Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Funds · Indexes and index funds

International index funds: country classification, taxes and pricing

Why MSCI and FTSE funds hold different countries, what South Korea’s status did to two emerging-market funds, how foreign dividend tax is credited, and fair-value NAVs.

On this page
  1. Developed and emerging: who decides
  2. The funds side by side
  3. Foreign tax on dividends
  4. Currency, briefly
  5. Fair-value pricing
  6. Where this misleads
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

A US investor who wants stocks from the rest of the world can buy them in one fund. The decisions inside that fund are less obvious than they are for a US index fund. Somebody has to decide which countries count as developed and which as emerging, and the two largest index providers disagree about some of them. Foreign governments tax the dividends before the fund receives them. And the fund has to put a price on Japanese and German shares at four in the afternoon in New York, when Tokyo closed fourteen hours earlier.

This lesson covers those three things: how countries are classified and what that does to a fund's holdings, how foreign dividend tax reaches an investor's tax return, and how funds price shares in closed markets. Currency is a fourth, with its own lesson (Currency risk in a portfolio: how exchange rates change returns). The numbers come from eight funds: EFA, IEFA and VEA for developed markets, EEM, IEMG and VWO for emerging markets, VXUS for both, and the single-country Korea fund EWY.

Developed and emerging: who decides

There is no official list. Each index provider classifies countries by its own published framework and reviews the list every year.

MSCI uses three criteria: economic development, the size and liquidity of the stock market, and market accessibility for foreign investors. The economic test applies only to developed status and requires national income per person to be 25% above the World Bank's high-income threshold for three consecutive years. Accessibility covers things like whether foreigners can own shares freely, move money in and out, and trade the currency.

FTSE Russell sorts countries into four groups: Developed, Advanced Emerging, Secondary Emerging and Frontier.

They agree on most countries. The United States, Japan, the United Kingdom, Germany and France are developed everywhere. China and India are emerging everywhere. The disagreements are few and matter a great deal, because one of them is a large market.

Country MSCI FTSE Russell
South Korea Emerging Developed
Greece Emerging; moves to developed at the May 2027 index review Developed since September 21, 2026
Taiwan Emerging Advanced Emerging
China, India Emerging Secondary Emerging
Vietnam Not emerging Secondary Emerging since September 21, 2026

The Korea question

South Korea is the important case. FTSE classes it as Developed. MSCI keeps it in emerging markets, and in its June 2026 review again did not put Korea on the list for possible reclassification, citing among other things that the won cannot be traded freely outside Korea.

So the answer to "is Samsung in an emerging-market fund?" is: it depends on whose index the fund follows.

South Korea’s weight in seven international index funds, 2026 EEM, emerging (MSCI) 17.8% IEMG, emerging (MSCI) 17.3% VWO, emerging (FTSE) none EFA, developed (MSCI) none IEFA, developed (MSCI) none VEA, developed (FTSE) 9.2% VXUS, all ex US (FTSE) 6.7% iShares funds: holdings of November 16, 2026. Vanguard funds: September 30, 2026. Source: the issuers.
South Korea as a share of each fund. iShares funds at November 16, 2026; Vanguard funds at September 30, 2026.

On November 16, 2026 Korea was 17.78% of EEM and 17.30% of IEMG, both on MSCI emerging indexes. It was not in VWO, the Vanguard emerging-market fund on a FTSE index, whose largest countries on September 30, 2026 were Taiwan (35.1%), China (26.0%), India (16.0%) and Brazil (4.5%). On the developed side the reverse holds: Korea was 9.2% of VEA, on a FTSE developed index, and absent from EFA and IEFA, on MSCI's.

A second difference sits in the names. EFA follows the MSCI EAFE index, which stands for Europe, Australasia and the Far East, and so leaves out Canada. VEA's FTSE index includes Canada, at 10.8% of the fund.

What it did to returns

When Korea leads, the fund that holds it leads: EEM against VWO, 2014 to 2025 −6 −3 0 +3 +6 +9 −30 −15 0 +15 +30 +45 +60 +75 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Korea fund (EWY) return minus EEM return in the year, percentage points EEM return minus VWO return, percentage points Calendar-year total returns. EEM follows MSCI (Korea is emerging); VWO follows FTSE (Korea is developed).
Each point is a calendar year. When Korea beat the rest of emerging markets, the fund that holds Korea beat the fund that does not.

For each year from 2014 to 2025 the chart sets the gap between EEM and VWO against how far Korea ran ahead of or behind EEM. The two move together: the correlation is 0.85, and the gap had the same sign as Korea's lead in 10 of the 12 years.

