Investing basics · Stocks in depth
Direct listings: how Spotify, Slack and Coinbase went public
How a direct listing works without underwriters: the reference price, the opening auction, primary listings since 2020 and the first days of Spotify and Coinbase.
On this page
A direct listing takes a private company's existing shares and starts trading them on an exchange without an underwritten offering. No banks buy the shares and resell them, no offer price is set the night before, and in the classic version the company raises no money at all. Shareholders who want to sell simply put in orders on the first morning, and buyers meet them in the exchange's opening auction.
The idea was niche until Spotify used it on the NYSE on April 3, 2018. Slack, Palantir, Roblox and Coinbase followed. How IPOs work: from S-1 filing to first trade and lock-up compares direct listings with IPOs and SPACs in a paragraph each. This page goes into how the first price is found, what the "reference price" is and is not, what the 2020 rule change allowed, and what happened on the first day of three well-known listings.
How a direct listing works
A company going the direct route still has to become an SEC reporting company. It files a registration statement (Form S-1, or F-1 for a foreign company) that registers its existing shares for resale and contains the same audited financial statements and risk factors as an IPO prospectus. The SEC reviews it in the same way. What is missing is the offering: there is no book of orders taken by banks, no allocation and usually no lock-up, the agreement that keeps insiders from selling for months after an IPO. On a direct listing's first day employees, early investors and founders can sell.
Financial advisers are still hired, to help prepare the filing and to advise the exchange on the opening. They are paid fees, but they do not buy shares and resell them.
The reference price is not a price anyone pays
Before trading starts, the exchange publishes a reference price. It exists because exchange systems need a previous price to work from, and a private company has none. It is usually tied to recent trades in the private market for the shares, or to an independent valuation when there were none.
It is easy to mistake for an offer price. Jay Ritter's table of US direct listings is explicit: no shares trade at the reference price. The first trade happens at the open, typically as one large block.
The opening auction
On the first morning, buy and sell orders build up without trading. The exchange's market maker (the designated market maker on the NYSE) publishes indications of where supply and demand might meet, adjusts as orders arrive, and opens the stock at the single price that matches the most shares. On a busy debut that can take a while. From then on the stock trades like any other.
A traditional IPO sets the opening differently: the banks have already sold the shares at the offer price the night before, and the first trade measures how much more (or less) the market will pay.
Primary direct listings since 2020
The classic direct listing could not raise money, which limited it to companies that did not need any. On December 22, 2020 the SEC approved an NYSE rule change (Release 34-90768, SR-NYSE-2019-67) that allows a primary direct listing: the company sells new shares itself in the opening auction, alongside or instead of existing holders. The mechanics sit in Section 102.01B of the NYSE Listed Company Manual. The company then gets the cash from the shares sold at the opening price, without an underwriting spread.
In practice the large listings since then have still been existing-share sales. Ritter's table notes that since 2022 the companies using direct listings have generally been microcaps.
Three first days, against the reference price
Ritter's Table 13a (updated November 5, 2026) lists every US direct listing with its reference price and first-day prices. Three large ones:
| Company | Reference | Open | Close |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spotify | $132 | $165.90 | $149.01 |
| Slack | $26 | $38.50 | $38.62 |
| Coinbase | $250 | $381.00 | $328.28 |
Spotify listed on the NYSE on April 3, 2018. It opened 25.7% above its reference price, then slid: the close was 10.2% below the open, still 12.9% above the reference.
Slack listed on the NYSE on June 20, 2019. It opened 48.1% above the reference price and closed almost exactly at its opening level, up 0.3%.
Coinbase listed on Nasdaq on April 14, 2021. It opened at $381, 52.4% above its $250 reference, traded between $310 and $429.54, and closed at $328.28: 13.8% below the open, 31.3% above the reference.
The useful comparison is not with the reference price, which nobody paid, but with the open, which is where the first buyers paid. Measured that way, the first-day return was −10.2%, +0.3% and −13.8%. Ritter computes direct listings' first-day returns from the open for exactly this reason, while IPO first-day returns run from the offer price, which some investors did pay (IPO returns: first-day pops and long-run performance).
What it costs, and what it gives up
The cost case for a direct listing starts with the gross spread an underwritten IPO pays the banks. Ritter's Table 10 (updated December 31, 2025) counts operating-company IPOs raising at least $30 million from 2001 to 2025. Of those raising $30 million to $160 million (in 2025 dollars), 93.3% paid exactly 7%. Larger deals pay less: of those above $160 million, 54.4% paid under 7%.
The IPO also costs a company the first-day pop: the gap between the offer price and the first close is money the company could have raised (the "money left on the table" in IPO returns: first-day pops and long-run performance). A direct listing has no offer price, so there is no such gap.
What it gives up:
- No guaranteed buyer. The banks in an IPO line up investors and commit to buy the shares. In a direct listing the opening auction has to find buyers on its own.
- No price support. IPO underwriters often hold an over-allotment option they can use to buy shares back if the price falls. A direct listing has no stabilizing agent.
- Insider selling from day one. Without a lock-up, supply can be heavy early on.
- Volatility. Coinbase's first-day range was 36% of its closing price.
Pitfalls for investors
- Treating the reference price as a bargain line. It is a technical starting point, not a value.
