Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Protect your money Lesson 12 of 13

Investing basics · Brokers and automated investing

SIPC coverage: what it protects if your broker fails, and its limits

How SIPC’s $500,000 protection works in a brokerage failure, what it excludes, how a liquidation runs, and what happened to customers of Lehman and MF Global.

On this page
  1. What SIPC is
  2. What is covered, and what is not
  3. How a liquidation works
  4. Real cases: Lehman Brothers and MF Global
  5. Excess SIPC
  6. Pitfalls
  7. How Finabase helps
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding
  11. Exercise

Most people know that bank deposits are insured. Fewer know what protects a brokerage account. The answer is the Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC), a nonprofit created by Congress in 1970, and it works very differently from bank insurance. SIPC steps in when a brokerage firm that is a member fails and customer securities or cash are missing. It does not step in when investments simply lose value.

That distinction is the whole lesson. If your stocks fall 40%, SIPC does nothing. If your broker collapses and your shares cannot be found, SIPC helps get them back, or pays the value of what is missing, up to a limit. This page explains the limit, the exclusions, how a liquidation actually runs, why customers of two of the biggest brokerage failures in US history got their property back, and what "excess SIPC" coverage adds.

What SIPC is

SIPC was created by the Securities Investor Protection Act of 1970 (SIPA), after a wave of brokerage failures in the late 1960s. Almost every broker-dealer registered with the SEC must be a member and pay assessments into the SIPC fund. SIPC is not a government agency and is not the FDIC; it is a nonprofit membership corporation overseen by the SEC.

It sits on top of a more important protection: the SEC's customer protection rule, Rule 15c3-3, which requires brokers to keep customers' fully paid securities and a reserve of customer cash separate from the firm's own assets. When that rule is followed, a failed broker still has its customers' property in hand, and the main job is moving it. SIPC is the backstop for when property is missing because of fraud, bad records or a shortfall in segregation.

What is covered, and what is not

SIPC covers securities and cash held by a member firm for customers. Securities include stocks, bonds, Treasury securities, certificates of deposit, mutual funds and money market funds. Cash is covered when it is in the account in connection with buying or selling securities.

The limit is $500,000 per customer, including no more than $250,000 for cash. It applies per separate capacity: an individual account, a joint account, an IRA and a trust account held by the same person each get their own limit, while two individual accounts in the same name are added together. The Brokerage accounts explained: types, opening, fees and protection lesson works through an example.

SIPC lists what it does not protect:

  • a decline in market value, for any reason;
  • worthless securities, bad advice or unsuitable investments;
  • commodity futures contracts and cash related to them, unless held in a portfolio margining account;
  • foreign exchange trades;
  • investment contracts, such as limited partnerships, and fixed annuities that are not registered with the SEC;
  • digital or crypto assets that are not securities, including stablecoins.
Situation SIPC helps?
Broker fails, shares missing from records Yes
Broker fails, all assets found intact Moves them
Your stock goes bankrupt No
Your broker gave poor advice No
Futures account at a failed firm No
Bitcoin held through a crypto exchange No

Cash swept out to a bank is a bank deposit, covered by FDIC rules rather than SIPC; the Cash sweep programs: where idle brokerage cash goes and what it earns lesson explains the difference.

How a liquidation works

What happens when a SIPC member firm fails 1. Firm fails Member broker-dealer cannot return customer property; SIPC steps in 2. Court appoints a trustee under SIPA (or SIPC acts directly in small cases) 3. Accounts move Trustee transfers whole accounts to another firm where it can 4. Claims Customers left behind file claims; customer property shared pro rata 5. SIPC advance Fills any shortfall up to $500,000 a customer, cash up to $250,000 Not covered Market losses, bad advice, non-security crypto, futures, forex SIPC replaces missing securities and cash. It never restores a fall in their value.
The usual sequence of a SIPA liquidation. SIPC can also pay customers directly in small cases without a court-appointed trustee.