Year EWY (Korea) EEM (MSCI) VWO (FTSE) EEM − VWO
2017 +44.9% +37.2% +31.5% +5.7
2021 −7.6% −3.6% +1.3% −4.9
2024 −20.4% +6.5% +10.6% −4.1
2025 +95.0% +33.9% +25.5% +8.4

Over the 12 years the difference nearly cancelled: EEM returned 4.50% a year and VWO 5.27%, with a monthly correlation of 0.990. Korea is not the only difference between the two indexes. VWO's includes smaller companies and Chinese shares listed on the mainland, and it charges 0.06% against EEM's 0.72%. But in any single year the classification of one country was the largest thing separating two funds with the same label.

The same holds among developed funds. VEA beat EFA by 3.6 points in 2025, the year Korea soared and VEA held it.

Mixing providers

An investor who buys a developed fund and an emerging fund separately should check that both follow the same provider.

Developed fund Emerging fund Korea
IEFA or EFA (MSCI) IEMG or EEM (MSCI) Held once, in the emerging fund
VEA (FTSE) VWO (FTSE) Held once, in the developed fund
IEFA or EFA (MSCI) VWO (FTSE) Not held at all
VEA (FTSE) IEMG or EEM (MSCI) Held twice

A single all-in-one fund avoids the question. VXUS, which holds developed and emerging markets together on a FTSE index, had 8,901 stocks on September 30, 2026, with Japan at 16.1%, Taiwan 9.3%, the United Kingdom 8.1%, Canada 7.9%, China 6.9% and Korea 6.7%.

Reclassification is an index change

When a country is promoted or demoted, every fund on that provider's indexes trades it on the same dates. Greece moved to Developed at FTSE on September 21, 2026 and will move at MSCI in May 2027. Emerging-market funds sell and developed-market funds buy, with the same advance notice and the same crowding described in Index reconstitution and rebalancing: calendars, buffers and the cost.

The funds side by side

Fund Index provider and scope Stocks Expense ratio 10-year return
EFA MSCI developed, large and mid-sized, no Canada 658 0.32% 8.99% (Sep. 30, 2026)
IEFA MSCI developed, all sizes, no Canada 2,627 0.07% 9.09% (Sep. 30, 2026)
VEA FTSE developed, all sizes, with Canada and Korea 3,903 0.03% 9.76% (Sep. 30, 2026)
EEM MSCI emerging, large and mid-sized 1,195 0.72% 8.40% (Sep. 30, 2026)
IEMG MSCI emerging, all sizes 2,826 0.09% 8.97% (Sep. 30, 2026)
VWO FTSE emerging, all sizes, with China A shares 6,507 0.06% 7.66% (Sep. 30, 2026)
VXUS FTSE developed and emerging 8,901 0.05% 9.20% (Sep. 30, 2026)

Returns are average annual returns at net asset value to September 30, 2026, from each issuer's fund page. For a sense of scale: from March 2011 to October 2026 SPY returned 13.70% a year, EFA 6.50%, VXUS 6.25% and EEM 3.97%, with monthly correlations to SPY of 0.83, 0.83 and 0.69. Whether that long US lead continues is not something past data can answer.

Foreign tax on dividends

Most countries tax dividends paid to foreign shareholders by withholding part of the payment. A US fund holding French or Japanese shares receives its dividends with that tax already taken, at a rate set by the country's law and its tax treaty with the United States. This is a real cost: it reduces the fund's income before the investor sees it.

Getting it back

US tax law offers a remedy. Under section 853 of the Internal Revenue Code a fund with more than 50% of its assets in foreign securities at the end of its tax year may pass the foreign taxes it paid through to its shareholders. Each shareholder is then treated as having paid their share and can claim the foreign tax credit, a reduction of US tax owed. The amount is reported in Box 7 of Form 1099-DIV.

The rules below are the IRS's for tax year 2025, as stated in Topic no. 856 and the instructions for Form 1116. They change, so check the current year's.

  • The credit can be claimed directly on the tax return, without filing Form 1116, if all of your foreign income is passive (dividends and interest), all of it is reported on a statement such as Form 1099-DIV, and your total foreign taxes are no more than $300, or $600 on a joint return.
  • Above those amounts Form 1116 is required. It limits the credit to the US tax attributable to your foreign income.
  • Using the simplified election means no carryover of unused credit to other years.
  • A holding period applies: the fund shares must be held for at least 16 days within the 31-day period that begins 15 days before the ex-dividend date.

An illustration with invented figures: $20,000 in an international fund that yields 3% pays $600 of dividends in a year. If 10% was withheld abroad, Box 7 shows $60. The investor reports $660 of dividend income, the $600 received plus the $60 paid on their behalf, and takes $60 off their US tax.

Two limits are worth knowing. The credit only exists where there is US tax to reduce: in a tax-deferred retirement account the foreign tax is still withheld and nothing is credited. And a fund of funds holds foreign stock only indirectly, so it cannot pass the 50% test itself; the law lets it pass the credit through anyway if at least half its assets are in other funds at the end of each quarter (section 852(g)).

