Investing basics · Stocks in depth
Tender offers: how they work, Dutch auctions and proration
Third-party and issuer tender offers under US rules: the 20-business-day minimum, withdrawal rights, Dutch auctions, odd-lot priority and how proration is calculated.
On this page
A tender offer is a public offer to buy shares directly from a company's shareholders, at a stated price, for a limited time. Instead of buying on the market or negotiating with a board, the bidder writes to every holder and asks them to "tender" their shares. It is how a buyer can take control of a company quickly, and how a company can buy back a large block of its own stock at once.
For a shareholder, a tender offer is a decision with a deadline: tender or keep. This lesson explains the two kinds of offer, the US rules that protect holders while one is open, how a Dutch auction sets the price, and how proration decides how many shares are accepted when more are tendered than the bidder wants. The real example is Johnson & Johnson's August 2023 exchange offer for its Kenvue shares, which was oversubscribed about four times.
Two kinds of tender offer
Third-party offers. A buyer offers to purchase a target's shares, usually at a premium to the market, and usually on conditions: often that a minimum number of shares is tendered, so the buyer ends up with a majority. Many friendly takeovers use this route instead of a shareholder vote. If the buyer reaches a majority and the merger agreement provides for it, Delaware law (Section 251(h)) lets it complete a merger straight away for the remaining shares at the same price, so holders who did not tender are bought out a few days later anyway. The Mergers and acquisitions: what happens to your shares in a deal lesson covers the vote route.
The bidder files a Schedule TO with the SEC on the day the offer starts. The target's board must tell holders within 10 business days whether it recommends accepting, rejecting or takes no position (Rule 14e-2), usually on a Schedule 14D-9. A hostile offer is one the board opposes.
Issuer offers. A company offers to buy back its own shares. It is a faster and larger way to repurchase than buying on the market, which the Stock buybacks: how share repurchases work and what they do lesson describes. The company files a Schedule TO-I. A company can also offer shares of another company it owns in exchange for its own, as J&J did with Kenvue: an exchange offer, used as a "split-off" (the Spin-offs: how they work, when-issued trading and your cost basis lesson compares it with a spin-off).
The rules that protect holders
Tender offers in the US are governed by Section 14(d) and 14(e) of the Exchange Act and the SEC's rules under them. Regulation 14E applies to every tender offer; Regulation 14D adds rules for third-party offers for registered shares, and Rule 13e-4 does the same for issuer offers. As of 2026 the main protections are these:
- Minimum period. The offer must stay open at least 20 business days from the day it is first published or sent. If the price or the number of shares sought changes, it must stay open at least 10 business days after the change (Rule 14e-1).
- Withdrawal rights. A holder who tenders can take the shares back at any time while the offer is open.
- All holders, best price. The offer must be open to every holder of the class, and everyone whose shares are bought gets the highest price paid to anyone.
- Pro rata acceptance. If a partial offer is oversubscribed, the bidder buys from each holder in proportion, not first come, first served.
- Prompt payment. The bidder must pay, or return the shares, promptly after the offer ends.
On April 16, 2026 the SEC's Division of Corporation Finance issued an exemptive order allowing a 10-business-day minimum for some offers. The consideration must be cash at a fixed price. An issuer offer must be for less than all of the shares; a third-party offer must be made under a negotiated merger agreement, for all the shares, with the target's Schedule 14D-9 filed by the next business day. Going-private deals under Rule 13e-3 are excluded, and if a rival offer appears the first one must stay open for the full 20 business days.
Dutch auctions
In a fixed-price issuer offer the company names one price and buys up to a set number of shares at it. In a modified Dutch auction it names a range instead, say $40.00 to $44.00, and invites each holder to say the lowest price at which they will sell. When the offer closes, the company lines the tenders up from the lowest price up and finds the lowest price at which it can buy the number of shares it wants. Everyone who tendered at or below that clearing price is paid the clearing price, even those who asked for less. Holders can also tender "at the purchase price", agreeing to whatever the clearing price turns out to be.
Worked example (invented)
A company wants to buy 10 million shares in a $40.00–$44.00 range. The tenders come in like this, counting all shares offered at each price or lower:
At $41.50 only 9.0 million shares are on offer, short of the target. At $42.00 there are 11.5 million. So the clearing price is $42.00, the company spends $420 million, and everyone who tendered at $42.00 or less is paid $42.00. Because 11.5 million shares were tendered at or below that price and the company wants only 10 million, each of those holders has 86.96% of their shares accepted (10 ÷ 11.5). Someone who tendered 1,000 shares at $41.00 sells about 870 at $42.00 and gets the rest back. Shares tendered above $42.00 are all returned.
Companies like the format because the market sets the price, and they can buy back stock without overpaying more than needed. Holders who name a low price to make sure they are included risk nothing: they receive the clearing price anyway.
Proration and odd lots
Proration is the rule that shares the pool fairly. The proration factor is the number of shares the bidder will accept divided by the number tendered (after setting aside any shares taken in full). Each holder's accepted shares are their tendered shares times that factor, with fractions handled as the offer documents say.
Issuer offers may give priority to odd-lot holders: people who own fewer than 100 shares and tender all of them. Their shares are bought in full before proration, which spares the company the cost of leaving thousands of tiny remaining positions.
Johnson & Johnson and Kenvue, August 2023
In 2023 Johnson & Johnson separated its consumer health business, Kenvue, partly through an exchange offer: J&J shareholders could swap J&J shares for Kenvue shares held by J&J. J&J filed its Schedule TO on July 24, 2023, and the offer expired at midnight at the end of August 18, 2023. Its final results, filed on August 23, 2023, show:
- 800,449,685 J&J shares were validly tendered.
- 6,529,526 of them came from odd-lot holders and were accepted in full.
