show which futures contracts a fund holds, does not calculate roll cost and does not publish tax character or indicate which funds issue a Schedule K-1. The issuer's prospectus states the structure.
Frequently asked questions
Why did USO fall when oil went up?
USO holds futures, not oil. Each month it sells expiring contracts and buys later ones, and when later ones cost more the fund loses a little. From May 2006 to October 2026 that cost turned a 46% rise in the front-month price into a 69% fall in the share price.
How are gold ETFs taxed in the US?
Trusts that hold bullion, such as GLD and IAU, are treated as if the holder owned the gold. Long-term gains are taxed as collectibles at a maximum of 28%, higher than the usual long-term rates. Short-term gains are ordinary income.
Which commodity ETFs send a K-1?
Funds organized as limited partnerships that hold futures, such as USO and UNG. Their gains are taxed each year at a 60% long-term, 40% short-term blend whether or not shares were sold. Funds with "No K-1" in the name use a registered-fund structure and report on Form 1099.
Is a gold ETF the same as owning gold?
Economically it is close: the share follows the gold price less a fee of 0.25% to 0.40% a year for the funds named here. Legally the holder owns shares of a trust, not specific bars, and ordinary investors cannot exchange shares for metal.
Do reverse splits in UNG or USO cost holders money?
No. A reverse split combines shares without changing the value held. It is a sign of the losses that came before it: UNG has needed four.
Summary
The label "commodity ETF" covers three structures. A metal trust holds bars, follows the price less its fee, and leaves the holder with a 28% long-term rate. A futures partnership holds contracts that must be rolled, sends a K-1 and is taxed every year at a 60/40 blend. A registered fund with a Cayman subsidiary rolls the same contracts and reports on a 1099 with ordinary-income distributions. The roll, not the fee or the tax, has decided the long-run result: GLD stayed within half a point a year of gold for twenty-two years, while USO lost 69% during a 46% rise in oil and UNG lost nearly everything. Spot bitcoin funds have followed the gold trusts' model, not the futures one.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
From May 2006 to October 2026 the front-month crude oil price rose 46% and USO’s share price fell 69%. What accounts for most of the difference?
- USO’s expense ratio
- The cost of rolling expiring futures into dearer later contracts
- Reverse splits
Show the answer
B. The cost of rolling expiring futures into dearer later contracts A futures fund must keep replacing contracts. When later contracts cost more than near ones (contango), each roll loses value. The gap was 7.4 points a year, far more than any fee. Reverse splits change the share count, not the value.
A US investor sells shares of a gold bullion trust after three years at a gain. What is the maximum federal rate on that gain?
- 15%
- 20%
- 28%
Show the answer
C. 28% A grantor trust’s holder is treated as owning the gold, and the IRS taxes long-term gains on collectibles, including bullion, at a maximum of 28%.
An investor holds a futures-based oil fund organized as a limited partnership all year without selling. What happens at tax time?
- Nothing, because nothing was sold
- A Schedule K-1 reports their share of the fund’s gains, taxed 60% long-term and 40% short-term
- A Form 1099 reports a collectibles gain
Show the answer
B. A Schedule K-1 reports their share of the fund’s gains, taxed 60% long-term and 40% short-term Partners are taxed on the partnership’s income each year. Futures are section 1256 contracts, marked to market at year-end with the 60/40 split regardless of holding period.
What does “No K-1” in a commodity fund’s name tell an investor?
- The fund holds physical commodities
- The fund avoids roll costs
- It is a registered fund holding futures through a subsidiary and reports on Form 1099
Show the answer
C. It is a registered fund holding futures through a subsidiary and reports on Form 1099 The fund places up to 25% of its assets in an offshore subsidiary that holds the futures. The roll cost is unchanged. Gains come out as yearly distributions taxed as ordinary income.
Why can a gold trust follow its commodity closely when an oil fund cannot?
- Gold is compact and durable enough to store, so the trust holds the metal itself and has nothing to roll
- Gold futures never trade in contango
- Gold trusts are actively managed
Show the answer
A. Gold is compact and durable enough to store, so the trust holds the metal itself and has nothing to roll A vault of bars is the commodity. Oil and gas are too costly to store, so funds hold expiring futures and bear the roll. GLD trailed gold by about 0.5 points a year, close to its 0.40% fee.
Sources and further reading
- United States Commodity Funds — United States Oil Fund, LP (USO) fund pages: partnership and commodity-pool status, Schedule K-1, the 1-for-8 reverse split of April 28, 2020, read November 18, 2026
- iShares — iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF (IBIT) fund page: inception date, sponsor fee, not a 1940 Act investment company or commodity pool, read November 18, 2026
- State Street / World Gold Council — SPDR Gold Shares (GLD) fund page and SPDR Gold Trust annual report (Form 10-K): expense ratio, grantor trust status, taxation of gold as a collectible
- Internal Revenue Service — Topic No. 409, Capital Gains and Losses (28% maximum rate on collectibles), updated November 9, 2026
- Internal Revenue Service — About Form 6781, Gains and Losses From Section 1256 Contracts and Straddles
- Invesco — Optimum Yield Diversified Commodity Strategy No K-1 ETF (PDBC) prospectus: Form 1099 reporting and the Cayman Islands subsidiary limited to 25% of total assets
- U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — Chair Gary Gensler, “Statement on the Approval of Spot Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Products,” January 10, 2024
- Finabase chart data — month-end prices of USO, UNG, GLD, IAU, SLV, PDBC and DBC and of front-month crude oil, natural gas and gold futures through October 2026, with split records; price only, statistics computed by Finabase
