Funds · ETFs in depth
SPY vs. VOO: the same S&P 500 in two different wrappers
Why SPY and VOO hold the same 500 stocks yet differ in structure, fees, trading and options, and how much VOO gained over SPY from 2010 to 2026: about 0.07 points a year.
On this page
SPY and VOO are the two best-known S&P 500 ETFs. Both hold the same 500 companies in the same weights, both trade all day on an exchange, and their returns move almost in lockstep. A newcomer could buy either and get, very nearly, the S&P 500.
The differences are in the wrapper. SPY, launched in 1993, is a unit investment trust with rules written before modern ETFs existed. VOO, launched in 2010, is a share class of an ordinary Vanguard index mutual fund. That structure decides the fees, what the fund may do with its cash, and who uses each one. This lesson compares the two and measures what the differences added up to over 16 years.
Two structures for one index
SPY, the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, was the first US-listed ETF. It is organized as a unit investment trust under the Investment Company Act of 1940. A UIT follows a fixed trust agreement: SPY must hold the index's stocks, may not lend them out to earn fees, and may not reinvest the dividends it receives. It holds that cash until it pays it out each quarter. The trust also has an end date: it terminates on January 22, 2118, or earlier under conditions in the trust agreement. Because it is a UIT, SPY is outside the SEC's 2019 ETF rule (Rule 6c-11), which applies to open-end funds.
VOO, the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, is one share class of Vanguard 500 Index Fund, an open-end management company. The same fund has mutual fund share classes, such as Admiral Shares (VFIAX). As an open-end fund it may lend securities and keep the income, reinvest dividends between payment dates, and use index futures to stay fully invested. How a fund is organized: board, adviser, custodian and the 1940 Act explains the legal forms.
SPY and VOO compared
| Feature | SPY | VOO |
|---|---|---|
| Launched | January 1993 | September 2010 |
| Legal form | Unit investment trust | Share class of an open-end index fund |
| Expense ratio | 0.0945% | 0.03% |
| Dividends between payouts | Held as cash | Can be reinvested |
| Securities lending | Not allowed | Allowed; income stays in the fund |
| Average daily trading, 2 years | About $43 billion | About $4.9 billion |
| Price, Nov. 17, 2026 | $732.44 | $672.97 |
Worked example: 16 years side by side
The test starts at the end of October 2010, VOO's first full month, and runs to the end of October 2026: 192 months. Both funds are measured on month-end prices with every distribution reinvested in the month it was paid. Fund fees are already inside the prices. The vendor's record repeats one VOO dividend in March 2019; the repeat is removed.
| Measure | VOO | SPY |
|---|---|---|
| $10,000 became | $85,356 | $84,429 |
| Total return | 753.6% | 744.3% |
| Return per year | 14.34% | 14.26% |
| Deepest fall from a peak | −23.9% (2021–22) | −23.9% (2021–22) |
Over 16 years VOO finished $927 ahead on $10,000, or 1.10% more in total, about 0.068 points a year. The expense ratios differ by 0.0645 points, so the fee explains almost all of the gap. The small remainder fits what the structures predict: SPY's dividend cash sits idle for up to three months, which costs a little in rising markets, while VOO keeps its securities-lending income.
The gap is steady rather than lumpy. VOO was ahead in 13 of the 15 full calendar years from 2011 to 2025, usually by 5 to 13 basis points (hundredths of a percentage point). It trailed by half a basis point in 2012 and by 1.4 in 2022. In a 2022-style fall, idle dividend cash slightly helps SPY, since cash does not fall. The figure shows the gap growing almost in a straight line, which is what a fee difference looks like over time.
What the gap means in dollars
On $100,000 held for 16 years, a 0.068-point yearly difference at these returns came to about $9,300 at the end, since the $927 gap on $10,000 scales with the amount. That is real money, though small next to the $750,000 of growth both funds delivered. For an investor who holds for decades, the cheaper fund wins by the same steady margin; for someone who holds for a week, the fee is irrelevant and the trading cost dominates.
Why traders still use SPY
SPY's assets and trading volume grew for 17 years before VOO existed, and liquidity attracts more liquidity. Over the two years to November 17, 2026, SPY traded about 65.5 million shares a day, about $43 billion, against 8.0 million shares, about $4.9 billion, for VOO. Both trade at a spread of about a cent, so for an ordinary order the difference is negligible. It matters for very large trades, and above all for options: SPY's option market is the deepest of any ETF, with expirations every trading day, which is why hedgers, market makers and option traders use it. VOO also has listed options, far less traded. ETF liquidity and bid-ask spreads: volume is not the whole story covers what drives an ETF's trading costs.
What the structure changes for a holder
Most of the time, nothing visible. Both funds publish their holdings daily, both trade close to the value of those holdings, and both pay dividends quarterly. Three differences can show up:
- Distribution amounts differ slightly. Because SPY pays out exactly the dividends it collected, minus expenses, while VOO also earns lending income and can time its payments, the two funds' quarterly payouts per dollar invested are close but never identical.
- Cash drag in rising markets. Between payment dates SPY holds collected dividends as cash. With a yield near 1.3%, that is on average a few tenths of a percent of the fund out of the market, which costs a little when stocks rise and saves a little when they fall.
- Rules frozen in a trust agreement. A UIT cannot change its investment practices without changing the trust itself, which is why SPY still works the way it did in 1993. VOO's fund board can change its practices, such as how much it lends, within the limits of its prospectus.
