Trading · Options
Volatility crush: why options lose value after the news is out
How implied volatility builds before a scheduled event and collapses after it, with a worked straddle that loses money on a 6% move, and real VIX data from 2024 and 2025.
On this page
A volatility crush is a sharp fall in an option's implied volatility right after an uncertain event has passed. The best-known case is an earnings report: implied volatility climbs for weeks beforehand, then drops overnight once the numbers are public. Because implied volatility is part of every premium, the drop takes value out of calls and puts alike, whatever the stock does.
This is how a trader can be right about the direction of an earnings move and still lose money on an option. The option was priced for a large move. A move that turns out smaller than the price allowed for leaves the buyer worse off, even if it was in the hoped-for direction.
The Trading earnings season: implied moves, IV crush and earnings gaps lesson introduces the implied move and the crush with real Meta reports. This page takes the mechanism apart: why implied volatility rises into an event in the first place, how much of a premium is at stake, and how large a move it takes to overcome the crush.
The idea: paying for one night
Think of the days in an option's life as carrying risk. Most days carry an ordinary amount. The night of an earnings report carries a great deal: the stock can open 5% or 10% away from where it closed. An option that is alive over that night must charge for it.
Implied volatility is an average over the option's whole remaining life, expressed per year. An option with a few ordinary days and one very large night has a high average. Once the night has passed, only ordinary days remain and the average falls back. Nothing has gone wrong. The option simply no longer covers the event.
The figure shows two things. The collapse after the report is the crush. The climb before it is less obvious and just as mechanical: the size of the expected jump is the same throughout, but as ordinary days drop away, the one large night makes up more and more of what is left.
How it works
The arithmetic of the build-up
Risk adds up as variance, which is volatility squared multiplied by time. An option's total variance is the ordinary days' variance plus the event's.
This also explains why the crush is concentrated in the nearest expirations. An option with a year to run holds the same 0.0081 of event variance against 0.1225 of ordinary variance. Its implied volatility would be about 36% before the report and 35% after.
What the crush does to a position
The premium paid, $8.26 on a $100 stock, is the market's implied move of roughly 8%. The break-evens after the crush sit almost exactly there. That is the general rule: a long option position held through an event makes money only if the actual move exceeds the move that was priced in.
A single call shows the trap for directional traders. The $100 call cost $4.17 before the report. If the stock opens at $103, up 3%, the call is worth $3.87. The trader was right about the direction and lost $0.30 a share.
The seller's side
Everything above reverses for someone who sold the straddle for $8.26. They keep $4.39 if the stock is unchanged and profit anywhere between the break-evens. Their risk is the open-ended loss beyond them: at $85 the straddle is worth about $15, a loss of nearly $7 a share, and earnings gaps of 15% or 20% are not rare. The crush is not free income. It is the premium for standing in front of the move.
Real markets do it too
The same pattern appears around any scheduled event that resolves uncertainty: a central bank decision, a court ruling, a drug approval date, an election.
On November 5, 2024, the day of the US presidential election, the VIX closed at 20.49. The next day it closed at 16.27, a fall of 21% in one session, and by November 8 it was at 14.94. SPY rose from $576.70 to $591.04, or 2.5%, on November 6. The size of the fall in implied volatility reflected the removal of a dated uncertainty more than the direction of the market.
Compare an unscheduled shock. Between April 2 and April 8, 2025, as new US tariffs were announced, the VIX went from 21.51 to 52.33 while SPY fell 12%, from $564.52 to $496.48. There was no build-up in advance, because nobody had the date in a calendar. On April 9, when a pause was announced, the VIX dropped to 33.62, down 36% in a day, and SPY rose 10.5%. Implied volatility can collapse after an unscheduled panic too, but only a scheduled event lets you see the crush coming.
Where it fails
The crush is known in advance, so it is in the price. Buying options before earnings is not a mistake because of the crush, and selling them is not an edge because of it. The premium before the event already contains the expected fall in implied volatility. What decides the outcome is the realized move against the implied move.
The model on this page is simplified. It treats the event as a single jump with a known size and ordinary volatility as constant. In practice implied volatility after a report depends on the report: a result that raises new questions can leave it elevated.
Not every report produces a crush of the same size. Options on a stock whose reports rarely move it carry little event premium to lose.
Longer-dated options are not immune to losses. Their implied volatility barely moves, but they are still exposed to the stock's gap through delta.
Stock price and implied volatility both change overnight. There is no chance to adjust in between. Stops and alerts on option positions do not protect against a gap at the open.
