Trading · Risk management
Gap risk: how often stocks open through a stop, and what it costs
Two years of overnight gaps in ten US stocks: how large they get, how often a stop one ATR away was jumped at the open, and how to size for a loss no stop can cap.
On this page
A stop order limits a loss only while the market is trading through its price. Between one day's close and the next day's open there are seventeen and a half hours in which news arrives and the regular market is shut. If the stock opens below the stop, the order fills at the open, wherever that is. The difference between the stop price and the fill is the part of the risk that position sizing did not plan for.
This lesson measures that part. It uses two years of daily data on ten well-known US stocks and funds to answer three questions: how large overnight gaps get, how often a stop placed one average day's range away was jumped at the open, and how much worse than planned the loss was when that happened. It ends with the ways traders size for a loss that no order can cap.
What a gap is
A gap is the jump from the previous regular-session close to the next regular-session open.
US stocks trade in the regular session from 9:30 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. Eastern Time. Earnings reports, guidance, analyst rating changes, economic data and news from abroad mostly arrive outside those hours (Stock market hours: regular, pre-market, after-hours and overnight). Trading does continue before the open and after the close, but most brokers' ordinary stop orders are active only in the regular session. By 9:30 a.m. the price has already moved, and the opening auction sets a single price that reflects everything since the last close.
Gaps as a chart pattern, and whether they tend to "fill", are covered in Gap trading: price gap types, gap fills and what the data shows and Chart gaps: common, breakaway, runaway, exhaustion and island gaps. This page treats the gap only as a risk to an open position.
How large gaps get
The sample is 500 trading days, November 19, 2024 to November 17, 2026, for one index fund and nine large stocks. The table lists the ordinary gap, the unusual one and the worst.
| Symbol | Median gap (either direction) | 1 day in 20 exceeded | Largest overnight fall | Date | Falls of 3% or more |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY | 0.30% | 1.21% | −3.4% | Apr 3, 2025 | 2 |
| KO | 0.29% | 1.38% | −5.3% | Apr 7, 2025 | 1 |
| JPM | 0.39% | 1.70% | −5.9% | Apr 4, 2025 | 2 |
| XOM | 0.52% | 1.87% | −6.3% | Apr 8, 2026 | 6 |
| MSFT | 0.48% | 2.16% | −8.6% | Jan 29, 2026 | 5 |
| AAPL | 0.38% | 1.94% | −8.6% | Jul 31, 2026 | 8 |
| META | 0.60% | 3.01% | −11.0% | Oct 30, 2025 | 9 |
| NVDA | 0.95% | 3.44% | −13.1% | Nov 12, 2026 | 16 |
| AMD | 1.26% | 5.73% | −11.2% | Feb 4, 2026 | 43 |
| TSLA | 1.00% | 4.14% | −8.8% | Jul 23, 2026 | 27 |
Three patterns are visible.
The typical gap is small and the worst is not. For every symbol the largest fall was between about nine and twenty-three times the median gap. A risk plan built on the ordinary day has no room for this.
Single stocks gap far more than the index. The worst overnight fall in SPY was 3.4%. Every single stock in the table had a worse one, and six of the nine fell more than 8% between a close and an open. An index fund spreads company news across hundreds of names.
The worst gaps follow scheduled news. Meta's on October 30, 2025 and Microsoft's on January 29, 2026 each came the morning after a quarterly earnings report, and Apple's on July 31, 2026 is worked through as a stop example in Stop-loss placement: volatility, structure and time stops. The April 2025 dates for SPY, JPM and KO fall in a market-wide sell-off. Company gaps cluster on dates that are known in advance. Market gaps do not.
Upward gaps were as large: AMD opened 37.5% higher on October 6, 2025. For a short position that is the same risk reversed, and with no ceiling (Short selling explained: borrowing, fees, rules and unlimited risk).
How much of the movement happens overnight
One way to weigh overnight risk is to split each stock's variation into the part between the close and the next open and the part during the session. Using squared daily log returns, the overnight share of total close-to-close variation over the two years was 37% for SPY, 29% for TSLA, 33% for JPM, about 40% for KO, XOM and AAPL, and 46% to 52% for NVDA, META, MSFT and AMD.
So between roughly a third and a half of the price variation in these stocks took place while the regular market was closed. A stop order is a tool for the other half.