Which to use when
How each is typically used, not a recommendation:
- Long-term holding favours the cheaper fund. VOO at 0.03%, or IVV at the same fee, keeps about 0.065 points a year more than SPY.
- Frequent trading, large blocks or options favour SPY, whose volume and option market are the largest.
- A taxable account sees almost no difference: both rarely pay capital gains distributions, thanks to in-kind redemptions (ETF tax efficiency: in-kind redemptions, heartbeat trades and limits).
- Switching from one to the other in a taxable account sells the first, which can realize a gain; the fee saving may take years to repay the tax.
- Other S&P 500 funds exist with fees from 0.02% to 0.03% (How to choose an index fund: a seven-step checklist).
Pitfalls
- Comparing share prices. SPY's higher price says nothing about value. Each share is a different slice of the same portfolio; VOO's price was about 0.92 of SPY's.
- Comparing price charts. Both pay dividends quarterly; a price-only chart leaves out about 1.3 to 2 points a year. Use total return.
- Expecting a big difference. The two funds' monthly returns are almost identical. Fees, not holdings, separate them.
How Finabase does it
The comparison tab draws VOO, SPY and IVV from the same start date. Each fund's Dividends tab lists its quarterly payments, and SPY's Options tab shows the depth of its option chain. The figures in this lesson come from frozen copies of Finabase's month-end prices, distributions and daily bars, computed in the lesson's figure script.
Frequently asked questions
Is VOO better than SPY?
For holding over years, VOO costs less: 0.03% against 0.0945% a year, and from 2010 to 2026 it returned about 0.07 points a year more. For active trading and options, SPY's far larger volume and option market are worth more than the fee gap.
Why is SPY more expensive?
Its unit investment trust structure and its sponsor's fee date from 1993. The trust cannot lend securities or reinvest dividends to offset costs, and its fee has not been cut to the level of the newest funds.
Do SPY and VOO hold the same stocks?
Yes. Both track the S&P 500 and hold its companies at index weights. Their monthly returns differ only by hundredths of a percentage point.
Can SPY really terminate?
Its trust agreement sets a termination date of January 22, 2118, or earlier in defined cases. In practice a successor arrangement would be expected well before then, but the date is in the prospectus.
Summary
SPY and VOO hold the same S&P 500 stocks. SPY is a 1993 unit investment trust at 0.0945% a year that holds dividend cash idle and cannot lend its shares; VOO is a share class of a Vanguard index fund at 0.03% that can do both. Over 16 years to October 2026 the difference added up to about 0.07 points a year in VOO's favour, almost exactly the fee gap, and VOO led in 13 of 15 full years. SPY's advantage is its trading volume and option market, nine times VOO's dollar volume. Long-term holders tend to pick the cheaper wrapper; traders tend to pick the deeper market.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
SPY and VOO hold the same S&P 500 stocks. What explains most of VOO’s lead of about 0.07 points a year from 2010 to 2026?
- VOO holds better stocks
- The difference in expense ratios: 0.0945% for SPY against 0.03% for VOO
- VOO’s lower share price
Show the answer
B. The difference in expense ratios: 0.0945% for SPY against 0.03% for VOO The fee gap is 0.0645 points a year, close to the measured 0.068. A small remainder fits the structures: SPY holds dividend cash idle and cannot lend securities.
Which feature of SPY comes from its unit investment trust structure?
- It cannot reinvest dividends between payment dates or lend its securities
- It can hold stocks outside the S&P 500
- It trades only once a day
Show the answer
A. It cannot reinvest dividends between payment dates or lend its securities A UIT follows a fixed trust agreement. SPY holds collected dividends as cash until the quarterly payout and may not lend shares. It also has a termination date in 2118.
Why do many option traders and large institutions use SPY despite its higher fee?
- Because SPY pays higher dividends
- Because its trading volume and option market are far larger, which lowers the cost of big trades and hedges
- Because VOO cannot be sold short
Show the answer
B. Because its trading volume and option market are far larger, which lowers the cost of big trades and hedges Over two years SPY traded about $43 billion a day against $4.9 billion for VOO, and its option market is the deepest of any ETF. For someone holding for years, the fee matters more.
VOO traded at $672.97 and SPY at $732.44 on November 17, 2026. What does that tell you?
- VOO is cheaper and so a better value
- Nothing about value: each share is a different-sized slice of the same index portfolio
- SPY has outperformed VOO
Show the answer
B. Nothing about value: each share is a different-sized slice of the same index portfolio Share prices depend on each fund’s starting price and share count. Returns, fees and trading costs are what differ, not the price of one share.
Sources and further reading
- State Street Global Advisors — SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY): prospectus, gross expense ratio 0.0945%, unit investment trust structure and termination date
- Vanguard — S&P 500 ETF (VOO), an ETF share class of Vanguard 500 Index Fund, expense ratio 0.03%
- Vanguard — S&P 500 ETF summary prospectus (April 28, 2026): an exchange-traded share class of Vanguard 500 Index Fund, total annual operating expenses 0.03%
- SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust — prospectus on SEC EDGAR: the trust terminates on January 22, 2118, or 20 years after the death of the last of eleven persons named in the trust agreement, if earlier
- SEC — Investment Company Act of 1940, section 4: classification of investment companies (unit investment trusts and management companies)
- 17 CFR 270.6c-11 — the ETF rule (2019), which covers ETFs organized as open-end funds, not unit investment trusts
- Finabase chart data — SPY and VOO month-end closes and distributions, October 2010 to October 2026, and daily bars for two years to November 17, 2026; results computed by Finabase