- Buying the open. Spotify’s open was its high for the day, and Coinbase closed 13.8% below its open. A market order at the open of a busy listing can fill far above where it trades an hour later.
- Forgetting the supply. Every pre-listing holder can sell. Check how many shares are registered for resale in the prospectus.
Direct listing, IPO and SPAC compared
| Feature | Direct listing | Traditional IPO | SPAC merger |
|---|---|---|---|
| New money | Only if primary | Yes | Trust plus PIPE |
| First price set by | Opening auction | Banks, offer price | Merger terms |
| Lock-up | Usually none | Usually 180 days | Varies |
| Main fee | Advisers | Gross spread | Promote and fees |
SPACs: how blank-check companies take private firms public covers the third column.
How Finabase helps
Finabase's charts of Spotify and Coinbase start in their first trading weeks, so you can see how far each traveled from its first day. The IPO calendar lists upcoming and recent listings with their exchange and deal size; a direct listing that sells no new shares has no deal size to show. Each company's exchange is on its symbol page.
Frequently asked questions
Does a company raise money in a direct listing?
Not in the classic form, which only lets existing shares trade. Since December 2020 the NYSE has allowed primary direct listings, in which the company sells new shares in the opening auction and keeps the proceeds.
What is a reference price in a direct listing?
It is a starting point the exchange publishes before the first trade, usually based on recent private-market trades or a valuation. No shares trade at it; the first price comes from the opening auction.
Is a direct listing cheaper than an IPO?
Usually, for the company. It avoids the underwriting spread, 7% on most mid-sized IPOs, and the gap between an offer price and the first-day close. It pays adviser fees and gives up the banks' buyers and price support.
Can retail investors buy in a direct listing?
Yes, from the open, through any broker that offers the stock. There is no allocation of shares at an offer price, so everyone buys in the market at the same time.
Did Coinbase raise money in its direct listing?
No. Its April 2021 listing registered existing shares, so the sellers were its existing holders, with no lock-up and no underwriting spread. Its first day showed the trade-off: a 36% intraday range and a close 13.8% below the open.
Summary
A direct listing lists existing shares without an underwritten offering. The exchange publishes a reference price, but the first real price comes from the opening auction, and pre-listing holders can sell from day one. Since an SEC order of December 22, 2020, a company can also raise money in a primary direct listing on the NYSE. Spotify, Slack and Coinbase opened 26% to 52% above their reference prices, and two of them closed well below the open. The route saves the 7% spread most mid-sized IPOs pay, in exchange for no guaranteed buyers, no price support and no lock-up.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
Coinbase’s reference price was $250. It opened at $381 and closed at $328.28. What first-day return did an investor who bought the first trade earn?
- +31.3%, from the reference price to the close
- −13.8%, from the open to the close
- +52.4%, from the reference price to the open
Show the answer
B. −13.8%, from the open to the close Nobody bought at the reference price; the first shares changed hands at the open. From $381 to $328.28 is −13.8%. That is why Ritter measures direct listings from the open.
What did the SEC’s December 22, 2020 order allow on the NYSE?
- Companies to sell new shares themselves in the opening auction of a direct listing
- Direct listings to skip SEC registration
- Underwriters to set a fixed offer price in direct listings
Show the answer
A. Companies to sell new shares themselves in the opening auction of a direct listing Release 34-90768 approved primary direct listings: the company can raise money by selling new shares at the opening price. Registration is still required, and there is no underwriter-set offer price.
A company raising $100 million (in today’s dollars) chooses an underwritten IPO. Based on Ritter’s data for 2001–2025, what spread is it most likely to pay?
- About 1%, like the largest deals
- Exactly 7%, as 93.3% of deals that size did
- Nothing, because the exchange pays the banks
Show the answer
B. Exactly 7%, as 93.3% of deals that size did For IPOs raising $30 million to $160 million (2025 dollars), 93.3% paid exactly a 7% gross spread. Very large deals pay less, but a mid-sized one rarely does.
Which risk is larger in a direct listing than in an IPO?
- That insiders sell heavily on the first day, because there is usually no lock-up
- That the company pays a 7% spread
- That retail investors are left out of an allocation
Show the answer
A. That insiders sell heavily on the first day, because there is usually no lock-up Without a lock-up, every pre-listing holder can sell from the open, and there are no underwriters to support the price. The spread and allocation problems belong to IPOs.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open Spotify’s chart at the longest range. Its first trade on April 3, 2018 was at $165.90 against a reference price of $132. Find when the stock first traded below $132 after listing, how often it came back there over the next five years, and where it stands against both prices now.
Open Spotify’s chartWhat you should find
Spotify was back above its $165.90 open within weeks, then fell below the $132 reference price in late 2018 and spent long stretches under it as late as 2023, before rising far above both. The reference price was never a floor, and the first day said little about the years that followed.
Sources and further reading
- Jay R. Ritter, “Initial Public Offerings: Updated Statistics” (University of Florida, November 5, 2026), Table 13a (Direct listings in the U.S., 2018–2026) and Table 10 (gross spreads, 2001–2025)
- SEC — Release No. 34-90768 (December 22, 2020), order approving NYSE primary direct listings, SR-NYSE-2019-67
- NYSE Listed Company Manual — Section 102.01B and its Footnote (E) on direct floor listings
- Finabase chart data — weekly bars of SPOT and COIN from their first trading weeks, frozen November 2026
