Investing basics · Stocks in depth
Secondary offerings: follow-ons, shelf registrations and ATMs
How listed companies and their big holders sell more stock: dilutive and non-dilutive offerings, Form S-3 shelves, at-the-market programs and Carnival’s 2020 sale.
On this page
- Primary, secondary and mixed
- Shelf registration: selling on short notice
- The kinds of deals
- A real prospectus supplement: Carnival, April 2020
- Worked example: what dilution does and does not do
- How prices react
- Pitfalls
- Comparison of ways to sell stock
- How Finabase helps
- Frequently asked questions
- Summary
- Check your understanding
- Exercise
Going public is not the last time a company sells stock. A listed company can sell new shares again whenever it needs money, and its large shareholders (founders, private equity funds, a parent company) can sell blocks of the shares they already own. Both are called secondary or follow-on offerings, though they have opposite effects on the company.
These sales are frequent and they move prices, usually down, on the day they are announced. This lesson explains the two kinds, the shelf registration that lets a company sell within hours, the at-the-market programs that sell a little every day, and how to read one real prospectus supplement. The share-count arithmetic of dilution is covered in Share count and dilution: basic, diluted and what moves them; here we stay with the offerings themselves.
Primary, secondary and mixed
Primary offering (dilutive). The company issues new shares and sells them. The share count rises, so earnings and dividends are divided among more shares. In exchange the company has new cash, to pay down debt, fund growth or, in a crisis, survive.
Secondary offering (non-dilutive). Existing holders sell shares they already own, often through the same banks and the same registration process. The share count does not change and the company receives none of the money. These sales typically follow the end of an IPO lock-up or a private equity owner's gradual exit.
Mixed offerings combine both in one deal; the prospectus supplement says how many shares come from each.
The word "secondary" is used loosely. News stories often call any follow-on a "secondary offering". The prospectus cover settles it: look for who is selling and where the money goes, usually in the section titled "Use of proceeds".
Shelf registration: selling on short notice
Every public sale of securities must be registered with the SEC. An IPO uses a full Form S-1 and weeks of review. A seasoned company usually has a faster route.
- Rule 415 lets a company register securities now and sell them later, in one or several pieces. Securities registered for a continuous or delayed offering may in general be sold for three years from the registration's effective date.
- Form S-3 is the short registration form a company may use once it has a record of timely SEC reporting. It refers to the annual and quarterly reports already on file instead of repeating them.
- A company with $75 million or more of common equity held by non-affiliates (its public float) may sell an unlimited amount of stock off an S-3 shelf (General Instruction I.B.1). A smaller listed company may use the form, but may sell no more than one-third of its public float in any 12 months (I.B.6, the "baby shelf" limit).
When the company decides to sell, it files a prospectus supplement under Rule 424(b) with the deal's terms: number of shares, price, underwriting discount, use of proceeds and the latest risk factors. The deal can launch after the close and price overnight.
The kinds of deals
- Marketed follow-on. The banks take orders over a day or two, much like a short IPO, and price at a discount to the market.
- Overnight or bought deal. Launched after the close and priced before the next open; in a bought deal a bank buys the whole block at a fixed price and takes the risk of reselling it.
- Block trade. A large holder sells a block to one or a few banks, which resell it to institutions, often within hours.
- At-the-market (ATM) program. Rule 415(a)(4) defines an at the market offering as one into an existing trading market at other than a fixed price. The company appoints a sales agent and sells new shares a few at a time in ordinary trading, at whatever the market pays. It avoids a single big discount, but holders learn how much was sold only when the company reports it, usually in its next quarterly filing.
A real prospectus supplement: Carnival, April 2020
In the first weeks of the pandemic Carnival's cruises stopped. On April 1, 2020 it filed a prospectus supplement (Form 424B5) to a shelf prospectus dated March 9, 2018. The cover page gives the terms:
- 62,500,000 shares of common stock at $8.00 a share, $500 million in total.
