Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investing basics · How markets work

NYSE vs. Nasdaq: two listing markets, one national market system

How the NYSE and Nasdaq differ in history, trading model, auctions and listing rules, why it matters little to a buyer, and what their composite indexes show.

On this page
  1. Two histories
  2. What the listing exchange still decides
  3. NYSE and Nasdaq compared
  4. Worked example: the two composite indexes, 1985 to 2026
  5. Which to use when
  6. Pitfalls
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are the two places where almost every large US company lists its shares. They are rivals with very different histories: one began under a tree on Wall Street in 1792 and still runs a trading floor, the other started in 1971 as a computer network for dealers and has never had a floor. Between them they list Apple and JPMorgan, Microsoft and Exxon Mobil, Nvidia and Visa.

For someone buying a share, the difference is smaller than it looks. US rules link every exchange, so a stock listed on the NYSE trades on Nasdaq's systems too, and the other way round. Where the two really differ is in how they run their opening and closing auctions, what they require of listed companies, and which companies have chosen each. This lesson covers those differences and what the two exchanges' composite indexes show.

Two histories

The NYSE traces itself to the Buttonwood Agreement of 1792. For two centuries trading meant people on a floor, with a "specialist" in each stock who kept order and traded from his own account. Today the NYSE is owned by Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) and most trading is electronic, but each listed stock still has a designated market maker (DMM), a firm with obligations to keep the market orderly and to run the opening and closing auctions, some of them from the floor at 11 Wall Street. ICE also owns NYSE Arca, where most US ETFs list, and NYSE American, for smaller companies.

Nasdaq began in 1971 as the National Association of Securities Dealers Automated Quotations, a screen that showed dealers' quotes for over-the-counter stocks. It added trading, grew into the home of technology listings (Apple, Microsoft, Intel and later Amazon and Google), and was approved by the SEC as a national securities exchange in 2006. Several competing market makers quote each stock, with no single firm in charge of it, and its auctions, the Opening Cross and Closing Cross, are run entirely by computer.

What the listing exchange still decides

Since Regulation NMS in 2005, US exchanges have been linked: a broker must not trade through a better price shown on another exchange, and any exchange can trade any listed stock. Most retail orders are in fact filled off-exchange by wholesalers (Stock exchanges explained: NYSE, Nasdaq and where your order goes explains the routing). So the listing exchange no longer means "where the stock trades". It still decides four things:

  1. The official open and close. The listing exchange's auctions set the opening and closing prices that index funds, mutual funds and most charts use. Closing auctions often handle a large share of a stock's daily volume.
  2. Listing standards. Each exchange sets minimums for share price, market value, number of holders and governance. Nasdaq has three tiers (Global Select, Global Market, Capital Market); the NYSE has its main board and NYSE American.
  3. Continued listing. Both police a $1.00 minimum. On Nasdaq a bid below $1.00 for 30 consecutive business days triggers a notice and, usually, 180 days to fix it. On the NYSE an average closing price below $1.00 over 30 trading days starts a six-month cure period. Falling short can end in Delisting: why stocks leave an exchange and what holders keep.
  4. Trading halts for news in a listed stock, which other venues follow.

NYSE and Nasdaq compared

Feature New York Stock Exchange Nasdaq
Founded 1792 1971 (exchange since 2006)
Owner Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) Nasdaq, Inc.
Trading model DMM per stock, floor plus electronic Fully electronic, competing makers
Auctions Opening and closing auctions run by DMM Opening and Closing Cross
Listing tiers NYSE, NYSE American; ETFs on NYSE Arca Global Select, Global, Capital Market
Leaning of listings Banks, energy, industrials, consumer Technology, biotech, growth companies
Composite index NYSE Composite (^NYA) Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC)

Companies can and do move. Honeywell moved its listing from the NYSE to Nasdaq in 2021, and Walmart moved its listing to Nasdaq in December 2025; others have moved the other way. A move changes the auction and the listing fees, not the shares' owners or where they can be bought.

