Investing basics · Stocks in depth
Proxy voting: how shareholders vote at the annual meeting
How to read a proxy statement and vote: directors, say-on-pay, auditors, shareholder proposals and broker non-votes, with Apple’s 2026 results.
On this page
Owning a share of common stock usually means owning a vote. Once a year, at the annual meeting, shareholders elect the board of directors and decide a handful of other questions. Almost nobody attends in person. Instead, the company sends a proxy statement describing what is on the ballot, and shareholders vote ahead of time by mail, online or by phone, giving a "proxy" to someone who casts the vote for them at the meeting.
This lesson explains what a proxy statement contains, what you are actually voting on, how voting works when your shares are held by a broker, why some votes are counted and others are not, and how to read the results. The worked example is Apple's annual meeting of February 24, 2026, using the vote counts Apple filed on Form 8-K that day.
The proxy statement
Before an annual meeting, the board fixes a record date. Shareholders of record on that date are entitled to vote, even if they sell before the meeting. The company then sends a proxy statement, filed on EDGAR as a DEF 14A, along with a proxy card (or, for street-name holders, a voting instruction form). Many companies now send a one-page Notice of Internet Availability instead of the full document, with a link to read it online.
A proxy statement is long but follows a standard order:
- the meeting's date, the record date and how to vote;
- each proposal, with the board's recommendation;
- the director nominees: biographies, independence, committee roles, how many other boards they sit on;
- executive compensation: the compensation discussion and analysis and the pay tables;
- the auditor: who it is and what it was paid;
- ownership: the largest holders and the shares held by directors and officers;
- any shareholder proposals, each with the proponent's statement and the board's response.
The SEC filings explained: 10-K, 10-Q, 8-K, proxy, 13F and more lesson shows where proxy statements sit among a company's filings. Apple filed its 2026 DEF 14A on January 8, 2026.
What you vote on
Directors. The core of every annual meeting. The board is shareholders' representative; voting for directors is how owners hold management to account.
Say-on-pay. Since 2011, under Rule 14a-21, US companies must hold an advisory vote on executive pay at least once every three years, and most hold one every year. It is non-binding, but a low result usually prompts changes the next year.
Auditor ratification. Shareholders are asked to confirm the board's choice of independent auditor. No law requires the vote at most companies, but nearly all hold it.
Equity plans and charter changes. Stock plans for employees and directors need shareholder approval under exchange rules. Changes to the charter need approval under state law.
Shareholder proposals. Under Rule 14a-8, a shareholder who meets ownership thresholds can have a short proposal (up to 500 words) included in the company's proxy statement. Since the 2020 amendments, the thresholds are $2,000 of stock held for three years, $15,000 for two, or $25,000 for one. Proposals are usually advisory requests: for a report, a policy, a governance change.
Voting when you hold in street name
Most investors' shares are registered in the name of their broker's nominee, not their own: "street name" (the street name versus direct registration lesson explains the chain). The broker is the legal holder; you are the beneficial owner. For voting, the broker (through an intermediary that handles the mailing) sends you a voting instruction form and votes your shares as you instruct.
If you send no instructions, NYSE Rule 452 decides what happens. A broker may vote uninstructed shares only on routine matters, and in practice that means little beyond the auditor ratification. Since 2010, director elections have been non-routine, and the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 extended the ban to executive pay votes. The rule binds NYSE member brokers whatever exchange the company lists on, so it covers Nasdaq companies too.
Shares a broker cannot vote on an item become broker non-votes on that item. They count towards the quorum (the minimum attendance the meeting needs) if the broker voted them on something, but not as votes for or against the non-routine items.
Apple's 2026 meeting
Apple's 8-K reports five items:
| Item | For | Against | For share |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tim Cook (director) | 9,022,191,821 | 101,386,531 | 98.9% |
| Art Levinson (director) | 8,297,337,255 | 822,322,806 | 91.0% |
| Auditor (Ernst & Young) | 11,794,611,709 | 202,435,745 | 98.3% |
| Say-on-pay | 8,304,055,118 | 781,645,634 | 91.4% |
| "China Entanglement Audit" | 129,158,181 | 8,939,194,258 | 1.4% |
(The "for share" is For ÷ (For + Against), ignoring abstentions; the eight directors ranged from 91.0% to 99.6%.)
Two details show the street-name machinery at work. First, every item except the auditor lists 2,889,260,668 broker non-votes: shares whose beneficial owners did not instruct their brokers. Second, the auditor item has none, because ratifying the auditor is routine and brokers voted those shares. Add up for, against and abstain on the auditor and you get 12,025,668,472 shares; do the same on say-on-pay and you get 9,136,407,804. The difference is exactly 2,889,260,668. Roughly a quarter of the shares voted at the meeting were voted only on the auditor, by brokers, because their owners never returned a form.
Majority and plurality voting
How many votes a director needs depends on the company's charter and bylaws.
- Plurality. The nominees with the most votes win. In an uncontested election, with as many nominees as seats, a nominee wins with a single vote; "withhold" votes are a protest, not a block.
- Majority. A nominee must receive more votes for than against. Many large US companies use this standard for uncontested elections, with a resignation policy for anyone who fails. Apple's proxy says its bylaws require a majority of the shares present and voting, and a majority of the quorum.
Contested elections, where there are more nominees than seats, normally revert to plurality, as at ExxonMobil in 2021 (see Activist investors: Schedule 13D, proxy fights and universal proxy).