When a member firm cannot meet its obligations to customers, SIPC asks a federal court to place it in liquidation under SIPA. The court appoints a trustee (in small cases SIPC can act directly). Then:

  1. Bulk transfer. Wherever possible the trustee moves whole customer accounts, with their positions, to a healthy broker within days or weeks. Customers end up with a new firm and the same holdings.
  2. Claims. Customers whose accounts cannot be moved file a claim stating their net equity: what the account would be worth if open positions were closed on the day of the filing.
  3. Customer property. All the securities and cash the failed firm held for customers form a separate pool, shared among customers in proportion to their net equity before general creditors get anything.
  4. SIPC advances. If a customer's share of the pool falls short of their net equity, SIPC advances money to replace the missing securities or cash, up to the limits.

The SIPC limit applies to the shortfall, not to the account size. A large account at a firm with only a small hole can be made whole.

Real cases: Lehman Brothers and MF Global

Lehman Brothers Inc. The broker-dealer of the failed investment bank went into a SIPA liquidation on September 19, 2008, with James W. Giddens as trustee. According to the trustee, more than 110,000 customer accounts holding over $92 billion were transferred to other firms within weeks. When the court closed the case on September 28, 2022, customers had received $106 billion, fully satisfying 111,000 customer claims, and general creditors had recovered about 41%. SIPC's release stresses that this was done without government or SIPC funds: customer property, segregated as the rules require, was enough.

MF Global Inc. The futures and securities broker failed in October 2011, and SIPC started its liquidation on October 31, 2011. MF Global is a useful case because much of its business was commodity futures, which SIPC does not cover. Securities customers were protected by SIPA; futures customers depended on the trustee's recovery of segregated funds. In April 2014 a final distribution of $6.7 billion to about 26,000 former securities and commodity futures customers fully satisfied their claims. That outcome came from recoveries, not from SIPC extending its coverage to futures.

Across its history, SIPC says it has helped an estimated 773,000 investors recover $143.8 billion of assets, for which SIPC itself advanced $3.6 billion. The pattern is the point: most of the money comes back from customer property, and SIPC's advances cover the gaps.

Excess SIPC

Many brokers buy excess SIPC coverage from private insurers, which applies after SIPC's limits are used up. It is not a government program, and policies differ: there is usually an aggregate cap for all customers of the firm, sometimes a per-customer cash cap, and the insurer's own strength matters. Read the firm's disclosure rather than the marketing line.

Pitfalls

  • Treating SIPC as investment insurance. It never restores a fall in value.
  • Assuming every app is a SIPC member. Crypto exchanges, futures commission merchants and some payment apps are not SIPC members, and assets that are not securities are excluded even at a member. Check the member list at sipc.org.
  • Counting accounts as separate when they are not. Two individual accounts in your own name at one firm share one limit.
  • Keeping very large cash balances at a broker. Cash has the lower $250,000 cap; swept bank deposits fall under FDIC rules instead.

How Finabase helps

Finabase is not a broker and holds no customer assets, so SIPC does not apply to it. A Finabase portfolio can mirror the holdings you keep at each brokerage firm, which makes it easy to see how much of your money sits at one firm and in which account types, the numbers that matter when you check SIPC's separate-capacity limits. For a listed broker, the financials page shows its revenue and earnings history.

Frequently asked questions

Is my brokerage account insured?

Not against market losses. If your SIPC-member broker fails with assets missing, SIPC protects up to $500,000 per customer per separate capacity, including up to $250,000 in cash.

What happens to my stocks if my broker goes bankrupt?

Usually they are transferred to another broker. Customer securities are kept separate from the firm's assets, and in a SIPA liquidation the trustee moves accounts in bulk where possible; any shortfall is shared and then topped up by SIPC within its limits.

Does SIPC cover crypto?

Only crypto assets that legally qualify as securities and are held at a SIPC member, and SIPC excludes digital asset securities that are unregistered investment contracts. It does not protect digital assets that are not securities, and the statute's definition of a security excludes stablecoins.

What is the difference between SIPC and FDIC?

