Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Investor psychology Lesson 8 of 15

Articles · Behavioral finance

Availability bias and attention: why investors buy what is in the news

How easily recalled examples distort judgment, what brokerage and search data show about attention-driven buying, and the case of a stock that tripled on old news.

On this page
  1. The original research
  2. From availability to attention: what investors buy
  3. A stock that tripled on old news
  4. A worked example
  5. What the evidence suggests helps
  6. How Finabase helps
  7. Frequently asked questions
  8. Summary
  9. Check your understanding
  10. Exercise

Availability bias is judging how common or likely something is by how easily examples come to mind. What comes to mind easily is what is recent, vivid, repeated or personal, and none of those is the same as frequent.

For investors the bias has a specific and well-measured form. There are thousands of listed stocks and nobody can consider them all, so people consider the ones that catch their attention: the company in today's headlines, the stock that jumped yesterday, the name a friend mentioned. The stocks you buy are drawn from the stocks you noticed, and what you noticed was chosen for you by events and editors.

The original research

Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman introduced the availability heuristic in 1973. In one experiment they asked people whether certain letters, such as K and R, appear more often as the first letter of English words or the third. Each of the letters is in fact more common in third position. Of 152 people, 105 judged the first position more frequent for a majority of the letters. Words are easy to retrieve by their first letter and hard to retrieve by their third, and people took ease of retrieval as a count.

In 1978 Sarah Lichtenstein and colleagues asked people to estimate how often various causes of death occur. Dramatic, reported causes were overestimated and quiet ones underestimated. Tornadoes were judged to kill more people than asthma, although asthma caused about 20 times as many deaths. A follow-up study by Barbara Combs and Paul Slovic (1979) found that the errors tracked how much newspapers wrote about each cause.

The parallel for an investor is direct. A market crash, a fraud or a stock that rose tenfold is a tornado: rare, vivid and heavily reported. Fees, taxes and a few percentage points of underperformance each year are asthma.

From availability to attention: what investors buy

Brad Barber and Terrance Odean pointed out in 2008 that buying and selling pose different problems. To sell, an individual chooses among the handful of stocks they own. To buy, they choose among thousands. Attention solves the search problem, so attention should matter far more for purchases than for sales.

They tested this on accounts at a large discount broker, a retail broker and a full-service broker, using three measures of whether a stock was catching attention that day: unusual trading volume, an extreme return the day before, and a mention in the news.

Stocks sorted by Individuals' buy-sell imbalance
Lowest unusual volume (decile) −18.2%
Highest unusual volume (top 5%) +29.5%
Not in the news that day +2.7%
In the news that day +9.4%

The imbalance is purchases minus sales, divided by all trades, by number of trades at the large discount broker. An imbalance of +29.5% means nearly twice as many purchases as sales; −18.2% means about 44% more sales than purchases.

The pattern held for stocks with large one-day falls as well as large rises. A stock that dropped sharply attracted net buying from individuals, which fits attention and does not fit any simple story about chasing winners. Professional managers, who use screens and analysts to search the whole market, did not show the pattern.

What happens to the price

Zhi Da, Joseph Engelberg and Pengjie Gao used Google search volume for ticker symbols as a direct measure of retail attention. A jump in searches predicted a higher price over the next two weeks, by a fraction of a percent, and the gain was almost entirely reversed within the year. Attention moved the price temporarily and added no lasting value.

Lily Fang and Joel Peress looked at the other side. Stocks with no media coverage earned higher returns than heavily covered stocks, by roughly 3% a year in their 1993–2002 sample after allowing for standard risk factors. Being ignored was, on average, rewarded.

Barber, Xing Huang, Odean and Christopher Schwarz studied Robinhood users from 2018 to 2020. The stocks most heavily bought by its users on a given day went on to underperform by about 4.7% over the next 20 days.

Joseph Engelberg and Christopher Parsons showed that coverage itself causes trading. They compared investors in different US cities reading different local newspapers on the same earnings announcements: local trading followed whether the local paper covered the story.

A stock that tripled on old news

In November 1997 the journal Nature published research on two compounds that shrank tumors in mice. A small company, EntreMed, held the licensing rights. The news was reported at the time and the share price responded.

