Skip to content
Menu
Finabase Learn

Articles · Market history

The South Sea Bubble of 1720: debt swaps, Newton and the crash

How the South Sea Company turned British government debt into shares, why its stock rose about eightfold in 1720 and fell back by autumn, and what Newton’s trades show.

On this page
  1. The company and the debt
  2. What the price did
  3. Isaac Newton's trades
  4. A worked example: the conversion at different prices
  5. Lessons for investors
  6. South Sea and its neighbors
  7. How Finabase helps
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. Summary
  10. Check your understanding

In 1720 the South Sea Company, a British firm with a trading monopoly it barely used, offered to take over much of the national debt in exchange for its own shares. Investors loved the plan. Its stock rose from about £128 in early January to close to £1,000 in the summer, pulled other shares up with it, and then fell back to about £200 by October. The collapse ruined many investors, toppled ministers and gave the English language the word "bubble" in its financial sense.

The episode is better documented than Tulip mania (1636–37): what really happened in the Dutch bulb bubble. Share prices were published several times a week, Parliament investigated afterward, and recent research has rebuilt the trades of one of its most famous losers, Isaac Newton. This lesson walks through how the scheme worked, why the price rose, why it fell, and what Newton's experience says about knowing a market is overpriced.

The company and the debt

The South Sea Company was founded in 1711. In return for taking over about £9 million of short-term government debt, it received a monopoly on British trade with Spain's colonies in South America. That trade was small, restricted by treaty, and often interrupted by war. The company's real business was being a holder of government debt and collecting interest on it.

By 1719 Britain had a heavy debt from decades of war, much of it in annuities that the government could not easily repay or refinance. The company proposed a conversion: holders of government debt would exchange it for South Sea shares, and the government would pay the company a lower interest rate on the debt it now held. Parliament approved the scheme in the spring of 1720 after the company outbid the Bank of England for the right.

Why a higher share price fed itself

The key detail was the exchange rate. Debt holders were offered shares at the market price, not at the shares' face value of £100. If the stock traded at £300, a holder of £300 of debt got one share. The company was allowed to issue new shares equal to the face value of the debt it took in, so at £300 it absorbed £300 of debt for each £100 share it handed out, and kept the other shares to sell. The higher the price, the more spare shares the company had and the more profitable the plan looked, which pushed the price higher still.

Two practices added fuel:

  • Installments. New shares were sold in subscriptions that required only a fraction of the price up front, with the rest due over months or years. A small cash outlay controlled a large position, much like buying on margin.
  • Loans on its own shares. The company lent money to investors with South Sea stock as collateral, which they could use to buy more of it. It was financing demand for its own shares.

What the price did

Prices were printed in London papers several times a week, so the path is known in outline. The figure joins a few of the published values; the stock moved up and down a lot between them.

South Sea Company stock in 1720: a few published prices (£ per £100 share) £0 £250 £500 £750 £1,000 Jan Mar May Jul Sep Nov Jan 1721 Early Jan: ~£128 April: ~£350 (Newton sells) 14 June: ~£700 (Newton buys back) Summer peak: close to £1,000 October: ~£200 Approximate values; the dashed line only joins them. Odlyzko (2019), Frehen et al. (2013).
A few published South Sea prices in 1720 (£ per £100 share). Sources: Odlyzko (2019), Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst (2013), Yale SOM (2020).

From the start of the year to the peak, the price rose roughly eightfold. Other shares rose with it. Bank of England and East India Company stock gained, and dozens of new companies were floated to raise money for projects, some sensible, some not. In June 1720 Parliament passed the Bubble Act, which banned joint-stock companies operating without a royal charter. It is often described as a crackdown on fraud, but it also protected the South Sea Company from rivals for investors' money.

Why it fell

The fall from late summer had several causes that reinforced one another:

  1. Installments came due. Investors who had paid a fraction up front had to find more cash, and many had to sell shares to do it.
  2. Credit tightened. The company and its banker, the Sword Blade Company, had lent heavily. When the Sword Blade Company failed in September 1720, credit in London dried up.
  3. Paris was unwinding. John Law's Mississippi Company in France had gone through its own boom and bust in 1719–20, and money moving between Paris, London and Amsterdam spread the strain. Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst (2013) find that the London rise and fall was tied to a wider European boom in companies linked to new trade and insurance.
  4. The new-share machine reversed. The scheme that worked well at a rising price worked badly at a falling one: debt holders who had swapped at high prices now held shares worth far less than the debt they gave up.

By October the price was back near £200. Parliament investigated in 1721. Directors had their estates confiscated, and the Chancellor of the Exchequer, John Aislabie, was expelled from the House of Commons and imprisoned in the Tower of London for his role. Robert Walpole managed the clean-up and became the dominant politician of the next two decades.

Isaac Newton's trades

Newton, then Master of the Mint, owned South Sea stock. The mathematician Andrew Odlyzko reconstructed his holdings from the Bank of England's and the company's records (2019). In outline:

When What Newton did Approximate price Result
Before 1720 Held South Sea stock as a long-term investment Around £100–£130 Steady income
April–May 1720 Sold most of his holding Rising past £300 Profit of about £20,000
June–August 1720 Bought back in, including about £700 on 14 June £700 and up Exposed close to the top
Late 1720 onward Held through the fall Down to about £200 Lost his early gains and much more besides

Odlyzko's estimate is that Newton ended the episode with a net loss that wiped out his spring profit and more. A well-known line about not being able to calculate "the madness of people" is attributed to Newton, but no contemporary record of him saying it has been found, so it is not quoted here.

What his trades show

Newton's first sale was right: the stock was far above anything its trade could justify. His mistake was psychological, not mathematical. Watching friends keep profiting after he sold, he bought back near the top. Knowing that something is overpriced does not tell you when the price will stop rising, and selling early can feel like a loss. The lessons on Regret aversion: how the fear of being wrong shapes investment choices and Herd behavior and FOMO in investing: cascades, manias and panics describe the same pull.

