Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investing basics · Foundations

Stocks vs. bonds: ownership against a loan, and 23 years of results

How a share and a bond differ in what they promise, how they are taxed and what they did from 2003 to 2026: SPY earned 11.0% a year, AGG 3.0%, and 60/40 between.

On this page
  1. What each one is
  2. Where the returns come from
  3. Stocks and bonds compared
  4. Worked example: 23 years of SPY and AGG
  5. Which to use when
  6. Pitfalls in the comparison
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

A stock and a bond are the two basic ways to put money into a company or a government. A stock makes you a part-owner: you share in whatever the business earns, with no promise of anything. A bond makes you a lender: you are owed fixed interest and your money back on a set date, and nothing more. Almost every other investment, from a target-date fund to a 401(k) menu, is some mix of the two.

The difference in the contract explains the difference in results. Owners get the upside and absorb the losses first, so stocks have paid more and swung far more. Lenders get a capped, contractual return, so bonds have paid less and fallen less, with one notable exception. This lesson sets the two side by side, then measures them on 23 years of real fund data, including 2008 and 2022.

What each one is

A share of common stock is a slice of a company's equity. Shareholders vote, receive dividends if the board declares them, and own whatever is left after everyone else is paid. There is no maturity date and no promised return. What is a stock? A complete beginner’s guide to shares covers the mechanics.

A bond is a debt security. The issuer, a company, a city or the US Treasury, borrows a fixed amount (the face value, usually $1,000), pays a fixed or floating coupon on a schedule, and repays the face value at maturity. Missing a payment is a default, with legal consequences. Bond basics: par value, coupon and maturity on a real Treasury note explains the parts of a bond.

The order of claims follows from that. In a US bankruptcy, creditors are paid before owners: secured lenders first, then unsecured bondholders, then preferred stock, then common stock. Shareholders of a failed company often receive nothing at all.

Where the returns come from

Stocks return what the business earns, through two channels: dividends paid out, and a rising share price as profits grow. Neither is promised. Over long periods the market has rewarded owners with an equity risk premium, a return above what lenders get, for carrying the risk of losses.

Bonds return their yield to maturity if bought and held to maturity without a default. The yield on the day you buy is a good guide to what a bond, or a fund of bonds, will earn over the next several years. A bond's price moves in between: when market interest rates rise, existing bonds with lower coupons fall in price until their yield matches the market. That interest-rate risk is the main way a high-quality bond loses money. The other is credit risk, the chance the issuer cannot pay, which is near zero for Treasuries and larger for companies with low ratings.

Stocks and bonds compared

Feature Stock Bond
What you hold Part-ownership A loan to the issuer
Promised payment None Coupon and face value
End date None Maturity date
In bankruptcy Paid last, often nothing Paid before shareholders
Main risk Business results, market falls Rising rates, issuer default
US federal tax Qualified dividends 0–20% Interest at ordinary income rates
Typical fund example SPY (S&P 500), 0.0945% a year AGG (US aggregate bonds), 0.03%

Worked example: 23 years of SPY and AGG

To compare the two on real data, take SPY, the oldest S&P 500 ETF, and AGG, which holds the investment-grade US bond market (Treasuries, mortgage-backed securities and corporate bonds). AGG began trading in September 2003, so the test runs from the end of October 2003 to the end of October 2026, using month-end prices with every dividend reinvested in the month it was paid. Fund fees are already inside the prices. Taxes are left out.

SPY (stocks) and AGG (bonds), total return, October 2003 to October 2026 SPY, S&P 500 fund AGG, US bond fund 11.0% 3.0% Return a year 14.5% 4.5% Volatility −50.8% −17.1% Deepest fall −36.8% −13.2% Worst year −18.2% −13.2% 2022 Monthly closes with dividends reinvested. Worst year: 2008 for SPY, 2022 for AGG.
SPY (S&P 500) and AGG (US investment-grade bonds), total return with dividends reinvested, month-end closes, October 2003 to October 2026.