On Sunday, May 3, 1998, The New York Times ran a front-page article about the same research. It contained no new scientific result. Gur Huberman and Tomer Regev documented what happened next.

EntreMed, May 1998: a front-page story about research published five months earlier Friday May 1 close $12.06 Monday May 4 open $85.00 Monday May 4 close about $52 Prices as reported by Huberman and Regev (2001). No new information was released.
EntreMed around a front-page newspaper story in May 1998 that reported no new information, from Huberman and Regev (2001).

EntreMed had closed at $12.06 on Friday. It opened on Monday at $85 and closed near $52, more than four times Friday's price. Other biotechnology stocks rose with it, although every fact in the article had been public for five months.

The information had been available all along. The front page made it prominent to a great many readers at once.

Buying the wrong company

Attention can be strong enough to skip the step of checking what is being bought. In March 2020, as the video-call company Zoom Video Communications (ticker ZM) became a household name, investors piled into Zoom Technologies, an unrelated and nearly dormant company whose ticker was ZOOM. The US Securities and Exchange Commission suspended trading in Zoom Technologies from March 26 to April 8, 2020, citing confusion between the two. Similar mix-ups between look-alike tickers were documented by the economist Michael Rashes in 2001.

A worked example

Suppose that over a year an investor makes 12 purchases and afterward writes down how each stock first came to their attention.

How the stock reached them Purchases
Headline or news alert 5
A "top movers" or trending list 3
Mentioned by a friend or on social media 2
Their own screen or research list 2

Ten of twelve purchases came from a pool chosen by attention. The published evidence on such pools is consistent: on average they are bought at a temporarily raised price. Using the Robinhood figure purely as an illustration, a stock bought for $5,000 at the height of attention that lags by 4.7% over the next month is about $235 behind where it would otherwise be. Over ten such purchases that is $2,350. The number is illustrative: the study describes the most extreme attention events on one platform and does not say every news-driven purchase loses.

The table shows something more useful than the dollar figure. This investor has no method for finding stocks, only a method for reacting to them.

What the evidence suggests helps

There is no experiment showing that a particular habit removes attention-driven buying. These follow from how the effect works.

  1. Separate the source from the reason. For each purchase, record how the stock reached you. If the answer is a headline, a price jump or a list of popular names, treat the idea as untested.
  2. Search by criteria. Professionals did not show the effect because they screen the whole market for characteristics they chose in advance. A screener does the same job for an individual.
  3. Wait. Attention effects on price are measured in days and weeks. An idea that is still good after two weeks has lost nothing by waiting. An idea that depended on buying today probably depended on the attention.
  4. Check whether the news is new. Look at the date of the underlying event, the size of the price move already made, and the ticker.
  5. Look where nobody is pointing. The neglected-stock result suggests that coverage and returns do not go together.

A broad index fund sidesteps the problem altogether, since it holds every stock regardless of whether anyone is talking about it.

How Finabase helps

The Screener searches the market by criteria you choose, such as valuation, growth, dividend yield and size, which is the opposite of waiting for a stock to find you. The Trending page shows which symbols are drawing attention right now. Read with this lesson in mind, it is a map of where attention-driven buying is likely to be concentrated. Each symbol's News tab lists recent stories with their dates, so you can check whether today's excitement rests on anything new.

Frequently asked questions

What is availability bias in investing?

It is judging an investment's prospects or risks by the examples that come to mind most easily, such as recent headlines or a vivid story, instead of by how often such outcomes actually occur.

What is attention-driven buying?

It is the tendency of individual investors to buy stocks that have caught their attention through news, unusual volume or a large price move. It affects buying more than selling because buyers must choose among thousands of stocks.

Do stocks in the news perform worse?

On average, studies find that prices pushed up by retail attention give back the gain over the following weeks or months, and that stocks with no media coverage have earned somewhat more than heavily covered ones. These are averages over many stocks and do not apply to each case.

Is it a mistake to buy a stock I read about?

No. News is how everyone learns about companies. The mistake is treating the fact that you noticed a stock as a reason to own it. The reason has to come from somewhere else.

