Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investing basics · Stocks in depth

Going-private deals: LBOs, Rule 13e-3 and what holders receive

How public companies are taken private: leveraged buyouts, management buyouts, Rule 13e-3 disclosure and appraisal rights, traced through Twitter’s $54.20 buyout in 2022.

On this page
  1. How a take-private works
  2. Rule 13e-3
  3. Twitter: a take-private that nearly failed
  4. Appraisal rights
  5. Pitfalls
  6. Take-private, strategic takeover and IPO compared
  7. How Finabase helps
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

A company goes private when a buyer acquires all its public shares and the stock leaves the exchange. The buyer might be a private equity firm, a wealthy individual, the company's own managers, or a controlling shareholder buying out the minority. For the public holders the result is the same: their shares are converted into cash, and the company stops trading.

Going-private deals differ from ordinary takeovers in who is buying and how it is paid for. Most are financed with a lot of debt, and many have insiders on the buying side, which is why the SEC adds a disclosure rule for them. This lesson covers the shape of a take-private, the leveraged buyout behind most of them, Rule 13e-3, and the appraisal rights that let a holder ask a court for a different price. The worked case is Twitter, taken private by Elon Musk for $54.20 a share in October 2022, after an attempt to walk away.

How a take-private works

The mechanics are those of any cash takeover, covered in Mergers and acquisitions: what happens to your shares in a deal. The buyer signs a merger agreement with the board, the shareholders vote (or tender their shares, as in Tender offers: how they work, Dutch auctions and proration), and on closing every public share is converted into the cash price. The stock is suspended and removed from the exchange with a Form 25, as the Delisting: why stocks leave an exchange and what holders keep lesson describes, and the company usually stops filing reports with the SEC.

What differs is the buyer. A strategic buyer, like Microsoft buying Activision, wants the business to combine with its own. A financial buyer wants to own the company on its own for a few years, improve or restructure it, and sell it or relist it later. Because the company is no longer public, the new owners avoid quarterly reporting and market pressure, at the price of running a business with far more debt.

The leveraged buyout

In a leveraged buyout the buyer puts up a slice of equity and borrows the rest. The loans are raised against the target's own assets and cash flows, so after closing the company itself owes them. How much is borrowed depends on the company's cash flows and on how willing lenders are at the time.

For the selling shareholders the debt is irrelevant: they are paid in cash. For anyone who later lends to or invests in the company, it changes everything. Interest has to be paid before any profit reaches the owners, so a heavily indebted company has less room when business turns down; the What happens to your stock when a company goes bankrupt lesson explains what happens when the debt cannot be paid.

Management buyouts and controlling holders

When the buyers include the company's own managers or a controlling shareholder, holders face a conflict of interest: the people who know the business best, and who may influence the board, are on the other side of the deal. Delaware courts look at such deals more closely, and boards typically form a special committee of independent directors to negotiate. The SEC adds its own disclosure rule.

Rule 13e-3

Rule 13e-3 under the Exchange Act applies when a company or one of its affiliates carries out a transaction that would take a class of shares off an exchange, or leave it held by fewer than 300 holders of record, so that the company can stop reporting. An affiliate is someone who controls, or is under common control with, the company: typically senior management in a buyout, or a parent company buying out the minority.

Those parties must file a Schedule 13E-3 and send its information to holders. It asks for more than a normal merger proxy, including:

  • the purpose of the deal and the alternatives considered;
  • whether each filer believes the deal is fair to unaffiliated holders, and why;
  • any reports, opinions or appraisals from outside advisers that bear on fairness, in summary;
  • the effects on the company and on the holders who are being cashed out.

The rule also catches small-company schemes such as a reverse split that cashes out small holders to get below 300 holders of record. A deal led by an unrelated buyer, with no insiders on the buying side, normally falls outside it.

