Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Trading · Options

Iron butterfly spread: a short straddle with protective wings

How an iron butterfly sells a straddle and buys a strangle around it, how to compute its credit, maximum loss and break-evens, and how it compares with an iron condor.

On this page
  1. How it is built
  2. Reward, odds and time
  3. The same position as a long call butterfly
  4. Assignment and pin risk
  5. Margin, approval and costs
  6. Conditions that hurt the position
  7. Compared with its neighbours
  8. How Finabase does it
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Summary
  11. Check your understanding
  12. Exercise

An iron butterfly sells a put and a call at the same strike, usually the one nearest the stock price, and buys a put below and a call above as protection. The sold pair is a short straddle; the bought pair, the wings, is a long strangle. The position collects a large credit, earns all of it only if the stock finishes exactly at the middle strike, and loses a fixed amount if the stock finishes beyond either wing.

It sits between two neighbours. An Iron condor: a defined-risk position on a stock staying in a range spreads the sold strikes apart and accepts a smaller credit for a wider range. A long call butterfly uses three strikes of calls for a small debit. As this page shows, the long call butterfly and the iron butterfly on the same strikes are the same position with the cash on the other side, a consequence of Put-call parity: the link between calls, puts and the stock.

The page builds the iron butterfly on the shared illustrative prices, compares it with the iron condor in numbers, and covers what is particular to it: a profit concentrated on one price, and a pin risk at the very price where that profit is.

How it is built

The example uses the same illustrative prices as the other strategy lessons: XYZ at $100, 45 days to expiration, 30% implied volatility, a 4% interest rate, no dividends, Black-Scholes values rounded to the cent.

The wings cost more than half of the straddle's premium. That is the price of turning an open-ended short straddle into a position whose loss stops at $95.

Iron butterfly ($95 / $100 / $105, credit $4.05) and iron condor at expiration −$3 −$2 −$1 $0 $1 $2 $3 $4 $5 $85 $90 $95 $100 $105 $110 $115 Iron butterfly: credit $4.05 Iron butterfly with 10 days left (model) Iron condor $90 / $95 / $105 / $110: credit $2.39 +$4.05 at $100 $95.95 $104.05 Stock price Profit / loss per share
Illustrative, XYZ at $100, 45 days, 30% implied volatility, 4% interest, no dividends, Black-Scholes values. Iron butterfly $95/$100/$105; iron condor $90/$95/$105/$110. Profit or loss per share, before costs.
Stock at expiration Iron butterfly Iron condor
$90 −$0.95 −$2.61
$95 −$0.95 +$2.39
$97 +$1.05 +$2.39
$100 +$4.05 +$2.39
$102 +$2.05 +$2.39
$105 −$0.95 +$2.39
$110 −$0.95 −$2.61

Reward, odds and time

The iron butterfly risks $95 to make up to $405, a ratio that looks generous until the odds are attached. With the example's inputs, the model puts the chance of finishing between the break-evens, for any gain, at about 30%; the chance of finishing within a dollar of $100, for a gain above $3, at about 8%; and the chance of finishing beyond a wing, for the full loss, at about 63%. The usual outcome is the small loss. Under the model the gains and losses balance out; the shape only changes how they are distributed.

Wider wings move the balance. A $90 / $100 / $110 iron butterfly collects $6.44, risks $3.56, has break-evens at $93.56 and $106.44, and finishes between them about 46% of the time. It is closer to a short straddle: more premium, a wider profitable range, a larger loss when wrong.

The profit also arrives late. With the stock sitting at $100, the model values the 5-wide iron butterfly at about +$0.29 a share after 20 days, +$0.91 with 10 days left and +$2.30 with 2 days left. Most of the $4.05 is earned in the final days, the same pattern as the long butterfly. At the start its exposures are small for that reason:

Per share, at the start Iron butterfly ($95/$100/$105) Iron condor ($90/$95/$105/$110)
Delta 0.00 0.00
Gamma −0.008 −0.019
Theta (per day) +$0.0095 +$0.024
Vega (per point) −$0.030 −$0.071

The narrow wings take back most of the straddle's exposure while expiration is far away. As expiration nears, gamma and theta concentrate at the middle strike and grow quickly: the position becomes very sensitive to where the stock is on the last days.

The same position as a long call butterfly

Buy the $95 call, sell two $100 calls, buy the $105 call: the long call butterfly from the butterfly lesson costs a $0.93 debit and pays at most $4.07, at $100. The iron butterfly on the same strikes collects $4.05 and loses at most $0.95. The payoffs are the same tent, two cents apart.

