Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investing basics · Brokers and automated investing

Robo-advisor vs. financial advisor: what each does and costs

How automated and human advice differ in services, legal duty and fees, with a year’s cost at $50,000, $250,000 and $1 million, and what a fee gap does over 25 years.

On this page
  1. What each one does
  2. The legal duty behind each
  3. Robo-advisor and financial advisor compared
  4. Worked example: a year of help in dollars
  5. Which to use when
  6. Pitfalls
  7. How Finabase does it
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

Investment advice comes in two broad forms. A robo-advisor is a website or app that asks a few questions, picks a portfolio of index funds, and then rebalances it and harvests tax losses by software, for a small yearly fee. A financial advisor is a person who may do the same and much more: plan for retirement, college and taxes, choose insurance, and talk a client out of selling in a panic, usually for a larger fee.

In the US both are often the same kind of firm under the law: a registered investment adviser with a fiduciary duty to the client. What separates them is the breadth of the service and the price. This lesson compares the two, shows what each costs in dollars at three account sizes, and works out what a fee gap does over 25 years.

What each one does

A robo-advisor runs a fixed process. It scores a client's risk tolerance and time horizon from a questionnaire, maps the score to one of a set of model portfolios (usually low-cost ETFs), invests new money, rebalances when weights drift, and in taxable accounts sells losing funds to harvest tax losses. Some add a human team that can be reached by phone, for a higher fee or above a minimum balance. Robo-advisors: how automated portfolios are built, run and priced covers how they build and run portfolios.

A human advisor can do the same portfolio work, though often with more customization: holding a client's existing shares, managing concentrated company stock, or building a bond ladder. The larger part of the service is usually planning: how much to save, when to claim Social Security, which accounts to draw from in retirement, Roth conversions, insurance and estate questions. Many advisors would say their most valuable work is keeping clients invested in a crash.

The label "financial advisor" is not regulated. What matters is the registration behind it:

  • An investment adviser, registered with the SEC or a state, owes clients a fiduciary duty under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940: a duty of care and of loyalty that applies to the whole relationship. The SEC's 2019 interpretation (IA-5248) restates it. Robo-advisors are investment advisers too, and the SEC's 2017 guidance on robo-advisers says the same duty applies to automated advice.
  • A broker-dealer representative who calls themselves a financial advisor works under Regulation Best Interest, in force since June 30, 2020: recommendations must be in the client's best interest when made, but unless the broker agrees to monitor the account, there is no ongoing duty to do so.

Both kinds of firm must give clients Form CRS, a short summary of services, fees and conflicts. Advisers also file Form ADV, searchable on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site; brokers appear on FINRA's BrokerCheck. Financial advisors and fiduciary duty: who must act in your interest and How to check a broker or adviser: BrokerCheck, IAPD and Form CRS explain both.

Robo-advisor and financial advisor compared

Feature Robo-advisor Human financial advisor
Core service Portfolio management by software Portfolio plus financial planning
Typical pricing About 0.25% of assets a year About 1% of assets, or a flat or hourly fee
Minimum account Often $0 to a few thousand dollars Often $100,000 or more for asset fees
Tax-loss harvesting Automatic in taxable accounts Varies by advisor
Planning and taxes Limited or none Usually included
Legal standard Fiduciary (registered adviser) Fiduciary if an adviser; Reg BI if a broker
Behavioural coaching Messages and settings A person to call

Worked example: a year of help in dollars

Fees are quoted as percentages, but they are paid in dollars, and the dollars depend on the account. Take three illustrative setups, each with the cost of the funds added:

  • Robo-advisor: 0.25% advisory fee plus 0.05% in fund expenses.
  • Advisor on an asset fee: 1.00% advisory fee plus 0.10% in fund expenses.
  • Flat-fee planner: $3,000 a year for planning, with the client holding index funds at 0.05%.

These are round numbers for illustration, not quotes for any firm. Many advisors charge less than 1% on larger accounts through tiered schedules.

What a year of investment help costs, in dollars (illustrative fees) Robo: 0.25% + 0.05% funds Adviser: 1.00% + 0.10% funds Flat $3,000 planner + 0.05% funds $150 $550 $3,025 $50,000 account $750 $2,750 $3,125 $250,000 account $3,000 $11,000 $3,500 $1,000,000 account Advisory fee plus fund expenses for one year. Real fees vary by firm and account size.
Illustrative fees: advisory fee plus fund expenses for one year. Real fees vary by firm and account size.
Account size Robo (0.30%) Advisor (1.10%) Flat $3,000 + 0.05%
$50,000 $150 $550 $3,025
$250,000 $750 $2,750 $3,125
$1,000,000 $3,000 $11,000 $3,500

The ranking changes with size. At $50,000 a flat $3,000 fee is 6% of the account a year, far too much for the money involved, and the robo is cheapest by far. At $250,000 the advisor and the planner cost about the same. At $1,000,000 the asset fee is three times the flat fee, because a 1% fee grows with the account while a flat fee does not.

Over 25 years

Costs compound like returns, in reverse. Take $250,000 growing 6% a year before costs for 25 years, with costs taken each year:

  • At 0.30% all-in, it ends at $999,573.
  • At 1.10% all-in, it ends at $826,661.

The 0.8-point gap costs $172,913, more than two-thirds of the starting balance. Whether the human service is worth that depends on what it changes. Advice that avoids one panicked sale in a bear market, a costly tax mistake, or an unsuitable annuity can be worth more than the fee. Advice that only picks index funds a robo would also pick is not.