Twitter: a take-private that nearly failed

Twitter's merger agreement with X Holdings, majority-owned and controlled by Elon Musk, was dated April 25, 2022: $54.20 a share in cash.

Twitter against the $54.20 buyout price, weekly $25 $35 $45 $55 $65 2022-01 2022-04 2022-07 2022-10 Deal price $54.20 Agreement Musk tries to end it Holders approve Closed TWTR weekly closes, Nov 2021 to Oct 27, 2022. Finabase data; $54.20 from the merger agreement.
Twitter (TWTR) weekly closes, November 2021 to October 27, 2022, against the $54.20 buyout price. Finabase data.
Week Event Close Gap to $54.20
to Apr 29 Agreement signed $49.02 10.6%
to Jul 8 Termination notice $36.81 47.2%
to Sep 16 Holders approve $41.45 30.8%
last close Deal closes Oct 27 $53.70 0.9%

On July 8, 2022, Musk's advisers sent Twitter a letter purporting to terminate the agreement, disclosed in an amendment to his Schedule 13D the same day. Twitter's closing price that day, $36.81, left a gap of 47.2% to the deal price: the market was pricing a real chance that the shareholders would end up with an independent company worth far less. Twitter sued in the Delaware Court of Chancery on July 12 to enforce the agreement.

At a special meeting on September 13, 2022, holders voted 453,106,848 shares for the merger and 4,149,957 against, with 2,387,234 abstaining: about 99.1% of the for-and-against votes, and, as Twitter's 8-K put it, holders of about 59.2% of all outstanding shares, above the majority of outstanding shares the merger needed. The gap was still about 31% that week, because the vote did not settle the lawsuit. The deal finally closed on October 27, 2022. The NYSE suspended the shares before the open on October 28.

Every holder who kept the stock received $54.20. The lesson of the chart is that a signed agreement is not cash in hand until the deal closes, and that the gap can widen sharply when the buyer's commitment is in doubt.

Appraisal rights

A holder who thinks the cash price is too low has one legal alternative to accepting it. Under Section 262 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, a shareholder of a Delaware company in a cash merger can ask the Court of Chancery to determine the fair value of the shares. To keep the right, the holder must, in brief:

  • make a written demand for appraisal before the vote;
  • not vote in favour of the merger;
  • hold the shares continuously through the closing.

The court then sets a value, which can be above, equal to or below the deal price, plus interest. For listed shares there is a size threshold, so small holders usually cannot use it on their own. Twitter's closing 8-K excluded shares whose holders had properly demanded appraisal from the $54.20 conversion. Appraisal is slow, expensive and uncertain, and it is mostly used by funds that buy shares specifically to pursue it. The Shareholder rights: what owning common stock really entitles you to lesson places it among a holder's other rights.

Pitfalls

  • Assuming the deal will close. Twitter showed how far a target can fall when a buyer tries to leave.
  • Ignoring the conflict. In a management buyout, read the special committee's process and the fairness discussion in the Schedule 13E-3.
  • Waiting for a higher bid. Rival bids happen, but most agreed deals close at the agreed price.
  • Taxes. Cash from a take-private is a taxable sale for US holders outside retirement accounts.

Take-private, strategic takeover and IPO compared

Event Buyer or seller Holders get Stock afterwards
Take-private Sponsor, insiders Cash Delisted
Strategic deal Another company Cash or its stock Delisted
IPO Company sells shares New listing Listed

Many take-private companies return to the market years later through an IPO, the reverse journey covered in How IPOs work: from S-1 filing to first trade and lock-up.

How Finabase helps

Before a take-private, the Ownership tab shows how much of a company insiders and large funds hold, which tells you how much of the vote is already committed. The Screener can list small and mid-sized companies by valuation, the pool private equity buyers fish in. Finabase does not track pending going-private deals or Schedule 13E-3 filings; those are on EDGAR under the company's name.

Frequently asked questions

What happens to my shares when a company goes private?