- Underwriting discount $0.24 a share, $15 million in total, so Carnival received $7.76 a share, $485 million before its other expenses.
- An option for the underwriters to buy 9,375,000 more shares.
- The last reported sale on the NYSE on April 1, 2020 was $8.80. On our data the stock had closed March 31 at $13.17, so a third of the price went between the March 31 close and the April 1 pricing.
- Delivery on or about April 6, 2020.
Three numbers fall out. The price to investors was 9.1% below the last trade ($8.00 ÷ $8.80). The banks' discount was 3.0% of the offering price ($0.24 ÷ $8.00), well under the 7% common in mid-sized IPOs. And every holder's stake was diluted by the new shares, in exchange for cash for a company whose revenue had stopped. The same supplement describes two concurrent private offerings, $4.0 billion of 11.50% senior secured notes and $1.75 billion of 5.75% convertible notes, so the share sale was one part of a larger financing; SEC filings explained: 10-K, 10-Q, 8-K, proxy, 13F and more shows where to find the rest.
Worked example: what dilution does and does not do
An invented company has 100 million shares, earns $200 million a year and trades at $50. It sells 10 million new shares at $46.
- Earnings per share fall from $2.00 to $1.82 in the first year, because the new cash earns nothing yet.
- A holder of 1 million shares owned 1.00% of the company and now owns 0.91%.
- The company has $460 million more cash (before fees).
Whether holders are worse off depends on the last line. If the $460 million repays debt costing 8% a year, interest falls by $36.8 million before tax, and much of the lost earnings per share comes back. If it funds a project that earns more than the company's cost of capital, holders gain. If it plugs losses, the dilution buys time and nothing else. A sale at a deep discount to a stock's value hurts the most, because new buyers get more of the company per dollar than the old holders paid.
How prices react
A primary offering is usually priced below the last trade, as Carnival's was, and the stock often trades down toward the offering price once a deal is announced. Two separate things are happening: the discount needed to sell a large block quickly, and what the market infers from the sale (that management thinks the stock is fully priced, or that the company needs cash). A secondary sale by holders carries only the first, plus whatever the market reads into an insider selling.
Pitfalls
- Ignoring the ATM. A company with an active ATM program can add shares every day. Check the quarterly report for shares sold under it.
- Reading "secondary" as harmless. Check the use of proceeds: many "secondary offerings" in the news are primary.
- Forgetting the over-allotment. An option for 15% more shares, like Carnival's, can make the dilution larger than the headline.
- Judging by the share count alone. The question is the price and the use of the cash.
Comparison of ways to sell stock
| Method | New shares? | Speed | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Marketed deal | Usually | 1–2 days | Fixed, after bids |
| Overnight deal | Often | Overnight | Fixed, overnight |
| ATM program | Yes | Months | Market price |
| Block trade | No | Hours | Fixed, to banks |
| Rights offering | Yes | Weeks | Set by the issuer |
Warrants and rights offerings: how they work and how they dilute covers the last row, which offers new shares to existing holders first.
How Finabase helps
A symbol's News tab, for example Carnival's, carries offering announcements as they are made, and its chart shows the price reaction. The quarterly balance sheet on the Financials tab shows the cash a sale brought in. To weigh a sale against the company's past buybacks, see Stock buybacks: how share repurchases work and what they do, which is the same decision run in reverse.
Frequently asked questions
Is a secondary offering bad for a stock?
A sale of new shares dilutes existing holders and is usually priced below the market, so the stock often falls on the news. Whether holders end up worse off depends on the price and on what the company does with the cash. A sale by existing holders creates no new shares.
What is the difference between a follow-on and a secondary offering?
"Follow-on" means any offering after the IPO. Strictly, a "secondary" offering is one in which existing holders sell; one in which the company sells new shares is primary. The news uses the terms loosely, so read the prospectus.
What is a shelf registration?
It is a registration statement, usually on Form S-3 under Rule 415, that registers stock the company may sell over the following three years. Each actual sale is a prospectus supplement filed on the day.