Worked example: the two composite indexes, 1985 to 2026

Each exchange publishes a composite index of the common stocks listed on it. Because the listings differ, so do the indexes. The figure uses quarterly closes of both price indexes (dividends not included) from early 1985, the start of the frozen data, to the last finished quarter.

Nasdaq Composite and NYSE Composite, growth of $1 (log scale), quarterly, 1985–2026 $1 $2 $5 $10 $20 $50 $100 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 Nasdaq Composite (^IXIC) NYSE Composite (^NYA) Nasdaq peak before the 2000–02 fall Price indexes, dividends not included. Quarterly closes: Nasdaq to Oct 2026, NYSE to Aug 2026.
Nasdaq Composite and NYSE Composite, growth of $1 on a log scale, quarterly closes from early 1985 (Nasdaq to October 2026, NYSE to August 2026), price only.
Measure (quarterly closes) Nasdaq Composite NYSE Composite
Level, early 1985 278.7 (Jan. 1985) 1,109.5 (Feb. 1985)
Level, 2026 25,437 (Oct. 2026) 24,462 (Aug. 2026)
Growth 91.3 times, 11.4% a year 22.0 times, 7.7% a year
Deepest fall −66.5%, Jan. 2000–Jan. 2003 −53.7%, May 2007–Feb. 2009
Back above the old peak January 2014 November 2013
From early 2000 to 2026 7.2% a year 5.3% a year

Quarterly closes smooth the extremes. On a daily basis the Nasdaq Composite closed at a record 5,048.62 on March 10, 2000 and at 1,114.11 on October 9, 2002, a fall of 78%. The NYSE Composite, heavy in banks and industrial companies, barely fell in 2000 and 2001; its worst fall came with the 2008 financial crisis.

None of this says one exchange is better. It says the two have attracted different companies. A technology boom lifts the Nasdaq Composite; a banking crisis hits the NYSE's. Index funds that investors actually buy, such as S&P 500 funds, hold companies from both exchanges, and the S&P 500 does not care where a company lists.

Which to use when

For investors, the listing exchange is mostly information, not a choice:

  • Buying a stock works the same way whichever exchange lists it. The broker routes the order; the price is protected across exchanges.
  • Using the closing price for a limit or market-on-close order means joining the listing exchange's closing auction, which has its own order cut-off times.
  • Reading an index means knowing what it holds. The Nasdaq Composite is a technology-heavy index of everything listed on Nasdaq; its 100 largest non-financial members form the Nasdaq-100 (Stock market indexes: S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq and Russell explained).
  • Judging a company by its exchange is a mistake. Both list giants and small speculative firms; the listing tier and the company's own filings say far more.

Pitfalls

  • "Nasdaq stocks are riskier." Nasdaq lists more young growth companies, so its composite is more volatile, but Microsoft and Costco are Nasdaq-listed too.
  • Confusing the exchange with its index. "The Nasdaq fell 2%" usually means the Nasdaq Composite, not the exchange company.
  • Mixing price and total return. Both composites leave dividends out, which understates the NYSE's, as its companies pay more.

How Finabase does it

Finabase shows both composites as symbols: ^IXIC and ^NYA can be compared from any start date, and the indices page lists the major US indexes. The screener can limit a screen to NYSE-listed or Nasdaq-listed stocks. The numbers in this lesson come from frozen copies of Finabase's quarterly index closes.

Frequently asked questions

Which is bigger, the NYSE or Nasdaq?

It depends on the measure. Nasdaq lists more companies, including several of the world's most valuable technology firms. By market value both list tens of trillions of dollars of stock, and which is larger moves with the prices of a handful of their biggest companies.

Can I buy an NYSE stock on Nasdaq?

Yes. Under unlisted trading privileges and Regulation NMS, exchange-listed stocks trade on every US exchange and off-exchange. A broker fills the order at the best available price wherever it is.