Reading the results
Companies must report the results on Form 8-K under Item 5.07 within four business days of the meeting; the Form 8-K: what triggers it, the item numbers and how to read one lesson covers the item. Read three things:
- Margins, not just outcomes. A director at 91% has passed, but 9% against is a signal that a meaningful group of holders is unhappy, often about one specific issue the proxy explains.
- Say-on-pay. A low score usually leads to changes in next year's pay plan.
- Shareholder proposals. Even a defeated proposal with a large minority can prompt a company to act.
Pitfalls
- Assuming your vote does not count. Uninstructed shares are not voted on directors at all.
- Missing the deadline. Brokers often need instructions a day or two before the meeting.
- Reading "for" as unanimous. Check the against and abstain columns.
- Confusing advisory with binding. Say-on-pay and most shareholder proposals are advisory.
Plurality, majority and advisory votes compared
| Vote | Binding? | Standard | Broker may vote? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Uncontested director | Yes | Majority or plurality | No |
| Contested director | Yes | Usually plurality | No |
| Say-on-pay | Advisory | Majority cast | No |
| Auditor | Usually advisory | Majority cast | Yes, routine |
How Finabase helps
A company's Ownership tab shows how much of its stock institutions and insiders hold. For Apple, as for most large companies, a handful of index and asset managers control a large share of the votes, which is why their voting policies shape results. Finabase does not show proxy statements or voting results; those are on EDGAR as DEF 14A and 8-K Item 5.07.
Frequently asked questions
What is a proxy vote?
A vote cast on your behalf at a shareholder meeting, according to your instructions, so you do not need to attend. The proxy statement explains what is being voted on.
What happens if I do not vote my proxy?
If you hold in street name, your broker may vote your shares only on routine items such as the auditor. Your shares are not voted on directors, pay or shareholder proposals.
What is a broker non-vote?
A share held by a broker that the broker cannot vote on a non-routine item because its owner sent no instructions. Apple reported 2,889,260,668 on every non-routine item in 2026.
What is say-on-pay?
A non-binding shareholder vote on executive pay, required at least once every three years. Apple's 2026 vote received 91.4% of the votes cast.
Summary
Shareholders vote once a year, by proxy, on directors, executive pay, the auditor and any proposals that made it onto the ballot, guided by the proxy statement filed as DEF 14A. Street-name holders vote through their broker's voting instruction form, and NYSE Rule 452 lets brokers vote unreturned shares only on routine items. Apple's 2026 results show both effects: 2,889,260,668 broker non-votes on every item but the auditor, and an auditor vote larger by exactly that number. Results arrive on Form 8-K Item 5.07 within four business days, and the margins say more than the pass or fail.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
You hold shares in street name and do not return your voting instruction form. On which item can your broker still vote your shares?
- The election of directors
- Ratification of the auditor
- The say-on-pay vote
Show the answer
B. Ratification of the auditor Under NYSE Rule 452, brokers may vote uninstructed shares only on routine matters. Auditor ratification is routine; director elections and pay votes are not.
Apple reported 2,889,260,668 broker non-votes on every item except the auditor in 2026, and the auditor item had exactly that many more votes in total. What explains it?
- Brokers voted unreturned shares on the routine auditor item but could not vote them on the others
- Some shareholders voted twice
- Apple counted the auditor vote differently by mistake
Show the answer
A. Brokers voted unreturned shares on the routine auditor item but could not vote them on the others Uninstructed street-name shares were voted by brokers only where Rule 452 allows it. On every non-routine item they appear as broker non-votes instead.
Under plurality voting in an uncontested election, what happens to a nominee who receives far more withhold votes than for votes?
- The nominee is still elected, because the most votes wins and there is no rival
- The nominee is automatically removed
- The election is rerun
Show the answer
A. The nominee is still elected, because the most votes wins and there is no rival With as many nominees as seats, any for vote is enough under plurality. Majority voting, with a resignation policy, was adopted by many companies to change that.
Where are the final results of a shareholder vote published?
- In the next year’s proxy statement only
- On Form 8-K, Item 5.07, within four business days of the meeting
- Only on the company’s website
Show the answer
B. On Form 8-K, Item 5.07, within four business days of the meeting Item 5.07 of Form 8-K requires the results, usually including for, against, abstain and broker non-votes for each item.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open Apple’s Ownership tab. Note the share of the stock held by institutions and the five largest holders. Add up the five largest stakes. Then ask: if those five voted the same way on a shareholder proposal, roughly what share of the votes would they control before any individual investor votes?
Open Apple’s Ownership tabWhat you should find
A handful of index and asset managers usually hold a large slice of a big company’s shares, so their voting policies go a long way toward deciding elections and proposals. Individual holders matter most in close votes, and only if they actually return their forms.
Sources and further reading
- Apple Inc. — Definitive proxy statement (DEF 14A), filed January 8, 2026, for the February 24, 2026 annual meeting
- Apple Inc. — Form 8-K of February 24, 2026, Item 5.07: voting results
- SEC — Release No. 34-89964 (September 23, 2020), amendments to Rule 14a-8 eligibility
- Congressional Research Service — “SEC Proposes Rescission of the Shareholder Proposal Rule”, LSB11489 (October 14, 2026)
- SEC — Release No. 34-60215 (July 1, 2009), approving the NYSE Rule 452 amendment on broker voting in director elections
- SEC — Rule 14a-21 (shareholder advisory votes on executive compensation), 17 CFR 240.14a-21 (read November 2026)