Withholding also explains an oddity in fund reports. International funds are measured against "net" indexes that deduct an assumed foreign tax. iShares notes in its fact sheets that these indexes assume the maximum rate applying to non-residents, often higher than the rate the fund pays, so a fund can beat its net index without doing anything clever (Tracking difference in index funds: why a fund trails its index).

Currency, briefly

The funds in this lesson do not hedge currency. A US holder's return is the return of the foreign shares in their own currencies plus the change in those currencies against the dollar. A falling dollar adds to the return of an international fund and a rising dollar subtracts from it, and over a few years the currency can outweigh the stocks. How large that effect has been, and what hedged funds do about it, is in Currency risk in a portfolio: how exchange rates change returns.

Fair-value pricing

A US fund calculates its net asset value at 4 p.m. New York time (Net asset value (NAV): how a fund’s share price is calculated). At that moment the Tokyo market has been closed for about fourteen hours and European markets for more than four. Their last closing prices are stale: US markets have moved since, and when Tokyo reopens it will move to catch up.

If the fund valued its shares at those stale closes, a trader could buy the fund on a day when US stocks had surged, knowing its foreign holdings would be marked up the next morning. To prevent that, funds adjust foreign closing prices to an estimate of what the shares would be worth at 4 p.m., using moves in US markets, futures and currencies. This is fair-value pricing, done under the fund board's valuation procedures.

It has two visible effects.

The fund and its index disagree day to day. The index uses local closing prices; the fund uses adjusted ones. On a volatile day the two can differ by a percent or more, and the difference reverses when the foreign market opens. A period that happens to end on such a day shows a large tracking difference that means nothing. Over the year to September 30, 2026, EFA trailed its index by 0.98 points and VEA by 0.84, while over five years they were within 0.03. iShares publishes a second, unadjusted NAV for its international funds for exactly this comparison.

An ETF's price is a live estimate. The market price of an international ETF during US trading hours reflects what traders think the closed markets are worth now. That makes its premium or discount to NAV look larger and more variable than a US stock fund's (Premiums and discounts in ETFs: why price and NAV disagree). Much of it is the ETF price being more current than the NAV, not less accurate.

Where this misleads

"Emerging" and "developed" are index labels, not economic facts. Korea is a wealthy industrial economy that one provider calls emerging for reasons of market access. Taiwan, the largest country in both major emerging indexes, is similar.

A fund's country weights are the result of market values, not a plan. Taiwan was 35.1% of VWO and 27.28% of EEM in mid-2026 because its largest companies had grown, not because anyone chose a third in Taiwan. Country concentration in international index funds can be as high as company concentration in US ones.

Past gaps between providers do not repeat on schedule. Korea helped MSCI emerging funds in 2025 and hurt them in 2024. Over twelve years the two approaches ended close together.

The stock count is not the diversification. VXUS holds 8,901 stocks, and its monthly returns from 2011 to 2026 had a correlation of 0.83 with SPY's. International funds fall with US stocks in global sell-offs.

Tax rules are dated. The $300 and $600 thresholds and the form instructions quoted here are for tax year 2025. This lesson is general information, not tax advice.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not build indexes, classify countries or publish index membership changes. It shows the funds themselves. Every fund has a symbol page with its quote, chart, news and a Dividends & splits tab listing each distribution, and the Holders tab can show a fund card with issuer, expense ratio, assets, net asset value, holdings and sector weights when the data feed carries them.

The comparison tab shows the classification effect directly. Open EEM and add VWO and EWY: the tab rebases each to percent change from the first bar in view and tabulates price returns from one week to two years, excluding dividends. In periods when the Korea fund pulls away from the others, EEM follows it part of the way and VWO does not. /portfolio tracks fund holdings and the dividends they pay; foreign tax amounts come from your broker's Form 1099-DIV, not from Finabase.

Frequently asked questions

Is South Korea a developed or an emerging market?

Both, depending on the index provider. FTSE Russell classes it as Developed and MSCI as Emerging, as of their 2026 reviews. A fund holds Korean stocks or not according to which provider's index it follows and whether it is a developed or emerging fund.

Should my developed and emerging funds come from the same provider?

If they are meant to cover the world between them, matching providers avoids leaving a country out or holding it twice. An MSCI developed fund with a FTSE emerging fund has no Korea; the opposite pairing has it in both.

Do I get the foreign tax credit in an IRA?

No. The credit reduces US tax on the income, and income inside a tax-deferred account is not taxed in the year it is earned. The foreign tax is still withheld before the dividend reaches the fund.

Why does my international ETF move when foreign markets are closed?