The results:

Measure SPY, stocks AGG, bonds 60/40 mix
$10,000 became $109,157 $19,666 $58,200
Return per year 11.0% 3.0% 8.0%
Volatility (yearly) 14.5% 4.5% 9.3%
Deepest fall from a peak −50.8% (2007–09) −17.1% (2020–22) −32.3%
2008 −36.8% +7.9% −21.1%
2022 −18.2% −13.2% −15.9%
Losing calendar years, of 22 3 3

Three things stand out.

  1. The gap compounds. An 8-point yearly difference turned the same $10,000 into $109,157 for stocks and $19,666 for bonds. That is the reward for carrying stock risk over a long period.
  2. The falls differ in kind. SPY lost half its value from October 2007 to February 2009 and took until March 2012 to recover. AGG's worst fall was a third as deep, but it came from rising interest rates, ran from July 2020 to October 2022, and AGG was still below its 2020 peak at the end of the test.
  3. They usually move independently. The correlation of their monthly returns was 0.23. In 2008 bonds rose while stocks fell, which is what makes holding both useful. 2022 was the exception: inflation pushed rates up, and both fell together.

The 60/40 column is a portfolio of 60% SPY and 40% AGG, reset to those weights every month. It earned 8.0% a year with a deepest fall of 32.3%, so it gave up about three points of yearly return to cut the worst fall by more than a third. The 60/40 portfolio: rules, a price-only backtest and 2022 tests that mix in more detail.

Which to use when

This is a description of how people use each, not a recommendation for anyone.

  • Money needed within a few years usually goes to bonds or cash. A stock fund can be down 30% or more at the moment the money is needed; SPY was below its 2007 peak for more than four years.
  • Money left for decades is where stocks' higher return has had time to show. Every 15-year stretch inside this test ended higher for SPY, the weakest by 196%, though the path included a fall of half.
  • Steady income comes more predictably from bonds: the coupons are contractual. Stock dividends can be cut, as many were in 2009 and 2020.
  • Protection in a crash has usually come from high-quality bonds, especially Treasuries, as in 2008 and early 2020. It did not come in 2022, when inflation was the problem.
  • Most investors hold both. How much of each is the Asset allocation: how stock, bond and cash mixes have behaved decision, which depends on time horizon and on how large a fall a person can sit through (Time horizon and risk tolerance: matching investments to goals).

Pitfalls in the comparison

  • "Bonds are safe." High-quality bonds rarely default, but their prices move. Long-term Treasury funds fell more than stocks did in 2022. A short-term bond fund carries far less of that risk than a 20-year one.
  • Past premiums are not promises. The 8-point gap in this test came from a strong period for US stocks and a long stretch of low bond yields. When bond yields start higher, bonds' future returns start higher too.
  • Taxes change the numbers. Bond interest is taxed as ordinary income each year, at up to 37% federally in 2026. Qualified dividends and long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%, and a stock's gain is not taxed until it is sold. In a taxable account that favours stocks; inside an IRA or 401(k) the difference disappears (see How dividends and interest are taxed: qualified, ordinary, muni).
  • Inflation. A bond's payments are fixed in dollars. Rising prices shrink what they buy, which is why TIPS exist. Stocks have no fixed dollar payments, so over long periods they have kept up with inflation better, though not over every short stretch.

How Finabase does it

The comparison tab on any symbol page draws two or more symbols from the same start date, so SPY and AGG can be checked over any range. AGG's Dividends tab lists each monthly payment, which shows a bond fund's income rising after rates rose in 2022 and 2023. The Treasury page shows today's Treasury yields from one month to 30 years, the starting point for what high-quality bonds can earn from here. The numbers in this lesson come from frozen copies of Finabase's month-end prices and dividend records, computed in the lesson's figure script.

Frequently asked questions

Are bonds safer than stocks?

They have been less volatile: AGG's yearly volatility was 4.5% against 14.5% for SPY, and its worst fall was about a third as deep. They are not risk-free. Bond prices fall when interest rates rise, as in 2022, and lower-rated issuers can default.

Do stocks always beat bonds over the long run?