Why do companies switch exchanges?

Usually for cost, marketing or the way the auctions are run. Honeywell moved to Nasdaq in 2021, and Walmart moved to Nasdaq in December 2025.

Why did the Nasdaq Composite fall so much more in 2000 to 2002?

Because it was concentrated in the internet and technology companies whose prices had risen most in the late 1990s. On daily closes it fell 78% from March 2000 to October 2002; the NYSE Composite, with more banks and industrial companies, fell far less.

Summary

The NYSE and Nasdaq are the two great US listing markets: one a 1792 institution with a floor and a designated market maker for each stock, the other a fully electronic market that grew up with the technology industry. Since Regulation NMS, a stock trades wherever the best price is, so for a buyer the listing exchange matters mainly for its opening and closing auctions and its listing standards. Their composite indexes differ because their companies differ: from 1985 to 2026 the Nasdaq Composite grew about 91-fold with a 66.5% fall along the way, and the NYSE Composite about 22-fold, more steadily.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. You place a market order for an NYSE-listed stock. Where can it be filled?

    1. Only on the New York Stock Exchange
    2. On any US exchange or off-exchange, at the best available price under Regulation NMS
    3. Only on the NYSE floor during the closing auction
    Show the answer

    B. On any US exchange or off-exchange, at the best available price under Regulation NMS US exchanges are linked, and listed stocks trade on every exchange and with wholesalers. Most retail orders are filled off-exchange. The listing exchange runs the official auctions and sets listing rules.

  2. What does a stock’s listing exchange still control?

    1. Which brokers may sell the stock
    2. The official opening and closing auctions, listing standards and delisting
    3. The company’s dividend
    Show the answer

    B. The official opening and closing auctions, listing standards and delisting The listing exchange’s auctions set the official open and close, and its standards decide who may list and when a company is warned or delisted, for example for a price below $1.00.

  3. From 1985 to 2026 the Nasdaq Composite rose about 91-fold and the NYSE Composite about 22-fold. What best explains the gap?

    1. Nasdaq’s electronic trading makes its stocks rise faster
    2. The two indexes hold different companies: Nasdaq’s lean to technology, which led this period, while the NYSE’s lean to banks, energy and industrials
    3. The NYSE Composite includes dividends and the Nasdaq Composite does not
    Show the answer

    B. The two indexes hold different companies: Nasdaq’s lean to technology, which led this period, while the NYSE’s lean to banks, energy and industrials An exchange’s composite reflects whatever companies list there. Both are price indexes. The same concentration explains the Nasdaq Composite’s 78% daily-close fall from March 2000 to October 2002.

  4. Which describes the NYSE’s trading model?

    1. Fully electronic with no single firm responsible for a stock
    2. A designated market maker for each stock, a floor and electronic trading together
    3. Trading only by telephone between dealers
    Show the answer

    B. A designated market maker for each stock, a floor and electronic trading together Each NYSE stock has a designated market maker with obligations to keep the market orderly and run its auctions. Nasdaq has always been electronic, with competing market makers.

Sources and further reading

  1. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission — National Securities Exchanges (registered exchanges list)
  2. SEC — Regulation NMS (2005): order protection and access across exchanges
  3. SEC — Order approving Nasdaq’s registration as a national securities exchange (Release 34-53128, January 13, 2006; 71 FR 3550)
  4. Nasdaq Listing Center — listing requirements and continued listing standards (Rule 5550(a)(2), bid price)
  5. NYSE — Listed Company Manual, Section 802.01C (price criteria)
  6. Walmart Inc. — Walmart to transfer stock exchange listing to Nasdaq (November 20, 2025; trading on Nasdaq from December 9, 2025)
  7. Honeywell — Honeywell announces transfer of stock exchange listing to Nasdaq (April 30, 2021)
  8. Finabase chart data — ^IXIC and ^NYA quarterly closes, 1985 to 2026; results computed by Finabase