Summary

People judge likelihood by ease of recall, and investors choose what to buy from the small set of stocks that have caught their attention. Brokerage data show individuals are strong net buyers of stocks in the news and of stocks with unusual volume or extreme moves in either direction. Search and trading-app data show the resulting price rise is temporary. EntreMed's jump from $12 to $85 on a re-told story shows how large the effect can be. The practical defense is to notice how each idea arrived, search by criteria of your own, and let the first wave of attention pass before deciding.

Check your understanding

5 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Why does attention affect individual investors’ buying much more than their selling?

    1. Selling is taxed and buying is not
    2. Buyers must choose among thousands of stocks and consider the ones they notice; sellers choose only among the few they own
    3. Brokers restrict selling on news days
    Show the answer

    B. Buyers must choose among thousands of stocks and consider the ones they notice; sellers choose only among the few they own Barber and Odean’s point is about search. Attention narrows thousands of candidates to a handful, so it shapes purchases. The sell decision has a short list already.

  2. A stock falls 15% in a day on heavy volume. According to brokerage data, what do individual investors as a group tend to do?

    1. Become net sellers
    2. Become net buyers, as they do after large rises
    3. Stop trading it
    Show the answer

    B. Become net buyers, as they do after large rises Extreme moves in either direction attracted net buying. That fits attention and does not fit a simple story of chasing winners.

  3. Studies using Google searches and Robinhood data looked at prices after bursts of retail attention. What did they find?

    1. A permanent rise
    2. A short-lived rise that was later reversed
    3. No effect on price
    Show the answer

    B. A short-lived rise that was later reversed Search spikes predicted higher prices for about two weeks and a reversal within the year. The most-bought Robinhood stocks lagged by about 4.7% over 20 days.

  4. EntreMed went from $12 on Friday to $85 at Monday’s open in May 1998. What was unusual about the news?

    1. It was false
    2. The research had been published and reported five months earlier; the Sunday front page added prominence, not information
    3. It was about a different company
    Show the answer

    B. The research had been published and reported five months earlier; the Sunday front page added prominence, not information Huberman and Regev called it a nonevent. The price moved on attention to facts that were already public.

  5. Which habit addresses attention-driven buying most directly?

    1. Buying faster when a stock is in the news
    2. Recording how each idea reached you and searching by your own criteria
    3. Reading more headlines
    Show the answer

    B. Recording how each idea reached you and searching by your own criteria Professionals who screen the whole market by chosen criteria did not show the effect. Noting the source of an idea separates noticing a stock from having a reason to own it.

Exercise

One task to do in Finabase. Nothing is graded or saved.

Open Trending and write down the first five symbols. For each, open its page and note two things: how far the price has already moved today and over the past month, and whether the top item in its News tab reports something new or repeats something older. Then ask of each: would this stock be on any list of mine if it were not on this one?

Open Trending
What you should find

Most names on a trending list are there because of a large move or a burst of coverage that has already happened, so the price you see includes it. The list changes daily. If none of the five would have appeared on a list built from your own criteria, the list is telling you what other people are looking at, which is what the research says to be careful with.

Sources and further reading

  1. Tversky and Kahneman — Availability: a heuristic for judging frequency and probability, Cognitive Psychology 5(2), 1973
  2. Lichtenstein, Slovic, Fischhoff, Layman and Combs — Judged frequency of lethal events, Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 4(6), 1978
  3. Combs and Slovic — Newspaper coverage of causes of death, Journalism Quarterly 56(4), 1979
  4. Barber and Odean — All that glitters: the effect of attention and news on the buying behavior of individual and institutional investors, Review of Financial Studies 21(2), 2008
  5. Da, Engelberg and Gao — In search of attention, Journal of Finance 66(5), 2011
  6. Huberman and Regev — Contagious speculation and a cure for cancer: a nonevent that made stock prices soar, Journal of Finance 56(1), 2001
  7. Fang and Peress — Media coverage and the cross-section of stock returns, Journal of Finance 64(5), 2009
  8. Barber, Huang, Odean and Schwarz — Attention-induced trading and returns: evidence from Robinhood users, Journal of Finance 77(6), 2022
  9. Engelberg and Parsons — The causal impact of media in financial markets, Journal of Finance 66(1), 2011
  10. US Securities and Exchange Commission — Order of suspension of trading, Zoom Technologies, Inc., Release No. 34-88477, March 25, 2020