Investor psychology Lesson 6 of 15
Articles · Behavioral finance
The endowment effect and status quo bias: why you keep what you own
What the mug experiments and the 401(k) default studies found, where the endowment effect fails to appear, and a clean-slate test for the holdings you already have.
On this page
The endowment effect is the tendency to value a thing more once you own it. Status quo bias is the tendency to stay with whatever is already in place, whether you chose it or not. Together they explain why a portfolio tends to remain what it was last year: the stock you inherited, the fund the plan picked for you, the position that has grown to a third of the account.
Neither is always an error. Doing nothing is often the best investment decision. The trouble is that these two effects make doing nothing feel right for reasons unrelated to the merits.
The mug experiments
In 1990 Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler ran a series of classroom markets. In the best-known version, half the students in a room were given a university coffee mug. Owners could sell and non-owners could buy, at prices each wrote down in advance.
Mugs were handed out at random, so the half of the class that valued mugs most should have included about as many non-owners as owners. Economic theory therefore predicted that about half the mugs would change hands: 11 trades out of 22 mugs. Across four mug markets the actual numbers were 4, 1, 2 and 2. The typical owner would not sell below about $5.25, and the typical buyer would not pay more than about $2.25 to $2.75.
A further experiment added a third group. "Choosers" owned nothing and were asked, at each price, whether they would rather have the mug or the money. Their position is the same as a seller's in every respect except ownership: both walk away with either a mug or cash.
Sellers valued the mug at $7.12, choosers at $3.12 and buyers at $2.87. Choosers behaved like buyers. The gap comes from owning the mug: giving it up registers as a loss. The authors read this as loss aversion applied to possessions.
An earlier experiment by Knetsch made the point without any prices. One class was given mugs and offered the chance to swap for a chocolate bar: 89% kept the mug. Another class was given chocolate and offered a mug: 90% kept the chocolate. A third class, given a free choice, split 56% to 44%. What people preferred depended mostly on what they had been handed minutes before. Thaler had named the pattern the endowment effect in 1980.
Status quo bias: the option already in place
William Samuelson and Richard Zeckhauser gave the second effect its name in 1988. In their experiments, 486 students faced decisions such as how to invest an inheritance. Some saw a neutral list of options. Others were told the money was already invested in one of them. An option was chosen noticeably more often when it was described as the current position.
They also looked at real behavior. Among participants in the TIAA-CREF retirement plan, which then served university staff, the typical participant had never changed the way contributions were divided between its funds: only about 28% reported ever having made a change, although many had been in the plan for years.
The default studies
The cleanest evidence came in 2001, when Brigitte Madrian and Dennis Shea studied a large US company that changed one rule in its 401(k) plan. Before the change, new employees had to sign up to take part. After it, they were enrolled automatically at a 3% contribution rate in a money market fund, unless they chose otherwise. Nothing else about the plan changed and anyone could opt out or pick differently at any time.
Participation among comparable employees went from 37.4% to 85.9%. The default worked in the other direction too. Of those hired under automatic enrollment, 61% were at both the default 3% rate and the default fund, a combination almost nobody had chosen before. A default designed to help people start saving also held many of them at a low rate in a low-return fund.
This is the result that led to automatic enrollment and target-date default funds becoming standard in US retirement plans. For an individual it carries a simpler message: a large part of what is in your account may be there because it was the option already in place.
What it looks like in an account
The inherited or awarded position. Consider an illustrative investor with a $200,000 portfolio who inherits $60,000 of a single stock, or receives it as employer shares. The position is now 23% of everything they own. Asked whether they would take $60,000 in cash and put all of it into that one company, most people say no. Yet most keep the shares. The two situations differ only in the starting point (and in tax, covered below).
The default nobody revisited. A contribution rate set at enrollment ten years ago, or a money market default that was meant as a holding place.
The unrebalanced portfolio. A 60/40 mix that has drifted to 75/25 after a long rise in stocks has become a different portfolio from the one that was chosen, without any decision having been made.
The price you will not sell below. An owner's idea of what a holding is "worth" tends to sit above what the same person would pay for it, which stalls sales that the owner would otherwise agree were sensible.