Parity explains why. Replacing the iron butterfly's put spread with a call spread at the same strikes changes only when the cash moves: the iron butterfly receives its money at the start and may pay up to $5 at expiration, while the call butterfly pays at the start and may receive up to $5 at expiration. Their prices add up to the present value of the $5 width: 4.05 + 0.93 = 4.98, against 5 × e^(−0.04 × 45/365) = $4.975. The difference is interest, not an edge.

In practice the choice between them comes down to quotes and assignment. Out-of-the-money options often have tighter markets, and the iron version uses only out-of-the-money wings, while the call butterfly's lower call is in the money. The iron version also leaves cash in the account while it is open.

Assignment and pin risk

US equity options are American-style, and the iron butterfly has two short options at the money. Either can become in the money and be assigned early: the short call before an ex-dividend date, the short put if the stock falls far.

Pin risk is sharper here than in an iron condor. The maximum profit is at the middle strike, and at that price one of the two short options is a cent in or out of the money. A close at $100.20 leaves the $100 call in the money: it is exercised automatically (US, 2026, anything $0.01 or more in the money), and the account is short 100 shares over the weekend with nothing hedging them. A close at $99.80 does the same with the put, leaving the account long 100 shares. A close at exactly $100 leaves the holder unsure whether a call buyer exercised. Most holders close the position or at least the short straddle before the final day, giving up part of the maximum gain to avoid an unhedged stock position. Option exercise and assignment: how it works and when it happens has the cut-off times.

Margin, approval and costs

In a US margin account (2026), brokers typically hold the maximum loss: the wing width less the credit, $95 here, under FINRA Rule 4210 and the Cboe margin rules, which treat the position as a put spread and a call spread on which only one side can lose. Firms can require more. It needs spread-level options approval (Options risks and approval levels: what brokers check and why).

Four legs mean four bid-ask spreads and four commissions each way. Because the maximum loss is small, $95, costs are large in proportion to it: a round trip at $0.05 a leg in spread and $0.65 a contract in commission is about $25, more than a quarter of the maximum loss. Entering all four legs as one order with a net limit price avoids a partial fill.

Conditions that hurt the position

Any sizable move. The profitable range is narrow: $95.95 to $104.05, about 4% either side. A normal month's move can leave it.

A rise in implied volatility early on. The short straddle is closer to the money than the wings and gains more from a rise, so the position shows a loss with the stock unchanged.

Earnings and news. A report inside the life of the position makes a move larger than the range likely, and the full loss is the usual outcome then.

Holding for the last dollar. The final days hold most of the gain and all of the pin risk.

Compared with its neighbours

Position Legs Opened for Maximum gain Maximum loss Profit range (example)
Iron butterfly $95/$100/$105 4 Credit $4.05 $4.05 at $100 $0.95 $95.95 – $104.05
Iron butterfly $90/$100/$110 4 Credit $6.44 $6.44 at $100 $3.56 $93.56 – $106.44
Iron condor $90/$95/$105/$110 4 Credit $2.39 $2.39, $95–$105 $2.61 $92.61 – $107.39
Long call butterfly 4 Debit $0.93 $4.07 at $100 $0.93 $95.93 – $104.07
Short straddle 2 Credit $8.39 $8.39 at $100 Not limited $91.61 – $108.39

Going down the table, the iron butterfly is the short straddle with insurance bought, and the iron condor is the iron butterfly with its peak flattened into a plateau. The long call butterfly is the iron butterfly paid for the other way round.

How Finabase does it

On a Finabase option chain such as SPY options, choose an expiration in the Expires row; calls are on the left and puts on the right of each strike, with bid, ask, last price, volume, open interest and implied volatility. Find the strike nearest the price: the call and put bids on that row are the straddle you would sell. Read the asks of a put a few strikes below and a call the same distance above for the wings. The straddle bids minus the wing asks is the credit at realistic prices, and the strike distance minus that credit is the maximum loss.

Finabase does not combine legs, draw payoff diagrams or compute Greeks or probabilities; the figures here come from the Black-Scholes model with the stated inputs. The earnings calendar shows whether a report falls inside the position's life. Quotes may be delayed, and Finabase does not place orders.

Frequently asked questions

What is the maximum loss on an iron butterfly?

The distance from the middle strike to a wing, minus the net credit, per share, times 100. In the example, $5 − $4.05 = $0.95, or $95 per position.

What is the difference between an iron butterfly and an iron condor?

