Investing basics · Brokers and automated investing
Robo-advisors: how automated portfolios are built, run and priced
How robo-advisors pick a portfolio, rebalance and harvest losses, what they charge in advisory and fund fees, and what 0.30% versus 1.10% a year costs over 30 years.
On this page
A robo-advisor is an investment adviser that manages your money through software instead of a person. You answer an online questionnaire about your goals, time horizon and tolerance for losses; an algorithm assigns a portfolio, usually a handful of low-cost index ETFs; and from then on the program deposits new money, rebalances, and, in taxable accounts, may sell losing positions to harvest tax losses. You pay an annual fee, normally a percentage of the account.
The automation is new; the legal role is not. A robo-advisor is a registered investment adviser, owes its clients the same fiduciary duty as a human adviser, and must file the same disclosure document, Form ADV. This lesson explains how robo portfolios are built and run, what they cost when the advisory fee and the funds' own fees are added together, how that cost compounds over 30 years, and what two SEC cases show about where the risks sit. It does not recommend any service.
How a robo portfolio is built
The questionnaire. Questions cover age, income, goal, time horizon and reactions to losses. The answers are scored and mapped to a risk level. A higher score means a higher share of stocks. The Asset allocation: how stock, bond and cash mixes have behaved and Time horizon and risk tolerance: matching investments to goals lessons explain the ideas the questionnaire stands in for.
The model portfolio. Each risk level has a pre-set mix of asset classes: US stocks, international stocks, bonds and sometimes real estate or inflation-protected bonds. Each slot is filled with one or two index ETFs. Firms describe their methods in their brochures; many start from modern portfolio theory, which looks for the highest expected return for a given level of volatility, and then add their own limits and judgment.
Ongoing management. The software then:
- invests new deposits in whatever is most underweight;
- rebalances when holdings drift from targets, by a threshold or on a schedule, using new cash or sales (see Rebalancing a portfolio: calendar vs threshold, drift and taxes);
- reinvests dividends, often with fractional shares so no cash sits idle;
- in taxable accounts, may run tax-loss harvesting: sell a fund that has fallen below its cost to realize the loss, and buy a similar but not identical fund so the portfolio keeps its exposure. The wash-sale rule in IRS Publication 550 disallows a loss if a substantially identical security is bought within 30 days before or after the sale; the Tax-loss harvesting: how it works, the wash-sale rule and its limits lesson covers what that means.
Some services add a human layer: phone or video access to advisers, sometimes for a higher fee or above an account minimum.
What it costs
A robo account carries two layers of cost:
- The advisory fee, charged by the robo firm as a percentage of assets per year, usually deducted monthly or quarterly. Some firms charge a flat monthly subscription instead.
- Fund expense ratios, charged inside each ETF the portfolio holds and taken out of the funds' returns (see Expense ratios and fund costs: what you pay and how it compounds).
A third, less visible cost appears in programs that advertise no advisory fee: the portfolio holds a cash allocation, swept to a bank that earns more on it than it pays. The Cash sweep programs: where idle brokerage cash goes and what it earns lesson explains that spread.
What a fee does over 30 years
Take $100,000 that grows 6% a year before costs, for 30 years. Compare three all-in costs: none; 0.30% (for example a 0.25% advisory fee plus 0.05% of fund expenses); and 1.10% (a 1.00% fee plus 0.10%).
| All-in yearly cost | After 10 years | After 20 years | After 30 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| None | $179,085 | $320,714 | $574,349 |
| 0.30% | $173,784 | $302,009 | $524,845 |
| 1.10% | $160,333 | $257,065 | $412,159 |
The 0.30% account ends $49,505 (8.6%) below the no-cost path; the 1.10% account ends $162,190 (28.2%) below it. A fee that looks like one percent turns into more than a quarter of the final balance, because each year's fee also removes the growth that money would have earned. These numbers are illustrative; real returns vary from year to year, and an advisory service may be worth its fee to someone who would otherwise not invest, not rebalance, or sell in a panic.
The legal role: an investment adviser
A robo firm is an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. That has three consequences.
Fiduciary duty. The SEC's 2019 interpretation of the adviser standard (Release IA-5248, June 5, 2019) applies to automated advisers too: a duty of care, to give advice in the client's best interest based on a reasonable understanding of the client, and a duty of loyalty, to disclose and address conflicts. The SEC staff's February 2017 guidance update on robo-advisers added points specific to software: explain how the algorithm works and its limits, make sure the questionnaire gathers enough information, and have compliance programs that test the code.
Registration. Most robo-advisors register with the SEC under the internet adviser exemption, which lets an adviser that serves clients through an interactive website register federally regardless of size. The SEC tightened that rule in March 2024: since the March 31, 2025 compliance date, an adviser relying on it must give advice to all of its clients through an operational interactive website.
Disclosure. Every registered adviser files Form ADV. Part 2A, the brochure, describes fees, methods, conflicts and disciplinary history in plain English, and the client relationship summary, Form CRS, condenses it. Both are free on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site.
Two dated cases
Undisclosed cash, 2022. On June 13, 2022, three Schwab adviser subsidiaries agreed to pay $187 million to settle SEC charges about Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, from March 2015 to November 2018. The service charged no advisory fee and held part of each portfolio in cash. The SEC found the cash level was presented as the product of a disciplined method, while Schwab's own data showed that under most market conditions it would make clients less money; the cash was swept to Schwab's bank, which earned the spread. The firm neither admitted nor denied the findings.
Harvesting that didn't harvest, 2023. On April 18, 2023, Betterment agreed to a $9 million penalty. The SEC found that from 2016 to 2019 it did not disclose a software change that reduced how often accounts were scanned for losses, and that two coding errors stopped harvesting for some clients. About 25,000 accounts lost roughly $4 million in potential tax benefits.