They are converted into the deal price, usually cash, at closing and removed from your account. The company leaves the exchange, so there is nothing left to trade.

What is Rule 13e-3?

An SEC rule that applies when a company or an affiliate, such as its management or a controlling holder, takes it private. It requires a Schedule 13E-3 explaining the purpose, the alternatives and whether the filers believe the price is fair to unaffiliated holders.

Can I refuse a buyout offer?

Not in a merger approved by the required vote: your shares are converted either way. In a Delaware cash merger you can instead demand appraisal, if you meet the conditions, and let a court set the value.

How much did Twitter shareholders get?

$54.20 a share in cash, when the deal closed on October 27, 2022.

Summary

A going-private deal buys out every public share, usually for cash, and takes the company off the exchange. Most are leveraged buyouts that load the company with debt, and when insiders are among the buyers, Rule 13e-3 requires a Schedule 13E-3 that discusses fairness to the holders being cashed out. Delaware's appraisal rights offer a route to a court-set value for holders who meet strict conditions. Twitter's $54.20 deal, signed in April 2022, showed the risk between signing and closing: the gap to the deal price reached 47.2% when the buyer tried to walk away, before the deal closed on October 27, 2022.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. What makes a leveraged buyout different from an ordinary cash takeover, from the selling shareholder’s point of view?

    1. Nothing much: sellers are paid cash either way; the difference is the debt the company carries afterwards
    2. Sellers receive bonds instead of cash
    3. Sellers keep a share of the company
    Show the answer

    A. Nothing much: sellers are paid cash either way; the difference is the debt the company carries afterwards In an LBO the buyer borrows heavily against the target itself. Selling holders are paid in cash; the debt matters to the company and its future lenders and owners.

  2. When does Rule 13e-3 require a Schedule 13E-3?

    1. In every acquisition of a public company
    2. When the company or an affiliate, such as management or a controlling holder, takes the company private
    3. Only when the company goes bankrupt
    Show the answer

    B. When the company or an affiliate, such as management or a controlling holder, takes the company private The rule targets conflicts of interest. When insiders are on the buying side, they must disclose the deal’s purpose, alternatives and whether they believe it is fair to unaffiliated holders.

  3. On July 8, 2022, Twitter closed at $36.81 against a $54.20 deal price. Why was the gap so wide?

    1. The deal price had been lowered
    2. The buyer had sent notice that it was terminating the agreement, so the market doubted the deal would close
    3. Twitter had paid a special dividend
    Show the answer

    B. The buyer had sent notice that it was terminating the agreement, so the market doubted the deal would close The 47.2% gap priced a real chance that holders would be left with an independent company. The deal closed at $54.20 on October 27, 2022.

  4. A Delaware company is bought for cash and you think the price is too low. What legal route is available?

    1. None: you must accept the price
    2. Appraisal under DGCL §262, if you do not vote for the deal and follow the required steps
    3. Keeping your shares after the merger
    Show the answer

    B. Appraisal under DGCL §262, if you do not vote for the deal and follow the required steps Appraisal lets a qualifying holder ask the Court of Chancery to set fair value. The court may award more, the same or less than the deal price.

Sources and further reading

  1. SEC — Rule 13e-3 (going-private transactions by certain issuers or their affiliates) and Schedule 13E-3, 17 CFR 240.13e-3 and 240.13e-100 (read November 2026)
  2. Twitter — Form 8-K of October 28, 2022 (merger with X Holdings completed October 27, 2022; $54.20 per share; appraisal shares excluded; NYSE suspension)
  3. Twitter — Form 8-K of September 13, 2022, Item 5.07 (special meeting vote on the merger)
  4. Elon Musk — Schedule 13D/A of July 8, 2022 (notice of termination of the merger agreement)
  5. Delaware General Corporation Law §262 (appraisal rights) (read November 2026)
  6. Finabase data — Twitter (TWTR) weekly closes, November 2021 to October 27, 2022