A worked example: the conversion at different prices

Take a holder of £1,000 of government debt and suppose the company may create one new £100 share for every £100 of debt it takes in.

  • At a share price of £200, the holder gets 5 shares. The company takes £1,000 of debt and may create 10 new shares, so it keeps 5 shares to sell for about £1,000.
  • At £500, the holder gets 2 shares. The company may still create 10 shares, so it keeps 8 to sell, worth about £4,000 at that price.
  • At £800, the holder gets 1.25 shares and the company keeps 8.75, worth about £7,000.

The scheme's apparent profit depended entirely on the share price, and the share price depended on belief in the scheme's profit. That loop is what made the rise fast and the fall hard.

Lessons for investors

South Sea and its neighbors

Episode Years What rose Engine of the rise
Tulip mania (1636–37): what really happened in the Dutch bulb bubble 1636–37 Bulb contracts Unpaid promises traded in taverns
Mississippi Company 1719–20 John Law's company, Paris New paper money from Law's bank
South Sea Company 1720 Its shares, London Debt-for-shares swap, installments, loans on its own stock
The crash of 1929: causes, the 1929–32 decline and lessons 1927–29 US stocks Broker margin loans
The dot-com bubble: the 1995–2002 boom and the 78% Nasdaq fall 1995–2000 Internet and technology shares New issues, stock-financed deals, retail inflows

How Finabase helps

Finabase cannot chart 1720, but it can show today's equivalents of its warning signs. A long monthly chart (range=max) puts a run-up in a decades-long frame, and the Portfolio page shows how much of a portfolio sits in one holding, the exposure that hurt Newton. The History of stock market crashes: every major US drawdown compared lesson compares modern drawdowns on real data.

Frequently asked questions

What was the South Sea Bubble?

It was the 1720 boom and crash in shares of the South Sea Company, which took over British government debt in exchange for its stock. The price rose from about £128 in January to close to £1,000 in the summer and fell back to about £200 by October.

How much did Isaac Newton lose in the South Sea Bubble?

He made about £20,000 selling in the spring of 1720, then bought back near the top. Odlyzko's reconstruction concludes that he ended with a net loss that wiped out that gain and more; exact totals depend on how his later holdings are valued.

What was the Bubble Act?

A law passed in June 1720 that banned joint-stock companies without a royal charter. It limited new company formation in Britain until it was repealed in 1825.

Yes. John Law's Mississippi Company in France boomed and crashed in 1719–20, and capital moved between Paris, London and Amsterdam. Research by Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst ties the episodes to one European boom.

Summary

The South Sea Bubble was a 1720 boom in a company whose main business was holding British government debt. A debt-for-shares swap made the company's profit depend on its own share price, and installments and loans on its shares fed buying, so the stock rose about eightfold and then fell back by autumn as payments came due and credit tightened. Newton's early profit and later loss show the hardest part of any bubble: being right about value is not the same as being right about timing.

Check your understanding

4 questions on this lesson. Each answer comes with the reason, and nothing is scored.

  1. Under the South Sea debt swap, why did a higher share price make the scheme look more profitable?

    1. Because the government paid more interest at higher prices
    2. Because debt holders received fewer shares per pound of debt, leaving the company more new shares to sell
    3. Because the South Sea trade grew with the share price
    Show the answer

    B. Because debt holders received fewer shares per pound of debt, leaving the company more new shares to sell Debt was swapped at the market price of the shares. At a higher price each pound of debt cost the company fewer shares, so it kept more to sell. Price and apparent profit fed each other.

  2. How did installment subscriptions and company loans on its own shares affect the 1720 rise and fall?

    1. They had no effect on prices
    2. They let small cash outlays control large positions, which fed buying on the way up and forced selling when payments came due
    3. They made the shares safer because fewer investors held them
    Show the answer

    B. They let small cash outlays control large positions, which fed buying on the way up and forced selling when payments came due Both worked like margin: little cash up front, more owed later. When installments fell due and credit tightened, holders had to sell.

  3. Newton sold at a profit in spring 1720 and bought back near the top. What does that sequence best illustrate?

    1. That the stock was fairly valued
    2. That seeing an overvaluation does not tell you when it ends, and that watching others profit can pull a seller back in
    3. That mathematicians are poor investors
    Show the answer

    B. That seeing an overvaluation does not tell you when it ends, and that watching others profit can pull a seller back in His first judgment about value was right. The loss came from re-entering after watching the price keep rising, a timing and psychology problem.

  4. Which feature makes the South Sea episode better documented than tulip mania?

    1. Share prices were printed in London papers several times a week, and Parliament investigated afterward
    2. Every trade was recorded on a blockchain
    3. The company published audited accounts each quarter
    Show the answer

    A. Share prices were printed in London papers several times a week, and Parliament investigated afterward Regular printed prices and the 1721 inquiry left a record that historians have used to rebuild the price path and even Newton’s trades.

Sources and further reading

  1. Odlyzko — Newton’s financial misadventures in the South Sea Bubble, Notes and Records of the Royal Society 73(1), 2019
  2. Frehen, Goetzmann and Rouwenhorst — New evidence on the first financial bubble, Journal of Financial Economics 108(3), 2013
  3. Yale School of Management — Looking back 300 years at the South Sea Bubble of 1720 (2020)
  4. Dale — The First Crash: Lessons from the South Sea Bubble, Princeton University Press, 2004
  5. Neal — The Rise of Financial Capitalism, Cambridge University Press, 1990
  6. Garber — Famous First Bubbles: The Fundamentals of Early Manias, MIT Press, 2000