Compared with its neighbours
| Effect | Cause | Speed | Predictable in timing? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volatility crush | A scheduled uncertainty is resolved | Overnight | Yes |
| Time decay | One day fewer until expiration | Every day | Yes |
| Volatility spike | An unexpected shock | Minutes to days | No |
| Mean reversion of volatility | Fear fades after a shock | Days to months | No |
| Vega loss | Any fall in implied volatility | Any | n/a: it is the measure |
Vega is the tool for sizing a crush: the change in an option's price for each point of implied volatility. A fall of 35 points is too large for vega alone to be accurate, which is why the example re-prices the options in full.
How Finabase does it
Finabase gives you the two things needed to see an event premium. The earnings calendar lists the companies reporting each day, and each symbol page's earnings tab, for example NVDA, shows the next expected report date. The option chain shows the implied volatility of every contract for every listed expiration. Click through the expirations before a report: the first one that falls after the report date will show a clearly higher at-the-money implied volatility than the expirations before it and a higher one than those far beyond it.
Finabase does not chart a stock's implied volatility over time, does not compute an implied move, and does not mark earnings dates on the option chain. For the market-wide picture, the VIX chart shows the falls of November 2024 and April 2025 described above. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.
Frequently asked questions
How much does implied volatility drop after earnings?
It depends on how much of the option's life the event was. In the nearest weekly expiration a fall of a third to a half is common; in an option several months out the fall is a few points. The example on this page, from 70% to 35% with a week left, is at the large end.
Can you avoid a volatility crush?
Not while holding options through the event. A position that is long options loses the event premium by definition. Spreads that are long one option and short another offset part of it, because the short leg gains what the long leg loses.
Why did my call lose money when the stock went up after earnings?
Because the rise was smaller than the move the option was priced for. The gain from the stock moving was outweighed by the loss from implied volatility falling back to its ordinary level.
Does a volatility crush happen only around earnings?
No. Any dated event can produce one: central bank meetings, elections, regulatory decisions, product launches, index inclusion announcements.
Summary
Options that span a scheduled event carry extra premium for the move the event may cause, and their implied volatility rises as the event comes to dominate their remaining life. When the event passes, the extra premium vanishes and implied volatility falls overnight, most of all in the nearest expirations. A straddle bought at 70% implied volatility for $8.26 was worth $3.87 after an unchanged open and needed a move of about 8% to break even. The crush is expected and priced in, so the result of holding options through an event depends on whether the actual move is larger or smaller than the implied one.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
A stock’s options show 60% implied volatility the day before earnings. The report is in line and the stock opens unchanged. What happens to the nearest-expiration options?
- Nothing, because the stock did not move
- Calls and puts both lose value as implied volatility falls back
- Calls lose value and puts gain
Show the answer
B. Calls and puts both lose value as implied volatility falls back The premium included payment for the report’s possible move. Once the report is out, that part of the premium has nothing left to cover, so implied volatility falls and both calls and puts are worth less. In the worked example an unchanged open took 53% off a straddle.
Implied volatility on a weekly option rises from 47% to 70% over three weeks before a report, with no news. What is the most likely reason?
- The market expects a bigger move than it did three weeks ago
- More traders have become bearish
- The event’s fixed risk is being averaged over fewer and fewer remaining days
Show the answer
C. The event’s fixed risk is being averaged over fewer and fewer remaining days Implied volatility is an average over the option’s remaining life. With the expected jump unchanged, each ordinary day that drops away makes the event a larger share of what is left, so the average rises mechanically.
Before earnings, a $100 stock’s at-the-money straddle costs $8. The stock opens at $105 the next day. Ignoring the little time value left, what is the result for the straddle buyer?
- A loss, because the 5% move was smaller than the roughly 8% move that was priced in
- A profit, because the stock moved 5%
- Break-even, because the call gained what the put lost
Show the answer
A. A loss, because the 5% move was smaller than the roughly 8% move that was priced in A long option position held through an event profits only if the actual move exceeds the implied move. The straddle’s price as a share of the stock, about 8%, is that implied move.
Two calls on the same stock span the same earnings report: one expires in a week, the other in a year. Which loses more of its implied volatility after the report, and why?
- The one-year call, because it has more vega
- Both lose the same number of points
- The one-week call, because the event is a much larger share of its remaining life
Show the answer
C. The one-week call, because the event is a much larger share of its remaining life The event adds the same lump of variance to both. Spread over one week it dominates; spread over a year it is a small addition. In the lesson’s model the weekly option falls from 70% to 35% while a one-year option would fall from about 36% to 35%.
Sources and further reading
- Cboe Global Indices — VIX historical data (daily closes)
- SPY daily closes for November 2024 and April 2025 (Finabase chart data, frozen October 30, 2026)
- Patell, J. and Wolfson, M., The Ex Ante and Ex Post Price Effects of Quarterly Earnings Announcements Reflected in Option and Stock Prices, Journal of Accounting Research 19(2), 1981
- Hull, J., Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives (Pearson), chapters on volatility and the Greek letters
- Options Industry Council — Options pricing