The clean-slate test, with numbers
The test asks one question of each holding: if this position were cash today, would I buy it, in this amount?
Take the inherited $60,000. The honest comparison has three lines.
| Keep | Sell and diversify | |
|---|---|---|
| Share of portfolio in one company | 23% | 0% to whatever you would choose to buy |
| Tax due now | $0 | Depends on the cost basis |
| Trading cost | $0 | Small |
Tax can be a real reason to keep a holding. In the US, inherited shares generally take the market value at the date of death as their cost basis, so the gain to tax may be small. Shares bought long ago are different: selling $60,000 of stock that cost $20,000 realizes a $40,000 gain, and at a 15% rate that is $6,000, or 10% of the position. Whether paying 10% to remove a 23% single-stock position is worthwhile is a judgment about concentration risk, and reasonable people decide it differently. Tax rules vary by country and change, so check your own.
What the test does is make the decision explicit. "I am keeping it because selling would cost $6,000 in tax and I accept the concentration" is a reason. "I am keeping it because I have it" is the endowment effect.
A milder version works for defaults: once a year, write down your contribution rate and the funds your new money goes into, and ask whether you would pick them today.
Where the effect does not appear
The endowment effect is one of the best-known findings in behavioral economics and also one of the most contested.
Experience. John List ran exchange experiments on the floor of sports-card shows. Dealers given one collectible and offered another of similar value traded about 45% of the time, close to the 50% expected with no endowment effect. Ordinary collectors traded 20% to 25% of the time. Among non-dealers, the experienced traded 47% of the time and the inexperienced 7%. Market experience seemed to remove the effect, at least for goods held for trading.
Procedure. Charles Plott and Kathryn Zeiler repeated the valuation experiments in 2005 with anonymity, training and paid practice rounds designed to remove misunderstandings about how to state a price. The gap between selling and buying prices disappeared. Later work has argued over which of their controls mattered.
Mechanism. A 2015 review by Carey Morewedge and Colleen Giblin concluded that loss aversion is not the only explanation. Ownership also directs attention to a thing's good features and ties it to the owner's identity.
There is an asymmetry worth noting for investors. Shares, fund units and cash held for exchange are exactly the kind of goods for which the pure valuation gap is weakest. The default studies, by contrast, are about real retirement money and show very large effects. For an investor, inertia is the better-supported half of this page.
When staying put is right
Status quo bias produces inaction, and inaction is frequently the better choice. Investors who trade more tend to earn less after costs, as overconfidence and overtrading shows. A broad index fund held through a decline is the status quo and usually the right one. Tax on gains and trading costs are real and count in favor of what you already hold.
So the correction is narrow. Review on a schedule, such as once a year or when a holding passes a size limit set in advance, and for each item either find the reason to keep it or change it. Outside the review, leave things alone.
How Finabase helps
A portfolio lists each holding with its market value and gain, so a position that has grown or arrived by inheritance is visible as a share of the total and not as a separate story. On any symbol, the Comparison tab sets the stock beside others, such as the index fund you would buy with fresh cash, across periods from one week to two years. A paper-trading account lets you build the portfolio you would choose from a clean slate and watch how it differs from the one you hold.
Frequently asked questions
What is the endowment effect?
It is the tendency to demand more to give up something you own than you would pay to acquire it. In the classic mug experiments, owners' median asking price was about twice what buyers would pay.
What is status quo bias?
It is a preference for the current state of affairs: the existing holding, the default option, last year's choice. In one company's retirement plan, participation rose from 37% to 86% when the default changed from out to in.
How is the endowment effect different from loss aversion?
Loss aversion is the general finding that losses weigh more than equal gains. The endowment effect is one of its proposed consequences: giving up a possession is felt as a loss. Later research suggests ownership and attention also contribute.
Is it wrong to keep inherited stock?
Not necessarily. Tax, trading costs and your view of the company are all legitimate reasons. The test is whether you would buy the same amount today with cash. If you would not, it helps to name the specific reason for keeping it.