How often a stop is jumped
To turn gaps into trading terms, the test below places a hypothetical long position each day with a stop one ATR below that day's close. ATR here is the simple average of the true range over the previous 14 sessions, Wilder's measure of a normal day's movement (Average True Range (ATR): volatility, stops and position size). The next day, the stop counts as hit if the low reaches it. If the open is already below the stop, the fill is the open; otherwise it is the stop price. The planned loss, 1R, is one ATR.
| Symbol | Days the stop was hit | Of which gapped through | Share | Average loss, all hits | Average loss on gap days | Worst loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY | 91 | 13 | 14% | 1.06R | 1.42R | 2.09R |
| KO | 57 | 4 | 7% | 1.04R | 1.56R | 2.67R |
| JPM | 67 | 6 | 9% | 1.04R | 1.47R | 2.02R |
| XOM | 68 | 8 | 12% | 1.06R | 1.54R | 2.11R |
| MSFT | 73 | 13 | 18% | 1.10R | 1.55R | 3.98R |
| AAPL | 69 | 9 | 13% | 1.11R | 1.88R | 3.54R |
| META | 70 | 6 | 9% | 1.13R | 2.48R | 5.24R |
| NVDA | 76 | 7 | 9% | 1.07R | 1.72R | 2.77R |
| AMD | 80 | 17 | 21% | 1.09R | 1.44R | 2.88R |
| TSLA | 77 | 8 | 10% | 1.04R | 1.42R | 2.02R |
| Total | 728 | 91 | 12.5% |
Read the columns from left to right.
- One stop-out in eight was a gap. Across the ten symbols, 91 of 728 next-day stop-outs opened below the stop. The rate ran from 7% (KO) to 21% (AMD).
- The average damage looks small. Taking all stop-outs together, the mean loss was 1.04R to 1.13R. Gaps added between 4% and 13% to the average planned loss.
- The damage is concentrated. On the gap days alone the mean loss was about 1.4R to 2.5R, and the single worst case in each stock ran from 2R to 5.2R. Meta's worst cost more than five times the planned loss.
The middle point is why gap risk is easy to underrate. Averaged over many trades it is a modest tax. It arrives, though, as an occasional loss several times the planned size, and the sizing rules in Risk of ruin: the chance a trading account does not survive and the Kelly criterion: the fastest-growing bet size, and why to halve it are sensitive to exactly that: the worst case, not the average.
The test has limits. It looks only one day ahead, uses one stop distance, and treats every day as a new trade, so the same gap is counted once per symbol. A wider stop is jumped less often. Two ATRs is a common choice, and the Apple example in Stop-loss placement: volatility, structure and time stops shows that a large gap clears that as well.
What a stop can and cannot do
| Order | In a gap below the trigger | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Stop (stop-market) | Triggers at the open and sells at the market | Out of the position, at a worse price |
| Stop-limit | Triggers, then waits for the limit price | May not sell at all; the loss stays open |
| No stop | Nothing happens | The decision is yours, after the fact |
| Protective put | The put gains as the stock falls below the strike | Loss capped at the strike, for a premium |
A stop order guarantees an exit, not a price. A stop-limit guarantees a price, not an exit (Stop and stop-limit orders: triggers, gaps and non-fill risk). Neither closes the gap. The only instrument that fixes the worst-case price in advance is an option, and it charges for the service every day it is held (Protective put: insuring a stock position with a put option).
Moving the stop closer does not help. A tighter stop is hit more often by ordinary movement and is just as far below the open in a gap. Because position size is the risk budget divided by the stop distance, a tighter stop also means more shares, so the same gap in dollars per share costs more dollars.
Sizing for the gap
Since no order removes the risk, the remaining tools are about how much is exposed and when.
- Check the position value, not only the planned loss. In a gap the loss is the gap percentage times the position's value. A position worth 25% of the account that gaps 10% costs 2.5% of the account, whatever the stop said. Capping any single position at a set share of the account caps this.
- Know the scheduled dates. Earnings dates are published in advance. Holding a smaller position, or none, through a report is a choice about a known event. Trading earnings season: implied moves, IV crush and earnings gaps shows how the options market prices the expected size of the move.
- Budget for a multiple of R. If the plan can survive several stops being hit at 1R, test whether it survives the same stops at 2R or 3R. Portfolio heat: adding up the risk of every open trade reruns a six-position book under those assumptions.
- Count what is held overnight together. A market-wide gap hits every long position at once, as the April 2025 dates in the first table show (Correlated positions: when five trades are really one bet).
- Decide the holding period on purpose. A day trader who is flat at the close carries no overnight gap risk and pays for that in other ways. A swing trader carries it every night and should size accordingly (Day trading vs swing trading vs position trading compared).
Trading halts are a related case. A stock halted for news can reopen far from its last price during the session, with the same effect on a stop as an overnight gap (Trading halts and Limit Up-Limit Down (LULD) pauses explained).
Gap risk beside related risks
| Risk | When it happens | What limits it |
|---|---|---|
| Gap risk | Between sessions, or across a halt | Position value, event calendar, options |
| Slippage | During the session, in a fast or thin market | Liquidity of the stock, order type |
| Ordinary stop-out | During the session | The stop itself |
| Liquidation risk | When margin runs short | Leverage used |
Liquidity and slippage: volume, depth, spread and market impact covers the second row. They add to each other: a stock that gaps often usually has wider spreads at the open as well.