The iron butterfly sells the put and call at one strike; the iron condor sells them at two. The butterfly collects more and needs the stock near one price; the condor collects less and profits anywhere between its short strikes.

Is an iron butterfly the same as a butterfly spread?

It has the same payoff as a long butterfly on the same strikes, built from both puts and calls and opened for a credit instead of a debit. The two differ by interest on the strike width.

Why does an iron butterfly lose money most of the time?

Its profitable range is narrow. In the example the stock had to finish within about 4% of $100, which the model gave a 30% chance; finishing beyond a wing, for the full loss, had about a 63% chance.

Should an iron butterfly be held to expiration?

That is the holder's decision. Holding earns most of the time decay but carries pin risk at the middle strike, which can leave an unhedged stock position after expiration.

Summary

An iron butterfly sells a straddle at one strike and buys a put and a call further out, for a net credit that is its maximum gain at the middle strike. On the shared prices the $95/$100/$105 version collected $4.05 and could lose at most $0.95, with break-evens at $95.95 and $104.05. The model gave it about a 30% chance of any profit and a 63% chance of the full loss, and most of its gain arrives in the last days. It is the long call butterfly with the cash flows reversed, the iron condor with its sold strikes joined, and the short straddle with its losses capped. Its best price at expiration is also where the risk of an unhedged assignment is greatest.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. An iron butterfly sells the $50 straddle for $4.00 and buys the $45 put and $55 call for $1.50 together. What are its maximum gain and maximum loss per position?

    1. Gain $250, loss $250
    2. Gain $400, loss $500
    3. Gain $250, loss $750
    Show the answer

    A. Gain $250, loss $250 The credit is 4.00 − 1.50 = $2.50, the maximum gain ($250). The maximum loss is the $5 wing width minus the credit: (5 − 2.50) × 100 = $250.

  2. Compared with an iron condor on the same outer strikes, what does an iron butterfly trade?

    1. A smaller credit for a wider profitable range
    2. A larger credit and lower maximum loss for a profit that depends on the stock finishing near one price
    3. Unlimited risk for a larger credit
    Show the answer

    B. A larger credit and lower maximum loss for a profit that depends on the stock finishing near one price Selling both options at one strike brings in more premium, which lowers the maximum loss, but the gain peaks at that strike and falls away on both sides. The condor’s plateau covers every price between its two short strikes.

  3. An iron butterfly collects $4.05 and a long call butterfly on the same strikes costs $0.93. Why do the two add up to nearly the $5 width?

    1. By put-call parity they are the same payoff with the cash paid at different times, so together they are worth the present value of $5
    2. Because market makers price them to cancel out
    3. It is a coincidence of the chosen strikes
    Show the answer

    A. By put-call parity they are the same payoff with the cash paid at different times, so together they are worth the present value of $5 Swapping the put spread for a call spread at the same strikes changes only when cash moves. The iron version receives money now and may pay $5 later; the call version pays now and may receive $5. The two cents of difference is interest on $5 for 45 days.

  4. At expiration the stock closes at $100.20, a few cents from the $100 middle strike of an iron butterfly. What happens if the holder does nothing?

    1. All four options expire worthless and the full credit is kept
    2. The short $100 call is exercised and the account is short 100 shares with no hedge
    3. The long $105 call is exercised to cover
    Show the answer

    B. The short $100 call is exercised and the account is short 100 shares with no hedge The $100 call is $0.20 in the money and is exercised automatically. The $105 call expires worthless. The holder is short 100 shares after expiration, the pin risk that sits at the iron butterfly’s best price.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open the SPY option chain and choose an expiration about a month away. On the strike row nearest the underlying price, add the call bid and the put bid: that is the straddle you would sell. Then read the ask of a put about 3% below and a call about 3% above. Work out the net credit, the maximum loss (wing distance minus credit) and the two break-evens.

Open the SPY option chain
What you should find

The credit is usually well over half the wing distance, so the maximum loss is the smaller number, and the break-evens sit the credit’s width either side of the middle strike. Compare that range with how far SPY has moved in a month recently: the profitable range is narrow, which is why the small loss is the common outcome.

Sources and further reading

  1. The Options Clearing Corporation — Options Disclosure Document (Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options)
  2. Options Industry Council — Short iron butterfly
  3. Options Industry Council — Long call butterfly
  4. FINRA Rule 4210 — Margin requirements
  5. Cboe — Margin requirements (Margin Manual)
  6. Black, F. and Scholes, M., The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities, Journal of Political Economy 81(3), 1973