FDIC insures bank deposits against a bank's failure, up to $250,000 per depositor per bank per ownership category. SIPC replaces missing securities and cash at a failed broker-dealer, up to $500,000. Neither protects against investment losses.

Summary

SIPC protects customers of a failed member broker-dealer when their securities or cash are missing, up to $500,000 per separate capacity including $250,000 of cash. It does not cover market losses, bad advice, futures, forex or crypto that is not a security. In practice the main protection is segregation under Rule 15c3-3: in the Lehman Brothers Inc. liquidation, customers received $106 billion and every one of 111,000 claims was satisfied in full without SIPC money, and MF Global's customers were also repaid in full. SIPC's fund fills the gaps that remain, and excess SIPC policies add private coverage above that.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. You own $80,000 of a stock at a SIPC-member broker. The company goes bankrupt and the shares become worthless. The broker is healthy. What does SIPC pay?

    1. $80,000, the full loss
    2. Nothing: SIPC covers a broker’s failure, not an investment’s fall in value
    3. Up to $250,000, the cash limit
    Show the answer

    B. Nothing: SIPC covers a broker’s failure, not an investment’s fall in value SIPC replaces missing securities and cash when a member firm fails. A share losing value, even to zero, is a market loss, which SIPC never covers.

  2. A failed broker can find 95% of customer property. Your net equity is $1,200,000, all in securities. What is your likely outcome?

    1. You lose everything above $500,000
    2. You receive 95% ($1,140,000) from customer property, and SIPC can advance the $60,000 shortfall, so you are made whole
    3. You receive $500,000 from SIPC and nothing else
    Show the answer

    B. You receive 95% ($1,140,000) from customer property, and SIPC can advance the $60,000 shortfall, so you are made whole Customer property is shared pro rata first. SIPC’s limit applies to the advance that fills the shortfall, here $60,000, which is well under $500,000.

  3. Which of these holdings at a SIPC-member firm is outside SIPC protection?

    1. Shares of a money market mutual fund
    2. A commodity futures contract in an ordinary futures account
    3. US Treasury bills
    Show the answer

    B. A commodity futures contract in an ordinary futures account SIPC covers securities such as fund shares and Treasuries, but excludes commodity futures and related cash unless they sit in a portfolio margining account.

  4. Why did Lehman Brothers Inc. customers get all their property back without SIPC money?

    1. Because the government bailed out the broker
    2. Because customer property had been kept separate from the firm’s own assets and was enough to satisfy the claims
    3. Because Lehman’s accounts were all under $500,000
    Show the answer

    B. Because customer property had been kept separate from the firm’s own assets and was enough to satisfy the claims The customer protection rule requires brokers to segregate customer securities and cash. In the Lehman liquidation that pool, transferred and distributed by the trustee, covered all 111,000 customer claims.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Take the latest statement of each brokerage account you hold, or invent a household with an individual account, a joint account and an IRA at one firm. For each account note its ownership capacity, its securities and its cash. Add up the totals per capacity at each firm and compare them with SIPC’s limit of $500,000, of which up to $250,000 may be cash.

What you should find

Each separate capacity gets its own limit, while two individual accounts in the same name at one firm are added together. Cash swept out to a bank falls under FDIC rules instead. Most failures end with accounts moved in bulk to another broker. SIPC never covers a fall in market value, bad advice, or crypto assets that are not securities.

Sources and further reading

  1. SIPC — What SIPC protects
  2. SIPC — Investors with multiple accounts
  3. SIPC — History and track record
  4. SIPC news release — Lehman Brothers Inc. liquidation closes (2022-09-28)
  5. SIPC news release — Liquidation proceeding for MF Global Inc. (2011-10-31)
  6. SIPC news release — MF Global final distribution, $6.7 billion to 26,000 customers (2014-04-03)
  7. Securities Investor Protection Act of 1970, 15 U.S.C. § 78aaa et seq.
  8. SEC — Customer protection rule, 17 CFR 240.15c3-3