Its market price reflects traders' current estimate of what the underlying shares are worth, based on US markets, futures and currencies. The foreign markets will open at prices that reflect the same news.

Does a total international fund include the United States?

Funds described as "international" or "ex US" hold no US stocks. Funds described as "global" or "world" usually include them. The fund's fact sheet lists its largest countries.

Summary

An international index fund inherits three sets of decisions. Its index provider decides which countries are developed and which emerging, and because MSCI and FTSE disagree about South Korea, emerging-market funds on the two differed by 8.4 points in 2025 and developed-market funds by several points too. Foreign governments withhold tax on its dividends, which a US investor in a taxable account can usually reclaim as a credit, up to $300 without Form 1116 for tax year 2025. And the fund values closed markets at adjusted prices, which makes short-period comparisons with its index unreliable. Checking the provider, the largest countries and the fund's account type covers most of what the label leaves out.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. An investor holds a developed-markets fund on an MSCI index and an emerging-markets fund on a FTSE index. How much South Korea do they hold?

    1. None: MSCI puts Korea in emerging markets and FTSE puts it in developed markets
    2. Korea is in both funds
    3. Korea is in the emerging-markets fund only
    Show the answer

    A. None: MSCI puts Korea in emerging markets and FTSE puts it in developed markets MSCI’s developed index excludes Korea because MSCI classes it as emerging, and FTSE’s emerging index excludes it because FTSE classes it as developed. The pairing misses the country entirely.

  2. In 2025 a Korea fund returned far more than emerging markets as a whole. Which emerging-market index fund would you expect to have done better?

    1. The one on a FTSE index
    2. The one on an MSCI index, which holds Korean stocks
    3. Neither: both hold the same countries
    Show the answer

    B. The one on an MSCI index, which holds Korean stocks MSCI emerging indexes include Korea and FTSE’s do not. In 2025 EEM returned 33.9% and VWO 25.5%.

  3. Your Form 1099-DIV for tax year 2025 shows $180 of foreign tax paid in Box 7, all from index funds, and you file a single return. What is the simplest treatment?

    1. Nothing can be claimed below $300
    2. You must file Form 1116
    3. You can claim the $180 as a foreign tax credit directly, without Form 1116
    Show the answer

    C. You can claim the $180 as a foreign tax credit directly, without Form 1116 The IRS allows the credit without Form 1116 when all foreign income is passive, it is reported on a payee statement, and total foreign taxes are $300 or less ($600 on a joint return).

  4. Why does an international fund adjust the closing prices of foreign shares when it calculates its NAV?

    1. To convert them into dollars
    2. Because the foreign markets closed hours earlier and those prices are stale by 4 p.m. New York time
    3. To match its index more closely
    Show the answer

    B. Because the foreign markets closed hours earlier and those prices are stale by 4 p.m. New York time Fair-value pricing estimates what the shares are worth when the NAV is struck, so that nobody can trade the fund against prices everyone knows are out of date. It makes the fund differ from its index on the day, not match it.

  5. An international index fund trails its net index by 0.9 points over one year and by 0.02 a year over five. What is the sensible reading?

    1. The one-year figure reflects pricing on the start and end dates and should be ignored
    2. The fund’s costs have risen
    3. The index provider made an error
    Show the answer

    A. The one-year figure reflects pricing on the start and end dates and should be ignored The fund’s NAV uses fair-value prices and the index uses local closes. The mismatch on two particular days can be a percent or more, which dominates one year and fades over five.

Sources and further reading

  1. MSCI — “MSCI Announces the Results of the MSCI 2026 Market Classification Review,” press release, June 23, 2026
  2. MSCI — Market Classification Framework (June 2026): economic development, size and liquidity, market accessibility
  3. FTSE Russell — FTSE Equity Country Classification, September 2026 Annual Announcement (published October 6, 2026)
  4. IRS — Topic no. 856, Foreign tax credit (updated October 26, 2026) and Instructions for Form 1116 (tax year 2025)
  5. Internal Revenue Code §853 — foreign tax credit allowed to shareholders of a regulated investment company (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
  6. Internal Revenue Code §852(g) — election by a qualified fund of funds (Cornell Legal Information Institute)
  7. Vanguard — fact sheets of VEA, VWO and VXUS, September 30, 2026: benchmarks, country weights, number of stocks, expense ratios
  8. iShares — product pages of EEM, IEMG, EFA, IEFA and EWY (holdings of November 16, 2026; average annual returns to September 30, 2026) and fact sheets of EFA, IEFA (September 30, 2026) and EEM (June 30, 2026)
  9. Finabase chart data — monthly bars and dividends of EFA, VEA, IEFA, EEM, VWO, VXUS, EWY and SPY through October 2026; statistics computed by Finabase