Over most long periods in US history they have, and they did by about 8 points a year from 2003 to 2026. There have been long stretches when they did not: an S&P 500 investor in early 2000 was behind high-quality bonds ten years later. A longer horizon improves the odds; it does not guarantee the result.

Why did stocks and bonds both fall in 2022?

Inflation rose and the Federal Reserve raised short-term rates quickly. Higher rates lowered bond prices directly and lowered the value investors put on future company profits. In 2008 the problem was a financial crisis and falling rates, which helped bonds while stocks fell.

What does 60/40 mean?

A portfolio with 60% in stocks and 40% in bonds, reset to those weights from time to time. In this test it returned 8.0% a year with a deepest fall of 32.3%, between the two funds on both counts.

Summary

A stock is ownership with no promise; a bond is a loan with a promised payment and an end date. That contract shapes everything else: who is paid first, how each is taxed, and how they behave. On real fund data from October 2003 to October 2026, SPY returned 11.0% a year with a worst fall of 50.8%, while AGG returned 3.0% a year with a worst fall of 17.1%. They usually moved independently and in 2008 in opposite directions, but in 2022 both fell. That is why most portfolios hold some of each, in a proportion set by how soon the money is needed and how much of a fall its owner can bear.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. A company goes bankrupt. Who is paid first from what is left?

    1. Common shareholders, because they own the company
    2. Bondholders and other creditors, before any shareholder
    3. Everyone shares equally in proportion to what they invested
    Show the answer

    B. Bondholders and other creditors, before any shareholder A bond is a debt, so its holders are creditors and rank ahead of preferred and common stock. Shareholders own what is left after creditors are paid, which in a failure is often nothing.

  2. From 2003 to 2026 SPY returned about 11% a year and AGG about 3%. What explains most of the gap?

    1. AGG charged much higher fees
    2. Stockholders carry the business risk and the first losses, and over long periods have been paid more for it
    3. Bond funds do not reinvest their interest
    Show the answer

    B. Stockholders carry the business risk and the first losses, and over long periods have been paid more for it Both funds charge very little and both results include reinvested income. The gap is the equity risk premium: owners absorb losses first, as SPY’s 50.8% fall in 2007–09 shows, and in return have earned more over long periods.

  3. Why did both stocks and bonds fall in 2022, when bonds had risen in 2008?

    1. Rising inflation pushed interest rates up, which lowered bond prices and the value of future profits at the same time
    2. Many bond issuers defaulted in 2022
    3. Bond funds were forced to buy stocks
    Show the answer

    A. Rising inflation pushed interest rates up, which lowered bond prices and the value of future profits at the same time Bond prices fall when market rates rise. In 2022 the Federal Reserve raised rates quickly to fight inflation, so stocks and bonds fell together. In 2008 rates fell during a financial crisis, which helped high-quality bonds.

  4. An investor holds both funds in a taxable account. Which statement about US federal tax in 2026 is right?

    1. Bond interest and qualified dividends are both taxed at 0%, 15% or 20%
    2. Bond interest is taxed as ordinary income; qualified dividends and long-term gains at 0%, 15% or 20%
    3. Neither is taxed until the fund is sold
    Show the answer

    B. Bond interest is taxed as ordinary income; qualified dividends and long-term gains at 0%, 15% or 20% Interest is ordinary income each year. Qualified dividends get the lower long-term capital gains rates, and a share’s price gain is taxed only when it is sold. Inside an IRA or 401(k) none of this applies until withdrawal.

Sources and further reading

  1. Investor.gov (SEC) — Stocks
  2. iShares — Core U.S. Aggregate Bond ETF (AGG): inception September 22, 2003, expense ratio 0.03%
  3. State Street Global Advisors — SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (SPY): inception January 22, 1993, gross expense ratio 0.0945%
  4. Investor.gov (SEC) — Bonds
  5. FINRA — Bonds: the basics, including interest rate and credit risk
  6. IRS — Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses (interest and dividends)
  7. U.S. Courts — Chapter 11 bankruptcy basics (order of claims)
  8. Finabase chart data — SPY and AGG month-end closes and dividends, October 2003 to October 2026; results computed by Finabase