Which to use when

Common patterns, not advice for a particular person:

  • Starting out with a small balance and simple needs: a robo, or a target-date fund, costs the least for the same diversified portfolio.
  • Complicated finances: business income, stock options, an inheritance or a coming retirement are where human planning earns its fee.
  • Large balances: a flat-fee or hourly planner, or an advisor with a tiered fee, avoids paying a percentage on every dollar.
  • One-off questions: an hourly, advice-only planner reviews a plan without managing the money.
  • People who know they would sell in a crash: a person to call can matter more than the fee.
  • Hybrid services combine a robo's portfolio with access to planners, at a price in between.

Pitfalls

  • Comparing advisory fees alone. Add the fund expenses. An advisor charging 0.75% who uses funds costing 0.60% costs more than one charging 1% who uses index funds.
  • "No-fee" robos. Some are paid through cash held in the portfolio instead of a fee. In 2022 the SEC fined Schwab's robo-adviser affiliates $187 million over how they disclosed the cash in Schwab Intelligent Portfolios.
  • Assuming the title means fiduciary. Ask whether the person is acting as an investment adviser or a broker, and read Form CRS.
  • Paying for planning that never happens. An asset fee is charged every year whether or not the client gets a plan.

How Finabase does it

Finabase does not give personal advice or manage money. Its portfolio tracker can hold an advised or robo account's positions, so their mix and returns can be checked independently of the provider's own reports. The comparison tab shows how the stock and bond index funds most robo portfolios are built from have moved. The fee figures in this lesson are computed in its figure script from the assumptions stated.

Frequently asked questions

Is a robo-advisor better than a financial advisor?

For portfolio management alone, a robo usually costs less: about $750 a year on $250,000 against $2,750 for a 1% advisor in this lesson's example. A human advisor can add planning, tax and behavioural help that a robo does not offer. Which is better depends on whether that help is needed.

Are robo-advisors fiduciaries?

Most are registered investment advisers, and the SEC's 2017 guidance says the fiduciary duty of the Investment Advisers Act applies to them. Check the firm's Form ADV to confirm its registration.

How much does a financial advisor cost?

Common models are a percentage of assets, often around 1% a year on smaller accounts and less on larger ones, a flat yearly retainer, or an hourly rate. Fund expenses come on top.

Can I switch from an advisor to a robo-advisor?

Yes. Accounts can usually move between brokers by an ACATS transfer, often without selling, though a robo may sell holdings it does not use, which can create taxable gains in a taxable account.

Summary

A robo-advisor automates portfolio management at a low percentage fee; a human financial advisor adds planning, tax and behavioural advice at a higher one, or for a flat fee. Both are usually fiduciaries when registered as investment advisers. In dollars, the cheaper choice depends on the account: the robo wins easily at $50,000, the two are closer at $250,000, and a flat fee beats an asset fee at $1 million. Over 25 years, a 0.8-point difference in yearly costs on $250,000 came to $172,913, which is the bar human advice has to clear.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. At which account size in the lesson’s example is a flat $3,000-a-year planner clearly cheaper than a 1% asset fee?

    1. $50,000
    2. $250,000
    3. $1,000,000
    Show the answer

    C. $1,000,000 A 1% fee grows with the account: $11,000 a year at $1 million (with 0.10% in funds) against $3,500 for the flat fee plus funds. At $50,000 the flat fee is 6% of the account, far more than either percentage fee.

  2. A person calls themselves a “financial advisor”. What tells you whether they owe you a fiduciary duty?

    1. The title itself
    2. Whether they are acting as a registered investment adviser or as a broker, as shown in Form CRS and Form ADV or BrokerCheck
    3. Whether they charge a fee
    Show the answer

    B. Whether they are acting as a registered investment adviser or as a broker, as shown in Form CRS and Form ADV or BrokerCheck “Financial advisor” is not a regulated title. Investment advisers owe a fiduciary duty under the Advisers Act; brokers follow Regulation Best Interest. Form CRS and the public registration records say which role applies.

  3. Why did a 0.8-point gap in yearly costs on $250,000 come to $172,913 over 25 years?

    1. Because fees are charged on the original deposit only
    2. Because each year’s fee also removes the growth that money would have earned in later years
    3. Because advisors charge exit fees
    Show the answer

    B. Because each year’s fee also removes the growth that money would have earned in later years Costs compound in reverse. The account at 0.30% ended at $999,573 and at 1.10% at $826,661, both growing 6% a year before costs.

  4. A robo-advisor advertises “no advisory fee”. What should a careful client check?

    1. Nothing; no fee means no cost
    2. How the firm is paid instead, for example through cash held in the portfolio, and the funds’ expense ratios
    3. Only the minimum balance
    Show the answer

    B. How the firm is paid instead, for example through cash held in the portfolio, and the funds’ expense ratios Some programs are paid through the interest the firm earns on cash it keeps in client portfolios. The SEC fined Schwab’s robo-adviser affiliates $187 million in 2022 over how that cash was disclosed.

Sources and further reading

  1. SEC Division of Investment Management — IM Guidance Update No. 2017-02, Robo-Advisers (February 2017)
  2. SEC — Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, IA-5248 (2019-06-05)
  3. SEC press release 2024-42 — Internet adviser exemption amendments (2024-03-27; compliance 2025-03-31)
  4. SEC press release 2022-104 — Schwab Intelligent Portfolios cash allocations (2022-06-13)
  5. SEC press release 2019-89 — Regulation Best Interest and Form CRS adopted (2019-06-05)
  6. SEC — Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (Form ADV search)
  7. FINRA — BrokerCheck