What is an at-the-market (ATM) offering?
An ATM program sells new shares gradually into the market at current prices through a sales agent, rather than in one discounted block. Companies report the amount sold in their periodic filings.
Why do companies sell stock at a discount?
To sell a large number of shares in a day, they must pay buyers to take on more stock than the market normally trades. Carnival's April 2020 offering was priced 9.1% below the last trade.
Summary
A follow-on is any stock sale after the IPO. A primary one creates new shares and gives the company cash; a secondary one transfers existing shares and gives the company nothing. Most seasoned companies sell off a Form S-3 shelf under Rule 415, filing a prospectus supplement on the day, and many run at-the-market programs. Carnival's April 2020 sale of 62.5 million shares at $8.00, 9.1% below the last trade and with a 3.0% bank discount, shows the terms in a real filing. Dilution is a cost; whether it is worth paying depends on the price and on what the cash earns.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A private equity fund that owns 30% of a listed company sells 10 million of its shares in a registered offering. What happens to the company’s share count and cash?
- Both rise by the size of the sale
- Neither changes: existing shares changed hands and the fund got the money
- The share count falls and the company pays the fund
Show the answer
B. Neither changes: existing shares changed hands and the fund got the money This is a secondary sale in the strict sense. No new shares are created, so other holders are not diluted, and the proceeds go to the selling holder, not the company.
Carnival sold shares at $8.00 when the last trade was $8.80, and paid the banks $0.24 a share. Which is right?
- Investors paid 9.1% below the last trade and Carnival received $7.76 a share
- Investors paid $8.80 and Carnival received $8.00
- Carnival paid a 7% spread, like a mid-sized IPO
Show the answer
A. Investors paid 9.1% below the last trade and Carnival received $7.76 a share $8.00 ÷ $8.80 − 1 = −9.1%. The underwriting discount of $0.24 is 3.0% of $8.00, leaving Carnival $7.76 a share before other expenses.
A listed company has a public float of $60 million and a Form S-3 shelf. How much stock may it sell off the shelf in the next 12 months under the baby shelf rule?
- Any amount
- Up to $20 million, one-third of its public float
- Nothing, because S-3 requires a $75 million float
Show the answer
B. Up to $20 million, one-third of its public float Below $75 million of public float, General Instruction I.B.6 lets a listed company use Form S-3 but caps primary sales at one-third of its public float in any 12 months: $20 million here.
A company sells 10% more shares and uses the cash to repay debt costing 9% a year. Compared with using it to cover operating losses, this is:
- Worse, because debt repayment creates more shares
- Identical, because dilution is the same either way
- Better for holders, because the saved interest offsets part of the drop in earnings per share
Show the answer
C. Better for holders, because the saved interest offsets part of the drop in earnings per share The dilution is the same, but repaying expensive debt raises future earnings, which partly or fully restores earnings per share. Cash that plugs losses buys time without adding earnings.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open Carnival’s chart and find early April 2020, when it sold 62.5 million new shares at $8.00 on April 1 with the last trade at $8.80. Where did the stock trade in the weeks after the sale, compared with the $8.00 offering price? Remember that the chart is adjusted only for splits, so these are prices of the day.
Open Carnival’s chartWhat you should find
The stock closed March 31, 2020 at about $13, fell to $8.80 on the day the sale was priced, dipped below the $8.00 offering price soon after and closed June at about $16. The discount was the price of selling a large block in a hurry; it neither protected the buyers nor predicted the next three months.
Sources and further reading
- Carnival Corporation — prospectus supplement (Form 424B5) for 62,500,000 shares, dated April 1, 2020, to the prospectus of March 9, 2018
- SEC — Rule 415, delayed or continuous offering and sale of securities (17 CFR 230.415), including the definition of an at the market offering
- SEC — Form S-3, General Instructions I.B.1 ($75 million public float) and I.B.6 (one-third of public float in 12 months)
- Finabase chart data — quarterly bars of Carnival (CCL), frozen November 2026