How Finabase does it
- Earnings calendar. The earnings calendar lists the companies reporting on each date from the past five days to the next twenty, the scheduled sources of the largest single-stock gaps. A symbol page's Next earnings card shows the expected date for one company.
- ATR on a chart. The Average True Range study on any chart gives the size of a normal day, the yardstick used in the test above. The chart's ATR uses Wilder's smoothing; the test on this page used a simple 14-day average of the true range, which gives slightly different values.
- Pre-market and after-hours prices. A symbol page shows the extended-hours price when there is one, so a gap in the making is visible before the open.
- Alerts. A price alert notifies you when a level is crossed. It does not place an order, and like a stop it cannot act between sessions.
The paper account has no stop orders, so gap risk in a paper position shows up simply as the change in value at the next open.
Frequently asked questions
What is gap risk in trading?
Gap risk is the chance that a price moves from one level to another with no trading in between, usually from one day's close to the next day's open. A position held across the gap takes the whole move, and a stop order fills at the first available price after it.
Can a stop-loss protect against a gap?
Only partly. A stop order still closes the position, but at the opening price, which can be well below the stop. In the two-year test here, about one stop-out in eight was a gap, and the loss on those days averaged roughly one and a half to two and a half times the planned amount.
Which stocks have the most gap risk?
Single stocks more than index funds, and volatile, news-sensitive stocks most of all. In this sample AMD opened 3% or more lower on 43 days in two years and SPY on 2.
How do traders reduce overnight risk?
By holding smaller positions overnight, by reducing or closing positions before scheduled events such as earnings, by limiting how many positions are open at once, or by buying puts, which cap the loss at the strike price for a premium.
Summary
A gap carries a price past a stop without trading at it, so the loss on a gapped position is set by the opening price and the position's size, not by the stop. Over two years the largest overnight fall was 3.4% for SPY and between 5% and 13% for nine large stocks, and a third to a half of all price variation occurred outside the regular session. One in eight next-day stop-outs at a one-ATR stop was a gap, with losses on those days of about 1.4R to 2.5R on average and 5.2R at worst. Tighter stops make this worse. What limits it is the value of each position, awareness of scheduled news, and a risk budget that assumes some losses will be a multiple of the plan.
Check your understanding
4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
You hold 200 shares bought at $60 with a stop order at $57. After bad news overnight the stock opens at $52. What is the likely loss?
- $600, because the stop is at $57
- About $1,600, because the stop becomes a market order and fills near the $52 open
- Nothing, because the stop price was never traded
Show the answer
B. About $1,600, because the stop becomes a market order and fills near the $52 open A stop order triggers at the first trade at or below its price and then sells at the market. With the open at $52 the fill is near $52: 200 × $8 = $1,600, about 2.7 times the planned $600.
A trader reacts to gap risk by moving stops closer to the entry and keeping the same dollar risk per trade. What happens to the loss in an overnight gap?
- It gets smaller, because the stop is tighter
- It stays the same
- It gets larger, because a tighter stop means more shares for the same risk budget
Show the answer
C. It gets larger, because a tighter stop means more shares for the same risk budget Position size = risk budget ÷ stop distance. Halving the stop distance doubles the shares, and the gap costs the same dollars per share on twice as many shares.
In the two-year sample, taking all next-day stop-outs together, the average loss was only 1.04R to 1.13R. Why is gap risk still a serious matter for sizing?
- Because the average hides occasional losses of two to five times the plan, and sizing rules are sensitive to the worst case
- Because the average is wrong
- Because gaps only affect index funds
Show the answer
A. Because the average hides occasional losses of two to five times the plan, and sizing rules are sensitive to the worst case Gaps were one stop-out in eight, but on those days losses averaged about 1.4R to 2.5R and reached 5.2R. Risk of ruin and Kelly-type sizing depend heavily on the largest losses, not the mean.
Which of these fixes the worst-case exit price of a long stock position in advance, even through an overnight gap?
- A stop-limit order
- A protective put
- A trailing stop
Show the answer
B. A protective put A put gives the right to sell at the strike whatever the stock does, for a premium. A stop-limit may not fill at all in a gap, and a trailing stop is still a stop order that fills at the open.
Sources and further reading
- SEC, Investor.gov — Investor Bulletin: Stop, Stop-Limit and Trailing Stop Orders
- FINRA — Extended-hours trading: know the risks
- J. Welles Wilder Jr., New Concepts in Technical Trading Systems (1978) — true range
- Finabase chart data — daily bars of SPY, KO, JPM, XOM, MSFT, AAPL, META, NVDA, AMD and TSLA, November 18, 2024 to November 17, 2026; gaps and stop tests computed by Finabase