- The other 793,920,159 were subject to a final proration factor of 23.231832%.
- J&J accepted 190,955,436 shares in total and delivered 1,533,830,450 Kenvue shares, an exchange ratio of 8.0324 Kenvue shares per J&J share.
For a holder who tendered 1,000 J&J shares (not an odd lot), the factor means about 232 were accepted and 768 were returned. The 232 accepted shares became about 1,863 Kenvue shares (232 × 8.0324), with cash for the fraction. Split-off exchange offers are usually priced so that the new shares come at a discount to their market value, which explains why so many holders tendered; the proration decided how that discount was shared out.
Pitfalls
- Assuming you will sell everything. In an oversubscribed partial offer you may sell only a fraction, and the rest goes back to you after the offer, possibly at a lower market price.
- Missing the broker's deadline. Brokers collect instructions before the offer's own expiration, often a day or more earlier.
- Mini-tender offers. Offers for less than 5% of a company escape most of Regulation 14D. The SEC warns that some are made below the market price, counting on holders who assume any offer is a premium.
- Taxes. Selling in a cash tender is a taxable sale in the US. An issuer buyback can, in some circumstances, be treated as a dividend; the offer documents explain the treatment.
Tender offer, open-market buyback and merger vote compared
| Route | Who sets price | Speed | Holders choose? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tender offer | Bidder | Weeks | Yes, each |
| Dutch auction | Holders' bids | Weeks | Yes, each |
| Open-market buyback | The market | Months | Only sellers |
| Merger vote | Agreement | Months | By majority |
How Finabase helps
Tender offers are announced as company news, so they appear on a company's News tab and the News page. J&J's chart shows the period of the Kenvue offer, and Kenvue's page has its trading since the 2023 listing. Finabase does not track open tender offers or compute proration; the Schedule TO and its amendments on EDGAR carry the terms and the final results.
Frequently asked questions
What is a tender offer?
A public offer to buy shares directly from shareholders at a set price, or a price range, for a limited time. It can come from an outside buyer or from the company itself.
Should I tender my shares?
That is your decision; this lesson does not advise either way. The offer documents and the board's Schedule 14D-9 or the company's Schedule TO explain the terms, the conditions and the board's view.
What does proration mean in a tender offer?
When more shares are tendered than the bidder will buy, each holder's shares are accepted in the same proportion. In J&J's 2023 Kenvue offer that proportion was 23.231832%.
How long does a tender offer stay open?
At least 20 business days under Rule 14e-1, and 10 more after any change in price or size. Since April 2026 some all-cash, fixed-price offers may run for 10 business days.
Summary
A tender offer asks shareholders to sell directly to a bidder at a stated price within a set window. Outside buyers use it to gain control; companies use it to buy back stock in bulk, often through a Dutch auction in which holders' bids set one clearing price. US rules keep most offers open for 20 business days, let holders withdraw, require the best price for all and divide an oversubscribed offer pro rata, usually after taking odd lots in full. J&J's 2023 Kenvue exchange offer shows proration at work: 800 million shares tendered, a factor of 23.231832%, and about 191 million accepted.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A company runs a Dutch auction for 5 million shares between $20 and $22. Shares tendered at or below $21.00 total 4.6 million, and at or below $21.25 total 6.0 million. What happens?
- The company pays each holder the price they asked for
- The clearing price is $21.25; everyone at or below it is paid $21.25 and prorated to about 83%
- The clearing price is $21.00 and the company buys 4.6 million shares
Show the answer
B. The clearing price is $21.25; everyone at or below it is paid $21.25 and prorated to about 83% $21.25 is the lowest price at which at least 5 million shares are offered. All accepted shares get that single price, and 5 ÷ 6 ≈ 83.3% of each tender is accepted.
In J&J’s 2023 Kenvue exchange offer the proration factor was 23.231832%. A holder of 1,000 J&J shares (not an odd lot) tendered them all. Roughly how many were accepted?
- All 1,000
- About 232
- About 768
Show the answer
B. About 232 Each tendered share outside the odd-lot priority was accepted at the proration factor: 1,000 × 23.23% ≈ 232. The other 768 went back to the holder.
Why can a holder of 60 shares be taken in full in an oversubscribed issuer tender offer when larger holders are prorated?
- Because the SEC requires small holders to be paid first
- Because the offer may give odd-lot priority to holders of fewer than 100 shares who tender all of them
- Because small orders are processed first
Show the answer
B. Because the offer may give odd-lot priority to holders of fewer than 100 shares who tender all of them Issuer tender offers may accept odd lots in full before prorating. J&J did so in 2023, accepting 6,529,526 odd-lot shares without proration.
You tendered shares on day 5 of a 20-business-day tender offer and then changed your mind. What can you do?
- Nothing: a tender is final
- Withdraw the shares while the offer remains open
- Withdraw only if the bidder agrees
Show the answer
B. Withdraw the shares while the offer remains open US tender offer rules give holders withdrawal rights for as long as the offer is open.
Sources and further reading
- SEC — Regulation 14E, including Rule 14e-1 (minimum offer period) and Rule 14e-2 (target’s position), 17 CFR 240.14e-1 to 14e-8 (read November 2026)
- SEC — Rule 13e-4 (issuer tender offers) and Regulation 14D, including Rules 14d-7, 14d-8 and 14d-10, 17 CFR 240 (read November 2026)
- SEC Division of Corporation Finance — Exemptive Order for Tender Offers for Equity Securities (April 16, 2026)
- Johnson & Johnson — Schedule TO-I/A, Amendment No. 4 (August 23, 2023): final results of the Kenvue exchange offer
- Johnson & Johnson — press release filed on Form 425 (August 23, 2023): final results and proration
- SEC — Mini-tender offers: tips for investors