Both cases make the same point: the algorithm is only as good as the code and the disclosures around it, and the brochure is where those choices are written down.
Robo, human adviser or do-it-yourself
| Approach | What you get | Typical cost structure |
|---|---|---|
| Do it yourself | Full control, no advice | Fund fees only |
| Robo-advisor | Automated portfolio management | Small % fee + fund fees |
| Hybrid robo | Automation plus human access | Higher % fee or minimum |
| Human adviser | Planning, judgment, behavior | % of assets, flat or hourly fee |
The Financial advisors and fiduciary duty: who must act in your interest lesson compares human advisers' fee models.
Pitfalls
- Comparing advisory fees alone. Add fund expenses, and ask whether part of the portfolio is held in cash and at what rate.
- Overvaluing tax-loss harvesting. Most of its benefit is a deferral of tax, not a saving, and it does nothing in an IRA or 401(k).
- Wash sales across accounts. A robo selling a fund at a loss while you buy the same fund in another account can disallow the loss. The robo cannot see your other accounts.
- Treating the questionnaire as a plan. It sets a risk level; it does not know your debts, pension or other savings unless you tell it.
- Ignoring transfer friction. Leaving a robo can mean selling, if its funds or fractional positions cannot move in kind.
How Finabase helps
Finabase does not manage money or give personalized advice. You can still look inside a robo portfolio: the comparison tool lays the returns of the broad-market ETFs such portfolios commonly hold side by side, each fund's symbol page shows its price and dividend history, and a Finabase portfolio can mirror a model allocation so you can watch how it drifts between rebalances.
Frequently asked questions
How do robo-advisors work?
You answer a questionnaire, software assigns a mix of index funds matching your risk level, and it then invests deposits, rebalances and, in taxable accounts, may harvest losses automatically. The firm charges a yearly fee on your assets.
How much do robo-advisors charge?
They charge an advisory fee, usually a fraction of a percent of assets a year or a flat subscription, plus the expense ratios of the funds they hold. Add the two, and check whether a "no-fee" program keeps part of the portfolio in low-yielding cash.
Are robo-advisors fiduciaries?
Yes. They are registered investment advisers, subject to the Advisers Act's fiduciary duty of care and loyalty, and they must disclose fees, methods and conflicts in Form ADV.
Are robo-advisors safe?
The account is usually held at a SIPC-member broker, so the assets are protected against the custodian's failure within SIPC limits. They are not protected against market losses, and the quality of the service depends on its code and disclosures.
Summary
A robo-advisor is a registered investment adviser that uses software to assign a model portfolio of index funds, rebalance it and, in taxable accounts, harvest losses. Its cost is the advisory fee plus the funds' expense ratios, and sometimes a cash allocation that earns the firm a spread. Over 30 years at 6% before costs, $100,000 ends at $524,845 with 0.30% a year of costs and $412,159 with 1.10%, against $574,349 with none. The SEC's cases against Schwab in 2022 and Betterment in 2023 show that the Form ADV brochure, not the marketing, is where to read how a robo really works.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A robo-advisor charges a 0.25% advisory fee and its portfolio’s ETFs have a weighted expense ratio of 0.08%. What is the all-in yearly cost, before any cash effect?
- 0.25%
- 0.33%
- 0.08%
Show the answer
B. 0.33% The two layers add: the robo’s fee on the account plus the funds’ fees inside the ETFs, 0.25% + 0.08% = 0.33% a year.
A robo service charges no advisory fee but keeps 8% of each portfolio in cash swept to its affiliated bank at a low rate. Why can that still be a cost?
- Because cash is not protected by SIPC
- Because the cash earns less than the market rate and less than the portfolio’s other assets, and the firm keeps the spread
- Because the cash is charged an expense ratio
Show the answer
B. Because the cash earns less than the market rate and less than the portfolio’s other assets, and the firm keeps the spread The client gives up the return the cash could have earned, and the affiliated bank earns the gap. The SEC’s 2022 case against Schwab Intelligent Portfolios turned on exactly this.
On $100,000 growing 6% a year before costs, a 1.10% all-in yearly cost leaves $412,159 after 30 years against $574,349 with no costs. Why is the gap so much larger than 30 × 1.10% × $100,000 = $33,000?
- Because the fee is charged on the growing balance, and each year’s fee also removes the future growth on that money
- Because fees are taxed
- Because the fee rises every year
Show the answer
A. Because the fee is charged on the growing balance, and each year’s fee also removes the future growth on that money A percentage fee is taken from a balance that keeps growing, and money removed early would have compounded for decades. The total drag, $162,190, is several times the simple sum.
Where can you read a robo-advisor’s fees, methods and conflicts in its own words?
- In its app store reviews
- In its Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS, free on the SEC’s adviser search site
- Only in its marketing pages
Show the answer
B. In its Form ADV Part 2A brochure and Form CRS, free on the SEC’s adviser search site Every registered investment adviser must file Form ADV. Part 2A, the brochure, and the Form CRS summary describe fees, methods, conflicts and disciplinary history.
Sources and further reading
- SEC Division of Investment Management — IM Guidance Update No. 2017-02, Robo-Advisers (February 2017)
- SEC — Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, IA-5248 (2019-06-05)
- SEC press release 2024-42 — Internet adviser exemption amendments (2024-03-27; compliance 2025-03-31)
- SEC press release 2022-104 — Schwab Intelligent Portfolios cash allocations (2022-06-13)
- SEC press release 2023-80 — Betterment tax-loss harvesting disclosures (2023-04-18)
- SEC — Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (Form ADV search)
- IRS — Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses (wash sales)