Summary
People value what they hold above what they would pay for it and stick with whatever option is already in place. Mug owners asked about $7 for an item others valued at $3, and a change of default moved retirement-plan participation from 37% to 86%, with most people also staying at the default rate and fund. The valuation gap weakens with trading experience and careful procedure. Inertia in real accounts is the sturdier finding. The practical response is a scheduled clean-slate review: for each holding and each default, would you choose it today, and if not, what specific cost justifies keeping it.
Check your understanding
5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.
In the mug experiment, “choosers” were asked whether they would rather have a mug or money at each price. Why did the researchers include them?
- To make the group larger
- Choosers face the same mug-or-money choice as sellers but do not own the mug, so comparing the two isolates the effect of ownership
- Choosers were the only group using real money
Show the answer
B. Choosers face the same mug-or-money choice as sellers but do not own the mug, so comparing the two isolates the effect of ownership Sellers valued the mug at $7.12 and choosers at $3.12. The only difference between them was that sellers already had it.
When one company switched its 401(k) from sign-up to automatic enrollment, participation went from 37% to 86%. What else did the study find?
- Most automatically enrolled employees also stayed at the default contribution rate and in the default fund
- Employees quickly moved to higher contribution rates
- The default had no effect on fund choice
Show the answer
A. Most automatically enrolled employees also stayed at the default contribution rate and in the default fund About 61% of the new cohort sat at both defaults. Inertia helped people start and then held many of them at a low rate in a money market fund.
An investor inherits $60,000 of one stock, which becomes 23% of their portfolio. Which statement is a reason to keep it and not the endowment effect?
- “I’ve always had it.”
- “It was my father’s.”
- “Selling would realize a large taxable gain, and I have decided the concentration is acceptable.”
Show the answer
C. “Selling would realize a large taxable gain, and I have decided the concentration is acceptable.” The clean-slate test asks whether you would buy this amount with cash today. A specific cost of switching, weighed against the risk, is a reason. Having it is not.
What did John List’s sports-card experiments suggest about the endowment effect?
- It is strongest among professional dealers
- It was largely absent among experienced traders and strong among inexperienced ones
- It does not exist
Show the answer
B. It was largely absent among experienced traders and strong among inexperienced ones Dealers traded about 45% of the time, near the 50% expected with no effect. Inexperienced collectors traded 7% of the time.
Why is status quo bias not a reason to trade more?
- Because doing nothing is often correct, and the fix is a scheduled review with reasons, not more activity
- Because trading is always wrong
- Because defaults are always the best option
Show the answer
A. Because doing nothing is often correct, and the fix is a scheduled review with reasons, not more activity Frequent traders tend to earn less after costs. The correction is to check at set times that each holding and default is one you would choose today.
Exercise
One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.
Open Paper trading (signed out, it shows a sample account). In the Positions table, read Market value for each position and work out each one’s share of Account value. Then apply the clean-slate test to the largest: if the account were all cash today, would you put that share of it into this one company? Write yes or no and one reason before you look at its Gain %.
Open paper tradingWhat you should find
If your answer changed once you saw the gain, the position’s history is doing the deciding. The test uses only two things: the position’s share of the account and what you know about the company today. A largest position well above the others usually got there by rising, not by a decision to make it that large.
Sources and further reading
- Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler — Experimental tests of the endowment effect and the Coase theorem, Journal of Political Economy 98(6), 1990
- Knetsch — The endowment effect and evidence of nonreversible indifference curves, American Economic Review 79(5), 1989
- Samuelson and Zeckhauser — Status quo bias in decision making, Journal of Risk and Uncertainty 1(1), 1988
- Madrian and Shea — The power of suggestion: inertia in 401(k) participation and savings behavior, Quarterly Journal of Economics 116(4), 2001
- Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler — Anomalies: the endowment effect, loss aversion, and status quo bias, Journal of Economic Perspectives 5(1), 1991
- List — Does market experience eliminate market anomalies?, Quarterly Journal of Economics 118(1), 2003
- Plott and Zeiler — The willingness to pay–willingness to accept gap, the “endowment effect,” subject misconceptions, and experimental procedures for eliciting valuations, American Economic Review 95(3), 2005
- Morewedge and Giblin — Explanations of the endowment effect: an integrative review, Trends in Cognitive Sciences 19(6), 2015
